This years projects.
-
Thanks for taking the time to reply Dean

I'm struggling with belt and platten issues, but looking at your photos I realized I need to setup my grinder differently at get more angles of attack

This is the grinder I want, My grinder is 1 hp and can run 2 10" wheels but I only keep one wheel on it at a time so it will spin up faster. I could bolt this attachment to the right side and be good to go.
Multitool 4x48, sold by Trick-Tools
While getting advice on the above-mentioned issue a knife maker my senior in years and experienced explained to me why the disc grinder is such an indispensable tool....looks like that machine has the bases covered.

-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
Thanks for taking the time to reply Dean
I'm struggling with belt and platen issues, but looking at your photos I realized I need to setup my grinder differently at get more angles of attack


While getting advice on the above-mentioned issue a knife maker my senior in years and experienced explained to me why the disc grinder is such an indispensable tool....looks like that machine has the bases covered.

You can't really find a great platen on a grander from shelf stock at Lowe's.
There are belt grinders dedicated to knives but they are way out of my league and budget.
The right side is the only angle of attack I have on that grinder. The tensioner housing gets in the way on the other side. Today I'm going to cut out a couple of inches of the right side platen radius, which will put me into good flat plate.Most people who do this use 2"x 72" or longer belts but room issues an the fact this grinder does other general work a 4"x 48" would be ideal for me. Both sides of the belt would in a sense give me 96" inches of usable belt.
-
Very nice job. I enjoy this these type projects. Really satisfying work.
-
Made the grinder modifications this morning. A milling machine would have been nice but around here it got hogged out with a 3" cut off wheel.
This gets me to flat platen and will make getting the tang area Much easier It even allows for thumb studs.
The next project will be the Rat 2 for $35 it's a nice enough knife but at .024 behind the edge it has poopy edge geometry. Hard use maybe but I have tools for that.


Yesterday I tried the 700 trizat paper on the loin steel barlows M390, that was a waste of time. M390 was just to hard for it. I used it today on some 1095 a few passes and the old grinding marks were gone polished to a nice satin sheen. :D

-
@Dean51 said:
You can't really find a great platen on a grander from shelf stock at Lowe's.
There are belt grinders dedicated to knives but they are way out of my league and budget.I got a weld-it-together-yourself kit, I like to tell myself splurging on on 1.5kW motor and VFD was a good investment, but I've run into a belt bump issue 220 grit and upwards......eats a worm into the blade.
Except for being a bit short, my platen is mild steel, so that wasn't a great start
I could make and harden a platen myself......IF I could get 50mm wide steel 
-
ceramic kitchen tile?

-
You would have to find a way to attach ceramic.
-

There's a lot happening pretty fast, I considered glass and tiles.....same problem.
-
@Dean51 said:
Tangs are usually left as stamped and only finished enough to fit and flush the back spring. In this case I cleaned up the stamping marks and put a small angle (less than 10 degrees) on the tang end that contacts the spring. That made the first 10 or 15 percent of the opening much smother but didn't affect the rest of the opening.I hope to own one....or a few
.......some day, but this is the first time I thought to myself "GEC could/should do better" 
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I hope to own one....or a few
.......some day, but this is the first time I thought to myself "GEC could/should do better" 
GEC could do better but I don't know if it's necessary that they should.
On traditional's the only thing that resembles automation is stamping the tang and liners. The rest of the fit and finish is by hand, thats expensive. To do better would be a lot of added cost, that cost might do more harm than good. They are already the best production knife I've seen and that includes the old brands that are no longer.Really all I did was break in the knife. I could have just used it and in time it would have smoothed out on it's own.
Knives like the Lionsteel barlow and Maserin plow are built with much newer equipment. There quality relies on precision maching that can just be screwed together, with minimal hand fitting.
Traditional purists tend not to like the aesthetics of a screw.
-
This Guys a barrel of fun but...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xcdGzoe9Pkw -
Good video I didn't realize this was a common enough problem to find youtube videos on it.
Find a floor supply and some smooth tile and get them to cut it, a little PC-7 epoxy might be all it takes. -

I spend far too much time on the interweb ::)
-
You found some useful info. Thanks

-
RE ground the Rat 2's this morning, these knives were about .023 Behind The Edge. Well that's not bad for a modern knife but it's not good geometry for a knife used as a knife. With the thin blade stock it could be better.
They're about .015 BTE now and they are excellent cutters.I tried to as an experiment and ground the R2-D2 to 220 grit but it gets difficult on the harder steels to get the 400 grit marks off. Lesson learned I went back to 400 grit and I think it looks better that way, it is after all a $35 knife.


-
@Dean51 said:
RE ground the Rat 2's this morning, these knives were about .023 Behind The Edge. Well that's not bad for a modern knife but it's not good geometry for a knife used as a knife. With the thin blade stock it could be better.
They're about .015 BTE now and they are excellent cutters.I tried to as an experiment and ground the R2-D2 to 220 grit but it gets difficult on the harder steels to get the 400 grit marks off. Lesson learned I went back to 400 grit and I think it looks better that way, it is after all a $35 knife.


That's great job! I just measured my 91mm SAK, and it's about 0.015 BTE. I could imagine being a much bigger blade, 0.023 BTE probably won't make it as good as a slicer, and improvement should be very noticeable afterwards.
This is a territory I really want to learn more about as a knife enthusiast, I could touchup/sharpen/reprofile a blade edge ok, but making that primary grind is something I totally lack experience of.Btw, R2-D2, what a cool name for this value knife.

-
@comis said:
That's great job! I just measured my 91mm SAK, and it's about 0.015 BTE. I could imagine being a much bigger blade, 0.023 BTE probably won't make it as good as a slicer, and improvement should be very noticeable afterwards.
This is a territory I really want to learn more about as a knife enthusiast, I could touchup/sharpen/reprofile a blade edge ok, but making that primary grind is something I totally lack experience of.Btw, R2-D2, what a cool name for this value knife.

To do it takes nerve, or confidence or a lack of common sense, I have plenty of the last.

This is my entire modern collection, minus the two Rat's.
The Bugout, Freek & Smith & sons are the thickest BTE at .019, the Mini Barrage & Saibu are .016, the red & black wasp is under .015.
The Bugout has become afraid of grinders and for good reason, it's got a good sized blade and is lighter than many knives half it's size.
It's just asking for a regrind, I do like a knife that cuts well.

-
@Dean51 said:
To do it takes nerve, or confidence or a lack of common sense, I have plenty of the last.
This is my entire modern collection, minus the two Rat's.
The Bugout, Freek & Smith & sons are the thickest BTE at .019, the Mini Barrage & Saibu are .016, the red & black wasp is under .015.
The Bugout has become afraid of grinders and for good reason, it's got a good sized blade and is lighter than many knives half it's size.
It's just asking for a regrind, I do like a knife that cuts well.

Regardless the formula, look how well it works though! :D
These are all pretty good purchase, many of which are classics.
I am just slowly learning how to mod my SAKs, and should I know how to grind, that will probably open so many doors to endless MT modding fun... >:D -
I see a Cypress in that bunch ol'knives. I didn't know you had one of those. Smith has only done or two
runs of those. Good score. What your assessment of it? -
@David said:
I see a Cypress in that bunch ol'knives. I didn't know you had one of those. Smith has only done or two
runs of those. Good score. What your assessment of it?I got this shortly before I swore off new knives for the year, I blame the purchase on all the Buck 110 & 112 chatter here. The moderns get carried as the second knife regularly but I don't post the moderns very often. I was never able to talk my self into a Buck 112, so this is what I decided on instead.
It's 1/8th” longer & 1.5 to 2.0 ounces lighter than a standard 112. It's all steel so it has a very substantial feel to it and all the steel inside and out has a well done stone wash finish. The stone wash gives the liners and back spacer a small radius so there are no sharp edges. The handle is large enough and has a very comfortable feel without any hot spots and the G10 is well executed. No texture is needed on the handle. The tang rides low and mostly hidden with a rediused corner that won't eat pockets.
Blade is .115 at the spine substantial enough to do what knives are made to do with out being a wedge. I never use the pocket clip but it is an excellent clip. There is enough of a rise that it easily slides over pocket seams, enough tension to hold it and the G10 won't eat your pocket's.
I use mine a lot for recycling cardboard and 2 gal plastic cat litter jugs the D2 seems to hold an edge well. If sharpening is any indication the heat treat was good.
If you've ever read many knife reviews you'll see a sentence or paragraph on ergo's, steel, materials etc and 3 or 4 paragraphs on deployment. Well I could don't give a smurfs patoot about deployment. Lock up is excellent with the liner stopping just where it should. The liner spring is strong and that's where the whip out and deploy with a resounding clank crowd will not like this knife. The combination of strong liner tension and a light blade do not make for a good whip out and deploy action.
I'm not part of that crowd, I open knives I do not deploy my knives. So this knife suits me perfectly. I'm one of those slowly roll it open and deliberately one hand roll it closed kind of people.
The thumb stud is positioned well back on the tang and not in the way when cutting.
The first complaint I have is the stud should be a bit thicker and longer, it is a bit small. The second complaint is the combination of a strong liner spring and a deep detent and it was hard to open. For a couple weeks I pondered whether to send it back or fix it. You know me I decided to fix it and send a note to Smith and Sons. I used it for a couple weeks to let the detent ball rub the tang and leave a light mark. I used a 600 grit tapered diamond file the ones sold for serrated blades and made 4 light passes followed by 800 wet/dry paper on a toothpick. It's an easy knife to disassemble and put back together.
If you can fix the opening detent it's an excellent knife. If you want a fidget flipper you won't be happy with it.
The more I use it the happier I am with it, this knife will not be sold off.





Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login