Do you buy knock-offs?
-
@DaveK said:
I consider "knock-off" to mean an illegal copy of someone else's design, rather than just a cheaper alternative.I agree. A cheap wal-mart or dollarstore multi-tool isn't a knock-off unless it's blatantly ripping off the design or name of another tool/brand. Sure, they're poorer in quality but they're not really knocking off another company's name or design... unless it's something like "Leathermen", "SOGG Powerstock" or something silly like that.
-
@DaveK said:
I consider "knock-off" to mean an illegal copy of someone else's design, rather than just a cheaper alternative.Good point. "Knock-off" was the best word I could think of, but I agree with you, specifically because even as a tool neophyte I recognized the Stanley brand. Is there a better word that means "Not Leatherman, VIC, SOG, Gerber, or Bear?"
-
Yeah, a knockoff would be like "clone" tools.. Like the Protocol Juice I have!
-
I consider "knock-off" to mean an illegal copy of someone else's design, rather than just a cheaper alternative.
Good point. "Knock-off" was the best word I could think of, but I agree with you, specifically because even as a tool neophyte I recognized the Stanley brand. Is there a better word that means "Not Leatherman, VIC, SOG, Gerber, or Bear?"
Or CRKT, or Buck or Kershaw.... There are a lot of manufacturers to consider really.
-
I consider "knock-off" to mean an illegal copy of someone else's design, rather than just a cheaper alternative.
Good point. "Knock-off" was the best word I could think of, but I agree with you, specifically because even as a tool neophyte I recognized the Stanley brand. Is there a better word that means "Not Leatherman, VIC, SOG, Gerber, or Bear?"
Or CRKT, or Buck or Kershaw.... There are a lot of manufacturers to consider really.
Maybe "off-brand"?
-
I consider "knock-off" to mean an illegal copy of someone else's design, rather than just a cheaper alternative.
Good point. "Knock-off" was the best word I could think of, but I agree with you, specifically because even as a tool neophyte I recognized the Stanley brand. Is there a better word that means "Not Leatherman, VIC, SOG, Gerber, or Bear?"
Or CRKT, or Buck or Kershaw.... There are a lot of manufacturers to consider really.
Maybe "off-brand"?
or maybe "the others" :D
-
[quote author=DaveK link=topic=10607.msg197393#msg197393 date=1240349173]
I consider "knock-off" to mean an illegal copy of someone else's design, rather than just a cheaper alternative.Good point. "Knock-off" was the best word I could think of, but I agree with you, specifically because even as a tool neophyte I recognized the Stanley brand. Is there a better word that means "Not Leatherman, VIC, SOG, Gerber, or Bear?"
Or CRKT, or Buck or Kershaw.... There are a lot of manufacturers to consider really.
Maybe "off-brand"?
or maybe "the others" :D
[/quote]knockoffs= The $5 walmart special and such...
-
I checked, it was a Stanley 12-in-1.
http://www.stanleyproto.com/xhtml/LITERATURE/P20855_12IN1_MULTI_TOOL.PDF
Only difference is it came packaged with a box-cutter. So, definitely not a knock-off, but not the typical brand I'm used to seeing.
-
I honestly don't look at them like that turbov21. The brands that you and Ben listed there are good, reliable, quality brands, but I always try to judge a tool on its merits. You do come across "cheaper" tools that are actually quite good.
@rockyman500 said:
knockoffs= The $5 walmart special and such...I'm happy to report that most people don't agree. Knock-off means something completely different to cheap.
-
Do you mean Stanely, or Stanley?
I checked, it was a Stanley 12-in-1.
http://www.stanleyproto.com/xhtml/LITERATURE/P20855_12IN1_MULTI_TOOL.PDF
Only difference is it came packaged with a box-cutter. So, definitely not a knock-off, but not the typical brand I'm used to seeing.
I had one almost exactly like that, which I used for quite awhile until I came to this site looking for something to replace it and I ended up with a LM New Wave, been down hill ever since.
-
@DaveK said:
I honestly don't look at them like that turbov21. The brands that you and Ben listed there are good, reliable, quality brands, but I always try to judge a tool on its merits. You do come across "cheaper" tools that are actually quite good.I wasn't sure how that kind of thing worked, but I have a much better idea now. Thank you!

-
I don't have any particular knock offs but I do have a cheap multi from aldi which i keep as a spare in the car. I quit leaving anything of value in the car after a couple of break-ins. At worst it's useful as a second pair of pliers to go with the decent ones I'm probably carrying.
-
"Knock-offs" = Blatantly copying or illegally using a brand name or design.
"No-namer/Cheapies" = Cheap, department store, bargain bin specials (ie: Walmart multitools) -
@nuphoria said:
I don't have any particular knock offs but I do have a cheap multi from aldi which i keep as a spare in the car. I quit leaving anything of value in the car after a couple of break-ins. At worst it's useful as a second pair of pliers to go with the decent ones I'm probably carrying.I too have an Aldi multitool and it's not at all bad considering the price. On the other hand I bought a cheap multi from Woolworths years ago and hated it.
-
Got this H. B. Smith 20-in-1 multitool today for $5. Could this be called a knock-off or just a cheapy?

-
If you buy a 5$ tool then you get 5$ quality and customer service. Instead of buying 10 5$ tool at walmart then buy 1 SOG, Leatherman or other quality brand names with respectable customer service.
-
I'm thinking maybe get a couple of the cheap knock-offs so that you can impress upon people the importance of buying a good, name brand multi by showing them the difference in quality.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login