Lansky V Sharpmaker
-
So the only difference between here and the meet was that you were face to face :D Well at least you guys are consistent ;)
-
Any updates on this one Flash? Lansky still the winner??
-
@Flash said:
Any updates on this one Flash? Lansky still the winner??
Still the winner....hands down. (IMHO ;))
I agree.
My Lansky system produces hair-poppingly sharp edges that I've never been able to duplicate with any of the crock stick sharpeners including Sharpmaker.
Sharpmaker requires a user with considerable skill (good eye-hand coordination and muscle memory) to get results as good as a Lansky.
Even in the hands of a rather clumsy, uncoordinated person like myself the Lansky system works superbly.
.
-
I had a Lansky system once. I modified it into a mini EdgePro and it worked pretty darned good. The nice thing about my modification was no clamping of the blade. Too bad I accidentally tossed it out while cleaning the garage. :(
Could probably make another one, but I'm a freehand guy now. :D
Mike
-
The Standard Lansky is also really cheap. It goes for about $25! I have the Deluxe and that was $40; still cheaper than the Sharpmaker!
-
@Mike said:
I had a Lansky system once. I modified it into a mini EdgePro and it worked pretty darned good. The nice thing about my modification was no clamping of the blade. Too bad I accidentally tossed it out while cleaning the garage. :(Could probably make another one, but I'm a freehand guy now. :D
Mike
Actually, freehand is good enough for practical purposes.
Using just a bench stone I can produce an edge sharp enough for most any purpose.
It's the OCD (Obsessive Compulsive Disorder) part of me that wants knives to have hair-poppingly sharp edges.
Sharpen with the Lansky, strop with an old leather belt, and WOWSERS!
Now it'll pop hairs and push cut cigarette papers.
That's sharp!
.
-
With hand sharpening, I split atoms. :D
Mike
-
@Leatherman123 said:
The Standard Lansky is also really cheap. It goes for about $25! I have the Deluxe and that was $40; still cheaper than the Sharpmaker!I think I only gave 45 or so for my Sharpmaker
and I feel that I can get a very good result being a fairly new SM owner :DThat said I am becoming better and better at freehand sharpening

-
@Poncho65 said:
I think I only gave 45 or so for my Sharpmaker
and I feel that I can get a very good result being a fairly new SM owner :DThat said I am becoming better and better at freehand sharpening

Getting a REEEEEAAAALLLLLLYYYY sharp edge:
Lansky - dead easy. Just follow directions and it always works.
Sharpmaker - takes more skill. Depends on the user manually maintaining the angle during sharpening. The angled sticks help in setting the angle, but ultimately the accuracy of the angle depends on the user keeping the blade vertical throughout a stroke, and also from one stroke to the next. Results will vary depending on the skill of the user.
Freehand - requires the most skill. Results are totally dependent on manual skill.
.
-
6 months ago I would more or less dull a blade when stone sharpening ::) :D now I can make it shave with freehand and I can get an extra (not quite scary sharp yet :o ;) ) sharp edge with a SM

Of course it requires a steady hand to freehand or to use the SM (luckily I am still young and my hand is fairly steady
:D ) -
@Poncho65 said:
6 months ago I would more or less dull a blade when stone sharpening ::) :D now I can make it shave with freehand and I can get an extra (not quite scary sharp yet :o ;) ) sharp edge with a SM
Of course it requires a steady hand to freehand or to use the SM (luckily I am still young and my hand is fairly steady
:D )Some guys just have a knack for freehand sharpening.
One of my college roomies could put a scary sharp edge on a dull knife in very short order, using just a small pocket stone and whatever belt he happened to be wearing.
He gave me some pointers which helped, but working freehand I never got any better than producing a reasonably sharp edge.
In the 15 years or so that I've been using it, the Lansky has spoiled me for other sharpening methods. Maybe I've just grown lazy, but it's nice to know the Lansky will always give me good results.
.
-
I don't doubt in time I will probably end up with 1
but for now I am gonna try and master freehand and the SM 
-
The Lansky must be good - even I can get decent results with it :). Clamping heavy tools can be tricky though.
-
If it's any consolation, if you can dull a knife freehand ..... then you can sharpen a knife freehand.
You'd be surprised at how relatively easy it is to maintain a relatively consistent angle. For example, place one of your hands flat on the table palm down. Now, turn it so that it's 90 degrees to the table, like your karate chopping it. Now, angle your hand to 45 degrees ..... that was easy. Now, angle it further so that your hand is about half of that .... again, pretty easy and you are now at about 22 1/2 degrees, so it's just a little more for about 20 degrees. In fact hardly much of a change at all. Now move your hand like your petting a cat or a dog only using the wrist, maintaining that angle, across the table, not too difficult. If you can do that with your hand, then you can probably do that with your knife.
If some of you have whet stones or diamond stones, try doing that say 10 times in a row on one side of the blade. Flip the blade over and do it 10 times. Flip the blade over and do it 9 times, flip to the other side and do it 9 times. Keep going until you are down to 1 time per side.
You can start with 5 times per side if you wish and work your way down. Doesn't really matter.
You may have to increase the angle slightly as you come to the tip, that's ok. Just don't slide the tip off the edge of the stone. Also, let the stone do the work, do not push down too much on the blade especially with diamond stones. But don't be a whimp about it either.
If you want me to say something about the burr people mention I will, or changing grits and all that I can as well. But this should get you started if you feel like trying it.
Mike
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

:D)