How to determine value...it's difficult
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
My way of valuing things, is imagine the pile of money next to the item. So if a NIB Scientist was sat next to £100, which would I walk away with? I'd take the cash. Others might not. The value is the point at which you'd leave the cash and grab the item. This also allows for my opinion on something's worth fluctuating over time, depending on what my priorities are. Now the value that I put on something, might not be reflected in the market, which probably accounts for why there are some things I never bought, but it also stops me feeling like I've overpaid for things.That’s a very interesting perspective. I like it.
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
My way of valuing things, is imagine the pile of money next to the item. So if a NIB Scientist was sat next to £100, which would I walk away with? I'd take the cash.The SAK is more likely to increase in value than the stack of £, unless they bin Brexit.
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk
-
My way of valuing things, is imagine the pile of money next to the item. So if a NIB Scientist was sat next to £100, which would I walk away with? I'd take the cash.
The SAK is more likely to increase in value than the stack of £, unless they bin Brexit.
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk
I don't make the decision based on what the item might be worth to someone else, either now, or in the future. The decision is based on what it is worth to me.
Lets not bring politics into this.
-
Thank you for your insights kamakiri, I enjoyed reading them.


Thanks to you both! I have a problem with overthinking things and analysis paralysis. 
Just easier to hit Buy-it-Now and ponder 'what have I done?' later. :D
-
I didn't buy this, but WOW. Bid at $282 for a Fisherman labelled 'Fieldmaster'...not sure what label is on the box, but there's a catalog listing for $14.70 from the '60s...for a Craftsman.

I gotta wonder what the label on the box says.

Crazy. I bet the boxes got mixed up almost 60 years ago.
-
That SAK is a good example of how difficult it is to determine value. It was obviously valuable to the person who bought it. Maybe the box does say Fisherman.

The auction ended higher than I thought it would, but then, if I had a Fisherman with bail and lost it, I'd probably bid a fair amount to have an older one again for sentimental reasons. -
I started thinking about that box and remembered my Woodsman has the same box.
I wonder how long they used the box because my large awl Woodsman is original to the box, and I see that the Fisherman is newer without the large awl.

-
As a side note, there was a time when I thought the value of an exposed rivet SAK was $100 per layer. It held true for some ended auctions that I saw and/or bought.
-
@FolderBeholder said:
I started thinking about that box and remembered my Woodsman has the same box.
I wonder how long they used the box because my large awl Woodsman is original to the box, and I see that the Fisherman is newer without the large awl.
That's the same box my exposed rivet Champion has
-
@FolderBeholder said:
That SAK is a good example of how difficult it is to determine value. It was obviously valuable to the person who bought it. Maybe the box does say Fisherman.
The auction ended higher than I thought it would, but then, if I had a Fisherman with bail and lost it, I'd probably bid a fair amount to have an older one again for sentimental reasons.I certainly understand that. I have a problem If I think it's been too long a losing streak with a particular model. At some point I just buck up and pay.
@FolderBeholder said:
I started thinking about that box and remembered my Woodsman has the same box.
I wonder how long they used the box because my large awl Woodsman is original to the box, and I see that the Fisherman is newer without the large awl.

Good question and I don't know, but they could be somewhat close in production if that Fisherman is early '60s and yours is at the tail of the exposed pin range in the mid '50s?
@VICMAN said:
That's the same box my exposed rivet Champion hasNice samples from you both!

-
That's the same box my exposed rivet Champion has
Love that one Vicman!

Thanks FB!

-
@FolderBeholder said:
As a side note, there was a time when I thought the value of an exposed rivet SAK was $100 per layer. It held true for some ended auctions that I saw and/or bought.That's an interesting rule of thumb. I'll keep that in mind with future purchases or next time I chase one in good condition. Certainly makes some of mine feel like real steals!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
