Evogrip S54 10-layer Appreciation?
-
@Max Stone said:
...I did not appreciate at the time that less is more, and for EDC a 3- or even 2-layer SAK is all you need...I completely agree, for EDC (i.e. on person carry) less is definitely more for me. I can do 2 layer cellidor, or 3 layer alox, but anything more I find to be a chore to carry comfortably.
The fat SAKs are good for an EDC bag though... It works for me to have a lean SAK in the pocket, and a “tool chest” type in a bag, which is close-by when needed.
Current favorites are Cadet, Pioneer, Farmer, Spartan in pocket. I often bag carry a 3-4 layer 111mm or a LM Rebar, and I have a Workchamp that comes along on holidays. The S54 looks like it’s made for this.

-
Found this.. Doesn't give me much more than before and I don't see how this is going to be more effective than using the fingers or putting the line through the first line loop in the rod before starting to fill the reel.. Fun little thing though but I guess it can be used for other things as well
"Line guide update
The introduction of a line guide makes it possible to use this for hook disgorging as well. A line guide is made as a tool for distributing the line on a device. This is to prevent a line to clump. On fishing rod reels you use the thumb to distribute the line on the reel if it does not have a line guide mechanism. It would be difficult to use the line guide on SAKs and reel at the same time. This line guide i would expect can be used for more stationary devices to avoid clumping of the line and burning of the fingers."
[It's not failure if you learn something from it]
-
@Brock O Lee said:
I completely agree, for EDC (i.e. on person carry) less is definitely more for me. I can do 2 layer cellidor, or 3 layer alox, but anything more I find to be a chore to carry comfortably.The fat SAKs are good for an EDC bag though... It works for me to have a lean SAK in the pocket, and a “tool chest” type in a bag, which is close-by when needed.
Current favorites are Cadet, Pioneer, Farmer, Spartan in pocket. I often bag carry a 3-4 layer 111mm or a LM Rebar, and I have a Workchamp that comes along on holidays. The S54 looks like it’s made for this.

This is a good carry plan BoL. I’m alternating between Pioneer and Cadet for the pocket, adding a modded Rebar or Wave (or PST, or SOG, or OHT) on the belt on weekends. I will certainly look at some of the 3+ layer SAKs to compliment what’s in my pocket for an EDC bag carry.

-
@Max Stone said:
Some years ago, before I began collecting SAKs or finding MTO, I bought a Victorinox Evolution Grip S54, thinking it was the bees knees to have so many tools crammed into such a little ‘tool chest’.But it was just too big to carry, and has been sitting in a draw unused, unloved and forgotten for years. If anything, it put me off SAKs as I did not appreciate at the time that less is more, and for EDC a 3- or even 2-layer SAK is all you need.
Now with a little more understanding, I have more respect for what this knife represents. Not a knife you would use, but a showcase of the tools available in more pocketable-sized 85mm models.
So a little love is returning and I may even spoil this little guy with a sheath so he can get some sunlight away from the draw some day. I think he deserves it.

The Evogrip S54 10-layer is a impressive gadget knife worthy of daylight imho also.
-
given my dexterity with huge, fat SAKs, I'd use the notch in the fish scaler to hang the S54 in the air from a fishing line after my trip, because it'd have fallen to the water and gotten all wet

-
Ok guys, picked up a 4.0521.3 leather sheath today (with a few other goodies)

The S54 is a good fit. Not too tight. Locking lever does not cause a problem. Some room in the bottom but the shaped sides match the scales and stop it from dropping down too far. Enough of the scales exposed to extract the S54.
So now on the belt and getting some sunlight for the first time in probably 3 years.





-
@Max Stone said:
I agree.
The layer takes up 7.1mm (0.28in) which is 20% of the 35mm (1.4in).
And I never have much success with the tiddly compass. The magnetic ‘dip’ where I live means the South end of the needle tips down and sticks, so it’s a real fiddle to get the needle to swing freely.
One MT.O member had the idea to use the empty space behind (inside) the ruler for storing a couple of matches, which is a nice idea. But I do look at how much more compact it would be without the ruler compass. Maybe a good mod opportunity?

Which crazy MTO member came up with that idea ... ::)
Spoiler:
@Top-Gear-24 said:
I've been thinking about using the plastic compass holder as storage for some small things, since the plastic is hollow.I'm thinking of using a piece of cork that I can jam in the plastic compass holder, in which I can put a needle (since the S54 has no needle storage near the corckscrew, like the Vics do), and maybe some fishing line, hooks and some small lead balls as fishing sinker (or whatever you call this in English). Or some matches and a piece of match striker, or even a small firesteel, if I can find one that fits ... I'm going to try some of these options and see what works best.
That way all the "lost space" would be put to good use ;).
About the compass, like I said in my S54 topic, it works quite well over here, and it can even be used to determine your location or heading using a topomap, thanks to the transparant ruler. Interesting that you have a magnetic ‘dip’ there, I guess one should need something like the "global compass" from Recta/Suunto which allows the "needle" to tilt while still being accurate, to use over there, right?
Like these ones:



Spoiler:
Okay I'll say it ... my name is Eric, I have a compass problem ... :-[ -
Also have a couple

Taking this picture I discovered the S54 was influencing the Perspex compass from even 10cm...which may explain why I battle to get a stable reading with the S54’s compass


-
@rxd said:
I actually like big SAKs but that is too much. I wish they made that knife without the ruler - compass thing. That is just a huge waste of space in my opinion...Ron
If you're willing to sacrifice the pliers and the locking knife, you could go for the Victorinox Evo 28
.It's a great SAK, and the only one able to replace my trusty Swisschamp in my EDC setup.
Strangely enough I can't seem to find pics of it on my Imgur account ... weird
. -
@Max Stone said:
Also have a couple
Taking this picture I discovered the S54 was influencing the Perspex compass from even 10cm...which may explain why I battle to get a stable reading with the S54’s compass

Have you tried
turning it off and on againpopping the compass out of the S54 ruler to see if it works then ? -
Ok so now I’m embarrassed

Did not know it pops out...

Swings a bit better, but still a fiddle to get a free swing and N-S alignment when rotating it on a flat surface. Looks like the pivot is creating a little resistance or the N-S pole is a little tired.
Don’t think I could rely on this in the field.
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
If you're willing to sacrifice the pliers and the locking knife, you could go for the Victorinox Evo 28
.It's a great SAK, and the only one able to replace my trusty Swisschamp in my EDC setup.
Strangely enough I can't seem to find pics of it on my Imgur account ... weird
.Thanks TG. The Evo 28 looks very good. I see the Evo S557 is also a good option?



-
@Max Stone said:
Ok so now I’m embarrassed
Did not know it pops out...

Swings a bit better, but still a fiddle to get a free swing and N-S alignment when rotating it on a flat surface. Looks like the pivot is creating a little resistance or the N-S pole is a little tired.
Don’t think I could rely on this in the field.
You could try taking it out and leaving it in a "neutral place" (I mean, a place free of magnetic disturbance like electronic devices or metal, tools, SAKs, ...).
I own five SAKs with a compass in them (two Vics S54, two Wenger Pathfinders and one older Wenger Pathfinder, for pics check this topic). And on two of them (one of the S54 and the oldest Wenger Pathfinder) the compass acted weird and very unreliable when I first got them, but after I took out the compasses and placed them in a magnetic safe spot in my home (one without magnetic disturbance where I store all my regular compasses as well) for a couple of days they acted normal again.
But maybe it's the magnetic dip around there that causes the trouble, since these small Wenger button compasses don't need much tilting for them to stop turning freely I suppose ...

-
@Max Stone said:
Thanks TG. The Evo 28 looks very good. I see the Evo S557 is also a good option?
I really like the S54 and the Evo 28, don't own an Evo S557 (yet ;)).
The S557 has been on my wanted list for some time, but it always gets pushed back by something else that comes along ... maybe it's time to go for the S557 this time
. -
Thanks TG. I’ll try leaving the button compass somewhere away from influences and where it won’t grow legs (it is rather tiny)

The S28 seems more on the evolutionary path of the S54 than the S557, so it may get the first nod.

Just noticed that the compass has the W logo, even though mine’s an early Vic-branded S54...don’t know if Vic has changed the compass branding?


-
"Just think, Hans! In 120 years we'll have run out of these crappy old Wenger compasses and we'll have to order some new ones with the Victorinox logo!"
-
“...but Kurt, Wenger had the cunning plan to put the W logo by the East to thwart the invaders. What will we do?”

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login