Smart Home devices
-
What phone do you have Grant?
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
My goal is to convert my three unit building to as many smart features as possible. Got any recommendations?Def
Look at the WYZE cameras first of all,if you are thinking of a camara system these are so cheap and so great it is actually hard to accept!
2 weeks rolling recording is free too and you can stick cheap memory cards in them to record all the time.Ring now has a $100 price on the original video doorbell and that is tough to match with anything else though you do have to subscribe to keep the recordings.
I use August Systems Locks mostly as they provide the most robust interface and options and have been pretty reliable for me which is the most important feature really.
All of the Lock Makers stuff though is also entirely reliable it seems too,it sort of has to be.As for Lighting I like Lutron like I said but all of the mainstream systems are really good and Best Buy has them all sitting next to each other in stores so you can see and compare them directly there,sometimes.
The NEST T-Stats are really the best I think though not the cheapest but you do really get what you pay for here too.
You can easily combine them with NEST Smoke and Security detectors for a really simple system if you want to go there?I have used a Water Detector several times now that I really like but can not think of the name now for some reason?
These have actually saved 2 properties that I know of from disaster in real time by detecting and shutting off the house water main immediately and sending messages about it as well,talk about paying for itself!I mostly use SONOS for Music,there is not much like it that I have tried and I have tried!
Alexa works simply with all of these things and while I will never have that witch in my house,everyone that I does that I install loves her deeply.
I have yet to try the Google platform and am not sure that I will.
If its not Broke,I am not Fixing it with Alexa.
YMMV of course.
-
I'm an Apple fangirl.
In here mostly everything is HomeKit based combined with HomeBridge on the Raspberry Pi.
I have:
Logitech Circle cams
Nest thermostat
Philips Hue lights, switches and motion detectors
Ikea lights and plugs
Eve plugs, door sensors and thermometers
Xiaomi smoke detectors, thermometers,window sensors and plant sensors
Music is played through my HomePods and AirPort Expresses I've connected to active speakersI mostly use Siri. But… HomePods still don't speak Dutch. And sometimes, it's just easier to speak in your own language.
That's why I bought two Google Home Mini's. They also connect to Hue, Ikea and Nest, so I can control my lights and thermostat. First bought one for the bedroom, but I found so easy I bought a second one.
-
I am pretty much Apples Bitch myself but I am also migrating all networking away from the now abandoned Apple stuff to more modern and much faster gear.
I sell and install the only Apple based commercial Automation System, Savant and these are scalable up to an almost unlimited number of Zones and Devices but of course this is all at one end of the spectrum of toys that can be made.
Most systems that I install are capable of running all systems in a property by themselves and combining these into a single,simple front end for anyone to be able to understand is the fun and challenge of what I do.
My Clients are not Hobbyists at all but just people with big homes and families who want the toys.At the other end I try to standardize on established gear and while it is all do it yourself these days,I have no problem staying busy all time doing it for you instead thankfully!
So while there are many ways to do the same things these days my clients seem to prefer as integrated an approach and interface as I can give them as long as it works and this is often not the way I would do it for myself,if I wanted any of it in the first place.
Happily I do not.If it works without fail,I love it and that is enough for me!
@Serena said:
I'm an Apple fangirl.In here mostly everything is HomeKit based combined with HomeBridge on the Raspberry Pi.
I have:
Logitech Circle cams
Nest thermostat
Philips Hue lights, switches and motion detectors
Ikea lights and plugs
Eve plugs, door sensors and thermometers
Xiaomi smoke detectors, thermometers,window sensors and plant sensors
Music is played through my HomePods and AirPort Expresses I've connected to active speakersI mostly use Siri. But… HomePods still don't speak Dutch. And sometimes, it's just easier to speak in you own language.
That's why I bought two Google Home Mini's. They also connect to Hue, Ikea and Nest, so I can control my lights and thermostat. First bought one for the bedroom, but I found so easy I bought a second one.
-
Not an iPhone!
I've got a Samsung A8 and two Samsung tablets. The only Apple product I've ever owned was my father's original iPod that he gave me when he upgraded. I could never get any music on it so I just used it to play Breakout. I still have it around here somewhere.
I'd rather stick to Google and Android options wherever possible. I've already sold my soul to Google, I'd rather not do it again to Alexa or the ghost of Turtleneck Steve.

Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
What phone do you have Grant?
Not an iPhone!
I've got a Samsung A8 and two Samsung tablets. The only Apple product I've ever owned was my father's original iPod that he gave me when he upgraded. I could never get any music on it so I just used it to play Breakout. I still have it around here somewhere.
I'd rather stick to Google and Android options wherever possible. I've already sold my soul to Google, I'd rather not do it again to Alexa or the ghost of Turtleneck Steve.

Def
If you have a Samsung than the most logical option is to buy a Google Home. Those work perfectly together.
-
I have Google Home Minis in both of my homes. :D
Def
-
Seems to a degree Amazon is reading my mind, the Echo Input is basically a dot but without the speaker, so you add your own...
-
Anyone using IFTTT? I just discovered it last night, and it basically just adds a lot more commands and functionality to your phone and other smart devices.
Of course, one of the first things I did was set it to respond to the command "Execute Order 66" because... you know... priorities...

Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Anyone using IFTTT? I just discovered it last night, and it basically just adds a lot more commands and functionality to your phone and other smart devices.Of course, one of the first things I did was set it to respond to the command "Execute Order 66" because... you know... priorities...

Def
does it order 66 donairs?
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Anyone using IFTTT? I just discovered it last night, and it basically just adds a lot more commands and functionality to your phone and other smart devices.Of course, one of the first things I did was set it to respond to the command "Execute Order 66" because... you know... priorities...

Def
I use IFTTT as a Bridge between devices all the time as there are no Alexa Commands for many others devices.
I use them most for AV Remote stuff probably. -
I've got IFTTT ad had a test of it, but haven't needed to set any widgets up with it yet.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Anyone using IFTTT? I just discovered it last night, and it basically just adds a lot more commands and functionality to your phone and other smart devices.Of course, one of the first things I did was set it to respond to the command "Execute Order 66" because... you know... priorities...

Def
Yep, I use it a lot. For example for Social Media forwarding etc.
But also in the house. My lights flash when someone rings my doorbell. Just for fun… -
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Anyone using IFTTT? I just discovered it last night, and it basically just adds a lot more commands and functionality to your phone and other smart devices.
Of course, one of the first things I did was set it to respond to the command "Execute Order 66" because... you know... priorities...

Def
Yep, I use it a lot. For example for Social Media forwarding etc.
But also in the house. My lights flash when someone rings my doorbell. Just for fun…That seems like it would come in very handy for my father, who has a major hearing problem. It is because of his hearing issues that he got a Smarsmurfch- the buzzing on his wrist made a lot more sense than than a ringing/beeping phone did. When they had a land line it was hooked up to a strobe light for him, and the scary part is that he can be standing right under the smoke alarm and not hear it, so I have been thinking of getting them a smart smoke alarm too.
Def
-
I also automated the smoke alarm. If it goes off, ALL the lights in the house turn on at 100% brightness.
Did that in Apple Home btw.I have a Ring doorbel and Philips Hue lights.
The lights in the living room flash 3 or 4 times if someone rings the doorbell. -
I have a Client who was Paralyzed in an accident and has around the clock nursing care in home.
They are not supposed to drift off but sometimes in the middle of the night.....So I rigged an Alexa in his bedroom so that when he says "Alexa Get Help" it blasts the Beatles Help through Sonos Speakers around the house.
It took a while to get it working as you can not just ask Alexa for "Help" as she already thinks this means help with her?
She is sort of Bitchy about it too! -
I picked up a couple of smart plugs the other day because I got a good deal on them. Unfortunately I ended up with exactly the same issue that the person I bought them from had- they seem to only work with a 2.5ghz router and I only have a 5ghz router so they are virtually useless to me.

I am pretty sure Megan has a dual band router in Ottawa, so they will probably go back with her when she visits next.
Def
-
I managed to wheel and deal a little bit today and got a 3rd Generation Alexa Echo Dot. And I though Google Home Mini had a long name...

The first thing I noticed, immediately out of the box, is that Alexa is HEAVY!
Both the Alexa Dot and Google Home Mini went on the scale (without their power cords) and the Mini came in at 174g versus 295g (6.1 oz vs 10.4 oz respectively). This is likely due to the better speaker on Alexa- we all know Alexa has better hardware while Google has the better software, or at least that seems to be the general consensus. I would concur as well, at least as far as my initial testing has taken me. But I am getting ahead of myself.
I will say that I also prefer Alexa's fancy circular light to the Mini's 4 dots. It is a lot easier to see if she's listening- and yes, I have fallen into the trap of calling them "she" because of the female voice on them. Yes, you can change it, but I'm pretty sure I prefer the female voice. Maybe I am sexist, wanting a female assistant, but I prefer to think of it as just preferring that the competent and helpful voice around the house doesn't sound like it's going to have a few beers later and take a swing at me.
Bear in mind that some of what I am about to say is the result of me already having Google Assistant software on my phone.
Alexa was harder to set up initially.
With the Google Home Mini, the app on my phone asked me if I wanted to connect my Mini to the same router, using the settings the phone used. I said yes and it did the rest for me. The app (Google Home) was already installed on my phone, and I believe it is already on most (all?) Android devices as part of the OS.
For Alexa I had to download the Alexa app on my phone, then connect to the device, then select the router and input the password. Not a big deal for most of us, but Google was a lot easier.
I then had to create a voice profile for Alexa, which resulted in me having to repeat ten phrases for her. With Google, creating a voice profile is a lot easier, as I think (if I recall correctly anyway, it has been a while since I set it up) you just say "Ok Google" three times and it's ready to go.
The speaker on the Dot is easily far superior to that of the Home Mini, and the light show you get while things are playing is much cooler, although I wonder what it is like to fall asleep to?
If you ask Google Home whether she is better than Alexa (or Siri, or Cortana etc) she will come up with one of many phrases that are amusing and noncommittal, while praising the others.
For example- I asked Google Home Mini right now whether she was better than Alexa. Google responded that she was sure that Alexa loved Canada as much as she did, and that she (Google) was looking forward to them singing the national anthem together someday. She then played O Canada.
I then asked her again and she said "I couldn't compare myself to Alexa- assistants have to stick together."
If you ask Alexa, she just says "I like all AI's" every time.
Not a big deal really, but it shows you that the difference between Alexa's AI and Google's is just as far apart as the difference between Google's speaker and Alexa's. Google's speaker is perfectly functional and adequate, but if you had Alexa first you'd be disappointed in it. Alexa's responses seem a lot more generic. Again, it is obvious in the Easter Eggs. Asking each of them silly questions like "will you be my girlfriend" or "drop a beat" and you will get the same (amusing) responses from Alexa each time. Ask the same questions to Google Home and it will come up with a different amusing answer every time.
For example:
How are babies made?
Alexa- "Babes are made through the process of reproduction."
Google- Actually gives the scientific process and then sends a link to your phone in case you want to know moreIs there a Santa?
Alexa- "Santa makes a lot of people Ho Ho Hopeful for a happy holiday and I definitely believe in that"
Google- dial tone, touch tones, elf switchboard, operator connects you to Santa, who then asks you to help him choose what band to have for Elfstock. Say yes you will help and it starts asking you some follow up questions which then leads to a holiday song.If your kids don't believe Santa exists after that virtual, simulated two way conversation, then you have failed miserably as a parent. :P
All in all, I like them both, but I think (at least so far, bear in mind I have only had Alexa for an hour or so!) if I had to choose one, I would stick with Google. I will continue to test them against each other over the next little while and let you know if I change my mind.
Def
-
The big reason for my indecision to jump on the black friday/holiday sales was that I want the amazon hardware with the google software
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



