Running Lean: An Experiment
-
I told you some of the pics might look abysmal
It's only when they were full size on the laptop that my defective vision could see how bad they were :-\So there you have it. That's all the items that made the final choice, and most of the stuff that didn't (I didn't bother with pics of all the keyring sized tools). As I said before, I don't think the choices that I've left out will leave me wanting in terms of function, but I don't know if I'll have to break into the box to scratch the itch of wanting something different, or how I'll feel about the stowed stuff after not laying my eyes on it for an extended period.
Will I need to replace something?
Will I miss not having more options?
Will I need to remind myself that I really don't need more stuff? ::)
Or have I simply chosen the wrong items - again?
Only time will tell.Thanks for reading

-
You still have enough for a minor apocalypse....

-
Interesting experiment. You definitely left out a good selection of choices.
-
Boy..........
I either need to step up my game now after reading this or I really am ready to admit that I have already arrived?!?!?
I thought I have a decent collection myself but I could easily just live with what I carry every day already and not feel that I am missing anything.
In fact I pretty much do carry the same thing EDC anyway once finding a combo that I know works.
I might switch out the Folder or switch to the Swisstool X based identical Skinth but otherwise I am good to go.

-
@ezdog said:
Boy..........
I either need to step up my game now after reading this or I really am ready to admit that I have already arrived?!?!?
I thought I have a decent collection myself but I could easily just live with what I carry every day already and not feel that I am missing anything.
In fact I pretty much do carry the same thing EDC anyway once finding a combo that I know works.
I might switch out the Folder or switch to the Swisstool X based identical Skinth but otherwise I am good to go.

Good to hear you've found a winning combo

I must admit, I might have found something that could easily handle the vast majority of days, and that's the Deluxe Tinker. Since I first started dabbling with this idea (before I got the combos all wrong), the Deluxe Tinker has been carried most of the time. I've occasionally swapped for one of the traditional knives, but keep going back to that one knife.

I'm certainly not ready to get rid of everything except that one though :o :D
-
A great exercise AW, and very interesting to read the motivation across each tool category and the combo options. Also how your needs have changed (matured - in the good sense) over the years, putting a different perspective on your carry options. Thanks for the detailed explanations, and don’t worry about the pic quality, the read is the more valuable aspect of what you’re sharing.

-
@Max Stone said:
A great exercise AW, and very interesting to read the motivation across each tool category and the combo options. Also how your needs have changed (matured - in the good sense) over the years, putting a different perspective on your carry options. Thanks for the detailed explanations, and don’t worry about the pic quality, the read is the more valuable aspect of what you’re sharing.
Thanks Max

I would say my needs have more than just matured, they've pretty much retired

In years past, some of the tools that have currently been sidelined, were needed on a very regular basis. Running an engineering company, plus owning a boat and running the boatyard, plus being involved with a stage society, all brought a variety of challenges that needed far different toolsets to what are needed today. As life has moved on, all those needs have been left behind. However, as I reassess my needs, of which this experiment is part of, and evaluate what has importance and what doesn't, there is one extra function the tools have that isn't readily visible. Providing memories.
There may be some tools which I look at with fresh eyes in a year's time, which bring back vivid memories. Should that happen (and assuming the memories are good :P) the tool will most likely stay, even if only for that "function". Others might just be good to get my mitts on again, and make me want to get it back working again. Others might just make me think "oh, yeah I forgot I had that", but not really care much for it.
I think when you see the same things week after week, it's different to seeing thing you haven't seen for a long time - which I think is what I'm trying to capture here, that fresh perspective. That and seeing just how comfortable I feel only having access to a small percentage of my full tool array.
-
Nicely put AW.

The needs of today with the memories of yesterday.
-
Cheers Max

-
Good read, AW

I think you have a solid selection there, and doubt you will ever have the need to switch out something. One question though: You said you would lose the eyeglass screwdriver on the Evo 14; yet in the photos it looks like that there is one mounted in the corkscrew. Am i seeing that wrong? If not, how did you get in there? :D
-
Great read AW. Just narrowing down to what you've chosen, I'm certain you are set for the experiment. You had quite a wonderful selection to begin with so well done.
-
@SirVicaLot said:
Good read, AW
I think you have a solid selection there, and doubt you will ever have the need to switch out something. One question though: You said you would lose the eyeglass screwdriver on the Evo 14; yet in the photos it looks like that there is one mounted in the corkscrew. Am i seeing that wrong? If not, how did you get in there? :D
Apologies for the confusion. I think I was rambling a bit at that point.I lost the eyeglass in the Deluxe Tinker, as after years of carrying only corkscrew backed knives, I finally started warming to the backspring Phillips a little more.

-
@Aloha said:
Great read AW. Just narrowing down to what you've chosen, I'm certain you are set for the experiment. You had quite a wonderful selection to begin with so well done.Thanks mate
It's taken me several years to cut down to the whole ensemble I own today, so choosing just 20% of what's left to keep accessible, and stashing the rest away, wasn't easy. :P -
@AimlessWanderer said:
Apologies for the confusion. I think I was rambling a bit at that point.I lost the eyeglass in the Deluxe Tinker, as after years of carrying only corkscrew backed knives, I finally started warming to the backspring Phillips a little more.

Ok, that makes sense

-
I had a couple of packages arrive in the mail today, and it was the canoe that was in the pocket, so I used that to open them up. As I did so, I noticed that I tend to use this knife differently...
I've occasionally griped about the "redundant" small blade on Victorinox knives, and that being replaced by a nail file is one reason why I tend to carry one of my Wenger Travelers rather than a Climber (I even have one Climber small, but still more often reached for one of my four remaining Travelers). Yet with the canoe, even though it's about the same size, I seem to be mostly using the smaller blade. In fact I think the only time I've used the larger blade is for eating apples. Had my Deluxe Tinker been in my pocket instead, I would have almost certainly used the larger blade.
I think on the two blade barlows, I tend to use both blades equally - but I can't be certain. Maybe there's more to be learnt and understood on this little experiment than I expected


-
I try to use the small blade as ‘default’ and the larger only when a longer cut is needed (apple a good example!). Of course, this assumes you have a small blade to start with...

-
All the full sized Vics I've left out have the small blade, and there's only the Evowood 14 that has the nail file instead. I had the Deluxe Tinker in pocket today, and when the last couple of second hand CDs I was expecting dropped through the letter box, I instantly defaulted to the large blade.
I wonder if it's because it's a sleeveboard pattern, and using the small blade feels like the handle's the wrong way round
It's the only reason I can think of for not using the small blade like I might on the canoe or barlow. Or maybe it's because it's on the wrong side of the tools (nearest the thumb, instead of the forefinger)
I do seem to be happier using the small blades on traditional (blade only) knives for whatever reason.I am kicking myself for leaving it so long to get a canoe pattern knife. I've hardly reached for one of the other patterns since this arrived. Sadly, on a lot of canoe patterns that i've seen, etching the blade seems to be quite common, which is not something I'm a fan of. That was the main reason I got this one, as it's just a plain polished finish
-
I do believe there is a lot to be observed in our uses. I use the larger blade of SAKs as default. If the SAK I am carrying has the small blade I use it in place of the scissors if the SAK doesn't have scissors ( Tinker/Recruit/Cadet 2 ) for example.
On my SAKs with scissor layer Explorer/CT34/Deluxe Tinker the small blade is generally not used much.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login