Leatherman Free P2/P4 Club and Feedback Thread
-
Good review Sam !

I don't see myself getting either of these tools in the future.
-
Good review Sam

I can’t see myself getting any of them two neither
Just hope that they will start making other models with a flat bit driver
-
@Sam Lim said:
Made myself carry just the P2 for work today. Its a new tool, capability was quite unknown, untested.My routine work involves opening packages, boxes, cutting copper cables, stripping, wire terminations on terminal blocks and I also get to screw many stuffs. End of my work day, very unfortunately, I have to say I am quite disappointed. First off, I didn't like the resistance when opening the main blade. It is not overly strong, but can be felt and if I am not careful, there is the chance of slippage and the blade will spring back. Just doesn't feel fluid. Also attempted to use the flat heads for termination but very soon realise it is not a very good idea. The the shaft of the drivers are sharp. One is an awl and the other is a file. It can scratch, cut, damage anything close enough. Though they are pretty long reach, They are also tapered and are useless for recessed screws. They are also made too thin to give u any kind of confidence when using them. I do not like that 3 Flat head screwdrivers at all. :( One thing that starts to annoy me is, this is one noisy pliers to deploy. When locking down the pliers, the snap is loud and catches attention. Anyone within 5m knows that u are opening the pliers. I didn't like the tension of that spring when closing either, its taking too much effort to open and close that pliers due to that spring latch/lock thing. I did some sanding around the sharp points and corner to try to make it more comfortable but no matter what I can still feel that spring tab and the handle ends working into my palm when using the pliers.
On the slightly brighter side, I manage to break in my pliers and they open and closes freely now. They work as they should but they feel just like any normal properly working LM pliers. Strongest? Not sure, feels the same to me but I do notice they are very slightly thinner than the ones on the wave plus which shouldn't make any real difference for the strength and durability. The "new" replaceable cutter definitely works better than the older model as they are grounded steeper. But these cutters are now common to the newer batch of tools from the factory. ST300, wave plus etc. Scissor, no complaints. Almost the perfect size and have a very decent cutting power.
End of the day, I feel very compromised. I really wanted to like this tool but for what it offers, with the fresh and newer ( slightly irritating) design, I still do not feel that this tool is an upgrade over a regular wave plus. :(
Sorry to read you did not enjoy your P2, Sam. Maybe there will be a way to mod it in the future to possibly help make it enjoyable like the modded tools you have that you enjoy. :)
-
@SteveC said:
Good review Sam !
I don't see myself getting either of these tools in the future.
I so wanted to tell myself to like the P2 but there are just too many short comings, at least for me. It just not suitable. The hype that built up over the many months probably contributed to the over expectation. I am sure many other will have different opinions.
Btw, I did unscrewed the tool side of the pivot to have a peek. The tang profile around the pivot is extremely big. None of the things I have laying around will fit. The only way I can see any modification on it is to fabricate new tools from it ground up. So I will leave this godly task to others that have proper access to CnC and mills.. I will be very excited if anyone can improve on this tool.
I notice there is no signs of locktite but unlikely the screw will loosen by itself under normal use. The screw post is the exact same size of what they use on the juice series. I dun have a caliper so I dun have the measurement. Be careful if anyone wish to play around with them. The screw is tiny and will break if it gets jammed. In my juice mods, I bought the barrel screw from a I forgot what knife making website. I accidentally jammed and broke 2 of the screws in the barrel with minimal effort. The screws size and thread is the same. Breaking the ones on the LM shouldn't be too hard. -
@gerleatherberman said:
Sorry to read you did not enjoy your P2, Sam. Maybe there will be a way to mod it in the future to possibly help make it enjoyable like the modded tools you have that you enjoy. :)Posted 2 mins apart. :) See reply to Steve above... I really wish I can enjoy it as much as you are. Keep rocking dude.

-
@Sam Lim said:
Posted 2 mins apart. :) See reply to Steve above... I really wish I can enjoy it as much as you are. Keep rocking dude.
Indeed. I would never buy a P4 to replace a Wave only as a user tool. I bought mine, because I enjoy the way they operate and look. I think the function works well enough for moderate use and would be suitable to a large swath of MT users. It won't be replacing my Charge and Surge as far as works tools, but it has performed well for the few days I've used it at work. Not like the Wave/Charge, but it did work.
I said in the beginning and still maintain that Leatherman really really smurfed up by implying(or misleading the public to infer) that the P series was better than the Wave. They should have marketed it as a top-notch quality tool that is fun to play with. Kind of like high-end folding knives. We know that $200+ folding knives don't offer any functional advantage over $50-$100 folding knives. But, with that being the case, there is a massive desire and market for "high-end" folding knives. Leatherman should have gone after that demographic by showing how much fun the P series is to use. I really like the P series, because it is so much more fun to use for me, that I am OK with what I paid, because it works as it should for most tasks, but while being all one-hand accessible and not using fingernail nicks. I don't like it for being 'better than a Wave', because the Wave is a better user tool. Wave just isn't as much fun to use/play with.
-
Thanks for the insights, Sam. Unfortunately there isn't anything there that I hadn't expected, aside from the resistance on blade deployment. Tapered drivers are always going to be problematic on recessed fastenings, and mounting drivers on the end of cutting implements isn't what. We'd expect to see from a seasoned toolmaker either. It's a lot of money to pay, to be left disappointed :(
-
Is it possible that LM already designed their "BEST" tool? The feedback on the Wave and Charge + QC overall
has been good. That platform seems to be what ( LM included ) compared the Free series too and for good reason.
In all fairness and stubbornness probably, I am a Wave/Charge/Surge/Bit Holder/Blade Exchanger fan. It would be a challenge to get me to really like another tool that didn't bring it. While I can admit there are somethings about the Wave/Charge that I'd like to see ( blade exchanger ), OHO scissors, top notch QC on every tool, I am not in a rush to seek out my primary tool.While I have made comments regarding Victoroinox plier offerings the small tweaks to their Swisstool have been really good ones. The Spirit gets the love because if you've handled one and used one you'll know what great engineering is at play. I think I've told y'all that I carry a Spirit now on my pants belt while the bulk of the work goes to my Charge TTi on my work belt. I work in wet conditions as well as use stuff like WD40 or similar and the handling of the tool has not been an issue. The issue is the soft steel. My Phillips will be rounded over soon enough.
I digress. the Free all on its own looks to be quite a good tool. When you go against the BEST in your line up then you'd better bring it. Thats my take. If it were marketed as, LMs Free series the BEST EDC tool, fine. You cannot unring a bell and for many of us we heard them.
The Wave and Spirit have battled for years. No clear winner. No champ will ever be crowned. Many of us love both and several of us have our favorites. Again the Free looks like a great tool but expectations from what I am reading doesn't live up to the hype. Interesting thing to consider, Victorinox has not ( have they? ) promoted their plier based tools nor any changes to the Swisstool when they made them? I bet most of their sales are word of mouth
of which they earned. -
@AimlessWanderer said:
Thanks for the insights, Sam. Unfortunately there isn't anything there that I hadn't expected, aside from the resistance on blade deployment. Tapered drivers are always going to be problematic on recessed fastenings, and mounting drivers on the end of cutting implements isn't what. We'd expect to see from a seasoned toolmaker either. It's a lot of money to pay, to be left disappointed :(
The closing of the blade in my opinion is more accident prone than what they do on their liner lock. They say that when closing, the thumb will not be in the way of the closing blade. In actual fact, with their tradition liner, the speed of the closing can be controlled. With this new system with that spring assisting closing, the blade snaps close somewhere after the halfway mark. The middle, ring and pinky can be in the way. It IS indeed alot of $ to pay for. But being a member at MTO, I have become an addict. -
Sam would you carry this tool around the house for casual use? Is this a tool that on a off day would make a good companion?
-
@Aloha said:
Sam would you carry this tool around the house for casual use? Is this a tool that on a off day would make a good companion?I dun like to deploy the blade, I dislike snapping the pliers open, I am afraid to use the screw drivers. If I only need a scissor and a pry tool, short answer, still no. Sorry..
-
Well that stinks
. For the collection then.......... 
-
Something else to note on my sentiment towards this new Free series. I am not from the part of the world that have wonderful no question asked warranty on LMs. This is not on my retail shelves yet. If we are talking about a regular LM with regular parts, I will not be afraid to use it. I can even volunteer to test them till the point of failure, if I am drunk enough. The Free is a whole new thing altogether. New parts, new design. I know repairing them myself is definitely out of question and sending back for warranty will be another challenge. Maybe, those drivers can withstand a reasonable amount of torque. But by gut feel and common physics, that is not quite possible. Many so called "improvements" are unnecessary. That pliers snap lock, to me is a hindrance, even rolling the tools open hurts my thumb. etc etc.. But as much as I do not have a positive feeling towards it, this is by far the most interesting and a completely new design by a manufacturer in many years. They are now like starting from ground zero again. There's heaps of refinement to be done to make this a comfortable and true user's tool.
-
When/if my P4 has a failure, I'll report it. I just can't know a driver is weak without seeing it fail(whether it is mine or a significant number of reports). Reasonable use so far hasn't shown the drivers to be a problem. I don't believe that conjecture is equal to evaluation. :)
-
@Aloha said:
Well that stinks
. For the collection then.......... 
I wouldn't go that far ...
Yes, the Free P4 doesn't offer that sturdy "I can handle anything" feeling that the Wave/Charge gives you, but this does not mean it will certainly let you down when you use it. As others have said here before, as long as you understand that the Free is more of a "fun to play with" tool and not something that can replace the Wave/Charge, or Surge/ST300 while working a construction site, you'll be fine.
When you go for a hike in the outdoors, or a trip to the city and you just want to bring a tool in case you need to fix something along the way, like unscrewing the battery compartment from a certain device, or filing down a sharp edge on something that broke during you trip, or cutting a piece of metal wire to hold up the exhaust on your car to prevent it from dragging under your car all the way back ... you know, just one of those things that occasionally happen and which can ruin your day, I'm pretty sure the Free will deliver.
It's just not the tool to take with you when you know you're going to cut hardwire 2 hours in a row, or when you need to screw in 200 screws by hand, or ... You guys know what I mean, right ?
And for all you "tool-photographers" out there, it does make for some sweet pics. I would place it next to the classic Leatherman tools like the original Supertool, the PST, etc ... and the new "old style" tools like the Rebar and the ST300 (and once again, last but not least, the Swisstool) when it comes to being photogenic.
Spoiler:

And in my opinion, it is fun to play with, just as I like to play with my Gerber MP600 (sliding pliers
), or the mechanickal "bolt action rifle" clicks you get from opening and closing a Swisstool.Just my 2 cents ;).
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
I wouldn't go that far ...Yes, the Free P4 doesn't offer that sturdy "I can handle anything" feeling that the Wave/Charge gives you, but this does not mean it will certainly let you down when you use it. As others have said here before, as long as you understand that the Free is more of a "fun to play with" tool and not something that can replace the Wave/Charge, or Surge/ST300 while working a construction site, you'll be fine.
When you go for a hike in the outdoors, or a trip to the city and you just want to bring a tool in case you need to fix something along the way, like unscrewing the battery compartment from a certain device, or filing down a sharp edge on something that broke during you trip, or cutting a piece of metal wire to hold up the exhaust on your car to prevent it from dragging under your car all the way back ... you know, just one of those things that occasionally happen and which can ruin your day, I'm pretty sure the Free will deliver.
It's just not the tool to take with you when you know you're going to cut hardwire 2 hours in a row, or when you need to screw in 200 screws by hand, or ... You guys know what I mean, right ?
And for all you "tool-photographers" out there, it does make for some sweet pics. I would place it next to the classic Leatherman tools like the original Supertool, the PST, etc ... and the new "old style" tools like the Rebar and the ST300 (and once again, last but not least, the Swisstool) when it comes to being photogenic.
Spoiler:

And in my opinion, it is fun to play with, just as I like to play with my Gerber MP600 (sliding pliers
), or the mechanickal "bolt action rifle" clicks you get from opening and closing a Swisstool.Just my 2 cents ;).
Well said, T-G!

And great pic! Indeed, it is a looker. Going to go get some pics in a bit. :)
-
Hard to get any pics without any shade today, but here are a few.




-
Thank you TG24. I wasn't generalizing I was more directing those comments to Sam ;). If the tool was going to be more for his collection purposes only based on his experiences so far.
I wholeheartedly agree this tool looks to be a fine tool. I like Sams follow up
. Since he is not able to take advantage of LMs warranty he will have to, for now, not push the tool beyond his comfort. Also that this tool is a "whole new thing". I am applauding LM for this.I dont foresee failures, materials that is. The drivers snapping, plier jaws breaking, etc etc. Its not out of the question but until we actually see we can only guess. I do hope this tool in those of you who have them continue to experience positive feelings from them. The Free series while spendy for some sure looks every bit a tool for things that pop up. TG24 you couldn't have said it better. Might not replace anything in LMs lineup but theres really no need to. We've got heavy duty tools and light duty tools. We have room for in between tools.
Sorry if I wasn't clear earlier.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login