Lets talk iconic knives.
-
Some good thinking and some great thoughts.
-
@Syem said:
After reading through, here are some thoughts on what I think are the boundaries of the "iconic knife" description.
Not getting into what makes it actually iconic (impactful, revolutionary, historic etc). Also, any specific brand/model combination can be argued to be an iconic knife... I'm just talking here about theoretical edge-cases and which conditions could allow one to be submitted in a "iconic knives" list.An iconic knife cannot be a brand. Unless that knife is the only one made by this brand. (exception 1)
In terms of military knives, a specific instance or a succession of "XYZ official knife" instances could be "an iconic knife". (exception 2)
In terms of civilian knives, a specific widespread design could be "an iconic knife".(3)
The Opinel, for example, had for the longest time only one model in multiple sizes. That historical Opinel (forgetting the new models and variations) either in the specific most common size or as a design (regardless of its size) could fit exception 1 and/or 3. "Historical Opinel" or "Historical Opinel design", for example, seem like potentially valid list entries.
I don't feel like SAKs can be defined as "an iconic knife" as a group. Each model/design would need to be argued individually; I can see the Spartan, Classic, SwissChamp or maybe Huntsman as possibly making the cut but probably not a climber or farmer.
On the other hand, the true SAK (official knives of the Swiss Army) could fit exception 2 although a case could be made for individual instances either under 2 or under 3.USMC knife(/knives) fits 2 and/or 3.
A "function" design (one concept/function, many makers, many shape/size variations) such as the chinese cleaver or the Chef's knife, fileting knife, oister knife or even steak knife (which household doesn't have one of those?), could fit in description 3 but the case for it being "iconic" would need to be very strong.
The "still in production" criterion seems like a pretext of the original article to advertise knives that can be sold. I'd argue that most iconic knives probably can't still be purchased in all their original materials (steel, scales, rivets etc..).
"iconic brands" should be another conversation unless it matches description 1.
Swords... I don't know... If we go down that path it may just turn out as a list of major swords and sabers designs that could be found on a historical replicas website. An exception could be a sword so iconic that some of its specific design features was later passed down to knives?
As for what constitutes an iconic knife, while not wanting to go encyclopedic I still think there should be some objective evidence; either documented reference or general/regional concensus.
Just my 2 cents [emoji14] disagree at will!
Thank you. I am liking where you are going with this.
-
Another iconic knife/model: the french Douk-Douk.

-
I'm inclined to second Santos' Douk-Douk nomination, but I don't know how well known that knife is outside of the Mediterranean.
For me, the Douk-Douk is an iconic knife. It represents a lot of history and has cultural significance. But even many knife people may have a hard time describing a Douk-Douk or its origins.
-
Mercator K55K and Higonokami also come to mind.
I dont know what I started here but it has really got me looking into knive more than I've ever done. My poor dog had to hear my ramblings the other day as he was the only one who didn't start to walk away when I began. Today however he seems completely uninterested.
-
@Nix said:
I'm inclined to second Santos' Douk-Douk nomination, but I don't know how well known that knife is outside of the Mediterranean.For me, the Douk-Douk is an iconic knife. It represents a lot of history and has cultural significance. But even many knife people may have a hard time describing a Douk-Douk or its origins.
It has a very rich and long history. Chack this out:
-
The former Wikipedia article reminded me of the Okapi knife. Originally from South Africa, the ratchet-like lock is very unique and recognizable.

-
@pfrsantos said:
The former Wikipedia article reminded me of the Okapi knife. Originally from South Africa, the ratchet-like lock is very unique and recognizable.
The Spanish Navaja and even Laguiole, I'd also suggest the Texas Toothpick looks to be "similar". What neat is the Yatagan or Yataghan blade similarity. Dont have a clue if this influenced any or just possibly the Laguiole.
While history always wants to connect things sometimes it just not that easy. Parallel development does occur like the Falcata and Kopi as many experts have asserted. Humans need for cutting tools and weapons could have easily developed "like" tools and weapons.
Its a neat knife thats for certain.
-
The Douk-Douk, Mercator K55K and the Okapi knife were icons in their region before the internet made them more recognizable to knife knuts world wide.
I would vote for them as icons. -
What a discussion :o I had to play catch up here but I am glad I did
Lot of great thoughts in here peeps
I have collected knives my whole life pretty much and I am back and forth in my mind what is iconic ??? So many points to support both sides of many of these knives that I am having a hard time figuring all this out for myself now :ahhhAs a kid growing up in the 80s and in a knife collecting area and family. I knew of Swiss Army Knives but not the Vic or Wenger brand, I even had a Red Champion like one, I had a Rambo knife and cherished it as a young boy
I went out in the woods and played Rambo some even :D I also had many different traditionals plus a few not so traditionals ;) I had not heard of Opinel nor Spyderco then and only caught up with those brands and a few more like Mora, when I first came here
I had heard of the Douk Douk, I had a kukhuri, I had heard of Laguiole, of course I knew of Case and had a few of their knives as well
German brands of knives were widespread in this are and very common such as Boker, German Eye, Hen and Rooster and several other brands as well
I knew about Buck knives and even though I didn't own a Buck growing up I had several similar lockbacks reminiscent of the 110 and knew of Barlows and Sodbusters 
Sorry to ramble but I was just typing as I was thinking of things :D
Just look over this post if you get bored of my rambling
but I did want to add something to this great topic 
-
The K55K

-
Thanks Poncho for your post. Its been a neat journey even if the list has not quite been made. I am really enjoying the discussion.
-
@pfrsantos said:
The former Wikipedia article reminded me of the Okapi knife. Originally from South Africa, the ratchet-like lock is very unique and recognizable.Originally from Germany but made famous and then taken over by South Africa.
Hard working peoples knives.Also got a reputation in the Caribbean.
-
I haven't abandoned this thread
. I've been pondering the knives and wonderful contributions made to this thread. I'm gonna have a go at a list and we'll see what happens. Thank you for all the comments and suggestions. -
Big fan of the Buck 110, Douk Douk, Mercator k55k, and opinel.
The Mercator was with me today.
Anka

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
-
I just reread thru this thread. Man what a fantastic discussion. We made a lot of progress and even got a working list thanks to Dean and Syem plus all the input.
I was thinking of Dean and his contributions to this little project of mine. While I eventually abandoned this thread it was not for lack of interest. I was enthusiastically researching and reading every response from knowledgeable members. I'm going to revive this thread in a little bit using Deans list inspired by Syem.
The discussion was so fun and I appreciate everyone who contributed. Dean thank you for such a great conversation. Its one I always appreciated and hoped you did too.
-
I read through the thread... All of it. Wonderful discussion.
It's been hard to define a criteria for an iconic knife, probably because it means different things to different people... Which, by definition, means that there is no definition.

To me, I think of an iconic knife to be archetypal. I think it has to start with the perception of non-knife people, and it has to end with a percieved purpose of use. What's in between is a smattering of history, culture, and several other variables that have been debated throughout the thread.
Ultimately, it's the archetypes that tell me what knives are iconic. To borrow from another similar thread within the last year or two... The quintessential knife(s) in the archetype are iconic. The image of the knife will bring a name (which may not be the proper one) and a purpose of use to a non-knife-knut observer.
Some rambling thoughts -
Buck Knife: 110 to be precise. When something like it is shown on Into the Wild, every movie-goer knows exactly why the older man gives it to the younger one.
SAK: it has to be red. Everyone knows it's the thing with all the things that MacGyver used.
Laguiole/Opinel/Navaja: what the average person might call a fruit knife. It's a pocket knife used for food, not fighting.
Rambo/Crocodile Dundee/Bowie: survival and fighting
And so on and so forth. Many others fall into the iconic knife category in this way... The F-S, stilleto, and any American traditional, are some other examples.
The casual observer may not be able to pinpoint the difference between a Navaja and a Laguiole, or a Barlow vs a Trapper. But they conjure up the same ideas. Then it's up to us to determine if the knife fits the archetype. For example, 20 years ago I saw an Opinel being used in the break room at work. It was the first and last time I've seen one that I didn't own, in the wild. So even though there are very significant differences between an Opinel and a Laguiole, they're in the same archetype, and their differences make them stand up as iconic in their own right.
What I wonder is...
Modern folders - are there any that are truly iconic? I think Spyderco may have some recognition as a police officer's knife. I fear that anything else - Benchmade, Civivi, Emerson, what have you... I fear they're all lumped into the icon of pocket jewelry or weapons.
I wonder if any modern knife will ever become an icon. If the Bugout will be seen in the same light as the 110... Or a Leatherman Micra in the same light as a Case penknife.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


