Bustin' out the traditionals, a 30-day challenge
-
@Nix said:
At some point those would seem to slip away from the intent of the tag, 'traditional'. A drop-point 110 with nylon scales starts to look awfully modern to me. And, of course the Buck 110 has it's own challenge. I think the intent here is to dip back into older styles of knives and work with those. Since all modern knives are essentially built on the traditions of traditional knives, I think it's challenging to define the "Traditional" category. Is a Spyderco Endura a Traditional? Nah. But it's no different than a 110LT, really. In that sense, I think it would be better to go with the J.E. Made which is clearly a modern take on a Traditional design (clip point, slip joint).My 2¢.
(Steve beat me to the punch.)
That was my plan, but wondered about the 110 Classic and the 110LT. I have a Winchester 112 clone as well.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
The JE Made is my choice. I love that knife!!!

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
A real looker.

-
I'm in, I love traditional slip joints. I have a green bone Case Russlock I am fond of. What might make this a funner challenge: traditional pocket tools! The P38, the four way screw driver, key chain nail clippers, pair of pliers instead of a MT. Maybe I'm just nuts, but that might be kind fun.
-
I like where you are going with this......

-
Traditionalists:
01 - Barry Rowland (with a sodbuster)
02 - Nix (with another sodbuster)
03 - Dean51 (with a GEC)
04 - SteveC (with a drawerful of knives)
05 - Fuzzbucket (with a size appropriate knife)
06 - RF52 (once he gets a sweet trad)
07 - Wspeed (with more size and law appropriate knives)
08 - Borg (with one or more that may or may not qualify)
09 - Antti Lammi ( Opinel N°09 )
10 - zrxoa1 (with.....)
11 - Greg Jones (Grohmann modern classic)
12 - Anka (with a genuine Barlow)
13 - getahl (with a Russlock and a P38) -
Traditionalists:
01 - Barry Rowland (with a sodbuster)
02 - Nix (with another sodbuster)
03 - Dean51 (with a GEC)
04 - SteveC (with a drawerful of knives)
05 - Fuzzbucket (with a size appropriate knife)
06 - RF52 (once he gets a sweet trad)
07 - Wspeed (with more size and law appropriate knives)
08 - Borg (with one or more that may or may not qualify)
09 - Antti Lammi ( Opinel N°09 )
10 - zrxoa1 (with a JE Made slipjoint)
11 - Greg Jones (Grohmann modern classic)
12 - Anka (with a genuine Barlow)
13 - getahl (with a Russlock and a P38)Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Traditionalists:
01 - Barry Rowland (with a sodbuster)
02 - Nix (with another sodbuster)
03 - Dean51 (GEC Bullnose)
04 - SteveC (with a drawerful of knives)
05 - Fuzzbucket (with a size appropriate knife)
06 - RF52 (once he gets a sweet trad)
07 - Wspeed (with more size and law appropriate knives)
08 - Borg (with one or more that may or may not qualify)
09 - Antti Lammi ( Opinel N°09 )
10 - zrxoa1 (with a JE Made slipjoint)
11 - Greg Jones (Grohmann modern classic)
12 - Anka (with a genuine Barlow)
13 - getahl (with a Russlock and a P38) -
When i was out for a walk at the weekend i found this bit of antler..

As soon as i saw the curve i knew what it could be used for :D

I am so tempted to finish this off and use it for the challenge, pointy sticky out bits at both ends might be an issue for carrying though

-
That looks really good Borg

-
Thanks Speedy, still need to finish the slot and beef up the pivot a bit probably with a sleeve, not sure antler can take the stress
i will check, this type of knife has probably been used for hundreds of years so i'm guessing it wont take much to make it usable 
-
It couldn't get more traditional that that!
I'm looking forward to seeing how it comes out. If it stays pointy...perhaps a slip sheath for the pocket?

-
I hope the antler is strong enough Borg

It would be nice to know how strong antlers are
-
-
So I have to ask.... what’s wrong with someone adding a pocket clip to a traditional knife?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Outstanding!! This is going to be a ton of fun! After so long, I'm dying to put my traditionals to work.
-
Does a Farmer count as a trad blade? If so, I'm in like Flynn

-
@magentus said:
Does a Farmer count as a trad blade? If so, I'm in like Flynn
Sorry Mags, Vic et al has been excluded from the challenge... Mainly, it has to be said, in a vain attempt to keep your sort out of it. I'm sorry, but somebody had to say it... got to be cruel to be kind... got to be cruel to be kind...
@Dean51 said:
Thanks just throw me under the bus.
all these - Knives considered traditional would include any of the traditional slipjoint pattern knives including more modern versions like the Lionsteel Shuffler etc. , Opinels, Douk Douks, Higos - the Mercator. Friction folders and Lockbacks like the Buck 110.
and these - For purposes of this challenge, if it's got a tang-stamp that says 'Victorinox' or 'Wenger', it is excluded (not that they aren't traditional, but they have their own challenges.). I think Opinels, Douk-douks, Mercators, Laguoiles, and anything that would fit the name of "Jack knife". If it would have looked at home in Grand-dad's or Grand-ma's pocket, I think it will qualify.
Knives would have to have a back spring or back lock, liner locks would be OK if they had a back spring like a boy scout or TL-29 but no Walker liner locks.
Friction folders like the Opinel are good as well.
No thumb studs, spidie holes, flippers or pocket clips.
So a traditional slip joint and a modern slip joint are fine.

On the extreme side the Manly Wasp had a pocket clip but it has been permanently removed so not even the holes show so it could be allowed as well.

Just get yourself a vintage scout knife!

-
Fuzzy beat me to it .
Sorry mags

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
