Leatherman Free P2/P4 Club and Feedback Thread
-
Peeps in the UK.
The local Leatherman support Whitby&co has the pocket clips for the P4s. The drawback is they wont send them out. They need the P4 to be returned under their warranty service as only they can replace the pocket clip :P.
I decided I'm OK without the pocket clip, will buy one when become widely available...The above is just for info if anyone interested to get a free pocket clip in the UK.

-
I received my replacement P2, and honestly, I am still happy with the multi tool.
I gave the tool a solid going over with a dry Teflon spray and everything is like butter now. Smooth and fluid.My only real issue(s) is the play in the handles and the loose feeling when closed. By loose, the amount of travel the pliers have inside the folded handle. You can slide the closed halves up and down quite a ways and get a clacking sound from the pliers hitting the internal stops.
I was seriously thinking about the P4 but aside from a saw, there wasn’t enough to justify the increase in size and weight.
The P2 feels a little more “elegant” and balanced to me.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@Wpgwave said:
I received my replacement P2, and honestly, I am still happy with the multi tool.
I gave the tool a solid going over with a dry Teflon spray and everything is like butter now. Smooth and fluid.My only real issue(s) is the play in the handles and the loose feeling when closed. By loose, the amount of travel the pliers have inside the folded handle. You can slide the closed halves up and down quite a ways and get a clacking sound from the pliers hitting the internal stops.
I was seriously thinking about the P4 but aside from a saw, there wasn’t enough to justify the increase in size and weight.
The P2 feels a little more “elegant” and balanced to me.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Glad the replacement is working for you, Wpgwave!

I wasn't really o.k. with the looseness of the handles either, so I tightened the pliers mount screws a bit and haven't looked back. It still flips open flawlessly and feels tight. :)
The design calls for really loose handles, but that isn't something I'm used to or want. Easy fix. :) -
A comparison between the P4 and the OHT would be interesting....
The P4 might even win the file comparison. ;) -
To be honest, it isn't even a contest for me. The OHT is just too big and clunky with tiny implements compared to the P4. The P4 is compact, good looking(that one is admittedly subjective), smoother, far more precise, and has better implements(except for oxygen tank wrench and strap cutter, which the P4 doesn't have, but the P4 makes up for it with a short(but very high quality) file, drivers, a tool that does kind of work as an awl, and scissors). The P4 makes the OHT look archaic and cumbersome. :ahhh
The OHT is the tool LM should have lambasted to promote the P4 instead of the venerable Wave. :(
Ya know, I guess I can do some comparison photos later today.

The OHT is not a bad tool, but it really isn't comparable to the P4 in most aspects. IMO of course.
-
I meant a usage comparison.
I like the OHT.... :'(
-
The OHT is a good tool, but it has its' drawbacks. I definitely wouldn't be upset if I got stuck out somewhere needing an MT and the OHT was the only one available. :)
The OHT has one HUGE advantage over the P4. It can get really dirty and be used around metal filings and not need maintenance for months. The P4 suffers the same issue as SwissTools, as dirt gets in the pivots, the action gets exponentially stiffer and needs serious maintenance to work right again. The P4 can be disassembled though, so it has that going for it over riveted construction. -
Alright, Syncop8r, here they are. I hope this helps put the two tools in perspective. There doesn't seem to be any real comparisons out there of the two. I've only had about a month of real work use out of each tool(the OHT I used was the two-tone used in the challenge), so it isn't extended or anything. But, that said, I have a tough-on-tools job and the environment gets dirty quite often and tools get dropped sometimes. The OHT smaller flat drivers are definitely thicker than those on the P4. The OHT pliers also seem more suited to hard pliers tasks. Same cutters on both tools.
I'll shut up now and get to the copious photos.
















-
Thanks!
The size difference is the most obvious thing. The only tool I find to be too short on the OHT is the saw, short drivers etc I can cope with. I'm surprised the P4's saw is nearly as short.I felt a comparison would be interesting since they are both all outside/one-handed opening multitools.
-
@Syncop8r said:
Thanks!
The size difference is the most obvious thing. The only tool I find to be too short on the OHT is the saw, short drivers etc I can cope with. I'm surprised the P4's saw is nearly as short.I felt a comparison would be interesting since they are both all outside/one-handed opening multitools.

-
My2cents.
OHT deployment of tools is better, easyer.
Oht can receive Wave blades/file/saw at a cost (loose the opossite implement or loose the one hand opening for the opposite implement) .
Tool is big yet light in the hand. Pliers have spring, i observed this is a must for some people.
Free P is compact, good size, needs maintenace for ease of deployment of implements and some practicr in the beginning, way handyer while using YET whaaaaayyyy more expensive.
It depends on what you need it for.
Both are good tools. -
Contacted Leatherman USA about the missing pocket clip for my P4.
Received it today

-
-
Kind of funny they sent a bit for a tool that doesn’t have a bit driver. [emoji57]
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
@gadgetman7 said:
Kind of funny they sent a bit for a tool that doesn’t have a bit driver. [emoji57]Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I think they were very kind, as I asked if they could provide me a wrench to install the pocket clip
-
Agreed. Question: did you buy the P4 via the LM USA web site?
-
@gadgetman7 said:
Kind of funny they sent a bit for a tool that doesn’t have a bit driver. [emoji57]Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
It is funny, because you cannot use the tool you're putting the clip on, to put the clip on it.
:D
I'm always happy to have spare bits.Sorry. Couldn't help myself. I'm kidding of course.

-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
Agreed. Question: did you buy the P4 via the LM USA web site?No, the tool was purchased in a shop here in Italy
-
:o basilio - remarkable. I thought they only honoured US acquisitions...
Time to remind them, my related mail must have gone missing. -
@gerleatherberman said:
It is funny, because you cannot use the tool you're putting the clip on, to put the clip on it.
:D
I'm always happy to have spare bits.Sorry. Couldn't help myself. I'm kidding of course.


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login