Favorite Matches!
-
Rumaged around in my camping gear to find some old favorites:

Top to bottom:
Coghlan's Wind and Waterproof matches. These work very well, and I like the small box for packing in backpacking gear, typically in a ziplock bag.
Davis Instruments Hurricane Match. I forgot I had these not sure how they worked, but obviously I kept some. I'm not sure these are made any longer........
Diamond Strike Anywhere matches. Put these in for comparison.
REI Stormproof matches. These are really good. They look and act exactly like the UCO matches, and I bet they are made by UCO. I usually refill my UCO match safe with these.
It's snowing fairly heavily out at the moment. I went outside and fired off an REI Stormproof just for fun. Big flakes were falling and landing on the match, but to no real effect. The match just burnt like a road flare.

-
As far as match safes go, I just use those cheapo orange ones with the rubber o ring

For UCO matches, I trim the stick a little to fit them in
And I’ll cut out strikers from matchboxes to put in the containers.
-
A few more match safes:

Top row, left to right:
This small stainless steel match safe is interesting in that the cap unscrews, but is attached at the bottom so it can't be lost. I find it a bit awkward to use. I stuff a bit of cotton in the lid to keep the matches from shaking around. There is a rubber gasket in the lid, but I'm never sure this match safe is really waterproof. Still, it works and the knurled surface is great for striking 'strike anywhere' matches.
This brass safe is similar to the one I posted above. It does not screw down, but depends on a set of double o-rings to keep the lid on and water out. The lanyard also keeps the top locked down if it's cinched up. Unfortunately the compass in the top is 180º out of true. I don't know how this happened. Because of the messed up compass, this match safe is just a relic.
The bright green match safe is the same idea, but made of aluminum. Lighter than the brass versions which is excellent. This one has a Suunto compass in the top, but it has developed a medium sized bubble. The compass still points North reliably, but the bubble makes me doubt it's accuracy a bit. Still, a nice match safe.
Bottom row:
Orange UCO match safe. Big safe, but you get quite a few stormproof matches. The lid on this one is cracked, though.... (see below for details).
Orange plastic match safe. Simple and reliable. An o-ring keeps it waterproof. Hard to beat this light weight safe.
OD plastic (Army surplus?). Same as the orange one next to it. This has the advantage of have a tethered lid. I carried this one in a small emergency kit during hunting season.
UCO safe fail:
The UCO safe has developed a nasty crack. I'm not sure how. Possibly some idiot over-torqued the lid, but since I'm the only one who has used this match safe, that doesn't seem likely.


The safe still hold matches and a spare striker pad.....but it is no longer waterproof. So, for you guys who like UCO matches, be careful with the match safe. Or use REI matches in a box and just keep the box in a plastic bag. You have been warned.

-
What a great group of safes Nix. Thanks for the warning about over tightening the orange safes cap. I've been known to over torque things

-
Great pics, Nix
The matches are nice and love the boxes that they are in
the match safes are great as well
the dark green one I have is similar to the orange one beside the UCO one
Also I will need to go home and loosen my UCO one :ahhh I overtighten a few things as well ::) 
-
@CallsignBadger said:
As far as match safes go, I just use those cheapo orange ones with the rubber o ring
For UCO matches, I trim the stick a little to fit them in
And I’ll cut out strikers from matchboxes to put in the containers.
I have trimmed matches and cut strikers off as well
it is a great tip too 
-
Such an interesting thread, for such a basic item

-
-
For those that haven't seen the Zippo matches


-
They are longer than the UCO storm proof matches as well
I have seen these in person (they are like small torches) and almost bought them then
wished I had now
:D -
I can't imagine those Zippo matches being much different? They certainly look cool and the water proof case is nice addition. I'm off to look at a head to head comparison of those and UCO.
-
Not sure theres a HUGE difference.
https://youtu.be/nEdy92dE9Uw -
Thanks for ther video, Aloha
I may have just been amazed that Zippo had matches like that and was enamored to much to notice that the size difference wasn't as much as I thought
:D -
Seems like a good size safe though.
-
AS TESTED the UCOs seemed to be a bit "better".
The Zippo case is nice. Easy work around for the exterior striker on the UCO case. What I think I am seeing is the Zippo match has a longer area of material to burn while the UCO has thicker material.
. I think either will do well for what they are. A little shake of the match when submerged introduces some oxygen and the match relights. Instead of submerge, remove, and wait for the match to relight. Simple adjustment on using and the Zippos appear to be a nice match.I do like the Zippo match safe.
-
Really great video, Aloha
That one was a good head to head of the two
I have several of the UCO and may take a bit more time looking for a good deal on some Zippo ones now
I will still get them because I really do like the match safe but now I am thinking I already have the better matches with me :D -
@Poncho65 said:
Really great video, Aloha
That one was a good head to head of the two
I have several of the UCO and may take a bit more time looking for a good deal on some Zippo ones now
I will still get them because I really do like the match safe but now I am thinking I already have the better matches with me :D
-
Decided to take a few pics myself
First the matches and the respective boxes 

From top to bottom, the first is Coghlan Waterproof safety matches, next small red tipped Diamond Strike Anywhere matches, next to that is the UCO Stormproof matches, then the green tipped kitchen sized Diamond Strike Anywhere matches and lastly the red tipped kitchen sized Diamond Strike Anywhere matches

Then here is just the matches side by side UCO Stromproof on top followed by the green and red tipped Diamond Strike Anywhere kitchen matches, then theCoghlan Waterproof matches and at the bottom the Diamond red tipped Strike Anywhere matches


Then finally a pic of the 2 match safes that I have
The orange one is a UCO one with Stormproof matches and strikers inside , plus a bit of cotton
the green one is one I picked up many years ago and it has the green tipped kitchen Diamond Strike anywheres 

-
Great post, Poncho.

I've been thinking since you started this thread. The humble match we now take for granted must have transformed fire making when it was developed in the 1800's. Before that most methods were tedious and somewhat unreliable. Then along came the match.
While matches must have seemed nearly magical, it's interesting to note that in the 1908 version of Jack London's "To Build a Fire", the main character perishes despite having matches. He fails to take advantage of this precious resource, squandering his pack of matches in a last desperate...and failed...attempt to get his fire going.

-
Matches were a game changer for sure
that is a bit grimmer for the main character in that story :o but that is the reality of bad preparation or just plain old bad luck :-\ this thread has went in a good direction though and I am glad I revived it 
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login