Man found after 5 days
-
The link worked OK for me,I also agree he was an idiot,and believe that people that do foolish things like that should have to pay back the cost of the rescue.

-
just goes to show you should always be as prepared as you can possibly be when you go to the woods

-
@1stcavmp77 said:
just goes to show you should always be as prepared as you can possibly be when you go to the woods
Damn right

-
in my book, even if you are a very accomplished woodsman it never hurts to take some good gear that you can use to save your butt in case you have a twisted/broken ankle or leg or you can only use one hand/arm because of injury. and know how to do at least a couple thins one handed.
-
I wasn't an MT.org member when this thread first came round, but I'll give my 2 cents here.
-
I've been on Mt Adams close to a dozen times. I have not yet summited it. It is not a technical climb--even in the slightest. Many people walk up with skiis on their backs and ski off. The biggest problem with Adams is sudden unpredictable changes in weather.
-
Climbers climb for the challenge, not the glory. It is hard work and "glory" consists of an assortment of reactions ranging from "Why would you want to do it?", "It doesn't sound like much fun to me...", "Wouldn't you rather just sit on a nice warm beach?" and "That's great! I once climbed....(insert the name of a hill, large bump or peak that can be reached by car)."
-
The majority of rescuers are volunteers and they are all mountaineers themselves. Sort of a "Pay it forward" sort of a thing.
-
Yes, the State/County/City cover the costs for helicopter service, communications and medical support. However, when a boater gets in trouble, a motorist has an accident, someone falls on the ice, etc, the State/county/City covers the costs of the emergency also. It's paid out of the taxes we all pay and is part of the social network.
You may not want to pay for rescue of a fallen climber, there may be others who don't want to pay for people in car accidents or pay for rescue resusitation for someone with obesity and diabetes who has a heart attack. Thankfully, as community, there are certain community services which are administered without a vote on "worth of cause".
JMO.
-
-
I don't agree entirely although I totally subscribe to the idea of pay it forward. When I get in my car I am legally obliged to have insurance to cover the cost of accidents so why shouldn't it be the same when people go off in to the wilds? It's the same as medical insurance in the US I guess - either you have it or you pay out when sh*t hits the fan.
It should be up to climbers etc to cover their own arses IMHO, so any costs incurred by their activities don't fall to others to pay. Taxes should be for essential community costs (which are hugely overburdened already), not for individual optional leisure outings - which is what this comes down to - choice. If you choose to take risks, choose to pay for it too.
-
I'm not against climbing or adventurous activities, I understand the "drive" and pleasure of such things,
the skill and sense of achievement felt, but some people take unnecessary risks, like lack
of safety equipment and clothes, or not telling others where they'll be,
or going alone in dangerous places when they don't have too (like this guy).Boating accidents are usually drinking related or inexperienced drivers and I do not like my
tax dollars paying for that kind of recklessness. Driving is necessary to our way of life, for work, getting
food etc, we have to do it; apples and oranges.Dangerous sports and leisure puts people who yes love the outdoors and want to give back,
at danger unnecessary and uses my tax dollars for others dangerous play time.
You play, you pay. -
@nuphoria said:
I don't agree entirely although I totally subscribe to the idea of pay it forward. **When I get in my car I am legally obliged to have insurance to cover the cost of accidents ** so why shouldn't it be the same when people go off in to the wilds? It's the same as medical insurance in the US I guess - either you have it or you pay out when sh*t hits the fan.It should be up to climbers etc to cover their own arses IMHO, so any costs incurred by their activities don't fall to others to pay. Taxes should be for essential community costs (which are hugely overburdened already), not for individual optional leisure outings - which is what this comes down to - choice. If you choose to take risks, choose to pay for it too.
Well, in response, I'll point a few things out:
-
Your car insurance doesn't cover the cost of the rescue or medivac if needed (ie, your insurance isn't billed for a helicopter ride to the trauma center). This is true in the US and I suspect the UK as well. Your car insurance pays for the damage to your car and the other motorist's car (and possibly his medical costs).
-
In in the British NHS, those who live unhealthy lifestyles (obesity, smoking, etc) are not penalized by paying for the long term extra costs of their poor health decisions. (Although there was a NHS study a year or so ago which debated if they should have to pay a percentage of their health costs). One could argue that general society shouldn't have to pay for poor decisions of the individual.
-
In the Pacific Northwest, most of the rescuers are purely volunteer. They are climbers who do it for the community. I have several friends in Search and Rescue--their operations cost the general public exactly nothing. The National Guard helicopters are an expense, however.
-
One could make the same argument for citizens who are victims of floods or wildfires. They live in areas that they know are at higher (or extremely high) risk. Yet, because we are community, we accept that we help those who put themselves at higher risk (Southern Californians for wildfires, mudslides and earthquakes, Louisianans in New Orleans, those who live along coastal areas at risk for hurricanes, those who live in flood plains, those who live in regions at risk for blizzards, etc).
-
Finally, most search and rescue is not for climbers; it is for average folks who get lost on a day hike or when mountain biking and can't find their way out. Places like Yellowstone, Yosemite, Glacier park. The last data I saw was somewhere between 50 to 100:1 (Rescues of day hikers and mountain bikers to climbers/trekkers/multiday hikers).
-
-
@WhichDawg said:
Dangerous sports and leisure puts people who yes love the outdoors and want to give back,
at danger unnecessary and uses my tax dollars for others dangerous play time.
You play, you pay.Not living in the high country, away from hurricane/tornado/wildfire/earthquakes, puts people at unnecessary risk. You pay, you pay? It's not how we as a society choose to act--at least not yet.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
4. One could make the same argument for citizens who are victims of floods or wildfires. They live in areas that they know are at higher (or extremely high) risk. Yet, because we are community, we accept that we help those who put themselves at higher risk (Southern Californians for wildfires, mudslides and earthquakes, Louisianans in New Orleans, those who live along coastal areas at risk for hurricanes, those who live in flood plains, those who live in regions at risk for blizzards, etc).Funny you mentioned that, I think if one knowingly build/buy a house in areas that flood every damn year should deal with it himself.
Right now there's flood problem in Manitoba/North Dakota (well every year really), there are plans to build dike that would solve the problem once and for all (like those in Holland), yet there are people dead against it and even threatened volunteers working on it because it would block their river view/decrease their property value...
-
@Micky d said:
just goes to show you should always be as prepared as you can possibly be when you go to the woods

Damn right


-
You raise some good point there mate, and I'll throw a few answers to them back if that's ok.
Having to drive and buy insurance isn't exactly the same as choosing leisure activities which put you at risk, although my insurance does cover both legal and medical costs. There are a lot of unmet costs for rescue organisations here (even with all the volunteers in the world) which are scraped together from fund raising and charitable donations - they often get no government funding at all and could benefit hugely from people having to contribute who end up using their services. I understand that the insurance culture is far more endemic in the US and perhaps us Brits are a little too used to getting things for free, however, the NHS resources are spread hopelessly thin and receiving fast treatment often depends on what we call the "postcode lottery".
There has also been a lot of debate as you mentioned about refusing treatment to certain people who live higher risk lifestyles - this isn't something that can easily be implemented but I think it's probably inevitable that cuts will be made using such criteria eventually. Certain surgeries are already withheld to clinically obese people due to the higher risks and chances of lower efficacy involved. As regards to smoking; the majority of people dying from smoking related cancers at the present time weren't necessarily educated to the truth about the risks. Those truths were not available mostly due to false studies funded by tobacco companies (namely Phillips if memory serves), and that propaganda perpetuated a habit which people weren't convinced would harm them. Too add to which, the government revenue created from tax on tobacco products funds a huge amount of NHS resources! (an argument still held in high esteem by smokers).
I am not suggesting for one second that people who are the victim of natural disasters due to their location should be made to pay - that's what public money and resources should be for. For instance, hurricane Katrina was an absolute travesty, and the residents didn't get the help that they deserved, certainly not fast enough.
Unfortunately the world is mostly governed by economics and perhaps the people with the money should be prepared to contribute beyond legislated taxes if they want to go the extra mile (pun intended) :)
Oh, and I only used climbers as an example - hence the etc. I am extremely capable of getting lost in the local park and needing chocolate to be airlifted in within hours :D
-
If I choose to live next to a Volcano (and I do!) and it exploded and wiped out all I have,
and I had medical issues, I would not expect you or anyone else to pay for that, that is
my choice and I would deal with it, the best I can.I feel it's the same for other area's, hurricane, flood, tornado's, earthquake.
It's a conscience choice, you get insurance. If somebody decided to live there,
they need to own up to that, We need to take responsibility for our actions and choices,
for someone to expect others to pay for their choices, right or wrong is not fair.More and more people are living in such places, we can't afford to pay for all the disasters,
if and when they happen.When some volunteer gets hurt or worst, it will be discussed and debated more,
why do we have to wait until then? -
@WhichDawg said:
If I choose to live next to a Volcano (and I do!) and it exploded and wiped out all I have,
and I had medical issues, I would not expect you or anyone else to pay for that, that is
my choice and I would deal with it, the best I can.Well, we weren't talking so much about the material losses and medical expenses. It was my impression we were more discussing the search and rescue costs. In your example, it would be the expenses involved in sending in searchers to find survivors and rescue efforts. IMO, it's what a society does to help the citizen (going in to find and rescue survivors).
I don't think there's any concern about getting the climber's gear off the mountain or to pay for his healthcare. His gear is gone and he's still responsible for his healthcare.
-
True we were talking about high risk activities/adventures, not material issues or car accidents.
Some people take unnecessary risks, not only for themselves but others also, and I personally
will do whatever I can to stop untrained, unskilled, foolish "adventurers"
from putting others in danger and wasting my tax dollars.Through voting, laws, awareness programs, threads like this, the internet and just talking about it.
I can't do it 24/7 but when opportunity comes, I will try.What is a little surprising to me, is this past year/winter I hardly heard about search and rescue
operations in our area (PNW) looking for someone, nothing like last year!Maybe I missed a few reports but even in Blade Forum I didn't see many threads about it.
Is it the economy or are people being more careful
I'm very glad for it and hope it continues. -
@WhichDawg said:
True we were talking about high risk activities/adventures, not material issues or car accidents.Some people take unnecessary risks, not only for themselves but others also, and I personally
will do whatever I can to stop untrained, unskilled, foolish "adventurers"
from putting others in danger and wasting my tax dollars.Through voting, laws, awareness programs, threads like this, the internet and just talking about it.
I can't do it 24/7 but when opportunity comes, I will try.What is a little surprising to me, is this past year/winter I hardly heard about search and rescue
operations in our area (PNW) looking for someone, nothing like last year!Maybe I missed a few reports but even in Blade Forum I didn't see many threads about it.
Is it the economy or are people being more careful
I'm very glad for it and hope it continues.More likely a case of Darwin's natural selection. ;)
-
@WhichDawg said:
True we were talking about high risk activities/adventures, not material issues or car accidents.Some people take unnecessary risks, not only for themselves but others also, and I personally
will do whatever I can to stop untrained, unskilled, foolish "adventurers"
from putting others in danger and wasting my tax dollars.Through voting, laws, awareness programs, threads like this, the internet and just talking about it.
I can't do it 24/7 but when opportunity comes, I will try.**What is a little surprising to me, is this past year/winter I hardly heard about search and rescue
operations in our area (PNW) looking for someone, nothing like last year! **Maybe I missed a few reports but even in Blade Forum I didn't see many threads about it.
Is it the economy or are people being more careful
I'm very glad for it and hope it continues.Mostly weather related. The icestorms made mountaineering less appealing but there was good ice climbing. Most problems arise when weather comes on quickly in the Cascades. This year, the weather was fairly predictable.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
