Lets talk iconic knives.
-
@microbe said:
What if the real iconic knife is no longer made, but if there are plenty ripoffs or tribute knives based on that icon still available and for sale now? I am referring to the Jimmy Lile First Blood knife.The First Blood knife IMO is an icon. Interesting the style is Bowie inspired. Not surprising as he was a prolific Bowie knife maker. The knife you mention certainly is one many people had or wanted at that time 80s and today even as a collectable. The knife is easily recognizable to that era and beyond. The knife is still made by custom makers and really bad copies/clones are manufactured. Mr Lile is not known by most outside the knife nut community however his "Rambo" knife certainly is.
-
@Aloha007 said:
Which makes me really rethink iconic as a whole. Iconic may not be the best way to describe well known knives/edged tools/wepons.I would distinguish between "Iconic", "Relevant" and "Famous"
to me, a **Gladius **sword or a **Kukri **are relevant. They fought wars, they raised civilisations, slayed cultures, shaped history. They had a big effect in the development of empires, the evolution o populations, their sustainment and victory or disappearance. WIthout them we simply wouldn't be here, or the world would have shaped in a different way. They are mostly older types and designs.
then, a "Switch blade" a "Balisong" or a **SAK **are iconic. They didn't change history in a defined, specific era or event, but they became a sign or "icon" for a generation and those that followed (kids watching "Rebel without a cause" or other 50s/60s movies all over the world and remembering the knife) and are easily described, drawn or identified all over the planet (like SAKs, be it by MacGyver or because most kids have seen a few before they are adults)
finally, we have the *famous *knives, which are what comes to mind when someone put a generic name on them, and are usually specific models or production blades, but they are hardly ever identified as such by the people other than nerds, aficionados or connoisseurs. Those would for instance be the Buck 110 when one says "locking folding knife", the KaBar Combat-Utility when one says "Military combat knife" and the Lile Hollow Handle Bowie when someone says or hears "Rambo knife" or "Survival knife"
I hope I put that into words in an understandable way

-
Whats interesting about Buck 110 is how well they got it right the first time. Yes the knife has changed over time with respect to blade steel and wood choices the design overall has endured. From what I gather the choice to go from 440c to 425m was due to this higher end steel being to hard to sharpen at the time. They later moved to 420hc from 425m for the same reasons. Kinda weird since the blades today are harder and harder.
-
Which makes me really rethink iconic as a whole. Iconic may not be the best way to describe well known knives/edged tools/wepons.
I would distinguish between "Iconic", "Relevant" and "Famous"
to me, a **Gladius **sword or a **Kukri **are relevant. They fought wars, they raised civilisations, slayed cultures, shaped history. They had a big effect in the development of empires, the evolution o populations, their sustainment and victory or disappearance. WIthout them we simply wouldn't be here, or the world would have shaped in a different way. They are mostly older types and designs.
then, a "Switch blade" a "Balisong" or a **SAK **are iconic. They didn't change history in a defined, specific era or event, but they became a sign or "icon" for a generation and those that followed (kids watching "Rebel without a cause" or other 50s/60s movies all over the world and remembering the knife) and are easily described, drawn or identified all over the planet (like SAKs, be it by MacGyver or because most kids have seen a few before they are adults)
finally, we have the *famous *knives, which are what comes to mind when someone put a generic name on them, and are usually specific models or production blades, but they are hardly ever identified as such by the people other than nerds, aficionados or connoisseurs. Those would for instance be the Buck 110 when one says "locking folding knife", the KaBar Combat-Utility when one says "Military combat knife" and the Lile Hollow Handle Bowie when someone says or hears "Rambo knife" or "Survival knife"
I hope I put that into words in an understandable way


-
I'm going to have to disagree a little there, El P.
The Ghurka knife is most definitely Iconic.

This is an image that defines the Ghurka soldier. The soldiers made the knife famous and legendary, and the knife is now a symbol...an icon...of the soldiers. Much the way the USMC combat/utility was (and still is) for US Marines. Both of these knives are used as symbols of their respective units. To the same extent, I'd argue that the F-S fighting knife (or variants) became the symbol, icon, of the Commandos or Special Forces.

At least for Americans, the Bowie knife is an iconic knife: it represents the frontier, the Wild West, maybe the cowboy. But some Bowie knives are also 'Famous', for example the Bowie in the Movie "Iron Mistress". A knife that became famous and helped solidify the Bowie knife's iconic status.

-
@Aloha007 said:
Whats interesting about Buck 110 is how well they got it right the first time. Yes the knife has changed over time with respect to blade steel and wood choices the design overall has endured. From what I gather the choice to go from 440c to 425m was due to this higher end steel being to hard to sharpen at the time. They later moved to 420hc from 425m for the same reasons. Kinda weird since the blades today are harder and harder.I can't think of a more widely used or copied or influential knife than the Buck 110. Versions are made everywhere. And the 110 became the symbol of Buck. It is what people, even non-knife people, think of as being a "lock-back" or a "Buck knife."
-
I think overall we are all closer to what is iconic. We have some distinctions that probably need to be made and foot notes on predecessors but over all we're closer than we think.
Icon, relevant, famous, would tend to close gaps rather than separate. Each knife would fall into several categories and maybe falling into several serves to elevate into iconic stature?
-
@Nix said:
I'm going to have to disagree a little there, El P.The Ghurka knife is most definitely Iconic.
This is an image that defines the Ghurka soldier. The soldiers made the knife famous and legendary, and the knife is now a symbol...an icon...of the soldiers. Much the way the USMC combat/utility was (and still is) for US Marines. Both of these knives are used as symbols of their respective units. To the same extent, I'd argue that the F-S fighting knife (or variants) became the symbol, icon, of the Commandos or Special Forces.
At least for Americans, the Bowie knife is an iconic knife: it represents the frontier, the Wild West, maybe the cowboy. But some Bowie knives are also 'Famous', for example the Bowie in the Movie "Iron Mistress". A knife that became famous and helped solidify the Bowie knife's iconic status.absolutely, not disagreeing,

I never meant to say that one knife or blade couldn't fall into more than one of those three groups, in fact most of them overlap and have a bit of each,
the **Bowie **is certainly iconic, and is famous too, because of films, tales, novels, and stories, but I wouldn't say it was really relevant, almost any other knife would've done what it did (a puukko, a nessmuk, a Khiber...) in the Sandbar battle, and the subsequent survival and fighting tales, fights, outdoors travels and exploration of the wild USthe **Gladius **is very relevant, it allowed for the Roman empire to fight in their formation techniques, gain terrain in the grounds and lands they invaded, conferred advantage over the weapon styles and designs of their enemies, proved superior to their adversaries defenses...but it's not really "famous" in that if you ask or question people about what a "Gladius" is or if they could draw the main Roman Empire Soldier's sword, they would fail to do so...or "iconic", in that the Roman Shield, Helmet, formation and peplum/armor are as well known and recognised as their Gladius, if not more
finally, a **Buck 110 **is iconic, because it's a symbol or drawing the shape of which embodies the "folding hunting knife" by itself, and its profile immediately brings to mind the idea and real knife to anybody's mind, it was relatively relevant in that it introduced the first reliable and successful folding knife with a lock back in the US; it sold millions, it was carried by everyone, but to me is hard to say it shaped history or became a necessary tool, as it is, to shape or develop the progress of its country of origin and inhabitants. A drop point liner lock, a trailing point frame lock or a spey blade compression lock of equal strength, at the time, would've been equally successful and also "the first" of all the things he 110 achieved and was
-
@ThePeacent said:
absolutely, not disagreeing,
I never meant to say that one knife or blade couldn't fall into more than one of those three groups, in fact most of them overlap and have a bit of each,
the **Bowie **is certainly iconic, and is famous too, because of films, tales, novels, and stories, but I wouldn't say it was really relevant, almost any other knife would've done what it did (a puukko, a nessmuk, a Khiber...) in the Sandbar battle, and the subsequent survival and fighting tales, fights, outdoors travels and exploration of the wild USthe **Gladius **is very relevant, it allowed for the Roman empire to fight in their formation techniques, gain terrain in the grounds and lands they invaded, conferred advantage over the weapon styles and designs of their enemies, proved superior to their adversaries defenses...but it's not really "famous" in that if you ask or question people about what a "Gladius" is or if they could draw the main Roman Empire Soldier's sword, they would fail to do so...or "iconic", in that the Roman Shield, Helmet, formation and peplum/armor are as well known and recognised as their Gladius, if not more
finally, a **Buck 110 **is iconic, because it's a symbol or drawing the shape of which embodies the "folding hunting knife" by itself, and its profile immediately brings to mind the idea and real knife to anybody's mind, it was relatively relevant in that it introduced the first reliable and successful folding knife with a lock back in the US; it sold millions, it was carried by everyone, but to me is hard to say it shaped history or became a necessary tool, as it is, to shape or develop the progress of its country of origin and inhabitants. A drop point liner lock, a trailing point frame lock or a spey blade compression lock of equal strength, at the time, would've been equally successful and also "the first" of all the things he 110 achieved and was
Hmmmmmm....certainly the Gladius was one of the most important edged weapons in history, for the reasons you note. I think you may be right about the gladius' limited recognition, but, dang, to me it would be iconic. Maybe better to say "the iconic edged weapon of the Roman Army."
I also think the Bowie knife was relevant. To be more precise, the idea of the Bowie knife. At the Sandbar fight, James Bowie is thought to have used a common 'butcher knife'. No one is really sure what that means. After the Sandbar fight he developed the 'Bowie Knife'. (maybe his brother Rezin or blacksmith James Black deserve the credit?) And no one is really sure what that looked like either.
But the* idea *of the Bowie knife became popular. It stood for something (self-defense? self-reliance? Capability?). That idea did change history. "Bowie Knives" were in high demand as people started to migrate West. It was the "Bowie Knife" that became popular all along the frontier (and back East, too). When the war between the states broke out (1860-1865), many soldiers equipped themselves with Bowie knives (of every size, shape, and description). After the war, gold miners, cowboys, ranchers, etc..., armed themselves with Bowie knives.
True...other designs could have served just as well--there was no standardized "Bowie Knife". But it was the fame and, I'd say Iconic status, of the Bowie knife that made it relevant in American history. I don't know for sure, but the "KaBar" seems to have been derived from a Bowie design. So too have many hunting knives. I'd say that makes the Bowie relevant, iconic, and famous.
-
It's interesting to note that even in the age when Mark Twain was writing about Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn (1870's-1880's), the Barlow pocket knife had already achieved an Iconic status:
*Mary gave him a bran-new "Barlow" knife worth twelve and a half cents; and the convulsion of delight that swept his system shook him to his foundations. True, the knife would not cut anything, but it was a "sure-enough" Barlow, and there was inconceivable grandeur in that - though where the Western boys ever got the idea that such a weapon could possibly be counterfeited to its injury, is an imposing mystery and will always remain so, perhaps. *
- <u>The Adventures of Tom Sawyer</u>
-
I thought of one last night that I think is iconic
The original Stanley Utility knife

I still call any utility knife a Stanley knife, kind of like kleenex for tissues.
Spawned many copies and of course has been improved over time but they still make the original design.
-
I was thinking along similar lines, Steve.
How about the Sabatier Chef's knife? Iconic kitchen knife......in the West....

On the other side of the globe, perhaps the Chinese chef's knife?

-

I've always referred to these as utility knives however in other parts this would have referred to a utility fixed blade. Just a quick glance the Stanley knife is what a lot of folks on both sides of the pond call it, at least in the trades. Very interesting blade to add to the conversation.
-
@ Nix
great knives to add to the conversation. The "cleaver" is very recognizable I'd say to any average knife person as is the "chefs" knife. They are both near and dear to me as I made my living using both for a good number of years. The "Chinese" cleaver to which many call it is actually as you call it and a very thin knife as opposed to cleavers which have always been meant to be hackers in the kitchen. I have two such knifes in my kitchen and one is certainly more robust and meant to impact bone while the Chinese chefs knife is clearly made to be a veggie slicing machine.Admittedly I do call my Chinese chefs knife "cleaver" but I know not to use it as such, tho it would do the job no problem.
-
@Aloha007 said:
@ Nix
great knives to add to the conversation. The "cleaver" is very recognizable I'd say to any average knife person as is the "chefs" knife. They are both near and dear to me as I made my living using both for a good number of years. The "Chinese" cleaver to which many call it is actually as you call it and a very thin knife as opposed to cleavers which have always been meant to be hackers in the kitchen. I have two such knifes in my kitchen and one is certainly more robust and meant to impact bone while the Chinese chefs knife is clearly made to be a veggie slicing machine.Admittedly I do call my Chinese chefs knife "cleaver" but I know not to use it as such, tho it would do the job no problem.
"One of these things is not like the other...."

As you can see, my Chinese chef's knife (made in Japan) gets more use......
-
One of both the knives mentioned by you certainly are in the kitchens of most if not all. They are easily recognizable and even when calling the Chinese chefs knife a Chinese cleaver most if asked would retrieve what pictured. As to the Western Chefs knifes, same goes. I have two in my kitchen and both are easily retrieved by those who rarely if ever step foot in a kitchen.
Coming back to iconic status for either. I'd say yes and what more interesting is this notion of iconic blades. As I think more on it, the term iconic is beginning to seem more and more
.The list of blades would certainly include quite a selection. "Categories" of blades might be a start. I am rethinking the guidelines as originally posted.
It is the knife and for sake of discussion certain "dna" features standing the test of time ( relatively speaking ). Its what we come to know as the knifes enduring features, not being able to necessarily determine maker that likely is what the average knife person sees as iconic.
In the case of Spyderco as mentioned earlier, we see a hole in the blade, the leaf blade shape, FRN, and pocket clip. If the knife is marked JOE KNIFE CO on the blade we'd call it Spyderco instinctively. Spyderco might be iconic simply as a brand thats so widely recognized by the average knife person
. Like Victorinox, every little red pocket knife irrespective of maker is a Swiss Army Knife to average person. Only one however IS Victorinox. Most average knife people will call the little red knife a SAK, hence Victorniox icon as both maker and product. -
I like where you are going with this......
-
As an outsider looking into a foreign culture regarding the Bowie knife it seems more that the appeal lies in the romantic notion of an every man's utilitarian rough and tumble tool over the highly structured ways of society. At that time if you wanted a bladed weapon it was the sabre that was the dominant thing and knives/daggers were backups or things of convenience. If you wanted something to dress different game animals with again there were more specialized butchering and skinning knives. If you were looking for utensils, you had your spoons, knives and forks for that as well.
But a Bowie knife sounded less fancy, less specialized, more utilitarian, more common man, more like you and me. A knife that can cut the guy who had 3 aces hiding up his sleeve as well as field dress a boar or a jackrabbit and be used as a fork.
Plus it isn't hard to get those romantic notions today when we have a lot of resources to get information and many things can be tried out in a fairly safe environment. Just imagine how hard would it be to distinguish fact and fiction in those days if you had a strong marketing like CS has or a following like Busse
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


