New Style Magnifying Lens Issue
-
@Ptisuisse said:
IMHO the best way to establish once for all if there is really an issue with those new mags is to do nothing in case one falls out.
nothing, short of applying for warranty repair. If no one bothers, Victorinox will never be officialy aware of the potential problem,
and will never try to fix it if needed.I would bet my left foot that Victorinox is fully aware of the issue. I've personally sent several emails to them about it. But, I am not paying the shipping to send mine back and wait weeks for another one. Shipping costs a lot more than super-glue. :P
Kind of funny, that when Vic has a quality issue, they don't get lambasted like most other companies do.

-
Kind of funny, that when Vic has a quality issue, they don't get lambasted like most other companies do.

[/quote]But they should be. >:( Nobody should be allowed to sell cra..p and get away with it. Send them just the lens to save on shipping. ;)
-
@Ptisuisse said:
But they should be. >:( Nobody should be allowed to sell cra..p and get away with it. Send them just the lens to save on shipping. ;)I have to agree.

Only thing about sending back the lens is that I have zero issues with the newer glass lenses. It is the translucent frame that holds the lens that isn't nearly as good as the earlier grey ones.
And, to be honest, I wouldn't be so adamant about it, except that I had grown accustomed to the strong grey lens frame of my older Vics. The old layer with the grey frame and longer phillips was one of my favorite things about SAKs that had it.But, like everything else, the older ones (SAKs) were better quality. :ahhh
On the plus side, there are a lot of older SAKs out there for sale.

-
But they should be. >:( Nobody should be allowed to sell cra..p and get away with it. Send them just the lens to save on shipping. ;)
I have to agree.

Only thing about sending back the lens is that I have zero issues with the newer glass lenses. It is the translucent frame that holds the lens that isn't nearly as good as the earlier grey ones.
And, to be honest, I wouldn't be so adamant about it, except that I had grown accustomed to the strong grey lens frame of my older Vics. The old layer with the grey frame and longer phillips was one of my favorite things about SAKs that had it.But, like everything else, the older ones (SAKs) were better quality. :ahhh
On the plus side, there are a lot of older SAKs out there for sale.

My preference would be a SwissChamp with the old magnifier with gray frame and the longer phillips screwdriver, but I prefer the newer metal file/saw over the old metal file/saw.
-
Like a few others I've complained about the lens falling out in my Explorer, even with careful opening and closing, and have long intended to use epoxy to fix it in place permanently. I didn't want to use superglue for fear of clouding the housing. I wasn't going to buy an epoxy kit specially though, so I was waiting for another job to come along. Crazy then, within an hour of my post about it yesterday, I found a 5 minute kit staring at me in my spare room. A tiny spot inside opposite sides of the frame means the lens ain't going nowhere, now! :D
It was a fiddly job and I was afraid to get resin on the lens as I put in place. I did smear a little of the fishy smelling part on it and was relieved that it wiped off readily with a lens tissue. The marks on the lens in the picture are dust.
I could see no point in sending the knife back to Victorinox since it would cost over 20 local dollars (big for me, and I only paid $25 or so for the knife) and could take months to come back, and I didn't feel assured the result would be much better.
-
I only own 3 SAKs with the new glass lens (all of which are SilverTech Swisschamps), and I've never had the lens fall out. So I do like them better than the previous plastic lens version, since those do get scratched after a while.
Don't know when Victorinox changed the plastic ones for the new glass ones, but I'm guessing my Swisschamps, being made in 2015, must be some of the first ones with the new glass lens in them. Maybe the problem is on the more recent "new style" magnifiers ? Or maybe I'm that lucky that I've got three of them that don't fall out ...? Or maybe it only happens on a very small percentage of them, but as always, you only hear about the ones which are having a problem and not about the ones who work just fine ...?
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
Like a few others I've complained about the lens falling out in my Explorer, even with careful opening and closing, and have long intended to use epoxy to fix it in place permanently. A tiny spot inside opposite sides of the frame means the lens ain't going nowhere, now! :DNice job Sawl!

-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
I only own 3 SAKs with the new glass lens (all of which are SilverTech Swisschamps), and I've never had the lens fall out. So I do like them better than the previous plastic lens version, since those do get scratched after a while.Don't know when Victorinox changed the plastic ones for the new glass ones, but I'm guessing my Swisschamps, being made in 2015, must be some of the first ones with the new glass lens in them. Maybe the problem is on the more recent "new style" magnifiers ? Or maybe I'm that lucky that I've got three of them that don't fall out ...? Or maybe it only happens on a very small percentage of them, but as always, you only hear about the ones which are having a problem and not about the ones who work just fine ...?
I think they changed to the latest magnifier around 2012. It might have taken some years though to complete the transition.
It could be that the problem only affects some early manufactures and has since been addressed. Or as you suggest, it's the other way round, maybe because of worn tooling. Who knows? Unfortunately you might not know how long shop stock has been kept. Buzzbait of this parish bought a brand new Explorer the other day that surprised him with the plastic lens.
-
For me it isn't the lens falling out all of the time. It doesn't do that much at all. What bothers me is that I can take my SAKs with the grey mag and not be able to push the lens out, but the new ones pop out quite easily when pushed. For me personally, nothing about a SAK should "pop out" and fall to the floor except the T&T&P when pulled out. And the intermediate plastic lens was a ridiculous decision in my opinion as well. Can't tell how many times that metal dust and/or dirt has gotten on my mag lenses. One wrong move and the plastic lens is scratched. I understand most SAK users don't utilize them in dirty work environments, but Vic producing lenses that can be easily scratched or pop out is a step backwards from the good ole' grey framed mags. I am not willing to sacrifice durability, reliability and/or magnigication for a slightly larger lens.
Disclaimer: These are my subjective thoughts on the issue. -
I think your criticisms are absolutely fair, G-man. There's no need to make a disclaimer for opinions and personal preferences!
I agree the grey magnifier is superior to the newer ones in reliability and durability. I've never heard of the lens falling out or even being pushed out, or know of the housing breaking, or anything. I don't feel let down by it in any way. As I've said before: if it's the only magnifier you have, it works just fine. But since I also can make comparisons, I prefer the optical quality of the current magnifier. I use it often and the wider field of view makes it better for reading fine print in particular, and I don't have to hold the lens as closely to the subject or text. I have much more confidence in it now. If only some of them came from the factory with a secure lens that doesn't need a user's intervention!

I have no doubt the plastic lens damages easily and can only understand Vic's decision to introduce it as a cost saving measure. Perhaps the dies for the old model were on their way out, who knows. Or maybe they underestimated the replacement's fragility. They must have had more than a few warranty returns before replacing it with the current one.
That's not to say the glass magnifier lenses aren't immune to damage either - just less likely to suffer it. Optical glass is relatively soft. The grey one on my SC has a mysterious rash of tiny pits in it on the pliers side. Not bad considering the knife had suffered so much abuse before I got it. The pits don't seem to affect the performance of the lens.
Here's a funny thing! While the lens on my new magnifier would often simply fall out upon opening or closing it, even slowly, I found it harder to push it out with my fingers. It wasn't that easy to reseat it correctly in the frame, either. ???
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
I think your criticisms are absolutely fair, G-man. There's no need to make a disclaimer for opinions and personal preferences!I agree the grey magnifier is superior to the newer ones in reliability and durability. I've never heard of the lens falling out or even being pushed out, or know of the housing breaking, or anything. I don't feel let down by it in any way. As I've said before: if it's the only magnifier you have, it works just fine. But since I also can make comparisons, I prefer the optical quality of the current magnifier. I use it often and the wider field of view makes it better for reading fine print in particular, and I don't have to hold the lens as closely to the subject or text. I have much more confidence in it now. If only some of them came from the factory with a secure lens that doesn't need a user's intervention!

I have no doubt the plastic lens damages easily and can only understand Vic's decision to introduce it as a cost saving measure. Perhaps the dies for the old model were on their way out, who knows. Or maybe they underestimated the replacement's fragility. They must have had more than a few warranty returns before replacing it with the current one.
That's not to say the glass magnifier lenses aren't immune to damage either - just less likely to suffer it. Optical glass is relatively soft. The grey one on my SC has a mysterious rash of tiny pits in it on the pliers side. Not bad considering the knife had suffered so much abuse before I got it. The pits don't seem to affect the performance of the lens.
Here's a funny thing! While the lens on my new magnifier would often simply fall out upon opening or closing it, even slowly, I found it harder to push it out with my fingers. It wasn't that easy to reseat it correctly in the frame, either. ???
Thanks and well said, Sawl!

I think the best we can hope for is that Vic will one day introduce a larger grey frame, made of the same nearly-invincible grey plastic as the old ones, with the newer glass lens( can live with the frame not being clear).

-
@gerleatherberman said:
Thanks and well said, Sawl!
I think the best we can hope for is that Vic will one day introduce a larger grey frame, made of the same nearly-invincible grey plastic as the old ones, with the newer glass lens( can live with the frame not being clear).

The best of both worlds.

And if they could somehow keep the extra length of the old Phillips... :P
-
How about a layer with the old and the new philips together?
:D
-
Just how big of an issue are we talking about here, how many people here at MTO have had the lens fall out ? I mean, it doesn't seem to happen as often as, for example, the misaligned handles on the Spirit, or the file rubbing on the Charge. If it did, this forum would be flooded with complaints about it, since the current magnifying glass is used on a couple of very populair SAKs, like the Explorer, the Swisschamp and the Cybertool.
Don't get me wrong, it shouldn't happen, and it must be very annoying if you're one of the unlucky ones. But maybe, just maybe that's just what it is, a couple of very unlucky few on thousends and thousends of SAKs with the magnifying glass which have no problems. Again, even if this is the case, it doesn't change the fact that somebody ends up having to fix or send in something that should have been okay when they bought it, I agree on that.
And another thing I've been wondering about, why is the old style grey plastic better than the current one ? I mean, have there been reports of the current one breaking or cracking up ? Except from the lens being too loose on some of them (which might not even be caused by the plastic holding the lens, it might as well be a glass lens tolerance issue, like Syph007 mentioned), but except from that, are there any other known issues with it ?
Judging from my own experience, I can only conclude for myself that the new style plastic and lens is the best so far. The first grey plastic ones were a bit too much (what was it 8x magnification) which wasn't easy to use, the next version had the plastic lens, which scored better in magnification, but scratched up very easily, and the last version has the best of both worlds in my opinion, especially since none of mine has ever fallen out (yet
).Just my 2 cents, as always ;).
-
I have only one of each, and I also feel as if the latest version is the best so far.
Good function overall, good magnification level, large field of view.
I haven't heard any reports on the frame braking either.
They shouldn't fall out of any version though, so it seems only safe if they'd drop a tiny bit of glue in the latest version from factory.My guess is that the thinner frame allows for more flex (especially since it's see-through plastic, which isn't as hard as solid plastic).
Does anyone of you with this problem forced out the lens to begin with? Just to see it pop out? Or did anyone buy his/hers second hand? -
Edit: Please disregard the joke. I apologize for not realizing how offensive it would be and apologize for writing it. Apologies specifically to T-G and Mechanickal. A big mistake on my part. :-[
Original text:
Oh my. <u>Seal Team Vic</u> is in full defense mode about them mag lenses. -
@gerleatherberman said:
Oh my. <u>Seal Team Vic</u> is in full defense mode about them mag lenses. :ahhhWhy do you always see things in a "them vs us" way ?
Aren't we here to talk about tools and to share our knowledge of (and experiences with) them ?
Edit: We don't have Seal Teams over here, we have Para-commando's.
Let me explain it to you, Para-commando's vs Seals are a bit like a Wave vs a Free, a lot less bells and whistles but just as practical ;).
-
Please tell me where I went into defending Victorinox?
I said that I haven't had any issues with the latest lens.
I openly admitted that it's something that shouldn't happen and that Vic could glue the lenses themselves as a plain and simple solution to this.
I further speculated about a possible cause. Since it only seems logical that the frame could weaken if someone was to pop the lens in and out of his frame multiple times.
I honestly feel it all made more sense than saying someone must have tampered with some bolts and screws to put a tool in a bad daylight.
I also feel as if you enjoy trying to put people in Victorinox and Leatherman camps since there's not a single week that passes by lately without someone being called a hater or a "defence team".I have always been open and honest about flaws in Vic designs when I see them.
Feel free to point out where I didn't.I never said I hated your beloved tool variants, only the extreme prices they catch these days.
Why do they catch less comments for it? Because their tools cost a third or quarter of the competition and is repairable with a drop of glue in this case.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login