Lets talk iconic knives.
-

(Sweet Scout, Dean!
) -
fair enough.Lets carry on then
.PLEASE HELP WITH THE GUIDLINES. Once we get a better working set of guidelines we can get back to the fun of picking knives for a list.
-
Easily and readily recognizable model/style/pattern/Brand. I think we have to include Brand, see below.
-
Knife must currently produced. Sorry no one offs or discontinued models.
Some things to consider.
There is no prerequisite to own the knife.
You do not need to know its origins or history. Many knives evolved to become what they are today. Unfortunately the predecessor doesn't always get the credit or become popular enough to stand the test of time ( stay in production ).
You do not need to know particular makers. Examples are the Bowie knife, Barlow pattern.
Knowing a specific model isn't important as some Brands have become iconic vs specific models. Because some Brands have done such a brilliant job at producing a wide array of models there are several models within the Brand that define the Brand. The Brand therefor has become iconic over specific models within the Brand.
One example is the Swiss Army Knife. With the vast array of models from both Victorinox and Wenger there wont be ONE single knife that'll stand out for everyone. The Brand has become iconic, particular features such as red plastic scales, multiple implements, and the shield are what identify the knife to the Brand. They have become one and the same.
Another example to me is both the Mora and Opinel. For some the Mora is both the Classic red handled knife and to others its the plastic Companion style while to others its both. When we say Mora for those that know the knife/s, rarely is a specific model called by name. The Brand has become the icon within the knife community.
Opinel is much the same to me as both Victorinox/Wenger and Mora. Opinel has many models denoted by number. Most just say Opinel knife. We know instinctively the knifes features without regard to the knife number.
I'd say Spyderco is or has done the same. No one model stands our for everyone however the Brand is widely known within the knife community. Is the Delica the stand out? Or is it the Endura? Maybe the Paramilitary 2 is? Much like the above mentioned knives when someone says Spyderco within the knife community instinctively we envision features and for some specific models. This Brand like the ones mentioned above has become known for many models yet no one for everyone stands out over the Brand.
To contrast this I as well as others suggested the Bowie, Balisong, and Barlow. Which Brand stand out for any of these? These are styles of knives that are easy to identify for most knife people because of certain features irrespective of Brand/Makers. I suggested the Puukko. I strongly feel this knife deserves a place on the list. However the STYLE of knife is whats iconic and no one Brand stands out across the board.
-
-
'No discontinued models' is a tough rule for me. I know this is going backwards, but... is the Barlow still in production? Case has plans for one. Maybe some custom makers make them still. Maybe GEC (I'm not sure). But what if nobody still made a Barlow?
There is no way I can go along with a definition of 'Iconic' that excludes the Barlow.

-
@Nix said:
'No discontinued models' is a tough rule for me. I know this is going backwards, but... is the Barlow still in production? Case has plans for one. Maybe some custom makers make them still. Maybe GEC (I'm not sure). But what if nobody still made a Barlow?There is no way I can go along with a definition of 'Iconic' that excludes the Barlow.


Not to worry they are still in production. :D GEC for one spits them out on a regular basis. -
Swiss Army Knife. * Not model specific. Victorinox and for many Wenger both have become synonymous with the little red knife.
Buck 110
Opinel. * Not model specific. Even tho there are several sizes available The Opinel knife with over a hundred year history is simply Opinel, company, model, inverter/maker.Mora. * Not model specific. Like many great knife companies this one is 125 young and counting. The Morakniv is recognized and known in its many iterations. Classic, Companion, and the newer models.
Laguiole. * Style. Sometimes a knife becomes its own thing. While the history suggests influences this style knife is its own thing.
Sodbuster. * Not brand specific. This one is tricky. The name is a trademark of Case. The pattern is much older than the trademark. To which wonderful country do we thank for this terrific pattern?
Bowie knife. * Style specific. What we know as the knife Jim Bowie carried.
Balisong/butterfly knife. * I'm not even going to touch on its origins. Most Americans know it as the "butterfly knife".
USMC KaBar fighting knife/1219C2 Combat Knife/USMC Mark 2/U.S. Navy utility knife, Mark 2. * This knife seems to be offically called a few things. The knife design being 70 plus years old probably best known as a USMC knife.
Stiletto/Switchblade. * Any knife that seems to be banned across a wide range of countries gets my vote. Is this the most banned knife? Italian Stiletto Switchblade is what some call it while others including myself just refer to it as Switchblade. Its the knife that many relate to 50s in the US as seen in movies and subsequently banned shortly thereabouts.
Barlow. * Style/Pattern. Good luck nailing down the origins. Obadiah Barlow of Sheffield, England, around 1670 seems to be widely regarded as its origins. Luke Furnace of Stannington is another name that'll pop up in most searches. The John Russell Company is an American company that is likely responsible for mass producing this terrific pattern en mass in the US.
Rambo knife. * I am no longer sure this makes the cut ( no pun intended ).
Khukuri. * Whatever the inspiration, whatever the origins, this knife is emblematic of the Gurkhas and Nepalese culture. Any blade that is so highly revered has got to make this list.
-
PLEASE HELP WITH THE GUIDELINES.
-
Easily and readily recognizable Model/Style/Pattern/Brand.
-
Knife must be currently produced.
3 Has stood the test of time. Has the knife played a great historical role or is part of a cultural identity? Is the knife a symbol of national pride?
- A knife that is emblematic of a style/pattern/Brand. * While some knives evolve over time to become what they are today. Certain knives regardless of origin or inspiration become their own. Parallel development sometimes is the reason for knives of seemingly similar DNA.
Am I getting close?
-
-
Does it really need to be currently produced to be iconic ?
-
@Aloha007 said:
Swiss Army Knife. * Not model specific. Victorinox and for many Wenger both have become synonymous with the little red knife.Buck 110
Opinel. * Not model specific. Even tho there are several sizes available The Opinel knife with over a hundred year history is simply Opinel, company, model, inverter/maker.
Mora. * Not model specific. Like many great knife companies this one is 125 young and counting. The Morakniv is recognized and known in its many iterations. Classic, Companion, and the newer models.
Laguiole. * Style. Sometimes a knife becomes its own thing. While the history suggests influences this style knife is its own thing.
Sodbuster. * Not brand specific. This one is tricky. The name is a trademark of Case. The pattern is much older than the trademark. To which wonderful country do we thank for this terrific pattern?
Bowie knife. * Style specific. What we know as the knife Jim Bowie carried.
Balisong/butterfly knife. * I'm not even going to touch on its origins. Most Americans know it as the "butterfly knife".
USMC KaBar fighting knife/1219C2 Combat Knife/USMC Mark 2/U.S. Navy utility knife, Mark 2. * This knife seems to be offically called a few things. The knife design being 70 plus years old probably best known as a USMC knife.
Stiletto/Switchblade. * Any knife that seems to be banned across a wide range of countries gets my vote. Is this the most banned knife? Italian Stiletto Switchblade is what some call it while others including myself just refer to it as Switchblade. Its the knife that many relate to 50s in the US as seen in movies and subsequently banned shortly thereabouts.
Barlow. * Style/Pattern. Good luck nailing down the origins. Obadiah Barlow of Sheffield, England, around 1670 seems to be widely regarded as its origins. Luke Furnace of Stannington is another name that'll pop up in most searches. The John Russell Company is an American company that is likely responsible for mass producing this terrific pattern en mass in the US.
Rambo knife. * I am no longer sure this makes the cut ( no pun intended ).
Khukuri. * Whatever the inspiration, whatever the origins, this knife is emblematic of the Gurkhas and Nepalese culture. Any blade that is so highly revered has got to make this list.
Puukko. * While all Puukko are knives, not all knives are Puukkos. I really like this. I see this phrasing pop up often. There is a description of what a Puukko traditionally is however I would defer to our Finnish members on that. I will say there is a Puukko for almost every task, woodwork, hunting, fishing, chopping, vegetables. and more.
-
@SteveC said:
Does it really need to be currently produced to be iconic ?I really struggle with this and I think #2 could be omitted then. I think #2 has to go. Historic and historically relevant knives certainly have to make the list whether they are currently produced or not.
@Aloha007 said:
PLEASE HELP WITH THE GUIDELINES.- Easily and readily recognizable Model/Style/Pattern/Brand.
2. Knife must be currently produced.3 Has stood the test of time. Has the knife played a great historical role or is part of a cultural identity? Is the knife a symbol of national pride?
- A knife that is emblematic of a style/pattern/Brand. * While some knives evolve over time to become what they are today. Certain knives regardless of origin or inspiration become their own. Parallel development sometimes is the reason for knives of seemingly similar DNA.
Am I getting close?
-
-
Easily and readily recognizable Model/Style/Pattern/Brand.
-
The knife played a great historical role.
-
The knife is part of a cultural identity.
-
The knife is a symbol of national pride.
-
A knife that is emblematic of a style/pattern/Brand. * While some knives evolve over time to become what they are today. Certain knives regardless of origin or inspiration become their own. Parallel development sometimes is the reason for knives of seemingly similar DNA.
-
-
Does it really need to be currently produced to be iconic ?
If it's not currently being produced, wouldn't that make it historic rather than iconic?
I tried this route however historic and historical cause more confusion.
I like this way of describing the use of the two words,
The word "historic" refers to any event, object, or place that is considered an important part of history. It is the more selective of the two terms.
The word "historical" refers to anything and everything that has happened in or is connected to the past, no matter its level of importance.
Oxford definition. Historic and historical are used in slightly different ways. Historic means ‘famous or important in history’, as in a historic occasion, whereas historical means ‘concerning history or historical events’, as in historical evidence; thus a historic event is one that was very important, whereas a historical event is something that happened in the past.
-
Swiss Army Knife. * Not model specific. Victorinox and for many Wenger both have become synonymous with the little red knife.
Buck 110
Opinel. * Not model specific. Even tho there are several sizes available The Opinel knife with over a hundred year history is simply Opinel, company, model, inverter/maker.
Mora. * Not model specific. Like many great knife companies this one is 125 young and counting. The Morakniv is recognized and known in its many iterations. Classic, Companion, and the newer models.
Laguiole. * Style. Sometimes a knife becomes its own thing. While the history suggests influences this style knife is its own thing.
Sodbuster. * Not brand specific. This one is tricky. The name is a trademark of Case. The pattern is much older than the trademark. To which wonderful country do we thank for this terrific pattern?
Bowie knife. * Style specific. What we know as the knife Jim Bowie carried.
Balisong/butterfly knife. * I'm not even going to touch on its origins. Most Americans know it as the "butterfly knife".
USMC KaBar fighting knife/1219C2 Combat Knife/USMC Mark 2/U.S. Navy utility knife, Mark 2. * This knife seems to be offically called a few things. The knife design being 70 plus years old probably best known as a USMC knife.
Stiletto/Switchblade. * Any knife that seems to be banned across a wide range of countries gets my vote. Is this the most banned knife? Italian Stiletto Switchblade is what some call it while others including myself just refer to it as Switchblade. Its the knife that many relate to 50s in the US as seen in movies and subsequently banned shortly thereabouts.
Barlow. * Style/Pattern. Good luck nailing down the origins. Obadiah Barlow of Sheffield, England, around 1670 seems to be widely regarded as its origins. Luke Furnace of Stannington is another name that'll pop up in most searches. The John Russell Company is an American company that is likely responsible for mass producing this terrific pattern en mass in the US.
Rambo knife. * I am no longer sure this makes the cut ( no pun intended ).
Khukuri. * Whatever the inspiration, whatever the origins, this knife is emblematic of the Gurkhas and Nepalese culture. Any blade that is so highly revered has got to make this list.
Puukko. * While all Puukko are knives, not all knives are Puukkos. I really like this. I see this phrasing pop up often. There is a description of what a Puukko traditionally is however I would defer to our Finnish members on that. I will say there is a Puukko for almost every task, woodwork, hunting, fishing, chopping, vegetables. and more.
Opinel. * Not model specific. Even tho there are several sizes available The Opinel knife with over a hundred year history is simply Opinel, company, model, inverter/maker.
I understand Opiniel because it's basically different sizes of the same knife.Mora. * Not model specific. Like many great knife companies this one is 125 young and counting. The Morakniv is recognized and known in its many iterations. Classic, Companion, and the newer models.
If Mora is not known for a specific knife, then you are saying it is known as a company. If that's the case you would have to include Spyderco, they're not known for a specific knife but a style. There are other companies that would have to be included as well.

Maybe when you narrow it down to a single knife there aren't that many icons out there. -
@Dean51 said:
Opinel. * Not model specific. Even tho there are several sizes available The Opinel knife with over a hundred year history is simply Opinel, company, model, inverter/maker.
I understand Opiniel because it's basically different sizes of the same knife.Mora. * Not model specific. Like many great knife companies this one is 125 young and counting. The Morakniv is recognized and known in its many iterations. Classic, Companion, and the newer models.
If Mora is not known for a specific knife, then you are saying it is known as a company. If that's the case you would have to include Spyderco, they're not known for a specific knife but a style. There are other companies that would have to be included as well.

Maybe when you narrow it down to a single knife there aren't that many icons out there.I'd agree with you there: If Mora is Iconic, then would not Buck, Sabatier, Case, Wilkinson, etc... also be 'Iconic'.

-
I would agree about Spyderco. Its certainly known by features specific to the Brand. In an early post I tried to compare it to Mora, Opinel, Swiss Army Knife as having become more than a single knife model/style. Its a Spyderco! :D
Lets add Spyderco to the list.

Swiss Army Knife. * Not model specific. Victorinox and for many Wenger both have become synonymous with the little red knife.
Buck 110
Opinel. * Not model specific. Even tho there are several sizes available The Opinel knife with over a hundred year history is simply Opinel, company, model, inverter/maker.
Mora. * Not model specific. Like many great knife companies this one is 125 young and counting. The Morakniv is recognized and known in its many iterations. Classic, Companion, and the newer models.
Laguiole. * Style. Sometimes a knife becomes its own thing. While the history suggests influences this style knife is its own thing.
Sodbuster. * Not brand specific. This one is tricky. The name is a trademark of Case. The pattern is much older than the trademark. To which wonderful country do we thank for this terrific pattern?
Bowie knife. * Style specific. What we know as the knife Jim Bowie carried.
Balisong/butterfly knife. * I'm not even going to touch on its origins. Most Americans know it as the "butterfly knife".
USMC KaBar fighting knife/1219C2 Combat Knife/USMC Mark 2/U.S. Navy utility knife, Mark 2. * This knife seems to be offically called a few things. The knife design being 70 plus years old probably best known as a USMC knife.
Stiletto/Switchblade. * Any knife that seems to be banned across a wide range of countries gets my vote. Is this the most banned knife? Italian Stiletto Switchblade is what some call it while others including myself just refer to it as Switchblade. Its the knife that many relate to 50s in the US as seen in movies and subsequently banned shortly thereabouts.
Barlow. * Style/Pattern. Good luck nailing down the origins. Obadiah Barlow of Sheffield, England, around 1670 seems to be widely regarded as its origins. Luke Furnace of Stannington is another name that'll pop up in most searches. The John Russell Company is an American company that is likely responsible for mass producing this terrific pattern en mass in the US.
Rambo knife. * I am no longer sure this makes the cut ( no pun intended ).
Khukuri. * Whatever the inspiration, whatever the origins, this knife is emblematic of the Gurkhas and Nepalese culture. Any blade that is so highly revered has got to make this list.
Puukko. * While all Puukko are knives, not all knives are Puukkos. I really like this. I see this phrasing pop up often. There is a description of what a Puukko traditionally is however I would defer to our Finnish members on that. I will say there is a Puukko for almost every task, woodwork, hunting, fishing, chopping, vegetables. and more.
Spyderco * Not model specific. This Brand has done what all great brand have, become known for its style and features. The hole in the blade, the blade shape, pocket clip, Spyder logo, all have come to be known as a Spyderco knife. They have a wide range of knives from pocket knives to fixed blades. They work with a wide range of knife makers and in house designers. They are made in many places around the world. The features of this brand are what are easily recognizable.
-

The Rambo knife seems like an Iconic movie prop.
However...if I saw three similar knives, I don't think I'd be able to pick out the actual Rambo Knife.
And I think he had a different knife in every movie.....so....just how iconic is any one of the Rambo knives?
-
If it's not currently being produced, wouldn't that make it historic rather than iconic?
No reason a knife couldn't be both.
The "Kentucky Rifle" aka the "Pennsylvania Rifle" is iconic, but not in production. It's certainly a historic rifle, too.
The Kentucky Rifle" aka the "Pennsylvania Rifle are still in production for traditional shooters of muzzle loader. aka the Pedersoli Kentucky Flintlock
-
If it's not currently being produced, wouldn't that make it historic rather than iconic?
No reason a knife couldn't be both.
The "Kentucky Rifle" aka the "Pennsylvania Rifle" is iconic, but not in production. It's certainly a historic rifle, too.
The Kentucky Rifle" aka the "Pennsylvania Rifle are still in production for traditional shooters of muzzle loader. aka the Pedersoli Kentucky Flintlock
True...it can still be had. I've got one. But.....they aren't in production in the sense they are being actively made for purposes of hunting and revolution.
-
I'm not trying to complicate things but maybe it can't be simple.
Multiple lists are needed.
Iconic knives that have stood the test of time, mostly unchanged.
Iconic companies known for a style of knife or knives.
Historical. The Roman sword and the first lock back, both gone but brought in a change in knives or history.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

