Lets talk iconic knives.
-
Balisong. What a wonderful thing it is. Whatever the origins, I tip my hat to our Filipino brethren for its perfection. There are some who say its origin is 800ce. There are other beliefs as to the origins. Could this knife be one of the most banned knifes across all continents? What a spectacular display in the hands of experienced flippers.
-
I think the origins of a knife pattern is important. Getting that particular pattern to iconic stature thru revisions is also important. I'm sure there are many knives that fall into this situation. The originator may not get the "credit" but I'm always more than appreciative of a knifes origins. We may never know the true origins but I'm also a fan of the stories told.
-
@Etherealicer said:
Balisong (also an extremely iconic design)
and the Karambit (ok, you can call me a HEMA-elitist, but that is neither a knife nor a weapon, just a toy)I'd have to agree that the Balisong Butterfly knife is iconic. Although, again, not a game changer.
(And, word to the wise, don't tel Doug Marcaida that the karambit is not a weapon. ;))

-
I would feel the need to distinguissh/differentiate between iconinc specific knives and iconic knife styles.
My picks would be:Iconic knife styles which many people can picture or imagine/relate to their name, era or time period, location or uses:
Spoiler:
- Bowie
- Stiletto
- Balisong
- Flipper Knife
- OTF/Automatic
- Dive knife
- Peasant Knife
- Combat/Military knife (ala SOG, KaBar, Ontario...)
- Machetes
- Kitchen knives of several types
- Hunting knives (ala Bucks)
- Puuko/Scandinavian Knives
- SAKs
- Traditional Knife (several patterns such as Stockman, Barlow, Sodbuster, Trapper)
- Karambit
- Dagger
· Fairbairn-Sykes
· Swiss/German dagger
· Rondell
· Bollock Dagger
· Fencing/Italian dagger
· Sai
· Kris - Kukri
- Short Sword
· Cinquedea
· Xyphos
· Falcata
· Gladius - Swords
· Two Handed Longsword
· Viking Sword
· Saber
· Katana and Wakizashi
· Basket Hilt Sword
· Scimitar
· Rapier
· Cutlass - Throwing Knife (*kunai *style especially)
and then iconic specific production knives, some discontinued, some still produced, depending on your knife-nerdiness some are more expected to be known than others :D
Spoiler:
Traditionals:
- Opinel
- DoukDouk
- Mercator
- Okapi
- Svord
- Higonokami
- Barlow, Stockman, and others made by Case, Queen, GEC...
- Buck 110 and 112
Modern sheath knives:
- Buck 119, 120 and maybe others
- Schrade Sharpfinger
- Randall (several models)
- KaBar COmbat Utility
- Ontario Pilot Knife and others
- Mora/Hultafors
- ESEE Junglas and Izula
- Gerber Trident, Mark I and II, LMF, Prodigy
- KaBar Becker BK9 and BK2
- Bradford Guardian series
- Marttiini knives
- Puukos (of several makers)
Modern folding knives:
- Spyderco Military, Police, Paramilitary, Delica and Endura, Worker, Harpy
- Benchmade 710, 940, Griprillian, Infidel, Adamas, Presidio
- Cold Steel Tantos, Recon, Espada,
- Gerber Paraframe, EZ Out, Gator
- Kershaw Leek, Shallot, Scallion, Blur, Skyline
- ZT 0652, and others
- Emerson CQC7, Horseman
- Microtech Scarab, and others
- CRK Sebenza, Insingo and others
and I left out a lot, I am sure
-
Balisong (also an extremely iconic design)
and the Karambit (ok, you can call me a HEMA-elitist, but that is neither a knife nor a weapon, just a toy)I'd have to agree that the Balisong Butterfly knife is iconic. Although, again, not a game changer.
(And, word to the wise, don't tel Doug Marcaida that the karambit is not a weapon. ;))

They call everything a weapon on that show, even a fiction folder.
-
@ThePeacent said:
I would feel the need to distinguissh/differentiate between iconinc specific knives and iconic knife styles.
My picks wouldIconic knife styles which many people can picture or imagine/relate to their name, era or time period, location or uses:
Spoiler:
- Bowie
- Stiletto
- Balisong
- Flipper Knife
- OTF/Automatic
- Dive knife
- Peasant Knife
- Combat/Military knife (ala SOG, KaBar, Ontario...)
- Machetes
- Kitchen knives of several types
- Hunting knives (ala Bucks)
- Puuko/Scandinavian Knives
- SAKs
- Traditional Knife (several patterns such as Stockman, Barlow, Sodbuster, Trapper)
- Karambit
- Dagger
· Fairbairn-Sykes
· Swiss/German dagger
· Rondell
· Bollock Dagger
· Fencing/Italian dagger
· Sai
· Kris - Kukri
- Short Sword
· Cinquedea
· Xyphos
· Falcata
· Gladius - Swords
· Two Handed Longsword
· Viking Sword
· Saber
· Katana and Wakizashi
· Basket Hilt Sword
· Scimitar
· Rapier
· Cutlass - Throwing Knife (*kunai *style especially)
and then iconic specific production knives, some discontinued, some still produced, depending on your knife-nerdiness some are more expected to be known than others :D
Spoiler:
Traditionals:
- Opinel
- DoukDouk
- Mercator
- Okapi
- Svord
- Higonokami
- Barlow, Stockman, and others made by Case, Queen, GEC...
- Buck 110 and 112
Modern sheath knives:
- Buck 119, 120 and maybe others
- Schrade Sharpfinger
- Randall (several models)
- KaBar COmbat Utility
- Ontario Pilot Knife and others
- Mora/Hultafors
- ESEE Junglas and Izula
- Gerber Trident, Mark I and II, LMF, Prodigy
- KaBar Becker BK9 and BK2
- Bradford Guardian series
- Marttiini knives
- Puukos (of several makers)
Modern folding knives:
- Spyderco Military, Police, Paramilitary, Delica and Endura, Worker, Harpy
- Benchmade 710, 940, Griprillian, Infidel, Adamas, Presidio
- Cold Steel Tantos, Recon, Espada,
- Gerber Paraframe, EZ Out, Gator
- Kershaw Leek, Shallot, Scallion, Blur, Skyline
- ZT 0652, and others
- Emerson CQC7, Horseman
- Microtech Scarab, and others
- CRK Sebenza, Insingo and others
and I left out a lot, I am sure
I'm certain the wording of the guideline I borrowed could have been refined much better, however thats why I thought "free flowing non stringent" preface need to be said. I like how you grouped knives.
-
Aye, I don't know that the "Original" of any given design is necessarily going to be the "Iconic"
for me, the "Iconic" fighting knife is a Fairburn-Sykes, for Yanks it might be the Ka-Bar
The FS itself is obviously put together from designs that the gents involved had seen and liked, as was the KaBar I have no doubt.
To say where the "game changing" was in that evolution is a bit hard to pinpoint, and I'm sure everyone would argue for their favourite one being the one that "defined" the category.
-
Game changing can be very hard to determine. In some instances the refinement in forging steel. In others subtle changes to egos and materials chosen. These refinements make a difference IMO and do make for a better "design". Now looking at the knife depot guidelines I see I should have taken more time to make changes to some wording
. Sorry about that. I was excited however to get this thread off and see the discussions that would follow. -
I think it is going great, Aloha
Great topic
Not much I can think to add to the list
so many great knives and patterns have been mentioned
It is great to see so many different styles and how different cultures have all gotten way different results in designing their own cutting tools
Environment has played a major factor in a lot of these design and also when they were designed and created had a big impact on what and how they were designed
As I said this is a great thread

-
@ThePeacent said:
I would feel the need to distinguissh/differentiate between iconinc specific knives and iconic knife styles.
My picks would be:Iconic knife styles which many people can picture or imagine/relate to their name, era or time period, location or uses:
- Traditional Knife (several patterns such as Stockman, Barlow, Sodbuster, Trapper)
and then iconic specific production knives, some discontinued, some still produced, depending on your knife-nerdiness some are more expected to be known than others :D
Traditionals:
Modern sheath knives:
Modern folding knives:
Very impressive listings Peacent!

-
@Poncho65 said:
I think it is going great, Aloha
Great topic
Not much I can think to add to the list
so many great knives and patterns have been mentioned
It is great to see so many different styles and how different cultures have all gotten way different results in designing their own cutting tools
Environment has played a major factor in a lot of these design and also when they were designed and created had a big impact on what and how they were designed
As I said this is a great thread


-
Great topic Aloha

I was thinking of the leather washer handle and how it has been used across a wide range of fixed blades for such a long time.
Originally thought F/S and Kabar as others have noted so here is mine with an Applegate updated version by Boker.
The “Kabar”is actually a late WW2 Camillus (guard marked).
The F/S is a Wilkinson made 3rd pattern with the thicker hand ground blade.
-
@sak60 said:
Great topic Aloha
I was thinking of the leather washer handle and how it has been used across a wide range of fixed blades for such a long time.
Originally thought F/S and Kabar as others have noted so here is mine with an Applegate updated version by Boker.
The “Kabar”is actually a late WW2 Camillus (guard marked).
The F/S is a Wilkinson made 3rd pattern with the thicker hand ground blade.Nice knives sak60 !

-
Thank you
Vicman -
Great set of blades there, sak60!

-
-
I was trying to think of a modern knife that might be considered iconic and I can't think of a one.
I don't know, maybe my mind set is preventing me from seeing it. Correct me if I'm missing something.
I see an icon as that long produced knife that has survived the test of time, with or with out some minor changes.
In modern knives I see ideas that became game changers, more than I see knives that are iconic. Ideas and innovations alone do not make a knife iconic.
The walker liner lock was a major innovation that all liner locks and frame locks are based on.Kershaw, ZT, Emerson, Microtech, might be well known but I'm not seeing any single knife model that has survived to become an icon.
Spyderco wasn't the first to use a pocket clip but they popularized the pocket clip and their bird head shaped blade. I don't think they have a knife that could be considered iconic out side of the Spyderco fans. I'm willing to bet Spyderco fans couldn't pick just one.
The same with Benchmade they are famous for their ambidextrous axis lock, more so than any single knife.
Cold steel had the idea of putting the end of a sword on a folder and made the tanto more main stream.
Mostly they are known for a fat man hacking chickens, dangling on a rope. -
@Dean51 said:
I don't think they have a knife that could be considered iconic out side of the Spyderco fans. I'm willing to bet Spyderco fans couldn't pick just one.I agree with you, Dean.
For the sake of argument, I'd like to put forth the Spyderco Endura as an iconic knife. When I think of "Spyderco", it's the Endura that springs to mind. And it's one of their older designs.
For me, the Endura was the first knife that combined FRN handles, the Spydie hole, and a clip. Before the Endura....I never gave a plastic-handled knife a second glance. And the Endura brought in an unusual blade shape, as well. Unusual for the time. Even the strengthened tip seemed to speak of purpose and intention.
I don't currently have an Endura, but for me, the Endura was THE Spydie....and maybe a game-changer.

-
I don't think they have a knife that could be considered iconic out side of the Spyderco fans. I'm willing to bet Spyderco fans couldn't pick just one.
I agree with you, Dean.
For the sake of argument, I'd like to put forth the Spyderco Endura as an iconic knife. When I think of "Spyderco", it's the Endura that springs to mind. And it's one of their older designs.
For me, the Endura was the first knife that combined FRN handles, the Spydie hole, and a clip. Before the Endura....I never gave a plastic-handled knife a second glance. And the Endura brought in an unusual blade shape, as well. Unusual for the time. Even the strengthened tip seemed to speak of purpose and intention.
I don't currently have an Endura, but for me, the Endura was THE Spydie....and maybe a game-changer.

No argument from me.

-
@Dean51 said:
I was trying to think of a modern knife that might be considered iconic and I can't think of a one.
I don't know, maybe my mind set is preventing me from seeing it. Correct me if I'm missing something.
I see an icon as that long produced knife that has survived the test of time, with or with out some minor changes.
In modern knives I see ideas that became game changers, more than I see knives that are iconic. Ideas and innovations alone do not make a knife iconic.
The walker liner lock was a major innovation that all liner locks and frame locks are based on.Kershaw, ZT, Emerson, Microtech, might be well known but I'm not seeing any single knife model that has survived to become an icon.
Spyderco wasn't the first to use a pocket clip but they popularized the pocket clip and their bird head shaped blade. I don't think they have a knife that could be considered iconic out side of the Spyderco fans. I'm willing to bet Spyderco fans couldn't pick just one.
The same with Benchmade they are famous for their ambidextrous axis lock, more so than any single knife.
Cold steel had the idea of putting the end of a sword on a folder and made the tanto more main stream.
Mostly they are known for a fat man hacking chickens, dangling on a rope.Well said. Certainly modern knives and makers have released game changers. The pocket clip is a great example. Iconic simple because of that, I'd say no. Locking mechanisms again great example.
Iconic may be a clumsy way to describe the type of knives we are after? Online I found, conventional formulaic as part of the definition of iconic. I quite like this.
Take the Khukuri for example. Widely known to most knife people. Certainly a blade shape that is easily brought to mind when Khukuri is said. While there are many thoughts as to how this blade came to be its likely forefather is the Greek Kopi. The Kopi may not be familiar to the average knife person. It may not be as known today as the Khukuri and therefore may not be deemed iconic by the vast majority of knife people. I dont believe it was mentioned thus far.
Being iconic may be just that, something that has set itself apart, enduring, become part of the general accepted pattern, style, classification of blade irregardless to its forefather.

The guideline mentions currently produced. I think as I've said sticking to these guideline was not terribly important. So currently produced is a case by case situation IMO.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

