Executive vs Pocket Tool Chest
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
While I wouldn't carry the Executive as often, that doesn't mean it wouldn't have a role to play. With some brass or stag scales, I'm thinking it would pair very well with these two items...That would be a good trio AW!

-
I had both a PTC and an Executive. I lost the Executive and can see no reason to replace it. I bought a spare PTC in case I lose my original one. PTC all the way!
-
Executive, which I also slightly prefer to my minichamp.
I absolutely loathe the serrated scissors on Wenger knives so if I carry my Nomad or S557 for the excellent Phillips & Wrench combo I also have to carry a vic classic for the smooth scissors.
If there was a PTC with smooth scissors I think it might edge out the Exec by a very slim margin.
I have found the "orange peeler" to also make a decent package/letter opener when I don't want to dull my other two blades.
-Wes.
-
For me the Executive is a awkward size with a tool set that doesn't give me much more usefulness then a Classic. Actually the Classic SD has a more useful screw driver.
Personally I fail to see how a silly little serrated blade/ almost useless screw driver can come close to being as useful as an Awl , Jewellers SD and a pry bar/SD/cap lifter.
When I trim my nails with a straight scissors like the Vic or the Wegner I need to use the nail file regardless if the scissors is serrated or not. The longer Executive file is nice but not nice enough to justify having to carry the awkward size 74mm.
In my opinion the Pocket Tool Chest the most useful SAK in the 74mm to 58mm "key ring size" SAK.

-
While I do like the Exec somewhat & just cannot see paying the price for a PTC, I will be happy with my choice, ............................MiniChamp.

-
I picked up a PTC in excellent condition on the Bay of E for $10.50 and missed out on a stainless one yesterday because I wasn't paying attention ::) that went for $17.00.
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
That was a shame! The stainless one is a great knife if you can snag one.What Multi tool is that?
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
IDL T7Thanks!
-
@Butch said:
While I do like the Exec somewhat & just cannot see paying the price for a PTC, I will be happy with my choice, ............................MiniChamp.
My first PTC was bought on accident. I was planning on getting a MC when I stumbled upon a lot of several Vic and Wenger SAK'S. Two of them ( a serrated Highlander and a Deluxe Climber) where SAK'S I really wanted. When I was able to inspect my purchase I discovered there was a PTC in the lot.
I planned on still getting my MC in a few months and figured the PTC would hold me over till then. Some four years later I still have not ordered a MC.
When I do get a MC I'm sure I'll find it very useful but I'm also sure I'll miss my awl, Jewellers SD, and small pry bar.
-
Trust me, I'm kicking myself. A friend dragged me to Hooters and my Ebay sniping acumen took a big hit :ahhh
-
Picked up a PTC in just about perfect condition at an estate sale recently and put titanium scales on it.
After carrying it for a couple weeks I have gotten more used to the serrated scissors. Enough so that it now will be part of my EDC rotation.
Overall a very nice, compact tool.
-Wes.

-
..like my Executive but niw I'll have to yry to find a PTC...

-
@Wessaen said:
Picked up a PTC in just about perfect condition at an estate sale recently and put titanium scales on it.After carrying it for a couple weeks I have gotten more used to the serrated scissors. Enough so that it now will be part of my EDC rotation.
Overall a very nice, compact tool.
-Wes.
Nice scales Wes!

-
...checked out the PTC on that used site, some are quite expensive!
-
Here's my spare one. I only paid $7.50 for it so the deals are out there if you're able to look around before you buy.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


