Lets talk iconic knives.
-
I don't think they have a knife that could be considered iconic out side of the Spyderco fans. I'm willing to bet Spyderco fans couldn't pick just one.
I agree with you, Dean.
For the sake of argument, I'd like to put forth the Spyderco Endura as an iconic knife. When I think of "Spyderco", it's the Endura that springs to mind. And it's one of their older designs.
For me, the Endura was the first knife that combined FRN handles, the Spydie hole, and a clip. Before the Endura....I never gave a plastic-handled knife a second glance. And the Endura brought in an unusual blade shape, as well. Unusual for the time. Even the strengthened tip seemed to speak of purpose and intention.
I don't currently have an Endura, but for me, the Endura was THE Spydie....and maybe a game-changer.

No argument from me.

-
@Dean51 said:
I was trying to think of a modern knife that might be considered iconic and I can't think of a one.
I don't know, maybe my mind set is preventing me from seeing it. Correct me if I'm missing something.
I see an icon as that long produced knife that has survived the test of time, with or with out some minor changes.
In modern knives I see ideas that became game changers, more than I see knives that are iconic. Ideas and innovations alone do not make a knife iconic.
The walker liner lock was a major innovation that all liner locks and frame locks are based on.Kershaw, ZT, Emerson, Microtech, might be well known but I'm not seeing any single knife model that has survived to become an icon.
Spyderco wasn't the first to use a pocket clip but they popularized the pocket clip and their bird head shaped blade. I don't think they have a knife that could be considered iconic out side of the Spyderco fans. I'm willing to bet Spyderco fans couldn't pick just one.
The same with Benchmade they are famous for their ambidextrous axis lock, more so than any single knife.
Cold steel had the idea of putting the end of a sword on a folder and made the tanto more main stream.
Mostly they are known for a fat man hacking chickens, dangling on a rope.Well said. Certainly modern knives and makers have released game changers. The pocket clip is a great example. Iconic simple because of that, I'd say no. Locking mechanisms again great example.
Iconic may be a clumsy way to describe the type of knives we are after? Online I found, conventional formulaic as part of the definition of iconic. I quite like this.
Take the Khukuri for example. Widely known to most knife people. Certainly a blade shape that is easily brought to mind when Khukuri is said. While there are many thoughts as to how this blade came to be its likely forefather is the Greek Kopi. The Kopi may not be familiar to the average knife person. It may not be as known today as the Khukuri and therefore may not be deemed iconic by the vast majority of knife people. I dont believe it was mentioned thus far.
Being iconic may be just that, something that has set itself apart, enduring, become part of the general accepted pattern, style, classification of blade irregardless to its forefather.

The guideline mentions currently produced. I think as I've said sticking to these guideline was not terribly important. So currently produced is a case by case situation IMO.
-
I also agree with Dean. ;)
-
I never hear of Spyderco before the forums. I was not a knife person other than the basic sporting goods selection. The more known knives were Buck 110, Kabar type fixed blades, SAK, and traditional slip joint types. Spydercos Delica could certainly be iconic. As mentioned there were a lot of firsts with that knife. I have 2 Delicas. I do have a question tho..... Does firsts ( game changers ) move a knife to iconic? I have thought about "game changer" since making this thread. Would game changer need to include other copying this feature? It would seem game changing meant there'd be hoards of makers jumping on the game change element? With patents and such it might not be an easy thing to do?
-
Does a more well known version/iteration to the "original" design take precedence?
The first incarnation sets the mold for subsequent incarnations, incorporating several recognizable and characteristic design features of the first. When we hear Bowie knife, we picture a certain blade shape and style. The Kabar USMC knife is bases on the Bowie knife. Both iconic yes? The Air Force Pilots Survival Knife also purportedly based on the Bowie seems to not be iconic
or is it? -
@Aloha007 said:
Does a more well known version/iteration to the "original" design take precedence?The first incarnation sets the mold for subsequent incarnations, incorporating several recognizable and characteristic design features of the first. When we hear Bowie knife, we picture a certain blade shape and style. The Kabar USMC knife is bases on the Bowie knife. Both iconic yes? The Air Force Pilots Survival Knife also purportedly based on the Bowie seems to not be iconic
or is it?The USAF Pilots knife will always have a special place in my heart: I carried one! But, iconic? Not the way the "KaBar" is.
-
Good call with the Kukri. An iconic knife if ever there were one.

-
Does a more well known version/iteration to the "original" design take precedence?
The first incarnation sets the mold for subsequent incarnations, incorporating several recognizable and characteristic design features of the first. When we hear Bowie knife, we picture a certain blade shape and style. The Kabar USMC knife is bases on the Bowie knife. Both iconic yes? The Air Force Pilots Survival Knife also purportedly based on the Bowie seems to not be iconic
or is it?The USAF Pilots knife will always have a special place in my heart: I carried one! But, iconic? Not the way the "KaBar" is.
I had one and moved it to a new owner. Lovely knife for sure. I'm sure any pilot would could argue this knife deserves high stature and deservedly so. Which makes me really rethink iconic as a whole. Iconic may not be the best way to describe well known knives/edged tools/wepons.
-
@Aloha007 said:
Spydercos Delica could certainly be iconic. As mentioned there were a lot of firsts with that knife. I have 2 Delicas. I do have a question tho..... Does firsts ( game changers ) move a knife to iconic? I have thought about "game changer" since making this thread. Would game changer need to include other copying this feature? It would seem game changing meant there'd be hoards of makers jumping on the game change element? With patents and such it might not be an easy thing to do?Well.....I now prefer the Delica, but to my mind---and I'm just speaking from my own perspective--the Endura is the one that I picture when I think of Spyderco. And I think it is easily recognizable as a Spyderco.
Now, look at all the Spydie features that have been incorporated into other makers' knives. Spydie drove the whole clip fad (which I hope we'll get past some day). So now, Benchmade offers knives with clips and Spydie holes (probably paying Spydie royalties).
-
@Aloha007 said:
I had one and moved it to a new owner. Lovely knife for sure. I'm sure any pilot would could argue this knife deserves high stature and deservedly so. Which makes me really rethink iconic as a whole. Iconic may not be the best way to describe well known knives/edged tools/wepons.But, relatively speaking, there are few people who have used or carried or even seen one. Everyone has seen a Kabar....even if it's just been in a Hollywood film.
A few people, like you and me, liking a knife doesn't make it 'iconic', does it?
-
How about the machete? Does that count as an iconic 'knife'?
-
Whats neat is how a predecessor can be "iconic" as well as incarnations when done right. In the above mentioned Bowie/USMC Kabar example we see this.
The stiletto has been mentioned and for good reason. I think of the 50s/60s switchblades. Whats interesting is a knife mentioned in this thread, F-S fighting knife is certainly a stiletto and a famous one at that. Both knives the stiletto as most know it and the F-S fighting knife are said to be iconic. Iterations like the Gerber Mark 2 and others also have quite a status.
-
I had one and moved it to a new owner. Lovely knife for sure. I'm sure any pilot would could argue this knife deserves high stature and deservedly so. Which makes me really rethink iconic as a whole. Iconic may not be the best way to describe well known knives/edged tools/wepons.
But, relatively speaking, there are few people who have used or carried or even seen one. Everyone has seen a Kabar....even if it's just been in a Hollywood film.
A few people, like you and me, liking a knife doesn't make it 'iconic', does it?
Sadly no. Liking a knife or small circles of rabid fans of a certain style doesn't make a knife iconic. Sad actually. Might be a case of use of said knife. A knife may have to earn the distinction? I dont know much the USAF Survival was used? Hopefully not much otherwise that meant downed aircraft. So maybe we are nearing a more refined definition of iconic?
-
Here's one to debate:

The "Nessmuck".
This knife is well known to knife-knuts and a few historians. It has led to numerous spin-offs by custom makers, and Bark River has a version in its catalogue. I'd argue that the Nessmuck pattern is iconic of an early period in American 'woodcraft'.
I like that in George Sears' book it is also shown being paired with another iconic knife, a double bladed folder.
As argument against it's iconic status: few people other than knife-knots and bushcrafters have ever heard of the man or the knife.
-
Another for consideration for inclusion in 'Iconic' status:

Emerson Commander.
Many felt this was a big game changer, especially inn the nebulously defined 'tactical' community. Small audience. Probably not well known to the general public. But amongst knife people, a classic with a sterling reputation.
Iconic?
(I had one of these for a while, but never bonded with it. Ended up giving it away. )
-
Take the Buck 110 there was nothing new about it, back locks had been around for generations.
But something about it clicked with people, as soon as the patents were off everyone and his uncle was making a copy of the 110. All the while the Buck 110 was in continuous production. Affordable classic and regardless of who makes the copy you always think of the original.Look at Spyderco and already the Delica & Endura have been mentioned, if this was a pure knife site then other models like the Paramilitary, Tenacious, would have been mentioned as well. Which is why I think Spyderco features make Spyderco recognizable. Spyderco features are recognizable but not a particular Spyderco knife.
It's the knife not the knife features, a classic icon has to pass the test of time.
For the sack of argument the Emerson Commander isn't there yet. ;)
-
It's an interesting question, before knife forums and EDC-ing a knife, what carry knives did I know of?
Swiss Army Knife (as a category, so very ubiquitous that no one even thought about them)
Kabar (I thought that Bowie and Kabar was synonymous, seen in Vietnam movies)
The 'Dagger' (as a British boy brought up on tales of WWII commandos)
Kukri (ditto on war tales and I bought a cheap fake one when I was 16 at a fair)
The 'Flick Knife'. (Italian Switchblade as seen in movies)
The Spyderco (one leaf blade shape defining the entire category, seen in ads poured over by teenage boys who couldn't afford them)
The Traditional (slipjoint, the knife my grandparents generation carried with their pipes or the MOP/Silver one my mother would sometimes let me play with). I had a cheap rusty slipjoint I carried in a coat pocket when I was 10-12 but I don't remember much about it.Other than that? Nope. They were all just categories and mostly in the 'history context' section of my brain. To be honest when I was growing up we were more interested in guns as a subject and air guns specifically as we could buy and use them as British teenagers. Not sure if that's even true any more.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



