Cull Update
-
@Happy Gilmore said:
This discussion has made me realize.. are there any knifeless multi-tools that have outside facing tools? Seems like a quick deploy outside facing tool would be great.There's small ones, like the knifeless version of the Dime and the Style PS. There's also the newer versions of the Sync that have just been announced. However, no "full sized" external access knifeless tools spring to mind.
-
@Happy Gilmore said:
This discussion has made me realize.. are there any knifeless multi-tools that have outside facing tools? Seems like a quick deploy outside facing tool would be great.
There's small ones, like the knifeless version of the Dime and the Style PS. There's also the newer versions of the Sync that have just been announced. However, no "full sized" external access knifeless tools spring to mind.
Maybe the P2 will be that tool, all I need to do is replace the blade with another tool.
Cheers,
HG -
Following on from before, here's part of the cluster of keyring sized items which are also part of the thinning out process. Why only part of them? Well, that will become clear in the next post or two.

-
Now we get to the fun bit, or at least, the fun bit for me. Weighing up one tool against another is all well and good, but that doesn't take into account the fact that I very rarely will only carry one pocket tool. As I mentioned before, the only one I might do that with is the Gerber Balance.
Most of the time, I'll have a combination of items, and as far as I'm concerned, combos are king. I find that it's how good a combo I can put together which dictates how frequently something gets carried, rather than how good individual items are. This is also how I was able to easily offload the stuff that went before taking these pictures without any sellers remorse. It wasn't just about an item not quite meeting my requirements, but about other tools building better combos.
The combos don't need to be large. The tool cluster on my keyring is a good example of that (Pic 1). A Gerber Dime, Utilikey and Nitecore tube. Some days this might be all I have. Other days, I might have the neck lanyard in the second picture, or I might have one of the trios from picture three. A good basic combo (for me) consists of scissors, knife, awl (or some form of general purpose pokey thing), pliers and Phillips. Not all combos need all of these, but it is the general template that I like to build around.
There's other "rules" too, such as making sure that if I'm carrying a locking blade tool, fixed blade, or a pocket clipped OHO folder, which some people might get the wrong impression from, I'll also have a low key traditional knife or other "people friendly" option, in case I need to use a blade in the midst of people who don't know me. But more on that later...



-
I do have some combos, which don't tend to get reached for, unless I'm doing a specific activity. For example, outdoorsy stuff is when the higher visibility stuff comes out to play.
The knifeless Fuse modification has two key shortages. A knife blade, and can/bottle openers. The Scout Jr handles both those roles easily. Also, whilst the Fuse has a custom awl which Eric (Metro) milled for me, there's also a good substantial awl on the knife, which is great for poking out stuff jammed in your boot tread, without either having to get the pliers tool out, or damaging the sharp edge on the custom awl. On top of all that, the knife can stay attached to me (along with a few other useful goodies) so it's unlikely to fall out of my pocket without me noticing. The kit can also be supplemented as required, if that little knife blade won't be up to the tasks I think I'm liable to encounter.
The lightweight version of all this, is the KF4 and Climber Small combo, again, most stuff I expect to encounter will be handles by the pocket knife, but I do have a small pliers tool with an assortment of useful functions should I need something that the 84mm Vic can't handle.
These two combos are hands down the best that I've come up with for the role. A great balance of size, weight and function. Easy to find should I drop it, or place it down to free my hand up for something, and therefore a good chance of them all making the journey back home with me.



-
I mentioned earlier, that the TurboDiesel resided in a "grab bag" for taking with me if I was visiting friends or family where odd jobs might need doing. I also grabbed this kit if someone was moving house, or there was some other activity where surprise jobs might arise. This kit has been a real day saver on many occasions.
Obviously the Diesel is knifeless, so the Boker XS takes care of that, as does the Swann Morton craft knife in the bottom right of the pic. The Soft Touch 14 is also on hand for when the XS might cause a stampede of unwanted questions. It also provides splinters, a better awl than the can opener on the Diesel (which does work very well as a scribe though), and as the can opener is BO coated, I won't use it for food, so the Wenger handles that too.
I also have the bit kit for the Diesel, and a couple of hacksaw blades which fit the blade carrier. The marking and measuring tools, plus the adjustable spanner and Knipex Cobra, round this kit off very nicely. I usually have some superglue and little tie wraps in there too, but they've been used and need replacing.
EDIT:
the Gerber Shard should have been in that picture too.
-
Not every combo is so rigidly defined. Some are more "mix and match". There's still a logic path of sorts though.
For example, if I fancy carrying a clipped folder, I need a "people friendly" option too, so that's either a traditional knife, or a Swiss knife with scissors. I see no benefit to carrying a Swiss knife WITHOUT scissors. I made that mistake on my first one, a Tourist, and that now lives in the kitchen drawer.
If I choose to pair the clipped folder with a traditional knife, or even forego the clipped folder and just carry a trad, I need a pliers tool with good enough scissors that I can get by without a Swissie. The top two choices here, are the MP400 modification, and the Balance. I may however go for the knifeless Wave instead, should I want a more heavily loaded toolset. The Balance does have its own non-locking sub 3" blade, but it's not the world's greatest, to be honest. Adding another plain edge blade gives me the option of serrations or not, but the Balance blade is people friendly enough that I can choose to carry it on its own, or add EITHER a clipped blade or traditional. I don't really need both like I do if I carry a clipped folder with the MP400. If I chose to, I can omit the clipped folder, and still have a good urban carry setup with either tool.
If however, I choose to go the Swiss knife route, a Sideclip or the knifeless Octane, provides both Phillips and pliers in a slim package, so I don't need a knife with inline Phillips. This gives me the choice of a wood or stainless Wenger Traveler, Salesman, the Sheepsfoot Duke, or the Original Outdoorsman, which not only adds a saw and file, but serrated and pruner blades too. Of course, I can forego the clipped folder here too, and still have a great urban pairing.


-
I really enjoyed the posts, thoughts and pics in here!

Totally agree with you on the Diesel, and this:@AimlessWanderer said:
On top of all those options for pocket carry, there's also a few tools that never leave home. These just sit on or near the desk, in case I need something special a regular multi can't provide, namely heavy duty shears, compound leverage pliers, or locking pliers. I don't actually have any dedicated tools to compete with those functions that these multitools provide.this applies to me and my tools as well,

-
@ThePeacent said:
I really enjoyed the posts, thoughts and pics in here!

Totally agree with you on the Diesel, and this:On top of all those options for pocket carry, there's also a few tools that never leave home. These just sit on or near the desk, in case I need something special a regular multi can't provide, namely heavy duty shears, compound leverage pliers, or locking pliers. I don't actually have any dedicated tools to compete with those functions that these multitools provide.
this applies to me and my tools as well,

Thanks TP
It's useful for me to "think out loud" like this, and good to know others enjoy following along :) -
What I find interesting is, no matter how many times we begin the "process" we will always tend to have more than we "need". I try to stay away from the "need" perspective. Reason being, simply because I like certain tools regardless if they are used, seldom used, or not used at all
. YMMV as each of us knows what works best for ourselves.Unlike the long standing myth of Crows collecting shiny things, we however as humans do. Its just that way and I'm a lot better at accepting it. That being said, I've gone thru many of my tools and culled quite a lot. I go thru periods of separating the tools I feel I no longer "need" and place them aside for further analysis. A few tools continue on their way to new homes and new owners while many return to their dark resting place :D.
I'm am thankful to not have been so hasty with some tools. I also make it a point as you allude to, to put certain tools into use to get a clearer understanding of that tool or as you state "Maybe I ought to force myself to start carrying them all more, and see which ones I get sick of quickest." My Skeletool CX is such a tool. I am glad I just put it aside and let enough time pass to try again. My Charge TTi is another.
I am not hesitant to assign a tool a purpose even if that purpose on the surface is lowly ;). I don't currently have a bathroom drain tool, YET
. I have tools parceled about my home. I have them on my coffee table, in my shed, garage, kitchen drawer, hall closet, small tool box, vehicle, evacuation bag, and other places. These are tools that are good tools just not tools I want to carry. This is yet another distinction I tend to make when deciding a tools fate. Just because I don't want to carry it doesn't mean its time to go.I really like this thread.

-
@Aloha said:
What I find interesting is, no matter how many times we begin the "process" we will always tend to have more than we "need". I try to stay away from the "need" perspective. Reason being, simply because I like certain tools regardless if they are used, seldom used, or not used at all
. YMMV as each of us knows what works best for ourselves.Unlike the long standing myth of Crows collecting shiny things, we however as humans do. Its just that way and I'm a lot better at accepting it. That being said, I've gone thru many of my tools and culled quite a lot. I go thru periods of separating the tools I feel I no longer "need" and place them aside for further analysis. A few tools continue on their way to new homes and new owners while many return to their dark resting place :D.
I'm am thankful to not have been so hasty with some tools. I also make it a point as you allude to, to put certain tools into use to get a clearer understanding of that tool or as you state "Maybe I ought to force myself to start carrying them all more, and see which ones I get sick of quickest." My Skeletool CX is such a tool. I am glad I just put it aside and let enough time pass to try again. My Charge TTi is another.
I am not hesitant to assign a tool a purpose even if that purpose on the surface is lowly ;). I don't currently have a bathroom drain tool, YET
. I have tools parceled about my home. I have them on my coffee table, in my shed, garage, kitchen drawer, hall closet, small tool box, vehicle, evacuation bag, and other places. These are tools that are good tools just not tools I want to carry. This is yet another distinction I tend to make when deciding a tools fate. Just because I don't want to carry it doesn't mean its time to go.I really like this thread.

You raise some good points there.

I just don't like owning stuff which I know I'll never use. It doesn't matter how infrequently I might reach for it, I just need to know that at some point I WILL reach for it.
The four tools that stay on my desk are good examples of this. It's very rarely that I will need locking pliers, compound leverage, or heavy duty shears. However, when you do need that, nothing else will do. Likewise, the bright orange and yellow combos are the best tools for that role. The last time I toted the bright orange kit was the UK meet, and I haven't pocketed the yellow combo for several months either, but when the time comes for me to be off tarmac, with mud, grass or shingle beneath my feet, those are absolutely the combos I want with me.
The ones I've already parted with, are the ones that I'd only use if I forced myself to. In all other situations, I'd have reached for one of the tools or combos I've posted pics of in this thread. The point of the journey for me, was always to find my ideal tools, I just failed to dispose as quickly as I acquired, but that gave me more assessment time with each item. Some trends became clear deal breakers for me, such as 3+ blade slippies, splayed handles, impeded gripping areas, Swissies without scissors, obvious design or production failings (such as the Flik pawls, I've just been discussing in another thread), and meant I could avoid or offload clumps of items easily. Now I'm just down to too many good workable options.
I still want to keep an element of surplus and redundancy, specifically a Plan B for each role or category in case of loss or breakage. That's why there's two Spirits and two Sideclips. The yellow and orange combos serve as a "reserve" for each other too. Yet I don't want five of something in the drawer, when I'll only ever reach for one or two of them. If there's something in there that's always overlooked for something else, I need to question why it's there at all.
I could come up with some convoluted reason for keeping everything, but I know when I look at the big group shots, there is no sensible justification for me other than pride of ownership - but ownership alone doesn't make me content. I have to feel benefit from it as a tool, not just a possession. That's just my quirks though, and I fully understand and appreciate that others think differently. So I feel the need to streamline, without losing options, back up plans, versatility, and suitability, which is where the tricky decisions come in :D
-
It is super tricky to find that balance you seek. There are some tools that can be easily parted with after trying and trying. I know those all too well. Back ups are good. Once I deem a tool a back up then I make peace with it so I don't deliberate on and on about selling or keeping.
Beater tools. I have tools that are tools I have no problem working hard with little regard. It if breaks then it breaks. I have a Swisstool in my garage for that as well as in my house tool box. I don't mind keeping them in their places. Out of sight, out of mind, till of course I need them. I have a few SAKs and folders that also fall into this category.
Next up the ladder are tools that are on standby. These tools are good tools that have proven themselves. I keep them closer at hand for things that pop up. My OG Surge and Modded Wave are my coffee table tools. If I need a tools I grab these first. If I need dedicated tools then I get my house tool box. If I need more specialized tools then out to the garage. I keep a SAK, folder, and Micra on my coffee table as well as a headlamp.
Further up the ladder are my on person tools while home doing chores. These are tools I rely on as I will have them on person. Today for example I have my Skeletool CX, OC Farmer, Squirt P4, and Benchmade Nimravus on me. If I require more then I can go to my garage or house tool box. If my Farmers saw comes up short for example, I'll go to my shed and fetch my saw. If my Skeletools pliers are a bit weak then out to my garage to get the big channel locks.
Work tools. This is much like my on person tools except that these tools are only used at work. My Charge TTi, Deluxe Tinker are examples of those tools. I like both tools a lot. They earned their spot on work detail.
Off day tools. I have tools that I carry off days. These are tools that I will leaving the house with on off days. Errands, trips to the store, lunch with my kids, etc.
Hiking, camping, walks tools, evacuation bag tools, etc.
Like many here I ended up with a lot of tools. Some were easily moved on. Some are just wonderful and are now shelf queens. Some have jobs. The spillover tools are the ones I have a hard time with, I've recently referred to these as benchwarmers. These are tools that aren't back ups, aren't still being tested, aren't bad tools, they are just EXTRA stuff accumulated over this process.
I think many of us who aren't actively collecting or seeking out tools to collect find ourselves in similar circumstances. I am still a collector to an extent admittedly. Funny thing is, I just don't know what the next tool I'd designate to shelf queen status until I meet it
. -
@Aloha said:
It is super tricky to find that balance you seek. There are some tools that can be easily parted with after trying and trying. I know those all too well. Back ups are good. Once I deem a tool a back up then I make peace with it so I don't deliberate on and on about selling or keeping.Beater tools. I have tools that are tools I have no problem working hard with little regard. It if breaks then it breaks. I have a Swisstool in my garage for that as well as in my house tool box. I don't mind keeping them in their places. Out of sight, out of mind, till of course I need them. I have a few SAKs and folders that also fall into this category.
Next up the ladder are tools that are on standby. These tools are good tools that have proven themselves. I keep them closer at hand for things that pop up. My OG Surge and Modded Wave are my coffee table tools. If I need a tools I grab these first. If I need dedicated tools then I get my house tool box. If I need more specialized tools then out to the garage. I keep a SAK, folder, and Micra on my coffee table as well as a headlamp.
Further up the ladder are my on person tools while home doing chores. These are tools I rely on as I will have them on person. Today for example I have my Skeletool CX, OC Farmer, Squirt P4, and Benchmade Nimravus on me. If I require more then I can go to my garage or house tool box. If my Farmers saw comes up short for example, I'll go to my shed and fetch my saw. If my Skeletools pliers are a bit weak then out to my garage to get the big channel locks.
Work tools. This is much like my on person tools except that these tools are only used at work. My Charge TTi, Deluxe Tinker are examples of those tools. I like both tools a lot. They earned their spot on work detail.
Off day tools. I have tools that I carry off days. These are tools that I will leaving the house with on off days. Errands, trips to the store, lunch with my kids, etc.
Hiking, camping, walks tools, evacuation bag tools, etc.
Like many here I ended up with a lot of tools. Some were easily moved on. Some are just wonderful and are now shelf queens. Some have jobs. The spillover tools are the ones I have a hard time with, I've recently referred to these as benchwarmers. These are tools that aren't back ups, aren't still being tested, aren't bad tools, they are just EXTRA stuff accumulated over this process.
I think many of us who aren't actively collecting or seeking out tools to collect find ourselves in similar circumstances. I am still a collector to an extent admittedly. Funny thing is, I just don't know what the next tool I'd designate to shelf queen status until I meet it
.That sounds very much like I used to do. :) I had all the above categories that I made posts on, plus the ones I haven't mentioned yet (waiting for natural daylight for more pics), then I'd have my work tools, my car tools, and my boat tools. Those last three categories no longer apply,
When I had more facets to my life, I needed more tools. As my life has simplified, I'm looking to simplify the tool array to suit. Even when I've done, I'll still have more tools than "normal people" do :D However, I'll have the very best suited tools for my evolved preferences, and tested methods.
I've got a few more combos to chuck up here when I get some daylight, then I plan to move onto looking at what didn't work, what things still feel incomplete, what's needed to fix them, where I might be able to simplify overlapping areas, or redefine the boundaries between them. The stuff I've posted so far, is some (most) of the background to the thought processes which follow next. I'm trying to not just show my tools and explain why they're here, but open up the thought processes about what's next, as well as what's behind me.
-
Moving on to the Spirit, which as mentioned earlier, is the last locking bladed tool in the array. This is a tool that tends to either get used at home, or taken with me if I'm going to be staying somewhere for a while - either on holiday, or staying with friends and family. It's an excellent tool for that, as the tool set is so diverse, you're unlikely to ever encounter a challenge that the Spirit doesn't offer something to attempt to conquer it with.
There's still the chance I might end up in the midst of people who don't know my intentions though, and still like to have a good "people friendly" option to hand. As such, I tend to carry a more capable (heavily tooled) Swiss knife, so there's a higher probability that I won't need the Spirit. Specifically, I want a Swiss knife with a Phillips. So while the Spirit is a fantastic tool, I only want to use it when not surrounded by idiots, or when all else has failed.
I may or may not choose to add a clipped OHO folder to the ensemble, but a Swissie with Phillips forms the foundation for a combo with a Spirit for me.

-
The only two full sized tools that haven't been attributed to a combo yet, are the MP6000 and the knifeless Wave. Both these are very capable tools in their own right, and the only thing they're missing, are the plain and serrated blades they started out with. The Wings Slipit nips that problem in the bud.
I don't know exactly what it is about the Wings, but it's the only one of my clipped OHO folders, that I feel comfortable not carrying a "people friendly" option with too. It just seems inherently less "tacti-cool" than the others. I do wish I'd picked up a spare when they were still in circulation.
I do have a people friendly alternative though, in the Victorinox Original Outdoorsman, which carries both serrated knife and pruned blade.

-
As regards spares and back ups, the modified MP600 and Wave also overlap with the Diesel, and each could serve as a replacement for one of the others, should they be wrecked, lost, or stolen.
The Wave does get carried a fair bit, but the MP600 does not, even though I really like that mod. The issue is the blunt pliers. It made sense to have a blunt pliers tool in engineering or marine setting, where I might need a little more grunt from my pliers, but it's overkill in my current lifestyle. A standard hybrid needlenose plier would probably be a better urban tool.
Luckily, I can do that. I do have a regular MP600 with integral cutters (I've no love for the evaporating carbide ones), in a pair of black handles. That would make this tool a much better pairing/alternative for the Wave as a fully loaded urban tool, as a step up from the MP400 or Balance mentioned a whileback.
The only reason to keep the blunt nosed pliers in it, would be for hobby use at home, and assign this tool to the other speSmurfpillsed ones with the shears, compound leverage, and locking pliers. However, unlike those tools, I do have several other dedicated options that I could reach for instead.


-
Of course, the other option for carrying more tools in an urban combo, is stick with the lighter, simpler pliers tools, and carry a thicker and more tool heavy Swiss knife instead. This can make more sense when pocket space is limited (I don't do the Batman utility belt sheath thing for several reasons), or you don't want to be faffing around with a pliers tool for everything that might need doing. Sometimes it's nice to just let the knife do the bulk of the work.

-
One of my combo themes, still isn't complete, even after all these years, and I've come to the conclusion that I won't be happy until I build my own solution - and that's formal carry.
When it's time to get suited up, a different set of tools come out to play. I want something light, pocketable without "printing", more glamorous looking than usual, and yet still be able to handle tasks that I realistically expect I might encounter.
At the larger end of the options, is a Wenger Traveler and Sideclip. I never got my hands on a polished version, but intend to polish one of mine up. I have some micro-mesh cloth, and some of those multi-grit nail buffer pads for that specific reason.
If I want to go lighter than that, I have the scrolled bolster Case barlow, and a decent little stainless toolset with quartz pocket watch, which will easily distribute about my person. I haven't quite got the "yellow metal" one complete though, to pair up with the gold plated mechanical watch. I do have the TiNi pliers and Cu Maratac, but need to carry out my intended modification of a Victorinox Executive to really round off that set.

-
Good thread Al and I'm enjoying reading your thoughts regarding what and why you carry .

-
One way of managing combos like all these, is to relate them to shoes. Bear with me, there is a logic path here, honest! :D
Lets go back over some combos to illustrate my point.
Hiking Boots
Spoiler:
Work Boots
Spoiler:
Polished dress shoes
Spoiler:
Light trainers or sandals
Spoiler:
Slippers (at home, or on holiday)
Spoiler:
And then there's the issue of the casual shoes for ordinary daily carry. Here's where is goes completely ape.
While I've posted pics only showing one or two combo formats at a time, once you push the "specific role combos" to one side, there's a huge abundance of regular daily carry options.... and it will get worse, before it gets better...

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login