Smart Home devices
-
The big reason for my indecision to jump on the black friday/holiday sales was that I want the amazon hardware with the google software
-
I feel like that is what we all want.

Def
-
It turns out that my preference for Google's superior software is not as cut and dried as I thought.
Compared to Google Assistant, Alexa is pretty dumb, but you can add more functionality with IFTTT, and that helps a lot. There is also a lot more setup with Alexa, such as having to give her access to your GPS data and phone, and then still having to input your location for weather data. Imagine how unamused I was when I gave her access to GPS data, then asked what the weather was, and she said she couldn't answer because she didn't know where I was. :facepalm:
Alexa cannot find your phone, and the weather data on the app appears to be stuck in F instead of C, although Alexa now reads me the weather in C. The app is kind of difficult to navigate as there are a lot of submenus to go through to get what you want. The Google app is also difficult to use for similar reasons- there are less submenus to navigate since it does a lot of stuff natively (assuming you have an Android phone or tablet) but the options are graphical and so you may have to guess the right icon to be in to accomplish something.
Using IFTTT though you can fix some of the things that Alexa doesn't do- sort of. I installed the Alexa find my phone option, and it worked, except that the VOIP call she made to my phone took almost ten minutes to actually ring my phone. If you are looking for your phone, you probably don't want to wait ten minutes for help finding it. :facepalm:
While it looks like Alexa may be kind of useless, at least by comparison, the hardware is much better. And I mean by a lot. I hadn't realized how tinny the Home Mini speaker was, and I find myself not having to yell at Alexa as often as I had to at Google, especially if it was playing the radio or music. And the sound coming out of it is far superior.
One annoying thing regarding sound on Alexa though- the timer.
When using the timer on Google (which I do a lot) it makes a noticeable but not too annoying alert. That's what you want in a timer, something you will notice, but not be terribly upsetting if you can't get to it to shut it off right away. The Alexa version beeps at you as if it was programmed by Milton from Office Space:
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
In fact, the first time I used it, I actually had to ask Alexa what the noise was and what it was trying to tell me. Of course, it couldn't answer that question. :facepalm:
I think that you can't make a bad decision getting either of these, but stick to whichever one you get, because you will judge the other harshly by what you get used to. If you get Alexa first you will get used to the better sound and microphone, and you won't really know what you are missing with the lack of functions. If you get a Google Home device first, you will appreciate how easy it is to set up and use, and how many things it can do, and the sound quality won't bug you, because again, you won't know what you are missing.
I have relegated Google to the bedroom as I prefer the morning and nighttime routines with it, and Alexa has taken over in the living room because I listen to the radio much of the day (if for no other reason than to keep the dogs from hearing and barking at things outside) and the sound quality is much better- it fills the room much nicer. The living room is also next to the kitchen, and the better microphone is handier when I am making supper. I just have to really listen for the alarm at the end. And, if I need a Google service when I am not in or near the bedroom, my phone is usually happy to do the job.
Def
-
I'm sticking with Alexa, I've got 6 of them now so no going back for me. I've also just bought my sister one for her birthday as she has been wanting one since she saw mine. She's an apple fangirl so really should get the homepod thingy they do, but they are way to expensive.
-
@Kev D said:
I'm sticking with Alexa, I've got 6 of them now so no going back for me. I've also just bought my sister one for her birthday as she has been wanting one since she saw mine. She's an apple fangirl so really should get the homepod thingy they do, but they are way to expensive.I agree- if you have one, don't go to the other. There's not much point in that. I think what bothers me is that they both have a call (intercom) feature, but as far as I can tell, they are not able to call eachother, which seems silly. Maybe there is something in IFTTT, but in the end it doesn't make much difference to me as my place is small enough- if I speak loud enough that either will hear me, chances are the person in the other room I am trying to communicate with will hear me too.
Having both will either make you appreciate what they each do better than the other, or more likely, frustrate you when you want to do something that device doesn't do.
My Chromecast should arrive next week, and, as I understand it, Alexa won't talk to it, so that will be another interesting test.
Def
-
I have Siri and Google. Because Apple ignores The Netherlands (No Apple pay, no HomePods (I do have them), no Dutch Siri on the HomePods etc.) I bought the Google mini's.
Talk to them for accessing 1 item. For the scenes I stick with Siri. -
I like the drop in feature on the Echo's, but I wish when they released a new feature it was world wide. Still not able to call phones with them unless they have the Alexa app. In the US you can call any number in your contacts.
-
I am making my first call on the Alexa right now.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I am making my first call on the Alexa right now.Def
Are you still waiting for an answer :ahhh
:D
-
No, it actually worked quite well.
Just like any other speaker phone anyway. :D
Def
-
Good to know

-
One thing to remember when using it to make calls is that they tend to come up on the other person's phone as Unknown Name, Unknown Number or similar, so the person on the other end may not bother responding.
That's why it had taken me so long to actually make a call on it- no one answered the first few times.
Def
-
Amazon echo and dots are reduced again in their spring sale
-
I have a dot on the way, spring sale in Spain means 35 instead of 60.
-
Dot arrived, plugged in, was pretty painless to setup to be honest
Haven't done much with it yet but I'm liking what I see so far
-
There's a battery speaker base for the dot 3 now, the reviews say it gives better sound than the echo plus and gives 8 hours of power. I'll get one sometime for use when I'm doing bbq's
-
Really haven't used any of my smart devices in a bit :ahhh Need to use them more I guess
Still debating on when and what to get with smart bulbs and plugs
I have also been looking really hard at the Nest Thermostat 
-
mostly been using ours for timers and alarms so far, and a bit of music.
-
I have been using mine largely for watching TV (Mini controls Netflix and Chromecast very well), as well as timers, reference info (weather, conversions etc), music and news.
I also love the Chromecast for the slideshows. I have it set to show photos of friends and family photos that I have stored in Google Photos and it randomly shows them on the TV. It is great to be reminded of various adventures that we've been on- most of the time I can identify them immediately, but some of them I have completely forgotten about, and it's great to be reminded! :D
Def
-
Echo Dots are on offer again
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



