Beach/Pool EDC?
-
I have a pick for you. I will show ya tommorrow a rusted Sak. I have a wenger ranger with a weird rust pattern, but it is at work.
Cool, thanks HC. Do you know if it was plain water that caused it or something else?
I've seen more rusty, corroded SAKs than Leathermans too, but then again, I've seen more grotty SAKs, bought as scrap than equivalent LMs too - so it's not too reliable a gauge really!
Steel rusts - whoever made it. I really do tire of some of the silly comments made about the "rust-proof" Vics on here, because they are truly silly. Not aimed at you Gareth - you were just nearest :D
-
Is Syderco's H-1 (maybe H-2, I forget) steel rust-proof?
-
I'll give you silly comments. LMs rust, Vics don't. neer neer neer neer... :P

-
@rockyman500 said:
Is Syderco's H-1 (maybe H-2, I forget) steel rust-proof? -
if some one drag me near a beach, maybe some SAK that i wouldnt mind loosing

-
I have a pick for you. I will show ya tommorrow a rusted Sak. I have a wenger ranger with a weird rust pattern, but it is at work.
Cool, thanks HC. Do you know if it was plain water that caused it or something else?
I've seen more rusty, corroded SAKs than Leathermans too, but then again, I've seen more grotty SAKs, bought as scrap than equivalent LMs too - so it's not too reliable a gauge really!
Steel rusts - whoever made it. I really do tire of some of the silly comments made about the "rust-proof" Vics on here, because they are truly silly. Not aimed at you Gareth - you were just nearest :D
No offence taken I assure you. I totally accept that any steel can rust, I'm just going by my experience with my SAKs. As I said earlier I also have a very positive opinion of Leatherman's rust resistance.
-
speaking of beach and blades
http://206.47.170.43/channels/images/halle-berry-swimsuit.jpg
-
@Sean said:
speaking of beach and bladeshttp://206.47.170.43/channels/images/halle-berry-swimsuit.jpg
Well, yeah, I would.
-
It pretty much doesn't matter if ya maintain your kit , a wee rinse in fresh water , dry it off an you are good to go ! Anything , cept H1 , Stellite , Talonite etc will rust . Even H1 will bond to particles of other rusted steels , giving the appearance of rust .
Divers of yore used to have to vasiline coat their blades , now all ya need is reasonable maintenance . a big improvement in my book .
Chris
-
Small SAK here as well.....A few extras tossed in a ManBag
-
Is Syderco's H-1 (maybe H-2, I forget) steel rust-proof?
Dave H-1 Steel is guaranteed not to rust . http://spyderco.com/catalog/details.php?product=295
Dunc
-
Is Syderco's H-1 (maybe H-2, I forget) steel rust-proof?
Dave H-1 Steel is guaranteed not to rust . http://spyderco.com/catalog/details.php?product=295
Dunc
Steel is made with Iron. Iron rusts. I grant you that the alloy might be made so that it doesn't rust easily - even to the extent that someone might be brave enough to offer to swap it if it did, but I reckon it would rust eventually under the right conditions.
There's a few metallurgists and similar on this forum, I'd be interested to hear their thoughts. It's a long time since I did my Chemistry A levels, but the laws of nature can't have changed that much since I left college.
I'm guessing that H-1 is quite brittle, would that be right?
-
H-1 is not brittle from my experience and the edge will tend to roll rather than chip.
Going back to what was said earlier, I also have had more experience of Vics rusting than Leathermans. I have never had a rusty Leatherman.
-
@Benner said:
H-1 is not brittle from my experience and the edge will tend to roll rather than chip.Just a guess on my part that. In fact thinking about it, I got it wrong, it probably has a much lower iron content (hence the rust resistance), so yes probably it might be "soft" compared to the steel used in MTs.
-
From the Spyderco website
H1 is precipitation-hardened steel, utilizing .1% nitrogen instead of carbon. Carbon is the component in steel that makes the blade hard and allows it to hold an edge. Carbon also reacts to chloride, making rust. With nitrogen replacing the carbon; hardness and edge retention are realized but nitrogen doesn’t react to chloride so it physically cannot rust.
Also Benchmade make a rescue / Divers knife in this stuff and I would love one

I'll find a pic
Dunc
-
@dunc5 said:
From the Spyderco websiteH1 is precipitation-hardened steel, utilizing .1% nitrogen instead of carbon. Carbon is the component in steel that makes the blade hard and allows it to hold an edge. Carbon also reacts to chloride, making rust. With nitrogen replacing the carbon; hardness and edge retention are realized but nitrogen doesn’t react to chloride so it physically cannot rust.
I don't even think that's true! It may facilitate the oxidising of the iron, but it's not what "makes rust" - that is surely oxidised iron ??? I can see that the presence of carbon could make things rust faster, but it it isn't critical to the formation of rust. I think.
I'm starting to wonder if I'm way off the mark now, but I don't think so.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login