What Traditional Knife are you toting today?
-
@Fuzzbucket said:
Look at all that GEC goodness!

How are you getting on with the Possum Skinner, is it holding up alright?
I'm getting on with it alright. Its a good knife. I've heard stories about weak springs and light snap but this one is good on both accounts. Like having the Wharncliff blade. That also eases my want of a Hawbaker Muskrat. :D
-
Nice knives Spartan and David

-

I like the atheistic about this GEC #54, but man o' man, the pull is serious for real. If 10 is wielded shut, then this gonna be either a 9 or at least a 8.5. I am debting whether I should keep it 3/4 opened to 'weaken' the spring(which I doubt it will do anything, I did picked up a SAK opened for years, if not decades, and the spring is almost gone...but with a strong spring like this, I doubt a week or two will mean anything) or I should jam a small screwdriver at the back to pull the spring back very little bit at a time to 'weaken' the spring...at this rate, this knife is only usable once a day(any more my nail will start to pull out, I could feel it).


Folks, what would you recommend me to do? Jam or no jam? Seriously don't want to let it down the road, love everything about it except the spring.
-
Nice looking knife comis

-
I like the atheistic about this GEC #54, but man o' man, the pull is serious for real. If 10 is wielded shut, then this gonna be either a 9 or at least a 8.5. I am debting whether I should keep it 3/4 opened to 'weaken' the spring(which I doubt it will do anything, I did picked up a SAK opened for years, if not decades, and the spring is almost gone...but with a strong spring like this, I doubt a week or two will mean anything) or I should jam a small screwdriver at the back to pull the spring back very little bit at a time to 'weaken' the spring...at this rate, this knife is only usable once a day(any more my nail will start to pull out, I could feel it).

Folks, what would you recommend me to do? Jam or no jam? Seriously don't want to let it down the road, love everything about it except the spring.
My #54 Harness Jack was the same way. You can ease the pull by carefully rounding the tangs with a small square file.
Mine is now a comfortable 5 or 6 pull. I went a little to far maybe as it did affect the closing snap of the blade and it's a bit lazy now. I'm fine with that though because before it was a nail breaker and had a really scary closing snap and I didn't carry it because of that.
-
Got me an artisanal Bandida, from the same maker of my Laggy. Been carrying it for a couple of days, but still haven't had a chance to use it.
- :( :D :P
Spoiler:
I know, I know... just copy/posted the same message in a few threads. I'm lazy, deal with it!

-
@SteveC said:
My #54 Harness Jack was the same way. You can ease the pull by carefully rounding the tangs with a small square file.Mine is now a comfortable 5 or 6 pull. I went a little to far maybe as it did affect the closing snap of the blade and it's a bit lazy now. I'm fine with that though because before it was a nail breaker and had a really scary closing snap and I didn't carry it because of that.
Just to be absolutely sure, should I file only one side of the tang(blue area) or rounding entire corner(red area)? (why does it feel like I'm asking whether to cut the red or the blue line on phone
:D )Photo borrowed from knife informer:

-
@pfrsantos said:
Got me an artisanal Bandida, from the same maker of my Laggy. Been carrying it for a couple of days, but still haven't had a chance to use it.- :( :D :P
Spoiler:
I know, I know... just copy/posted the same message in a few threads. I'm lazy, deal with it!

Like that unique look of the handle, nice! And I always think quattro is one of the coolest one piece tool.

-
@comis said:
Just to be absolutely sure, should I file only one side of the tang(blue area) or rounding entire corner(red area)? (why does it feel like I'm asking whether to cut the red or the blue line on phone
:D )Photo borrowed from knife informer:

When I get a nail-breaker, I just let it stay half open, so the blade is forcing the spring a little. Awlso try to open/close it a few times between half open time, so the spring rests a little.
I wouldn't try to file any of it.

-
Sword Brand today

-
@pfrsantos said:
When I get a nail-breaker, I just let it stay half open, so the blade is forcing the spring a little. Awlso try to open/close it a few times between half open time, so the spring rests a little.I wouldn't try to file any of it.

I've seen a few techniques from BF to deal with overly strong backspring, namely:
- open 3/4 or 1/4 to bend/soften the spring
- Tape the blade, keep on opening/closing the blade hundreds of times(essentially could be like filing the corner)
- Jam a small screwdriver into the gap between backspring and kinfe tang, then open very very slowly to stretch backspring
- Filing the tang
I just kinda want to see how different people deal tackle the same problem, ideally I'd like to leave it at 1/4 or 3/4 to weaken the spring, but with a 4-5" knife with a beefy back spring, I just don't know how long do I have to realistically wait before it soften. It could be weeks or months(I think waiting years, or even months, is just down right silly, don't you think?).
-
@comis said:
Just to be absolutely sure, should I file only one side of the tang(blue area) or rounding entire corner(red area)? (why does it feel like I'm asking whether to cut the red or the blue line on phone
:D )Photo borrowed from knife informer:
Here's a quick sketch. If you think about how the tang interacts with the spring while opening you want to ease the corner that is first in contact with it when opening. Go slow and check often. It helps to put a piece of cotton or tissue soaked in oil inside the knife to catch the shavings. You will get some in the pivot and have to flush well with oil. It also helps to check with a magnfier to make sure you are rounding the tang evenly side to side.
Proceed with caution.

I tried leaving this knife 1/4 open for a few weeks with no effect. YMMV

-
@comis said:
Just to be absolutely sure, should I file only one side of the tang(blue area) or rounding entire corner(red area)? (why does it feel like I'm asking whether to cut the red or the blue line on phone
:D )Photo borrowed from knife informer:

GEC does a good job with their springs, so leaving the blade 3/4 open won't help,
Never jam a screw driver between the blade and spring. Unless you want the Very possible risk of a broken the spring.Steve's advise is spot on.
Rounding the tang corner is the only fix I would attempt. I can't stress enough when you have it close to where you want it stop. The tang will work polish over time. Flush the knife with WD-40 and re-oil before testing your progress.
I use a combination of a very fine file and then polish with a soft 600 or finer grit Gesswein stone. Stones have the benefit of taking on shape making it easier to polish. Stones can be ground to fit as well. Gesswein has a wide variety of stones to choose from.
It doesn't hurt to practice on a cheap knife.
Edited to add Steve's advise.
Here's a quick sketch. If you think about how the tang interacts with the spring while opening you want to ease the corner that is first in contact with it when opening. Go slow and check often. It helps to put a piece of cotton or tissue soaked in oil inside the knife to catch the shavings. You will get some in the pivot and have to flush well with oil. It also helps to check with a magnfier to make sure you are rounding the tang evenly side to side.Proceed with caution.



Here's a couple tangs I've done to give you an idea of how little metal you are removing.



-
@pfrsantos said:
Got me an artisanal Bandida, from the same maker of my Laggy. Been carrying it for a couple of days, but still haven't had a chance to use it.- :( :D :P
Spoiler:
I know, I know... just copy/posted the same message in a few threads. I'm lazy, deal with it!

Now that's something different

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

