Anyone need a compact EDC compound cutter?
-
-
-
@zoidberg said:
For nails and fence staples etc etc. They are really very useful. Bolt cutter not so much.I only considered nippers with tiles and electronics, but I see cable cutters and the like might also fall in that category. That might actually work. How small is a good working head of that nature for your use?
-
For pocket nips probably couldn't go less than a 10mm edge.
Guessing (not on hand right now) the ones I use atm which aren't compounds have a 30mm edge and 250mm handle.
The important parts for me are the shoulder/fulcrum point? and handle length/lever ability. -
@zoidberg said:
For pocket nips probably couldn't go less than a 10mm edge.
Guessing (not on hand right now) the ones I use atm which aren't compounds have a 30mm edge and 250mm handle.
The important parts for me are the shoulder/fulcrum point? and handle length/lever ability.Something like style only less rigid and heavy? (This thing is my best small cutter - it makes my other one handed cutters feel weak and incapable).

-
-
I don´t want to rain on your parade, but isn´t this:
The Fencing Multi Tool you wre developing?!

Or are you planning somethinh different? -
@lowtech said:
I don´t want to rain on your parade, but isn´t this:The Fencing Multi Tool you wre developing?!

Or are you planning somethinh different?No, I do many projects but a specialized fencing tool isn't one of them. And I got one of those you linked to
It isn't exactly pocket sized, a bit on the heavy side, and has no compound leverage. It relies solely on long handles.This thread came to life basically because I've had this very compact high leverage concept laying around on the backburner for quite a while, and figured I'd find a suitable use or need.
On a sidenote I think it is fair to assume most wires, fences and bolts will be round. Given that there really isn't much point having a cutter length much longer than the diameter of the cut items. That should chop off some size and weight from a cutter head too.
As for raining on my parade I get plenty of that all the time, and the sooner it rains the better! There is a lot of exotic stuff on the market already and one can never really be sure one knows about all the relevant products. Still, that pales in comparison with the volume of existing patents that never even made it to the market - but which still lingers on as a minefield of live and dud patents to hit upon. And then there are registered designs..
One can try, but one can never be sure, so thanks for the post
Better to check one time too many than waste lots of work and resources on dead ends. -
I´m sorry. I should have read your explanations more toroughly. I skimmed the thread during my break and somewhere along the line I trhought "fencing, wait there is this plier I once saw..."
I did read the thread now and am curious what will come up.
There once was a user here who put wire cutters into his SOG - I don´t remember the user or details, but maybe someone does and maybe the old thread sparks some new idea. -
Your referring to J-Sew's(Bob's) SOG PowerCut homemade prototype-replica, and it is a great idea IMO.

Only issue there is the diagonal cutter head is going to be a bit on the weak side for things like fence wire and piano wire. But, that said, it could be done with the correct heat treating process. And Vidar's idea of shortening the cutter to just the rated-use necessary size would keep the material closest to the highest leverage point.

I cut piano wire with a set of these quite often. It uses a "PowerSlot" system that doubles the force applied.
https://www.amazon.com/Tools-VISE-GRIP-Max-Leverage-PowerSlot-1902412/dp/B00N3VSP1Y/ref=asc_df_B00N3VSP1Y/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=309811990469&hvpos=1o2&hvnetw=g&hvrand=9931427689824230250&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=m&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=1013074&hvtargid=pla-470538171564&psc=1Using the SOG leverage system with a shortened cutting head treated similarly(or better) would be a nice thing to have.
But, that is just my $0.02.
Anyway, I'm looking forward to the ideas/concepts you have, Vidar!

-
@gerleatherberman said:
Using the SOG leverage system with a shortened cutting head treated similarly(or better) would be a nice thing to have.Ah, there are some twists and nuances with those designs. One handed compound pliers with a classic single fulcrum, like the SOG, works perfectly in theory and do indeed provide the compound action claimed. And for gripping stuff at some featured point along the plier head there isn't much to add as long as it can open wide enough to grip.
In practice for cutting however there are some more nuances to the story. (I believe these are the causes why many reviewers don't really get expected full effect of the compound leverage - they likely actually don't).
Compound action pliers trade higher leverage towards more handle splay. And for one handed pliers we have a natural limitation for how wide we can grip. Combine this with the fact that most cutters have long cutting edges, where it doesn't matter where you cut, and you get some twist as illustrated in the pictures below.
The pictures show drawings of two pliers - first one with 2:1 compound leverage, and then one without any compound action. The handle position is the same (say your max grip width) for both pictures.
In the pictured jaws there are the profiles of two bolts to be cut. The small bolt is small enough to go all the way into the root of the plier head, and then the compound action is indeed twice as good as the normal pliers. The large bolt however is too big to get very deep into the cutters. The 2:1 leverage is still technically correct, but for the actual advantage over a normal plier one needs to compare: As the picture of the normal plier shows the bolt can get a lot closer to the fulcrum due to the jaws opening more. The difference is exactly halving the distance from the fulcrum, and thus largely eliminating the advantage of the compound leverage for this size bolt.
There are some more nuances to this, but that gives you some twists at least?



-
Ahhh, I see. Sorry, Vidar. I had assumed the cutters were just for piano and fence wire. Good to know the tool could be capable of cutting some smaller bolts/screws. REALLY

Here is the piano/fence wire compound leverage thingie I had in mind. Please excuse the horrible paint drawing. The round things over the cutter pivot are the SOG gear cover doodads. Imagine the gear setup under them. Again, sorry about the awful drawing.


-
@gerleatherberman said:
Ahhh, I see. Sorry, Vidar. I had assumed the cutters were just for piano and fence wire. Good to know the tool could be capable of cutting some smaller bolts/screws. REALLY
Here is the piano/fence wire compound leverage thingie I had in mind.
The cutter tool concept I consider is very far from any traditional cutters or pliers in general for that matter. Conceptually it can certainly do bolts - the limit is more about what size cutter head make sense for a pocket. Anyway, some more things in line first and then I'll make a functional prototype. Should be interesting.
If I get the drawing right it is a short head with just grip and cut? Small area for grip and a short area for cutting? I think there are some who make traditional cutters with a tiny grip area at the very end. I can't remember what they are used for though.
-
@Vidar said:
The cutter tool concept I consider is very far from any traditional cutters or pliers in general for that matter. Conceptually it can certainly do bolts - the limit is more about what size cutter head make sense for a pocket. Anyway, some more things in line first and then I'll make a functional prototype. Should be interesting.
Something that can be pocketed(maybe even folded up) that could reliable cut most "normal" screws would be awesome!@Vidar said:
If I get the drawing right it is a short head with just grip and cut? Small area for grip and a short area for cutting? I think there are some who make traditional cutters with a tiny grip area at the very end. I can't remember what they are used for though.Indeed, but the one I'm imagining, I don't have the skill to represent properly. But, it is a folding idea. Similar to the OG PowerPlier, but with a small cutting place full case hardened or even carbide tipped anvil cutting jaws and rigid handle structure that could fold up to <5" @ <8oz.
It is basically just day-dreaming on my part. I do wish I had the skills to design and build the tools. :ahhh -
@gerleatherberman said:
I do wish I had the skills to design and build the tools. :ahhhIt is a rabbit hole without a bottom, but the sooner you jump in the deeper you fall.. That didn't turn out quite as motivational as I had hoped

Nobody knows everything when they start, so if you really want to it is just about beginning somewhere with something?
-
@Vidar said:
It is a rabbit hole without a bottom, but the sooner you jump in the deeper you fall.. That didn't turn out quite as motivational as I had hoped
Nobody knows everything when they start, so if you really want to it is just about beginning somewhere with something?
Motivational as much as it can be. Thanks, Vidar!

So true. I may try and tackle a PowerCut concept at some point(retrofit a cutter head into a spare PowerLock). :ahhh
-
-
-
Thank you, There is a lot of truth to that - even the unintended double edgeness of it. I blame Freud and his slips.
Someone is still watching this one? Two other projects are lined up before this one, but I have worked a few weeks on it. (One tends to loose perspective when looking at the same things for too long, so some change is welcome now and then).
Either way a little update is in order I guess: Status is that I have a few conceptual versions now that in theory should work in practice. (As in having 3D models checked with simulation for function, stiffness and strength with normal materials and part designs that can be made at reasonable cost).
I have some parts for the functional prototypes ready while the rest will have to wait until I'm done with some other work. Provided these prototypes prove to work in practice as well as in theory, it then comes down to which versions seems most attractive from a usability and economical viewpoint. And then go on to a presentation prototype for the chosen one and maybe a small series made with small volume methods for wider testing.
Time will tell, and tales take time. I'm in the actual rabbit hole with this one, but falling is a bit slow as I'm busy falling in other rabbit holes too. (Which have proven way deep so far!)
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login