Leatherman Free P2/P4 Club and Feedback Thread
-
@Wpgwave said:
The little retaining tab inside broke off.
Not sure how the hell that happens!

That little double bend in the sheet metal might be a weak point. Especially if they formed the tab using two sheet metal operations and not a single pressing. Just the same as bending a paperclip back and forth.
My CAD model isn't perfectly accurate, but it looks like they put the first bend in to move the around the can opener. Than they put in a second bend to match the angle on the pliers.
If you close the tool with the pliers open, these little tabs close them for you, but it should not be enough force to break that tab, unless it was already cracked. -
Sounds like a plausible failure mode Zap...
Sorry that happened Wpgwave, hope it gets replaced soon!
-
You can see a line in the center of the broken half, it looks like it may have been cracked.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-

That little double bend in the sheet metal might be a weak point.** Especially if they formed the tab using two sheet metal operations and not a single pressing.** Just the same as bending a paperclip back and forth.
My CAD model isn't perfectly accurate, but it looks like they put the first bend in to move the around the can opener. Than they put in a second bend to match the angle on the pliers.
If you close the tool with the pliers open, these little tabs close them for you, but it should not be enough force to break that tab, unless it was already cracked.Agreed! I reckon it'll be coined in one hit, but that's still a fair bit of metal strain for a short return bend like that. When I was working in the drawing office with hydraulic folding machines, the golden rule for folding was 8x material thickness for the length of each bend . I never worked with press brakes though, so I don't know their true limitations before there's a risk of a tear.

@Wpgwave said:
You can see a line in the center of the broken half, it looks like it may have been cracked.Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Exactly what I thought

-
Thats the piece where the date stamp is on GLBM's newer sample

-
@Blackbeard said:
Thats the piece where the date stamp is on GLBM's newer sample
Excellent thought.

I will check the bend and thicknesses of the pliers return tabs in a bit.
We've got two recorded issues now.
- Scissors tang not cut correctly and pulling out with the drivers in one example.
- Pliers return tab broken off in one example.
-
O.K.
Looks like LM <u>may</u> have figured out there was an issue(possible tabs breaking during QC checks maybe), because the double-bend appears corrected slightly on the dated handle.
Dated handle bottom.

On the plus side, checking both P4s and the P2, I don't see any stress cracks or fissures on the 6 pliers return tabs.
-
That's still quite a sharp transition though
A softer nose radius there might be quite helpful (and on the inside of the other bend too) -
I pushed extremely hard on all of the tabs in my Ps and none of them broke and barely flexed. I think this is not going to be a common problem. The 420HC they used for the handles on the Ps is quite strong, even at the 'weak' areas.

-
A quick question, if it's cool. Is regular petroleum based gun oil immediately an issue for the elastomer cushions?
I had disassembled both of my P4 tools to make a swap of the handle scale only(with no date code) to the unused P4 that had a date code. Which meant an entire disassembly of one handle to swap the tools and swapping the other handle over to the other pliers head(decided I liked the first pliershead better for the collection P4). OK. The collection P4 does not do what I am about to describe. But, my user P4, after a day or so of use, has developed a slight "squeak" in one of the handles when opening/closing. I traced the noise the pivot where the elastomer cushion is at. Only one side does it, but I am not sure if I damaged it, or if it is the oil I used. It didn't occur to me when I oiled it after reassembly that I used petroleum based oil, since I usually use silicone based oil, but was out.
The P4(and P2) are somewhat troublesome to take apart, so I thought it might be a good idea to ask first. Well, not so much as troublesome to disassemble/reassemble, but getting the pivot tightness perfect(which took me about half an hour).
Should I wait and see if the "squeak" goes away, or do I need to take the pliers off, clean out all of the oil and dry the cushions, then apply some sort of rubber-safe grease?Any insight would be much appreciated.

-
Hi everyone
Just received a leatherman free p2 from leatherman australia for $290 aud or $202 usd, thats what they cost here.
First impressions are good. Nice solid lockup on all tools. Its a nice size thickness wise. It's kind of a skeletool with scissors, which is exactly what i was hoping for.
Here is a few thickness comparisons between some modern leatherman tools i have on hand.
First the new shiny itself

This is a skeletool


This one is a rebar

This one is a wave

This is a OHT


Thanks :)
-
GLBM
Maintenance Tips
A well-maintained Leatherman can last a lifetime. Learn how to care for your Leatherman.
Leatherman (www.leatherman.com)
I didnt see any info on what the material is in the P4 pivot but saw this page, not sure it will help, maybe there will be a PDF in the future that gives material specs
-
also saw a vid of a guy who switched some tools to make it more left hand useable, he mentioned there was some handle flex from the elastomer and the fact that the handles are made from 4 parts(2 per handle) as opposed to 2 on the other models, but didnt say anything about squeaking....but I doubt you could degrade the elastomer in such a short time period, maybe something got inside there?
-
Lube them so the squeak goes away, this is what we did in the automotive industry.
Regarding Bit adapter adn Tshank
From my point of view , the structure of the tool is not strong enough, although a carve-out in the pliers head can support the strength and provide the support for a bit adapter.
T-shank can be mounted yet it would sit without a tool, you would have to open it and mount the file or saw and than use it, which is somehow against the philosophy of the free(dom) P series. -
I'm studying the parts, i'll upload a reassembly tutorial tommorow. Those magnets definately are making the job harder, or easier depends if i can understand how the fields behave
https://youtu.be/TqRnRJ9dbWE -
@gerleatherberman said:
A quick question, if it's cool. Is regular petroleum based gun oil immediately an issue for the elastomer cushions?I had disassembled both of my P4 tools to make a swap of the handle scale only(with no date code) to the unused P4 that had a date code. Which meant an entire disassembly of one handle to swap the tools and swapping the other handle over to the other pliers head(decided I liked the first pliershead better for the collection P4). OK. The collection P4 does not do what I am about to describe. But, my user P4, after a day or so of use, has developed a slight "squeak" in one of the handles when opening/closing. I traced the noise the pivot where the elastomer cushion is at. Only one side does it, but I am not sure if I damaged it, or if it is the oil I used. It didn't occur to me when I oiled it after reassembly that I used petroleum based oil, since I usually use silicone based oil, but was out.
The P4(and P2) are somewhat troublesome to take apart, so I thought it might be a good idea to ask first. Well, not so much as troublesome to disassemble/reassemble, but getting the pivot tightness perfect(which took me about half an hour).
Should I wait and see if the "squeak" goes away, or do I need to take the pliers off, clean out all of the oil and dry the cushions, then apply some sort of rubber-safe grease?Any insight would be much appreciated.

Without knowing what they're made of, it's hard to say, but the sensible thing would be to have used an resistant grade. Assuming it's a good industrial grade O ring rubber, that same material can be found sealing hydraulic powerpacks, neat cutting oil delivery systems, auto lube systems, and many other industrial applications where they're subject to load, movement, and petroleum based products. They need to have done something very stupid for this to degrade with gun oil.
If it squeaks, add more lube. If it still squeaks, take it apart and give it a good clean and inspect.
-
@Raoul Octav said:
Lube them so the squeak goes away, this is what we did in the automotive industry.
Regarding Bit adapter adn Tshank
From my point of view , the structure of the tool is not strong enough, although a carve-out in the pliers head can support the strength and provide the support for a bit adapter.
T-shank can be mounted yet it would sit without a tool, you would have to open it and mount the file or saw and than use it, which is somehow against the philosophy of the free(dom) P series.Spending my first day with the p4, my second thought is it’s quite heavy. Don’t have a scale to see the difference between the p4 and a wave + so not sure but seems a bit lighter then the wave.
Anyway I wanted to share my findings regarding bit the bit adapter. I have a range of tools Gerber and SOG some with bit set. I found the sog bitset the most useable with the tool. The adapter sits on the top of the Phillips firm enough to use any standard bits. The only drawback I found is the adapter end goes to the Phillips doesn’t have a magnet so can fall off easier.




On the last image there is a similar adapter (Gerber) which potentially would be better but I don’t have tools to make the hole wider to fit the Phillips driver.
I also seen a YouTube video about a similar concept where a guy was using a wera adapter for the bits. If someone interested the video can be find online.
I hope the above would help someone who interested to extend the possibility of this tool... -
@Striker said:
Hi everyone
Just received a leatherman free p2 from leatherman australia for $290 aud or $202 usd, thats what they cost here.
First impressions are good. Nice solid lockup on all tools. Its a nice size thickness wise. It's kind of a skeletool with scissors, which is exactly what i was hoping for.
Here is a few thickness comparisons between some modern leatherman tools i have on hand.
First the new shiny itself

This is a skeletool


This one is a rebar

This one is a wave

This is a OHT


Thanks :)
Very nice, Striker!

@Blackbeard said:
GLBM
Maintenance Tips
A well-maintained Leatherman can last a lifetime. Learn how to care for your Leatherman.
Leatherman (www.leatherman.com)
I didnt see any info on what the material is in the P4 pivot but saw this page, not sure it will help, maybe there will be a PDF in the future that gives material specs
Thanks, Blackbeard!

@Raoul Octav said:
Lube them so the squeak goes away, this is what we did in the automotive industry.
Regarding Bit adapter adn Tshank
From my point of view , the structure of the tool is not strong enough, although a carve-out in the pliers head can support the strength and provide the support for a bit adapter.
T-shank can be mounted yet it would sit without a tool, you would have to open it and mount the file or saw and than use it, which is somehow against the philosophy of the free(dom) P series.Thanks, Raoul!

@AimlessWanderer said:
Without knowing what they're made of, it's hard to say, but the sensible thing would be to have used an resistant grade. Assuming it's a good industrial grade O ring rubber, that same material can be found sealing hydraulic powerpacks, neat cutting oil delivery systems, auto lube systems, and many other industrial applications where they're subject to load, movement, and petroleum based products. They need to have done something very stupid for this to degrade with gun oil.If it squeaks, add more lube. If it still squeaks, take it apart and give it a good clean and inspect.
Thank you very much, AW!

That was definitely what I was hoping. Will lube it up a bit more and see what happens. Perhaps the oil didn't make it to the pivot area. I called myself making sure it did, but like anything else, it could have just been 'one of those days' when messing with the P4s. :ahhh@shadow78 said:
Spending my first day with the p4, my second thought is it’s quite heavy. Don’t have a scale to see the difference between the p4 and a wave + so not sure but seems a bit lighter then the wave.
Anyway I wanted to share my findings regarding bit the bit adapter. I have a range of tools Gerber and SOG some with bit set. I found the sog bitset the most useable with the tool. The adapter sits on the top of the Phillips firm enough to use any standard bits. The only drawback I found is the adapter end goes to the Phillips doesn’t have a magnet so can fall off easier.




On the last image there is a similar adapter (Gerber) which potentially would be better but I don’t have tools to make the hole wider to fit the Phillips driver.
I also seen a YouTube video about a similar concept where a guy was using a wera adapter for the bits. If someone interested the video can be find online.
I hope the above would help someone who interested to extend the possibility of this tool...The P4 weighs about .3oz more than the Wave+. So the weight difference is negligible.

Thank you for your insights into the bit holder situation. I'm hoping LM releases a bit adapters at some point, because at this points, making a solid-setup bit adapter would involve reshaping the phillips shank on the P4. :ahhh
-
So, after gettin inside the Free and using it intensly i have to say the following:
-Inteligent platform, with real easy axx of the tools with one hand
-not quite as hardcore as other LMNs, Wave Surge, Rebar and ST300 are my points of refference
-tools are great EDC, yet i would have skipped a blade(serrated one) to have a larger file and some sort of bit holder/adapter
-Leatherman has skipped some washers/spacers, wich would make the tools more easy to deploy. And for that i am real pissed off -
@Raoul Octav said:
So, after gettin inside the Free and using it intensly i have to say the following:
-Inteligent platform, with real easy axx of the tools with one hand
-not quite as hardcore as other LMNs, Wave Surge, Rebar and ST300 are my points of refference
-tools are great EDC, yet i would have skipped a blade(serrated one) to have a larger file and some sort of bit holder/adapter
-Leatherman has skipped some washers/spacers, wich would make the tools more easy to deploy. And for that i am real pissed offI whole-heartedly agree with all, but the last point.

I think more washers and spacers would have either added to the thickness and/or compromised the thickness of the blades. IMO of course. And not to mention, the thing is already complicated to assemble/reassemble already with just two washers per handle(because of magnets). :ahhh
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login