PSA - Check your flashlights
-
Interesting. I've never had an eneloop leak.
Sent from my G8441 using Tapatalk
-
Using a non-technical subjective comparison.
I did the subjective math on Energizer Lithium ultimate batteries in my digital camera. An 8 pack of Energizer Lithium Ultimates is $9.99(so $1.25ea basically) locally. Alkaline cheapies are an 8 pack for $1.99($0.25ea basically). My digital camera can take an average of 20 photos on a pair of cheap alkalines($0.50 basically). And the Lithium batteries in the camera can take 200 photos on average with a pair of Lithiums($2.50 basically). So the Lithium batteries work at 10x the operating capacity in the camera and cost just 5x the price. The Lithiums cost me 1/2 the cost of the alkalines in the long run. Now, that said, those figures don't reflect operation in other devices. They also don't account for damage costs from alkaline leakage or shelf life if the camera goes unused for a while. :ahhh
-
@Comis
I have some L91 and L92 for emergency but I don't use themm I have these batteries to be able to use AA/AAA lights if for some reason it is not possible to recharge the Eneloops.
I have a old large stock of Eneloop and Fujtsu but I don't even use them, they are only for SHTF (I prefer 18650 battery lights)
Four L91 / L92 batteries cost approximately 7 euros, it seems a lot but it is a good price because they have a lot of autonomy and the duration in the time exceeds the expiration date on the package.
The ability of L91/L92 to work well in extreme temperatures (cold) is also important.Forgiving Eneloop leaves me very puzzled too!
A leaking NiMH battery is an exceptional case.
I've never heard this, won't they be fake batteries? (yes, there are also false batteries on the market..) -
@Stefano said:
@Comis
I have some L91 and L92 for emergency but I don't use themm I have these batteries to be able to use AA/AAA lights if for some reason it is not possible to recharge the Eneloops.
I have a old large stock of Eneloop and Fujtsu but I don't even use them, they are only for SHTF (I prefer 18650 battery lights)
Four L91 / L92 batteries cost approximately 7 euros, it seems a lot but it is a good price because they have a lot of autonomy and the duration in the time exceeds the expiration date on the package.
The ability of L91/L92 to work well in extreme temperatures (cold) is also important.Forgiving Eneloop leaves me very puzzled too!
A leaking NiMH battery is an exceptional case.
I've never heard this, won't they be fake batteries? (yes, there are also false batteries on the market..)I used to be a flashaholic, and all my flashlight friends used to run big incan mods from many eneloops at a time, so we do have pretty healthy sample size to learn from. It is really not that common an eneloop will leak, but from my flashlight days I know anything and everything will leak given time. A poorly designed circuit flashlight will trickle drain a battery without knowing, and eventually will kill the light.
I know you mentioned fake batteries, and yes, they are quite common if you are not careful where you get them from. But since we used to purchase batteries in bulk as flashaholics, we did take extra care to know our sources. In fact, we had learned so much about battery that one of our friends went on to eventually became one of the largest rechargeable lithium brand owner in the world, but that's another story for another time. :D
-
@Stefano said:
@comis
It would be nice to know how many years ago this happened (the leak of batteries)
Were there several generations of Eneloop, perhaps the first series had any problems? (it's just a hypothesis)Honestly, it was so long ago, I can't really remember when, but definitely not within the last few years. I actually don't think it is the fault of the eneloop, but probably a faulty circuit. The eneloop leak was very mild(IIRC, just felt something liquid-y between fingers) and no where as devastating as a leaky alkaline battery, where it could corrode everything and even kept the tailcap 'shut' in some extreme cases.
-
@comis said:
Honestly, it was so long ago, I can't really remember when, but definitely not within the last few years. I actually don't think it is the fault of the eneloop, but probably a faulty circuit. The eneloop leak was very mild(IIRC, just felt something liquid-y between fingers) and no where as devastating as a leaky alkaline battery, where it could corrode everything and even kept the tailcap 'shut' in some extreme cases.Sounds like I can stop worrying about leaky eneloops then.

-
You guys have me wanting to try Eneloops.

Is there any advantage(aside from being less expensive) to using then instead of Energizer Ultimate Lithium AAs and AAAs?
-
@gerleatherberman said:
You guys have me wanting to try Eneloops.
Is there any advantage(aside from being less expensive) to using then instead of Energizer Ultimate Lithium AAs and AAAs?
More environmentally friendly (because they're reusable).

They're also the best value battery option, if that's something you care about. Alkaline batteries are like $0.5 per battery, while the 2450mAh eneloops are like $4 per battery, but can be practically reused a hundred times. 1900mAh eneloops are cheaper, and can undergo more charging cycles.
While those Energizer Lithium batteries are the best by far, that does come at a price. :D
In terms of electrical performance, eneloops are in between Alkaline and said Lithium.(BTW, the slow but smart charger I use, BQ-CC17, works great, cost €20 and came with 4 1900mAh eneloops. There are faster smart chargers for a little more money.
And all "low self discharge" "pre-charged" batteries that are "made in Japan" are made at the same Fujitsu factory that Japanese eneloops are. So you aren't limited to buying eneloops. Example: Fujitsu sells them under their brand name.) -
@Don Pablo said:
More environmentally friendly (because they're reusable).
They're also the best value battery option, if that's something you care about. Alkaline batteries are like $0.5 per battery, while the 2450mAh eneloops are like $4 per battery, but can be practically reused a hundred times. 1900mAh eneloops are cheaper, and can undergo more charging cycles.
While those Energizer Lithium batteries are the best by far, that does come at a price. :D
In terms of electrical performance, eneloops are in between Alkaline and said Lithium.(BTW, the slow but smart charger I use, BQ-CC17, works great, cost €20 and came with 4 1900mAh eneloops. There are faster smart chargers for a little more money.
And all "low self discharge" "pre-charged" batteries that are "made in Japan" are made at the same Fujitsu factory that Japanese eneloops are. So you aren't limited to buying eneloops. Example: Fujitsu sells them under their brand name.)Thank you very much, Pabs!

Definitely worth getting back into rechargeable batteries again. My only experience with them is limited to the rechargeable NiCd and rechargeable alkaline batteries from the 90s(which weren't great and got set aside when they couldn't run my digital camera and other modern high-drain devices). Will be nice to try the NiMH, with Eneloops. :)
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Thank you very much, Pabs!
Definitely worth getting back into rechargeable batteries again. My only experience with them is limited to the rechargeable NiCd and rechargeable alkaline batteries from the 90s(which weren't great and got set aside when they couldn't run my digital camera and other modern high-drain devices). Will be nice to try the NiMH, with Eneloops. :)
No problems.

If you're coming from 90's NiCd, be aware that NiMH doesn't have to be empty to charge, as there's no memory effect. They can be topped up even if they're only half-empty.
In fact, not discharging them all the way makes them last for more cycles.
But that's not a big deal for little batteries.
(I understand that memory effect was a known issue with NiCd.) -

Battery memory...oh smurf...the worst enemy of NiCd. I ruined a lot of 9.6v NiCd battery packs for my R/C cars before I knew about that.

The rechargeable alkalines leaked a lot of the time, but worked fairly well for a dozen cycles or so. The NiCd batteries lasted more cycles, but making sure the batteries were dead before charge was a chore. Leaving incandescent lights on would drain them well enough though. And the drain curve was bad.

Thank you again for the help!

-
@Don Pablo said:
eneloops are like $4 per battery, but can be practically reused a hundred times. 1900mAh eneloops are cheaper, and can undergo more charging cycles.White Eneloop = guaranteed for 2100 cycles (2000/19000 mA)
Black Eneloop = 500 cycles (but they are around 2450 mA of capacity)The black version has more autonomy but also more expensive.
I prefer Eneloop or Fujtsu (white) they cost less and have longer life. -
@Stefano said:
White Eneloop = guaranteed for 2100 cycles (2000/19000 mA)
Black Eneloop = 500 cycles (but they are around 2450 mA of capacity)The black version has more autonomy but also more expensive.
I prefer Eneloop or Fujtsu (white) they cost less and have longer life.
Black has higher capacity, and white lasts for more cycles.
All my eneloops are white also, as cycles are more important than capacity for me.
If I need more capacity, I bring an extra battery. :D -
For me its cost over time. I have not purchased AA/AAA batteries in a while (2012). I bought them from Costco during xmas. I have the 2100 cycle and lessor cycle ones as well. I cannot tell you how happy I am using rechargeable over non. During xmas Costco has them on sale or you can try the Ikea LADD or Amazon Basics but read up on those just so you're clear on how they stack up against Eneloops. As for your cells for your camera, just carry a more recharables if you find them draining too fast for your comfort. My partner photographed MMA fights locally and did just that with her flash.
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Thank you very much, Pabs!
Definitely worth getting back into rechargeable batteries again. My only experience with them is limited to the rechargeable NiCd and rechargeable alkaline batteries from the 90s(which weren't great and got set aside when they couldn't run my digital camera and other modern high-drain devices). Will be nice to try the NiMH, with Eneloops. :)
I think the eneloop is light years ahead of good old nicd or even most nimh cells, they don't have as much 'memory' problem, and no need to empty to charge everytime. If you are into rechargeable, they are really nice to get.
Personally, I am just a really forgetful person, and it's hard to keep track what needs to get charged or not. So most of my AAA/AA remotes/appliances I use Lithium AA/AAA, but for stuff I use very frequently and track everyday(like my wireless keyboard/mouse), I think eneloops are the way to go.
-
thanks, comis! 
I was thinking Eneloops for my EDC lights, digital camera, and neck fan(I use at work to keep my face from sweating while finishing wood). They are all high-drain, so the costs would even out relative to the Lithium rather quickly. But, for emergency gear and such, Lithiums are still the best option as far as I can figure. 10-20 year average shelf life, high output, lower cost, and reliability are the strong suits.
-
Yeah, lithium is best for emergency gear that needs to stay on standby.

-
@comis said:
I think the eneloop is light years ahead of good old nicd or even most nimh cells, they don't have as much 'memory' problem, and no need to empty to charge everytime. If you are into rechargeable, they are really nice to get.Personally, I am just a really forgetful person, and it's hard to keep track what needs to get charged or not. So most of my AAA/AA remotes/appliances I use Lithium AA/AAA, but for stuff I use very frequently and track everyday(like my wireless keyboard/mouse), I think eneloops are the way to go.
An Eneloop is simply a Brand Name plopped on a NiMH Battery made by Sanyo/Panasonic.
I agree that they are great and can be a lifesaver if you are a Flashlight that gets sporadic use and if I were able to monitor and make sure that I was always carrying charged cells on the job every day.
I am not though and experience has shown me 2 things about this.
1-I will simply not have working batteries when I need them if I am required to keep charged units with me during work.
2-I will be OK with regular Alkaline Batteries as long as I make sure to use them quickly and move on to fresh ones as soon as I need them and I need them a lot.I am trying to balance the needs of work which I can not negotiate or plan for really vs. the idea of recharging batteries all the time so that I always have them ready and I just need them faster and more than I can recharge them.
If this is not your reality for whatever reason then I am happy for you but it is not mine.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login