Are backside tools overrated?
-
I've got an Alox model in my pocket today.....so I'm going with "yes".
But I might have a different answer tomorrow.....

-
I know the feeling all too well
. Nix, do you hesitate for just a moment tho? When I reach for my 84mm SAK I instinctively want to go with my Tinker. The backside tools call to my inner need for options. Then I grab my Cadet or Recruit and off I go not looking back one bit. -
I’m kinda hooked on alox so I’d say don’t need them, although I’m making a custom sak, which has backside tools, being a awl and Philips, only thing is there’s a Philips on the front, really only need the one on the back to fill in the spot, and the awl is a Wenger so kinda crapy, so still kinda a still don’t need backside tools
JR -
Yes of course they are overrated... when you don't need them.
But when you need one, you're so glad to have 'm! -
I say the more tools the merrier!
-
If there is no additional bulk created, why not?
I love the corkscrew on my Vic, even though I hardly drink. It's carries the mini screwdriver, and my anti-party-pooping tool. You could try to substitute the can opener for a phillips(I know, I know, same as don't pry with your knife), but no CS is just pure party pooping. The feeling is worse than no having any tool at all.

And without the backside CS/philips, I loose the needle holder too.
-
My inner need for options means the Tinker is best tool to carry. I used to carry a 91mm Recruit till the Explorer came into my life. When I reach for a 84mm these two stare at me a each is great. My instinct is Tinker but I think I equally reach for my Recruit.
Alox officiandos know all to well the can opener is a real multitool. Lots can be done with that tool as compared to the backside philips, am I right?
-
I think only tools are suited to back are cork screw and hook. Others just substitute lack of inline tools.
Sent from my VIE-L09 using Tapatalk
-
@Aloha said:
Alox officiandos know all to well the can opener is a real multitool. Lots can be done with that tool as compared to the backside philips, am I right?I guess it is a preference thing, I think the trade-off is between:
Having corkscrew + minidriver + use can opener for make-shift philips driver VS backside Philips.
Personally, I would tend to choose to have former rather than latter.
-
I have a hookless Explorer and do like the corkscrew for my mini driver. My CT29 has the corkscrew and awl but I use neither. I do like how the mini driver lives in the corkscrew tho.
-
The only backside tools I use regularly are the phillips and the package hook file when I would carry the compact. That being said, I think the inline phillips is definitely nicer than the backside one, but it is a trade-off of layers/thickness.
-
@temo said:
I think only tools are suited to back are cork screw and hook. Others just substitute lack of inline tools.Sent from my VIE-L09 using Tapatalk
@EMZ said:
Yes of course they are overrated... when you don't need them.
But when you need one, you're so glad to have 'm!I agree with both of these sentiments. I like having the option, and I especially like having the eyeglass screwdriver carried in the corkscrew.
-
Yes inline phillips layer is quite thick. So Ok compromise to have that in back. Mainly ment that hook and screw are actually better in back then would be inline. Others are a bit compromises to have extra tool. Without getting extra layer. And there is some attraction with vics without back tools. And no removable parts. Simplicity and usability versus large amount of tools. Have to say I can't tell wich is better..
Sent from my VIE-L09 using Tapatalk
-
Bulk adding, yes. Overrated, no.
Last week I repaired my brother's table using only my 'Troublemaker' (Marlboro Troubleshooter w/ Lite). Used the awl, chisel and backside phillips. On the top side, I used the metal saw to cut some 3/8" oak dowels and the small blade for some scraping, and the pliers. Oh, and the tweezers to remove some debris from the dowel holes. Not bad for something that fits in my jeans change pocket.
-
Not overrated at all. Perhaps underrated. The models I generally carry have the corkscrew, awl, and hook on the backside, and I use all of these.
-
While the backside tools barely rate for me nowadays, they're definitely not useless. Once upon a time, a Tinker and a 4 inch crescent wrench were the only tools I owned. I built a desk using that backside Philips. Adjusted my first kydex sheath with that backside Phillips. And then I got a set of real tools...plus that crescent wrench. Haven't used a backside tool since.
-
The only way to get the small slotted screwdriver (without going for bit driver, or a custom or retired model), is as a backside tool. Not an ideal placement, but better than nothing.
-
I've been carrying a modified DofE for about a week. It only has two backspring tools, and I've used them both. Topside tools tend to be better and stronger, but add more bulk and weight. I think the best way to consider the backspring tools is as bonus features, rather than primary ones.
Most of us wouldn't pick a car based on the size of the glovebox, or whether or not it has a power socket in the boot, or whether there's a USB socket to stick in a thumbdrive with your favourite songs on, but they can still be nice addition features to have for many people.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login