Been doing some work in the Wiki
-
Huntman , perhaps you can add some info to the HELMSMAN page https://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Helmsman
The MARINER is mentioned in that page but there is no further info.
Attached a MARINER picture. This SAK has a full serrated blade and not partially like the HELMSMAN .
-
@ Max - Added the family pic to the Pioneer SA variation
@ Ivo - Thanks for the info - I added the pic and a new variation - Now No. 4
Not too happy with this page (or at least the variations section) - It's a bit confusing with the name change (over time?) and possibly different names in different markets
For instance - Is variation 2 the same as variation 5 ? ??? ....... It looks like it - And was Helmsman CS an official name (I added the comments in brackets today)- I know previous editors sometimes made up names in some instances !! :o
If anyone can think of better wording please let me know - or make the change if you are an editor!
-
Thanks Huntsman , I'll try to find more info about this SAK models

-
@smiller43147 said:
I was checking out my favorite tool, the Pocket Toolchest on the wiki, and I followed the link to the Reamer page. No 65mm Reamer/awl on that page.Huntsman, could you add the 65mm awl/reamer to the Reamer page on SAKWiki?
https://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Reamer
-
Hi Smiler
- Thanks for the heads up on this omission - and the great piccie (that matches the others - cudos)
Will update soon - The whole page needs a bit of work as the piccies have gone tiny - This can be fixed but it's a bigger job
Re the Helmsman/Mariner - LeaF has chipped in with some useful info - I also checked the Wiki gallery - And this is where we are:
Please review and if we all agree I'll update accordingly ....The Mariner was the first version and it had a **fully serrated **blade and regular red scales
The Mariner was also available in a **corkscrew **version
The Helmsman was the later incarnation and introduced the blue scales
The Helmsman was available with **fully **or **partially **serrated blades..... (as was the Skipper)
The fully serrated version was unofficially known as a Helmsman CSPossibly either name was used in different markets? Any thoughts? ??? Or was it purely a time and scale thing - as described above?
I am not sure where the ***CS ***name came from (maybe a Wiki editor? ???) and why CS? - As CS normally means corkscrew
- Maybe - Completely Serrated - This is a bit confusing

If we think this is an unofficial/made up name - I would rather change it to FS - Fully serrated - Which is what the Wiki uses elsewhere.
Any comments or more enlightenments folks ? ???
Thanks all
- Thanks for the heads up on this omission - and the great piccie (that matches the others - cudos)
-
Just a question to soldier knives experts... Any reason why there is no model 1908 listed?
Soldier 1890 page mentions that same model with some variations continued on until 1951...
Whilst, LCSAS has a separate listing for 1908... the page even has a blue print for model 1908...
I can understand model 1901 isn’t there as some experts considered this to be the same as model 1890 except for the scales...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Hey Huntsman, wanna use this pic for the Wenger Soldat 1961 page?


It shows my specimens for the Soldat /Standard Issue (16520) / Swiss Army 70... I will need to take a better one... looks a bit dark...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@jaya_man said:
Just a question to soldier knives experts... Any reason why there is no model 1908 listed?
Soldier 1890 page mentions that same model with some variations continued on until 1951...
Whilst, LCSAS has a separate listing for 1908... the page even has a blue print for model 1908...
http://www.couteaux-du-soldat-suisse.ch/J01/index.php/en/les-couteaux-du-soldat
http://www.couteaux-du-soldat-suisse.ch/J01/images/photos_site/modeles/1908/1908.pdf
I can understand model 1901 isn’t there as some experts considered this to be the same as model 1890 except for the scales...Jaya are you suggesting a whole new page for the 1908 model?
So the main difference from 1890 model to 1908 is the drop point to spear point - Right?
In the Wiki we say this:
1890 Soldier Developments
The original Swiss Soldier Knife was issued to Swiss troops beginning in 1891, and has continued every year to the present day. This model was issued until 1951. Karl Elsener’s company, in conjunction with other Swiss cutlers, took over production in late 1891.- The knives were originally produced with wooden handles, regular carbon steel and a drop-point blade.
- After 1901 the handles were switched to a brown wooden fibrous material.
- In 1908 the blade was switched to a clip-point design.
- Knives produced from 1921 (to the present day) have the year of production stamped on the tang of the main blade as two digits: YY - e.g. '36 ' for 1936.
So I think we have it covered ?

LCAS for sure will always be the definitive source for Soldier information
Thoughts Soldier experts ?
-
Huntsman, I was just merely asking for background on the sakwiki approach... ie, why no soecific mention or page on the model 1908... Not only did it have the clip point blade, but the screw driver tool is different...
Ulli’s soldier evolution pic is to the point in terms of milestones but does not mention the model numbers...
Another basis for the query, is I was asked in a discussion on the local Indonesian SAK grp about this as well, when there are alot of references to the specific model 1908...
-
Oh here’s the edited Wenger Soldat pic...

-
I updated the 1890 Soldier page to really make clear the evolution of the 1890 model through the 1901 and 1908 variations
https://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Soldier+1890This was a good suggestion and improvement - Thanks Jaya
- As always comments/feedback/requests welcome
Hoping to get onto the catalogues next and finish off updating the Battle Series
-
Maybe interesting for the Wiki:
Wenger Porsche including paperwork
-
:ahhh
-
@CeHo said:
Maybe interesting for the Wiki: Wenger Porsche including paperworkIt was
...... https://sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Wenger+Porsche+Design+Series :D
The page was also a bit messed up - So I fixed it!Mauser variant also added - Thanks Meccy
-

Good job

-
Great page Huntsman.

-
@jazzbass said:
The confusion arises because the SAK collecting community - the American community in particular - over the years has come up with what I call "collector's names" to refer to certain models. In almost all cases, this is done when the model either didn't have an official name (as was typical prior to the mid 1970s) or where it's official name was subsequently recycled onto another knife. These names are typically derived from either their 91mm equivalents (e.g. Huntsman Small) or from names found in catalogs from other countries. The SIMCO Canadian catalogs especially have contributed several "collector's names".The knife we call the "Artisan" (136k, aka 84mm Fieldmaster) was sold in the US as the "Craftsman" almost exclusively. We use the Artisan name (French for Craftsman, btw) from the SIMCO to avoid confusion with the 91mm models of the same name. I have a several of these NIB - the boxes all say "Craftsman".
This is back from 2014...but perhaps this clears up some of the Craftsman 136ka issues regarding the use of 'Artisan'. Perhaps since jazzbass said it more than 5 years ago, there's a chance some will believe it's true.
I was actually looking for something else when I found this...related somewhat. I have a theory that the actual 50 Master Craftsman knives ordered by NASA in '78 were the fish scaler version. #5044 (US) referenced in the NASA letter may cross reference the 1.47 93 version. The 1976 dealer catalog may support the theory too.
-
^^^ Great find KK - I think most of us acknowledge that JB is the highest of the higher authorities !! ;)
Also I think SAKWiki editors have also been guilty of inventing a name every now and again !I gotta admit I am finding this name re-using; different names for the same models; different names in different markets; and 'made up names' thing to be getting more than a little frustrating.

I know I shouldn't as the situation has evolved over many decades and has only come about as the world is shrinking and we now have collectors interested in SAKs from years ago that were only ever conceived as working tools/pocket knives for sale in a certain geography!That is a really interesting theory about the NASA Craftsmen though - So you reckon NASA bought and sent up the six layer model that we now call the Craftsman
For sure ..... In the 76 dealer catalogue the six layer one is indeed called the ***Master ***Craftsman - And then you look at the 1982 catalogue and its called the ***Craftsman ***....... Grrrrrr - see what I mean !
However I am a little sceptical of this theory as the model that ended up as the *"Space Shuttle'' *model - For sure is five layers and I would have thought that model matched the one NASA bought? ??? - Thoughts
Anyway updating the Craftsmen pages is probably bubbled to the top of the Wiki do list. Will put a post here when it's done.
Also I am due one of my big Wiki update posts now as a lot has happened since the last one!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login