Evolution of Wood Saws on 91mm Victorinox SAKs
-
Or use the MTo gallery...
-
Thanks!

What about larger pictures, try to post them using Tapatalk application.
Relying on such external hosting services looks problematic from my perspective. If you go over some old threads here, you can see that such linked images tend to disappear over time. Attached images, on the other hand, seem to remain intact even when the OPs have not been seen here for years or are known to be deceased.
What tool will be next? Maybe Phillips on the back? ;)
We'll see. Doing Wenger saws can be far more challenging. The 85mm line should be easy (4-5 types, I think), but the older 92mm line is a big mess. :D
-
@MiniChamp said:
I don't really know anything about that. Does it require opening a new account? If so, how can it be done? Can you provide a link to related usage instructions?Yes, just send Def a PM and he'll add you to the list of users.
-
@zoidberg said:
Yes, just send Def a PM and he'll add you to the list of users.Thanks!

-
@MiniChamp said:
The pre-1940 era is very blurry for me. As noted above in this thread, there should be at least two more saw types from this era that are not yet in the list (there may very well be more;Well, it didn't take long for yet another type of wood saw to emerge: earlier today, a model 237 that appears to be from around 1902 was sold on eBay. It is shown in the attached image and has also been discussed on another thread. It has a saw with 23 teeth. This is the first time that I see a saw with this number of teeth on a 90mm/91mm Victorinox SAK.

-
@MiniChamp said:
Well, it didn't take long for yet another type of wood saw to emerge: earlier today, a model 237 that appears to be from around 1902 was sold on eBay. It is shown in the attached image and has also been discussed on another thread. It has a saw with 23 teeth. This is the first time that I see a saw with this number of teeth on a 90mm/91mm Victorinox SAK.
Would be nice if the winner is here and could get you better pics for your list.
-
@MiniChamp said:
Indeed! Unfortunately, I have absolutely no idea who that winner is. :(I guess its dave arnold / hobie. When he is up for a rare vintage knife, there s no limit.
-
@wengercollector said:
I guess its dave arnold / hobie.Unfortunately, it wasn't any of them, so it seems unlikely that we will be seeing this SAK featured in a nice Hobie video. Dave Arnold was actually one of the bidders, but (to my surprise) he didn't win. :o
-
As it has been just over a year since the last activity on this thread, I think that it may be worthwhile to give an update. Since I recently obtained an early model 237 with a type CN27ALS? saw that looks a little better than the one that I previously used, I made a new version of the table. Here it is:

What else?
As I kept following online sales, my findings concerning the post-1940 era revealed nothing new. I did not discover any new types of saws from this era, nor did I find any reason to change my previous estimates concerning the periods of time when the various types of saws were produced.
For the pre-1940 era, however, things are a little different and keep getting more interesting. I recorded only 6 newly observed saws on 90mm SAKs from this era. Out of these, 4 were left-weighted saws with 27 teeth (like most of the saws from this era seem to be), but two were different and thus unusual from my perspective.
The first of them, which is shown in the first attached image, is an early (probably pre-1920) model 237 with a (left-weighted) saw that has 29 teeth. While the scales on this SAK don't look original to me, I don't find strong reason to suspect the authenticity of the rest (although, one never really knows; the possibility that this saw isn't really original exists).
The second unusual saw can be seen in the second attached image. This is something truly remarkable from my perspective. The model 237 with this saw appears to be really VERY early, as it has the markers of the very first officer knives (an auger-type corkscrew and a "Gesetzlich Geschützt" stamp on the screwdriver). The saw is unlike any other saw that I have seen before on a Victorinox 90mm/91mm SAK. It seems to be unweighted with 30 teeth. Moreover, the shape of the tang is very unusual. Its bottom is in an angle and doesn't line up with the edges of the teeth like in other saws on 90mm/91mm Victorinox SAKs. Very strange.
So what is the conclusion?
I believe that, so far, I can say the following about the pre-1940 era:
-
It seems that most saws are left-weighted with 27 teeth.
-
Some saws are nevertheless left-weighted with 29 teeth (three such saws were shown above in this thread).
-
Some saws are nevertheless right-weighted with 27 teeth (I have seen two; One was shown above in this thread; a link to an image of the other was included in the opening post of this thread).
-
For very early SAKs one can find some very different types of saws (23 teeth and 30 teeth were shown above in this thread).
If anyone can shed more light on any of that, please do! I will greatly appreciate it!


-
-
A small update: I'm changing my estimate for the range of years when Victorinox used wood saws of type SN27ARLP to 1944-1949 (from 1945 - 1950). This is due to observing quite a few wood saws of this type on SAKs with the pre-1946 can opener, as well as observing quite a few saws with a standard nail nick (type SN27ARSP) on SAKs with the pre-1951 can opener.
It's now almost three years since this thread was started and I believe that the results of my little study are now sufficiently mature to be made easier to access. That is, I would like to make a single image file that would contain the main findings in a format that is easy to understand (bye bye cryptic type designations). Here is the first draft for such an image:

Feedback of any kind will be greatly appreciated.
-
Well done MiniChamp! Can you add few words about differences of 1966-1979 and post 1979 saw back spring please? It can be useful for beginners.
-
Thanks!
Can you add few words about differences of 1966-1979 and post 1979 saw back spring please? It can be useful for beginners.
Well, I thought that the remark "Reshaped tip (it is now resting on a bulge when folded)" should cover it. Can you propose better wording to explain it? Alternatively, do you think that it would be good to add an image explanation, like in the following version?

Thanks!

-
It looks grate for me, many thanks MiniChamp! Can we share it in other places please? What does SAKWIKI team think?
-
Whoa - How did I miss this thread? ???

Amazing research and images - Thanks to MC, JNOX, KK and all
As discussed these images are heading for the Wiki - Where they will be very much appreciated
:DPS. And I always thought that the saw had never changed much apart from 27 slopey teeth to 29 straight teeth! :o
-
Finally got MiniChamps brilliant saw evolution diagram in the Wiki - Apologies for the delay
https://sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Saw-wood
... via a link on the pageThanks MC
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

Very detailed information!