Combo tool vs opener layer
-
Huhh.... you do know you can add the mini screwdriver to any Sak with a corkscrew, right....?

I prefer the default configuration. Modding and adding tools ruins the look of the knife.
Er.... modding? It’s literally screwing a little piece of plastic into the corkscrew.

You can buy lots of genuine corkscrew screwdrivers on some online stores that sell scales and such.
If a an employee in a Vic store can do it, it’s not modding. :)Are we talking about the same thing?
IMHO, of course
-
Give me a Climber over a Compact any day.
A climber has no tools for small phillips screws. The Compact does (mini screwdriver.)
I really am drawn to the Compact. But, my Climber Plus has all that the Compact has, except the nail file. In a pinch, I use the can opened blade to "scrape" my nails shorter.
I would be willing to replace the hook or corkscrew with a dedicated nail file like that on a Cadet.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk -
Huhh.... you do know you can add the mini screwdriver to any Sak with a corkscrew, right....?

I prefer the default configuration. Modding and adding tools ruins the look of the knife.
~
Errr.... ok... so if the Compact that has a micro SD on the corckscrew as default from factory it's ok and looks good, but if you add the same micro SD to a Climber that doesn't come as default from factory with it, it ruins the look...? How do you figure...?

And if even so... you do know that you can carry the micro SD somewhere else other than being physically attached to the actual Sak, right...?
Bare in mind i'm not bashing either the Climber or the Compact here, in fact i would be the last person to do it, as i'm loving them so much i'm carrying both of them as i can't choose between them...
...it's just your earlier point doesn't make much sense to me, as there is an immediate solution to the difficulties you've mentioned... -
Necro vote for the openers layer
I prefer the variety and extra thickness of these tools ....... and having an **awl ** !!! I'm not so bothered about the small blade...
But I always thought it was a very poor trade - Four tools for one !!!!
Having said that I do quite like - and carry - the Compact - Eg in the evenings (going to friends or a party) or when you have posh thin trousers (dress pants) - So you do notice a thicker tool
EDIT: Hmmm - That did not sound too good :o
-
I've been carrying the Pioneer X for the last couple of years, but carried a Compact for years before that.
I voted combo tool as I figured (correctly) it would be the less popular one.
I agree with Huntsman that one tool in place of four is a significant difference. -
Well.. I think i prefer the openers but... BUT...
While I've heard many stories about the combo tool weakness, combo tools bended and so on, today i had to deal with a phillips screw and it was fairly tight, but still i opened it with the combo tool of my compact and it was good: no bend, no damage, just a well done job. That leaded me to ask myself why so many people hates combo tool? maybe they abuse it? It could be.. I had no problem today but I was also careful not to damage it and I worked slowly.. What do you think? -
I typically lounge around the house with nothing but a Bantam on me--for opening cans in the kitchen, or the quick tighten of a screw on a cabinet door or something, it gets it done. Same with the 108mm German Army Knife, when I just decide I want to go for a walk, and need a few tools on me, but not a whole lot of bulk. For EDC, the dedicated layers. For me--BOTH. It just depends on what I'm doing.
-
I like the combo tool and have not had any issues with it. Although, I most commonly have/use it on a Yeoman where I have an inline Phillips and refrain from using it for heavy prying.
-
Can't believe I missed this thread for so long, I voted 'something else' because the decision does depend on the layers/thickness of the knife.
If the SAK is 4 or less layers, and has everything I wanted, I think the opener layers is perfectly fine.
But if a SAK is 5 or more layers, I think I might prefer switching the opener layers to a combo tool if I could mod it.
-
I prefer the opener layer because it gives you more options. You can even modify one of the openers for specific tasks.
-
I own and carry both types.
-
both are good...and both can be used on common philips heads
Sent from my ONEPLUS A6013 using Tapatalk
-
@pfrsantos said:
I prefer the opener layer because it gives you more options. You can even modify one of the openers for specific tasks.Some people on here (kottskrapa?) grind off the 'can' part of the can opener tool to make a long skinny driver that can still be used as a Phillips. I think that's awesome!
-
@Trix said:
Well.. I think i prefer the openers but... BUT...
While I've heard many stories about the combo tool weakness, combo tools bended and so on, today i had to deal with a phillips screw and it was fairly tight, but still i opened it with the combo tool of my compact and it was good: no bend, no damage, just a well done job. That leaded me to ask myself why so many people hates combo tool? maybe they abuse it? It could be.. I had no problem today but I was also careful not to damage it and I worked slowly.. What do you think?It's important to understand and respect ANY tool's limitations. Is the full opener layer superior to the combo tool, yes. Will the combo tool do 90% of what the two dedicated tools do, while eliminating a layer, yes.
-
@Don Pablo said:
Some people on here (kottskrapa?) grind off the 'can' part of the can opener tool to make a long skinny driver that can still be used as a Phillips. I think that's awesome!Yup, and I think it still works as a can opener. There's awlso the bottle opener tip rounding and sharpening, to use in carving spoons and the like.

-
@Trix said:
Well.. I think i prefer the openers but... BUT...
While I've heard many stories about the combo tool weakness, combo tools bended and so on, today i had to deal with a phillips screw and it was fairly tight, but still i opened it with the combo tool of my compact and it was good: no bend, no damage, just a well done job. That leaded me to ask myself why so many people hates combo tool? maybe they abuse it? It could be.. I had no problem today but I was also careful not to damage it and I worked slowly.. What do you think?As with everything else, it's mainly a matter of personal preference and needs.
Here's my take on the matter, for the last months...
I also use to bash the combo tool for being weak compared to the opener layer, but when i got a Compact my opinion changed about it's usefulness (for me). Not because i now think it's as strong and tough as the opener layer, it's not, but because i asked myself what do i really need on an urban edc on a daily basis.
The actual functions of opening cans or popping off caps are near irrelevant to me, so that leves the screwdriver usage and prybar usage. I don't thing i'd ever use the combo tool (or the opener layer for that matter) for both of those functions with near enough force to damage it, unless it was an actual emergency and sacrifices had to me made.I'm pretty carefully in respecting all my tools limitations. And i'll never use a SAK for those functions when ever i have the proper tool near by. And if i needed an SD on a regular daily basis for more serious work, i'd carry a real one. A SAK get's the job done in a pinch, but it's nowhere near a substitute for real tools when those are needed regularly.
That being said, i've been carrying a Compact on an exclusive basis for months now, and it does everything i need it to do and then some. I also carry a Quattro SD and a couple of actual Phillips bits (modified to de used/turned with any flat piece of metal) on my coin pouch. For me it's more than enough for what i need, on the go.
And with two layers with scissors, it can't be beat... :D -
I like SAKs, in general, I like the combo tool a little more than the opening layer. I prefer a lighter and smaller tool in my pocket. They both open cans well the can opener is a little easier than the combo tool. To be honest I don't open too many cans with a SAK. Flathead screws about the same. Philips screws the small screwdriver on the can opener can handle Philips screws light duty. The way the combo tool is shaped it does a better job on Philips screws at least for me it does. For opening bottles, I think the combo tool is the winner. I really don't think you can go wrong with either way.
-
@Mike 56 said:
I like SAKs, in general, I like the combo tool a little more than the opening layer. I prefer a lighter and smaller tool in my pocket. They both open cans well the can opener is a little easier than the combo tool. To be honest I don't open too many cans with a SAK. Flathead screws about the same. Philips screws the small screwdriver on the can opener can handle Philips screws light duty. The way the combo tool is shaped it does a better job on Philips screws at least for me it does. For opening bottles, I think the combo tool is the winner. I really don't think you can go wrong with either way.Yea the combo tool is better for tightening loose philips.
But installing phillips from.scratch, i prefer the normal can opener.
Sent from my ONEPLUS A6013 using Tapatalk
-
Hmm. For me I feel its familiarity. I am familiar with the 2 tools vs combo tool. I am used to using the 2 separate tools effectively and efficiently. Neither has let me down that I can immediately recall.
I do have to mention on my 84mm Golfer I am not a fan and heres why, see the difference? The one no the Golfer doesn't have the sharp corner so for me its a terrible can opener and not as efficient a driver AS compared to the Bantam ( pictured ). I do like the combo tool with the sharp corner and my Bantam made me realize this.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
