Cull Update
-
Good to see you take those tools for a spin. Who knows, maybe this time round one or a few might make the cut and see some usage
. I like the retry tools that I liked but for whatever reason didn't stick. My Skeletool is a great example of that. I feel my Juice S2 and CS4 are tools that both deserved 2nd and 3rd tries. I'm glad I did as the both see some pocket time so keeping them was worth it. -
I think it's always worth revisiting stuff after a while. I've done it a few times. The Rebar, CS4 and XE6 were no better second time round, but the Sideclip was, and became one of my favourite pocket pliers. Life is also very different now, and the tasks have changed, which affects how well tools will suit my needs. The biggest change is my mindset, and wanting to use stuff that I previously didn't. Owning a NIB penknife from the 80s has become more pointless. I want it in my pocket.
I've lost the reasons to use my 7" stag handled bowie, but I can now use that NIB penknife, which wouldn't have been "enough" knife before. Yes, I could do everything I need to do now with the old favourites, but I can also discover new ones, from stuff that's already here. What was I saving those unused items for? The answer is, I was saving them for now :D There's no great monetary value to them, but there's potentially lots of usage value. I'm also less worried about breakage. I used to have a mindset whereby I would be very upset if a knife crapped out on me. I think now, I'd more easily think "never mind, I've got spares" and just move on to a different knife, happy that I'm outliving the tools, rather than pointlessly hoping they outlive me.
I remember when I got the pocket knife I inherrited from my grandfather. My grandmother was rooting through a tin, looking for something, and it had several of my grandfathers penknives in. Some had broken backsprings or cracked scales, and all of them looked well worn. THAT'S what I want to leave behind. Well worn stuff, not immaculate stuff. In fact, never mind leave behind, that's what I want to use now :D Stuff that I got new, that looks like it's been used daily for many years.
That's part of wanting to downsize too. With too many options, nothing gets enough use to develop that "faithful companion" look. In a strange way, I actually feel a bit disappointed that some of the items I've had for many years don't LOOK like I've had it many years. I do have a few though ;)
-
When you've got stuff distributed through various kits, or strategically placed around the house, you don't get a true perspective of just how much stuff you've accumulated.
Earlier in the thread, I showed this pic...
... of a few miscellaneous lights that aren't doing much at the minute. As part of my "use stuff to find out if you want to keep it", I started playing around with lanyards, long lanyards that I can cow hitch to the belt, for all the lights that don't have pocket clips or aren't already fastened to something.
As you might expect, I discovered a few that needed a battery change, which progressed to checking the batteries in everything, which progressed further to getting all my lights together in one pic...
:o More than I expected to see.
I did have even more, but have sold some, and given some away. None are particularly high powered. There's only one that goes above 200 lumens, and many of them are quite underrated to what's available now, but they're plenty good enough for my needs.

-
Man down :(
In working through all the lights, I discovered this Nitecore T0 has packed up. Last time I used it, all was well, but now it's kaput. Tried cleaning the threads and contacts, but no joy. Although I'm cutting down overall, I will replace this with something. Everything in the Fuse-ilier kit (which this is from) is orange, so I'll need to pick up a replacement of some description to continue that theme, unless I find a compatible replacement head.
I'm still working through the rest of the pile, so there may be more casualties yet. Failures are to be expected periodically with electronic stuff.
On the upside, I've got my Lumapower D-mini VX back up and running on 18650s. It's not a retina burning powerhouse at only 250/300lm at full tilt, but has excellent run times, particularly at the mid level. I'm not sure what the mid level is, but the high runs for 3 hours, and low is 13lm for 91hrs


-
Sorted out a few drawers today. While some of my stuff is assigned to fixed kits, the bulk of it is still pick 'n' mix. Grab a pliers tool, grab a knife, and away you go.
Till now, I had all the pliers tools in one drawer, but there's certain tools I'll carry with a Swiss knife, and others I'll carry with a traditional folder. I decided to swap things round, and put the right pliers tools with the right knives. It just minimises the drawers to go through to put a day's toolset together (and makes it seem like I don't have so many pliers tools
)Pic 1 - Swiss knives, relevant pliers tools, and mini-combos
Pic 2 - Traditional (mostly) folders, and relevant pliers tools.
Pic 3 - Neck knives, lock knives, clipped OHO slippies, and a couple of sheath knives.



-
Following on from something that was discussed earlier in this thread, I thought of something which might help lend a little focus on where I go from here in terms of usage, and possibly even further downsizing. It was just a simple question that popped into my head...
In 10 years (or whenever) which tools do I want to look as good as they do today, and which do I want to look like they've been put to hard graft day in, day out?
At the moment, I (still) have so much stuff, even the most carried pocket knives might only see a month of carry a year. So nothing is really getting that "wow, you got some mileage out of that one" look. If I'm going to achieve that on any of my tools, I need to be focussing on using them a lot more.
Duplicates would be a good place to start.
For example, I have two Case Barlows, the herringbone one has had a lot more use than the one with scrolled bolsters (the equivalent of a couple of year's carry on one, and a couple of days on the other), but doesn't see as much carry time as it could. The horn IXL barlow has also probably seen about a year's worth of use, whereas the rosewood one hasn't even seen one day's carry. I'd like my brushed stainless Wenger Traveller to keep looking respectable, but would love the Evowood 14 to develop the "faithful companion" look. I have two Byrd Terns, which don't look much different in terms of condition, and maybe they should.
I have two Sideclips, though one is in pieces getting polished up a little. Maybe the other should show more signs of being used. Both of the sheath knives I made in 2007 have been been mollycoddled far too much, and need to start looking like they've worked for a living (they do have a little wear to them, but not 12 year's worth).
I don't mind using the others occasionally, in fact I'd get bloody annoyed with myself if I didn't, but maybe sticking to certain ones and kicking the snot out of them (knowing I have back ups) would make me feel more like I'm actually more value from these tools. It feels too much like a collection at the moment, instead of an arsenal of working tools. Maybe more battle scars, and evidence of repeated sharpening is what is needed to make me feel better about the glut that still remains ...




-
Ok, I'm going to try to stick to picking from these tools on weekdays, and only let myself carry something different at weekends. Lets see how long it is before I get bored


-
Good read. I love seeing tools and items that have had years of faithful service. I particularly enjoy seeing leather thats worn. I've seen hammers that show exactly where the owner has held it over the years. Tools that show a respectable working life. Whats I also enjoy is the thought that someone spent their hard earned money to acquire the tool and used the heck out of it.
Now that being said, I can also appreciate a well cared for tool. Once that has been used but shows little evidence of it. I've always admired tools that look as good as they did when they left the package. I know its hard to imagine a tool that has worked that shows little wear. I've seen them and have a few. They might not have decades on them but several years at the least. They just were made to take it and come out fine.
I have go to tools. Tools that I carry when work needs to be done. Tools I instinctively reach for when I have a project. There are other tools that I consider stand by tools. Great tools and tools I can rely on. Fact is I just have to many to choose from. Not every one will get life time of work in as a result. Kit tools like my evacuation and car kit tools were chosen because I can rely on them. My hike kit tools are there because if I needed them I know they'd perform. Camping tools were chosen because they perform best in that role. Since I don't use any of these tool often enough they wont develop the patina they should. If I were to use the same fixed blade across several kits then you'd see some serious patina.
I'm ok with how this will work out. I try to keep my stand by tools close so they can get a work out. I try to rotate what I carry or carry multiple items and use them throughout their carry time. I was off today and worked in they yard all day. I carried 2 fixed blades. I used one to dig out a few weeds while the other broke down some boxes and cut jute to tie up plants. I also carried my Surge and SI. I tired to make it a point to used each tool. If I used one cuting tool all day that tool would surely show wear over a shorter period. I enjoyed using each tool as the task presented itself. Yes I was way over prepared but I had fun with each tool.
-
@Aloha said:
I've seen hammers that show exactly where the owner has held it over the years. Tools that show a respectable working life. Whats I also enjoy is the thought that someone spent their hard earned money to acquire the tool and used the heck out of it.Now that being said, I can also appreciate a well cared for tool. Once that has been used but shows little evidence of it. I've always admired tools that look as good as they did when they left the package. I know its hard to imagine a tool that has worked that shows little wear.
I'm really glad you just said that! :D
Those two points, the well used and well cared for, are why I made the decision regarding the two Wenger Travelers. The stainless one will show less wear externally that the Evowood will (which will hopefully wear like the hammers you mentioned), and so I want to keep the stainless one looking well maintained, while I don't mind the wooden scaled one looking like it been used hard for several years. I totally agree that there's a different type of elegance to both.
I have my hiking, camping, travelling kits too. My Diesel mod and fuse mod look pretty much immaculate compared to a lot of my gear. Even when I carry them, I don't always need to use them. My Wave mod looks like it's been dug out of a plane crash in comparison.
The faux pearl scaled penknife I was using recently, needs to stay as pristine as sensibly possible, which is why I made a little leather slip for it. It won't take wear well. Whereas the four main slippies that I'll be using have all had plenty of carry time already, and will just get better and better as time takes its toll. One of them was actually the only UK legal knife I owned for many years, and I'm impressed how well it still looks :)
Those are the four that I most want looking like I travelled the world with them.
My others will pick up some character along the way, that's inevitable. I have no desire for everything to look "wrecked", in fact the immaculate ones and the heavily used ones, both enhance the aesthetics of the other, to my mind. I'm quite happy to have occasional tools and regular tools, with the corresponding wear patterns. I just don't want to shuffle off this mortal coil looking like I never did anything with my tools, or that I abused everything I ever laid hands on :D
-
As an aside, I gave my brother one of my Wenger Travelers (evo 14 I think) a few years ago. He has that one, whilst I have a multitude. His knife has been used responsibly (though not regularly sharpened ::)) . Mine are all in decent nick, while his looks like it's been kicked from one end of the street to the other - and it's all just good honest wear. I know I've put at least as many miles in my tools as he has, but he put them all in one, whereas I didn't.
-
This is the joy of owning enough tools to rotate thru. Its also the reality that some tools just wont acquire the patina as your bothers did. I'm totally fine with that. My Manager is my longest carried tool. It and the sheath it rides in are both showing years of use and carry time.
There was a time when I kept my things meticulous. A time when I only owned one item at a time, no back ups. I used my things with what my mom would call a "soft touch". I cleaned them up and put them away after use. I didn't feel I was overly fussy then nor do I today. So when it comes to patina from use over extended periods of time, I say wonderful. If the tool looks modest in its wear, I also say wonderful.
I was the same way about shoes. Kinda still am to a degree. I have a pair of boots I've had for 20 + years that are in remarkable condition. These are going out shoes vs work shoes. Work shoes have come and gone in uncountable numbers. Kinda my take on tools as well now that I think about it.
I visited a home of a lady who had lived there since the 60's. She upgraded her appliances in the 80s. Most everything else including her furniture were from the 60s and 70s. Everything was in such amazing condition that I initially thought they were reproductions. She said when she bought items she bought the best she could afford at the time and took extra care to ensure it could last a lifetime even with regular use. Now upon closer inspection you could see the wear on her furniture. Some wear marks on smaller appliances. Even her car was in wonderful looking condition, she had a 70s Cadillac.
-
@Aloha said:
I was the same way about shoes. Kinda still am to a degree. I have a pair of boots I've had for 20 + years that are in remarkable condition. These are going out shoes vs work shoes. Work shoes have come and gone in uncountable numbers. Kinda my take on tools as well now that I think about it.Excellent analogy!
except for the fact I don't have 50+ pairs of shoes, like I do pocket knives 
:P
You're quite right of course. My dedicated tools are the same. Some are in excellent condition, and others are beaten up and have been replaced several times, depending how often I've needed to use them, and in what environment.




-
I don't have anywhere near that many shoes either which is also why I kept those boots in such great shape. I also like to buy shoes that I can replace the soles which extends the life of a good quality shoe.
I really like that lower hammer. Love how I can see where you held it. You're making quite the progress with this cull. I like the thought process with each of your posts. I may not have said it but I enjoy these threads. I enjoy all the thought individuals go thru when deciding what to carry/own/keep/buy. Its one thing to decide on what tool makes sense but a whole other dimension when deciding carry/role/compliment to other tools/etc.
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
As mentioned in another thread, I've been trying out yet another combo today... ::)I finally got round to fixing the smurfed up Micra that Leatherman shipped out unfinished. The scissor rivet was made too short I think, which meant it didn't peen up properly. As received, with no use or carry time, I could get 0.25mm (0.010") feeler gauges inbetween the blades at the pivot...
... and what seemed like about 0.5mm (0.020") side to side play...
... as new, from the factory, on their 30th anniversary ST300 set.

I managed to peen it up to a clearance of 0.04-0.05mm (just under 0.002") using pin punches, so it didn't completely mangle the top face of the rivet, or leave unsightly pop marks. The Micra is a tool, defect aside, which I've always struggled to incorporate into any of my combos with any real satisfaction. Same applies with the Style PS, which is why I decided to try them together.
The problem with that combo, is the only thing that the Style introduces, that the Micra doesn't have is the pliers. It's already got bottle opener, tweezers, scissors (which is good, because the spring on the Style PS scissors has snapped again), nail file, and a very similarly profiled screwdriver. As such, I might need to either replace the Style with something else, or mod it with something the Micra doesn't have.
Work in progress...
The little toothpick knife was dull, my fault, I should have checked first. In trying to hand sharpen it, there was a somewhat disconcerting flex to the blde, which rematerialised while trying to sharpen a pencil with it. Not a fault of the knife, but the overzealous operator. It did however make me wonder if this combo might require a little extra oomph, so I'll be adding some extras to the pockets tomorrow... (pic attached)
If I do piece together a working combo from this lot, I think it will benefit greatly from a pocket pouch.

This combo evolved.
I carried it a couple of times, to try to find the weak spots and correct them. Pairing the Style PS with the Micra wasn't a strong combo. The only thing the style added was pliers, and the rest of the tool was redundant. Removing the Style PS, and replacing it with a Dime made more sense. The Dime at least added package opener, and a more sturdy flat blade driver. I also swapped the pen for the smaller Inka, and added the mini Clipper, Shard, and True Utility Twistick. (pic 1)
The only thing left to do, is create a way to carry it. I did originally think about a mini tool roll, but thought that might be too bulky, and a bifold wallet with four tool slots per side, might be a very pocketable solution. Chris (hiraethus) gave me some industrial material (slideway cover offcut, I believe) at last year's meet, and I've been looking for a good project for it ever since. This seemed like the ideal project.
I did start it, but that stuff is a real swine to work with. I underestimated how inflexible it is, plus I gnarled up the stitching on the very first row. (pic 2)

I need to rethink this a little, to factor in the rigidity. I'm now thinking that an inner pocket beneath the tools, would give me somewhere to put a fresnel lens, and maybe a bit of notepaper, plus, give me something to stitch elastic retention loops to, without the stitching showing on the outside when closed. However, I still want some way of covering the ends of the tools, so they're neither visible, nor be able to escape, when the wallet is closed, so you do have to open the wallet right up to access what's inside. I've not figured out exactly how to make that work, and not make it difficult to get things back in the elastic loops.
Hopefully, I can get not much wider or longer than my small bifold wallet (pic3). It will be much thicker, but should still be reasonable to carry in a jacket pocket, or drop into the pocket of an overnight bag.



-
@Aloha said:
I don't have anywhere near that many shoes either which is also why I kept those boots in such great shape. I also like to buy shoes that I can replace the soles which extends the life of a good quality shoe.I really like that lower hammer. Love how I can see where you held it. You're making quite the progress with this cull. I like the thought process with each of your posts. I may not have said it but I enjoy these threads. I enjoy all the thought individuals go thru when deciding what to carry/own/keep/buy. Its one thing to decide on what tool makes sense but a whole other dimension when deciding carry/role/compliment to other tools/etc.
Absolutely, combos are key to me.
I've mentioned before that the current knife laws over here, let you carry whatever you NEED, even if they don't let you carry everything you want. I've been in a public place, even stood outside a courthouse in a town centre,with a 4" sheath knife on my belt, and was perfectly entitled to. If you do happen to be questioned, all you need to do is satisfy the four THATs.
Does THAT person, have lawful reason, or permission where applicable, to carry THAT tool, in THAT place, and at THAT time? This is where the 3" non-locking folder "rule" comes in, because it expressly gives you legal clearance to carry that anywhere that knives aren't expressly prohibited, instantly satisfying the four THATs. I legally stood outside a courthouse with a 4" fixed blade on my belt, because I was penning boats through the lock directly outside the main entrance. THAT person, tool, place and time, all ticked off nicely as essential safety equipment for rope work in a marine activity with rising/falling water levels and strong currents.
However, I take that same mentality when building a combo. Where will it be used and when? Who will be around me? If I need tools which might give folks the wrong impression for part of that event, will I need a people friendly option for the rest of the duration? This is why I carry a Swiss knife with Phillips if I carry the Spirit. If that "invisible" people friendly knife can't do the job, then I'm validated in getting the Spirit out. I may still be asked why I was carrying it in the first place, but if I am carrying it, I'll have that answer ready ;)
So when putting a combo together, I choose what I think is the minimum I need to do the toughest foreseen task, plus what I can carry with it that will suffice when I have lesser tasks. If I'll be preparing food at somepoint, I might have a fixed blade, but will have an "invisible" folder (Swiss knife or trad) for when I don't need it. Also, what is the most convenient and appropriate way of carrying all the capabilities. I don't need saw on both knife and pliers, so do I carry a Wave or MP600 with a slim Swiss knife, or carry a Sideclip with a Ranger or CT41. The pre-established combos I have, have all had those questions answered and thoroughly tested. With the pick'n'mix combos, it's a process I have to think through (and enjoy doing it).
I enjoy the process of balancing one tool's strengths and weakness against another, so all the "what if"s are catered for in the most streamlined, situation appropriate and ergonomic way. Colour coordination is a bonus :D
-
The Style PS which fit so badly in the previous combo, works brilliantly in this one. The knife's combo tool handles more stubborn screws than the Style's nail file tip can, and the Slim Clips make up for the defective scissors (I will replace those with something functional eventually). The essentials are all there, with only the bottle opener being duplicated - but that happens with most combos anyway.
I have way too many mini combos now though
but mini combos are useful gifts, so no major crisis there.
-
While there is increasing clarity of what works, and what doesn't, there are still a few loose ends. What I tend to refer to as "odd socks". Items that just don't seem to pair well with anything.
One example of this, is the SanRenMu H02.
Not exactly tactical looking, but still a little pokey. A one hand opening "gentleman's" folder, that I would typically ignore, and reach for a traditional folder instead. All three cost me less than a tenner combined, so they're not worth selling - the postage would cost more than they're worth. If I need one hand opening, I'd usually want a pocket clip too, but I could attach a lanyard or dangler clip.
They've hung around here mainly as sacrificial knives. If I was to go somewhere where I don't know if a knife would prevent me gaining access or not, I would rather have one of these confiscated than anything else I own. Obviously, if I know I'm going to a knife free zone, I'll empty the pockets before I leave, but you don't always know in advance what a venue will greet you with. There was a thread very recently where someone (in the US I believe) had to hand over something sharp to go in to watch a show at a theatre or something, and hadn't gone by car, so couldn't leave it somewhere close and collect it later. Bye bye pocket knife. :-\
It's nice to have something kicking around for times like that, when you can't be 100% certain that your possessions will make it back home with you. It's like the pocket tool equivalent of a "muggers wallet" :D

-
I've been doing another bizarre little exercise over the last few days, working out how many combos I would use a given tool in. Not how many I could, that would be obscenely high numbers, but what I would realistically pair up on the grounds of compatibility of toolset and aesthetics. This really opened my eyes as to how much stuff I still have.
For example, I would pair my rather dressy scrolled bolsters Case Barlow, with different tools to my rather pocket worn herringbone Case Barlow. I also wouldn't pair a BO modded knifeless Diesel with a faux pearl old two blade penknife. If I'm carrying the Diesel, I'll probably need more knife than that.
,A good example of compatibility, would be my knifeless Wave mod with either a Byrd Tern, UKPK, Terzuola Slipit, or Byrd Wings Slipit. I would be quite likely to carry a Swiss knife with them too for when around non-knife people, specifically a Soft Touch 14 or Swissbuck Sidekick. Four OHO slippies and two Swissies gives eight potential combos that I'd use with the Wave mod. In comparison, there was over 100 viable combos with the knifeless MP400 :ahhh That's any one of 9 traditional slippies (out of 20+) or 6 Swiss knives (out of 18), with or without any one of six modern OHO slippies as a quick grab knife when not around "the public".
I could easily carry a different combo every day for a year, and not come close to exhausting all my potential combos. :ahhh :ahhh Holy smurf! And there I was thinking of sticking to the pick'n'mix combos for a week at a time, to spend more time with them, and also considering bringing the Diesel into the current carry options, as it's not getting much use.

It would take me two years just to carry the viable combos for the MP400...
So today's lesson was "Don't count the combos, Al"

-
@AimlessWanderer said:
On the upside, I've got my Lumapower D-mini VX back up and running on 18650s. It's not a retina burning powerhouse at only 250/300lm at full tilt, but has excellent run times, particularly at the mid level. I'm not sure what the mid level is, but the high runs for 3 hours, and low is 13lm for 91hrs
I was wrong!
The info above, was what I gleaned from the net, because I couldn't remember the specs, but this isn't the D-mini VX, it's the D-mini VX Ultra, an overclocked version, that kicks out 550 lumens. I knew it wasn't considered wise to run this on high for long with one of the cells, but it turns out that's with RCR123s, and it performs better on the 18650s.
I don't have much call for a pocketable floodlight these days, but it used to be the light I reached for if I got called out at silly o'clock in the morning because the alarms were going off at work. Very good for illuminating a 20,000sq ft workshop. Much more use to me on the lower settings these days though.
-
Been a busy with work now that our rain has gone. Sure was a nice winter rainy season for us in SoCal. Anywho, I like the thinking behind your combos. I like having several combos to choose from and in the past I tended to have a few of exactly the same set up which now makes no sense
. Having a strong set of smaller tools or combos which may include a larger tool for different outings makes a lot more sense. I got lulled into thinking if my Manager and Squirt were a strong combo then I wanted 3 of said combos.It didn't take long to figure to that while one combo was strong in a scenario I may like another strong combo for something else. I also try to decide as you how I would carry the items. I am still working out what makes the most sense for me. What I've done is not carry everything as a unit. I've paired certain items into a pocket sheath while other items get place into certain pockets.
An example is my pocket sheath for my Salesman and Squirt. Both fit nicely together separated by a stitch. I usually place this into my rear right pocket. I'll then carry my pen in my shirt pocket. I tried to figure out a way to carry it in the sheath but sitting on the pen was not comfortable. Light, I also tried to find a way to carry the light in the sheath but I like to have quicker access so into my coin pocket it goes.
Playing with how to carry my items is actually kinda fun for me
. I just redid how I carry my work MT and SAK. I like to run with a new carry for a week unless it just doesn't work out immediately.I tried to carry some items in an Altoid tin but its just not for me. Parceling out items into pockets, sheath, keychain, etc is my method for carrying a few strong combos.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login