Vintage SAK Owners Club
-
An interesting knife on eBay :
-1963 advertisement- triangular awl
- aluminum small blade spacer
https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F233275192707

-
There are many difficulties to date a knife. One important thing is, that often, there`s not a changing point where one new tool replace an old one. One exception is the can opener. But for the screwdriver/caplifter for example, the old one was used for a long time where the new one already was introduced. You also could order a knife with the old or the new tool. The same thing with the rivets. I know some knives from arount 1900 with only 3 rivets and I know knives with 4 rivets from arount 1915. For mop scales for example, they used alway only 3 visible rivets - 2 rivets on smaller, 75 mm knives. And Victorinox provided some knifemakers with tool/scale kits. Then it was up to the knifemaker if they want to build up a knife with 3 or 4 visible pins.
The same thing with the triangular awl. The new one was available since 1961. But I`m sure that any dealer could order still knives with the old triangular awl if they want so.
-
@jnoxyd said:
An interesting knife on eBay :
-1963 advertisement- triangular awl
- aluminum small blade spacer
I've posted this Tourist before with similar features and date stamp:

@wengercollector said:
There are many difficulties to date a knife. One important thing is, that often, there`s not a changing point where one new tool replace an old one. One exception is the can opener. But for the screwdriver/caplifter for example, the old one was used for a long time where the new one already was introduced. You also could order a knife with the old or the new tool. The same thing with the rivets. I know some knives from arount 1900 with only 3 rivets and I know knives with 4 rivets from arount 1915. For mop scales for example, they used alway only 3 visible rivets - 2 rivets on smaller, 75 mm knives. And Victorinox provided some knifemakers with tool/scale kits. Then it was up to the knifemaker if they want to build up a knife with 3 or 4 visible pins.Agree with all of this. Post WWII I think the best you can get is +/- a year or two. Pre WWII? Lots of bets are off. As an example, I've been collection for > 10 years and when I first started most people (myself included) thought that 1923 was the "changeover" year from carbon steel > stainless. In other words, if you found a carbon steel knife it was pre-23 and a stainless knife was post-23. Now, having looked at thousands of knife sales and different pieces of members collections, I know that Victorinox continued making carbon steel Officer's Knives well past 1923 - into the mid 1940s at least. So yeah, a stainless knife will date to 1923 at the earliest, but a carbon steel knife? You have to look at other features. For at least two decades you could order the same knife in either carbon or stainless steel (I'm guessing the former were cheaper).
Even info from Victorinox is incorrect in the face of observed knives. For example, they say that fiber scales end in 1937 and the cap lifter is introduced in 1942:

I have never - not once in over 10 years of doing this - seen an Officer's Knife in celuloid/celidor scales with a large screwdriver. I have, however, seen > 100 different fiber scaled knives with cap lifters. I personally own at least 20, including one dated to 1935. Personally, I gave up trying to date knives to specific years long, long ago. I group mine into categories based on a shared set of observable features (e.g. fiber scales + caplifter), give that category a name, and leave it at that. When I first started I thought that this aforementioned fiber/caplifter category was from 1937-1942. Now I suspect it actually is from 1931-1937. But the category itself and the features it's based on are still the same.
-
Fiber scales with cap lifter, 1931 on scale

-
Great looking knives for sure
-
@jnoxyd said:
An interesting knife on eBay :
-1963 advertisement- triangular awl
- aluminum small blade spacer
https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F233275192707

Was just gonna post the same. Perfect example of why you can't count on any advertising or non-main line knife for reliable end dates. Ditto for Hoffritz and Elinox lines.
There are also lots of catalog cuts that show both types of awls together on the same page. I don't think it was a very hard transition, even for main line production.
-
@wengercollector said:
There are many difficulties to date a knife.True, but this is what makes it fun. :D
As I see it, there are actually two different questions here. One of them is the question of dating a concrete knife, which often cannot be done with much precision. In fact, I don't even know how to date a current Victorinox Huntsman, say, to any time window other than "post-2011." The other question is that of dating various evolution changes that occurred. This is something that, in principle, should be doable.
Over time, we do seem to make some progress as a community. The links at the top of the sticky MTO thread "SAK/Swisstool dating and identification resources" can take anyone to lots of information that would have been much harder to obtain just a few years ago. Sharing information can go a long way to increase our collective knowledge.
One important thing is, that often, there`s not a changing point where one new tool replace an old one.
True, most transitions take time and there are also other complexities, such as changes occurring at different times for different SAK models, but it shouldn't be beyond our ability to deal with such complexities.
But for the screwdriver/caplifter for example, the old one was used for a long time where the new one already was introduced. You also could order a knife with the old or the new tool.
Many thanks for this very interesting information.
Can you explain how you know this? Also, do you have any estimates for the start and/or end of this long transition?The same thing with the rivets. I know some knives from arount 1900 with only 3 rivets and I know knives with 4 rivets from arount 1915. For mop scales for example, they used alway only 3 visible rivets - 2 rivets on smaller, 75 mm knives.
I think that it is well understood that things were a bit different for special scales, etc. (the above shown model 290, for example, seems to have just one semi-visible rivet). For me, at least, the core question concerning the transition to three visible rivets is about officer knives with fiber scales. It's certainly possible that it was a long transition, but then it should have started at some point and ended on another and I'm very curious to know when.
And Victorinox provided some knifemakers with tool/scale kits. Then it was up to the knifemaker if they want to build up a knife with 3 or 4 visible pins.
This information about such hybrid production taking place is also very interesting. Can you explain how you know this? Thanks!
-
@MiniChamp said:
It's a very interesting knife!
Do have more pictures of it? If so, it would be great if you post them as well.It is not my knife to my regret, here are all pictures I have.



-
-
Can you help me with dating this 242 kU? No Victorinox shield on scales, steel liners, rivets and small blade spacer, nickel silver bail, back spring thickness decreases from one side to another. It has some imperfection in the form of a protruding spring with the main blade open.

-
My latest WENGER


-
@jnoxyd said:
Can you help me with dating this 242 kU? No Victorinox shield on scales, steel liners, rivets and small blade spacer, nickel silver bail, back spring thickness decreases from one side to another. It has some imperfection in the form of a protruding spring with the main blade open.

Interesting knife, Jnoxyd!
I hope that someone will indeed be able to shed some light on it. It may help if you could clarify the following:-
Are the blades and spring made of carbon steel?
-
What type of steel (carbon/stainless) are the liners, rivets and small blade spacer made of?
-
What material are the scales made of?
Thanks!
-
-
@jnoxyd said:
Can you help me with dating this 242 kU? No Victorinox shield on scales, steel liners, rivets and small blade spacer, nickel silver bail, back spring thickness decreases from one side to another. It has some imperfection in the form of a protruding spring with the main blade open.

For me this knife looks a bit strange. The mainblade is original, thats for sure.
But the scales, shackle, liners, pins not. Thats my opinion. If you compare the knife with the picture of the shown No 242k, you can see that the pin on the feet of the knife is more in the middle, where the original is more left; the middle pin is far more down to the feet.I think long time ago, someone brought the knife to a knifemaker for repair because of a broken mainblade. He changed it and used a blade he had, a Victoria blade. Such things were pretty common those days. Because everything was handmade and hand adjusted, so no problem for a knifemaker. The blade is from around 1910, so really old.
-
@MiniChamp said:
Interesting knife, Jnoxyd!
I hope that someone will indeed be able to shed some light on it. It may help if you could clarify the following:- Are the blades and spring made of carbon steel?
- What type of steel (carbon/stainless) are the liners, rivets and small blade spacer made of?
- What material are the scales made of?
Thanks!
Hi, MiniChamp. Blades, liners, rivets and spacer all are made of carbon steel, scales are from very good quality fiber. Riveting is really professional, it looks like factory made.
-
@wengercollector said:
For me this knife looks a bit strange. The mainblade is original, thats for sure.
But the scales, shackle, liners, pins not. Thats my opinion. If you compare the knife with the picture of the shown No 242k, you can see that the pin on the feet of the knife is more in the middle, where the original is more left; the middle pin is far more down to the feet.I think long time ago, someone brought the knife to a knifemaker for repair because of a broken mainblade. He changed it and used a blade he had, a Victoria blade. Such things were pretty common those days. Because everything was handmade and hand adjusted, so no problem for a knifemaker. The blade is from around 1910, so really old.
Thanks for the answer, Wengercollector. I think you are right, it looks like this is what you said, it explains the protruding spring.
I just would like to compare this knife with another 84mm from this time period (my picture above is from late 1940s catalog) -
I already had to use this photo on another board, to help a guy ID his knife.
Mid 1970s Craftsman. Couple years back, I went on a camping trip. SInce the Craftsman was in really rough shape, I put it in my tackle box, and a Fireman on my belt. Ended up carrying and using the Craftsman, gave the Fireman's sheath away (it was a 1980s Browning sheath, to which my friend owned the knife; but his sheath had been lost years ago), and kept the Fireman in my bag.
The problems: saw is bent; scale tools are non original (came from Artisan Vic repaired), and the scissors rub badly against the liners. Vic will straighten it out and make this knife better to use, I'm sure.


-
@jnoxyd said:
Hi, MiniChamp. Blades, liners, rivets and spacer all are made of carbon steel, scales are from very good quality fiber. Riveting is really professional, it looks like factory made.Thanks for the info, Jnoxyd!

@jnoxyd said:
I just would like to compare this knife with another 84mm from this time period (my picture above is from late 1940s catalog)I'm not sure what information you are looking for, but I looked at the three fiber-scaled tourists in the attached image, which I believe to be from the relevant time period. I tend to believe that the one on the right is from the 1910's, the one on the center from the 1920's and the one on the left from the 1930's.
The thickness of the springs on such SAKs cannot be measured precisely like on your knife, but I tried to estimate it by placing a caliper very close to the springs. As far as I can tell, the dimensions of the blades layer spring are roughly the same on all three. The thickness of the thinner side of the spring seems to be about 2.3mm (like on your knife), while the thickness of thicker side seems to be about 3.3mm, namely, a little more than on your knife.
The liners and spacers of all three are made of brass, as are the rivets of the (stainless steel) tourist on the center. The rivets of the other two tourists are made of carbon steel (like their blades and springs).
I don't know if such a comparison is what you had in mind or that you were looking to compare with a model 242k, but I should point out that I don't know if Victorinox made model 242k SAKs at any time before the 1940's. The earliest known catalog that has the model 242k (or any corkscrew-less officer's knife for that matter) is the late-1940's catalog from which you took the image and while I did indeed see such model 242k SAKs from the late 1940's, I don't recall seeing earlier ones.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


