Finesse.
-
@MI Yeti said:
A lot can be done with a 4 way screw driver, a p 38 and a decent pocket knife. I'd much rather leave my phone at home than my tools.Oh man, I could write volumes on what my old man did with his little Case peanut, his 4-way keychain screw diver, a P-38, and sometimes a bit of the black electrical tape that was the duct tape of his era. Toss in some cotton jute twine and a candle stick for wax, and he'd have limped the Titanic into Halifax or St. Johns, Newfoundland.
-
@cbl51 said:
Oh man, I could write volumes on what my old man did with his little Case peanut, his 4-way keychain screw diver, a P-38, and sometimes a bit of the black electrical tape that was the duct tape of his era. Toss in some cotton jute twine and a candle stick for wax, and he'd have limped the Titanic into Halifax or St. Johns, Newfoundland.
I often think the older generation are made of different material -
My wife has packed a Classic and a 4 Way since 1978 and has rarely asked for more.
-
My 2 cents:
I think the main problem nowadays can be summed up by a few points:
- people dont repair things as much as back the days (stuff isnt designed to be repaired and/or cant be repaired eg because of microelectronics, or is so cheap you throw it away and buy a new one)
- people dont do hand crafts as much as back then (when was the last time you have seen kids building huts or a wooden car?, most parents would freak out if they see 10yo whittling with a sharp knife)
- knifes have shifted from tools to weapons in the eyes of most people, they dont carry them anymore and dont see the usefullness in them. I got my first SAK-alike when I was 7 and had a knife of some sort in my pocket since then for every single day. For nowadayss kids a smartphone is more important than having a knife and crafting with it. As a boy with a SAK and some rope I was ready for days adventures.

...
I had a situation back in university when we organised a party for our year.
We had to unscrew something and someone asked for a phillips screwdriver. I handed him a SAK which had a Inline Phillips. He opened the blade straight forward.
Yelled at him, took the knife back and did the job myself and didnt lend my stuff to anyone again. -
One thing to add:
Things became more complicated these days.
When I was a kid all i needed to fully disassemble my bike was a bone shaped wrench and a flathead screwdriver. Add tyre levers and you were good to go.
My new bike has all sorts of Hex and Torx and Phillips and various sizes of Nuts on it.I often read stories about people repairing their cars with MTs. To be honest there isnt much to do on my car right now if it breaks down. Electronics, covers everywhere, you need special drivers...

Just look at your everyday items. Some even have deep sitting screws to make it harder to take them apart. No chance to reach that without a long proper screwdriver, because a bitholder is too large.
Things have changed.
-
And they didn't get better.
-
You know, I always read posts about this sort of thing where it's speculated that blue collar workers and tradesmen know more about handling tools than your average suburbanite, city slicker, or what have you...
To provide a counter point I'll tell you all about my great grandfather, the man who taught me how to use a saw and hammer around the same time I was learning to read. My grandfather was born in 1906, and grew up on Kentucky farmland. He learned how to raise livestock as well as barns, and went on to become a carpenter. He plied his trade for decades, and constructed so many of the buildings in this area that I doubt many people in the older parts of town live more than 50 feet from wood framing stained with his sweat.
With that background out of the way, on to the point; I have all of his old pocket knives, and every one he ever used on the job is thoroughly ruined. They're caked with gunk, some of which I can only assume is tar, others I couldn't venture a guess as to the origin of the substances. Every one of them has at least one broken off blade.
It disappoints me to some degree, because I subscribe to the same policy as most here, and wouldn't pry or turn anything with a knife blade outside of a true emergency. But, to my grandfather a pocket knife was just a convenient tool to keep on hand in case nothing more suitable was a quick, easy trip away. Something with which to scrape, pry, Jimmy, or retrieve a nail from a gap when searching for an alternative instead of pressing on with what was in his back pocket meant losing daylight.
While it's not my way of doing things, I try not to look on it too dimly. I've not worked half as long as hard as my grandfather, and it's hardly surprising that our sensibilities would differ on many points, being separated by two generations. He had his reasons, as I'm sure we all do.
Well.... This post has gone on far longer than I really planned. Don't know how to end it at this point, so I just will. Thanks for reading. -
Yeah, ^^^^^^
Some people just don't care about shortening the lifespan of a cheap knife if it does a good job for them in the process.
Most of us on MTO are knife admirers, not knife users, to some extent. -
Might be that knives were disposable due to their cost. Collectors covet those old knife but not nearly as much as the old timers. The pocket knife was a MT for them. I was recently at a home where a guy was sorting thru his parents things ( they passed ). His grandfathers and fathers pocket knives caught my attention. He was proud to show me but immediately said they all had broken blades.
-
I kept my 66 Beetle and my 71 Westy going with my Huntsman and a feeler gauge!! :D
-
I recently replace the drive motor on my washer and while I could have used my MT and SAK for the change out it was much faster using proper tools.
There are still a fair amount of adjustments ( day to day ) a MT or SAK can accomplish. Which is why the market/manufacturing for these items is still there. I will always look at these tools as convenient to carry and packing a lot of usefulness in my comings and goings.
-
@Don Pablo said:
Yeah, ^^^^^^
Some people just don't care about shortening the lifespan of a cheap knife if it does a good job for them in the process.
Most of us on MTO are knife admirers, not knife users, to some extent.That I believe is true. I think somewhere in our heart, there is this balance of use vs admire; but being MT or knife enthusiast, we are more likely to bias towards admiring.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login