Why so many of the same?
-
-
"One of the pics I saw had a dresser drawer full of red classics. "
Some people collect all kinds of different commercial or governmental inlays and inscriptions. Others collect all the different colors, or tang stamps.
There's also a category who collects technical changes. Somebody here found out that the SwissChamp had about 60 improvements during the last 35 years!
It's possible that you look at a drawer full of the same knives, but in fact they all are different in the details.
I identified 11 differences for the 'KL 1993' DAK. At first glance they look all the same, but there are some major and minor differences to be found.
-
@Don Pablo said:
I've come near to breaking SAKs before.
(My fault! :D )
-
It's a good question .......
Just to explain my collecting philosophy
I collect(ed) - All the versions of the 91mm tools after the mid 50s ..... in so far as I understood it.
Eg According to this .... /topic/51872
Although I now know there are loads of really subtle channges that are not so obvious - and that I maybe don't have- eg Just start talking to Kamakiri!! :) or JazzBass
I explicitly **did not **collect all the models - Although I could (and do) have a few of the same model if the tool versions are different - eg See SwissChamp comment above.
For me I did find I ended up with a few Climbers - I like the tool configuration - And I just could not resist a few ebay listings of very nice models eg the Beijing Opera model; a 125 Anniversary model; an old Traveller; a Damascus - So despite my no duplicate tool/model rule I did find myself collecting a few Climbers - I now have about 10 - All totally different scales.
I also do have a handful of Classics - Again as mentioned above these were all TSA confiscations are are for gifts
If the tool versions are different or they have interesting scales - I do keep them- I do not collect different scales - Although again as mentioned above several people do
And there are many themes for Classic scale collections - Colours, Military, Sporting etc etc
So there were a few reasons you may have duplicate models
Another reason of course is the Soldiers - And collecting each of the year tang stamps - A very worthy collection objective!
Not sure this answers your question - As I think you are talking about dozens of exactly the same model
- I have not seen too much of that to be honest
Although again I know models like the Grand Prix - even though it was only out for a couple of decades - had loads of evolutionary changes to the tools
And Kamakiri (that bloke pops up everywhere :o ) also has a thread at the moment on the inlay changes to the Grand PrixAnyway - Just some thoughts and musings !!
-
I try to steer clear of owning 2 dozen climbers with different scales.
Which is also why I don't start with gathering military issued SAKs since over half are OHT's with different camo patern scales and/or unit logos.I did end up with a handfull of Pioneers since they're collector's editions.
So I try to get only the discontinued and/or rare stuff but I can completely understand people who love a certain model and want to find alot of variations on it.
It's just not for me. Which is good! If we all had the same way of collecting/gathering, we'd all be competing here :D -
@EMZ said:
"One of the pics I saw had a dresser drawer full of red classics. "Some people collect all kinds of different commercial or governmental inlays and inscriptions. Others collect all the different colors, or tang stamps.
There's also a category who collects technical changes. Somebody here found out that the SwissChamp had about 60 improvements during the last 35 years!
It's possible that you look at a drawer full of the same knives, but in fact they all are different in the details.
I identified 11 differences for the 'KL 1993' DAK. At first glance they look all the same, but there are some major and minor differences to be found.That sounds like lots of fun

Now, after you've discovered the differences, would you consider selling them off again?
Our do they still serve another purpose? -
PS. I know this is the SAK board - But if you want a lesson in collecting many of the 'same' model
- Check out wowbaro and his PSTs - I thnk he has about 180 or so.
All PSTs - But all different in some slight way eg Tools, stamps, frame etc etc
- Check out wowbaro and his PSTs - I thnk he has about 180 or so.
-
@nate j said:
I can think of several reasons for ending up with a significant number of duplicates:- One is so fond of a particular model that one wishes to ensure a lifetime supply.
[/li]
Yep , that's me.
I literally had a panic attack when CASE locked the Seahorse Whittler away in the vault, several years ago.
It was terrible. -
@EMZ said:
It's possible that you look at a drawer full of the same knives, but in fact they all are different in the details.
I identified 11 differences for the 'KL 1993' DAK. At first glance they look all the same, but there are some major and minor differences to be found.I see, now this makes a lot of sense! Very subtle differences, not discernible in a pic displaying so many at once!
-
It's a pertinent question zenderfall, and one I think has a psychological answer that doesn't really belong on the forum. Just best to accept that we each belong to this forum for our very own individual set of complex reasons, but the one reason that binds us together as brothers and sisters is a love (or psychological need :D) for knives and multitools in our lives.
I know that my reasons for always having some kind of MT on me stems from being in some very iffy situations as a child where I felt helpless. Carrying a SAK is for me a physical manifestation of autonomy over that helplessness - a totem (albeit a useful one) if you like. Plus they come in all sorts of lovely colours.
And let's leave it at that :D
-
Amen to all those lovely colours, Magentus!

-
This is the most I've put together at one time, but nowhere close to the whole shebang:

@zenderfall said:
I don't think 1. works because Victorinox's quality is extremely good - I think a few (or even just one) would be considered a lifetime supply. 2. sort of works, but giving SAK's away and using SAK's as consumables means the collection will be gone. 3. If that is the case, and TSA lots are a bunch of the same, but random model, that would be a very bad deal for the buyer. I would never buy a lot expecting many of the same thing. 4. Works, for example, Soldiers, ;) but some of these collections are current models, like spartans, climbers, and campers. IT wouldn't explain those.All good reasons, and perhaps a combination and probably OCD as well. People will buy them because they like them and can afford the space and the $$ for them.
Actually, his answers ring pretty true for me. See below.
@nate j said:
I can think of several reasons for ending up with a significant number of duplicates:- One is so fond of a particular model that one wishes to ensure a lifetime supply.
- One buys inexpensive knives when the opportunity arises, with the intent of using them as giveaway and or throwaway knives.
- One buys large lots of (usually TSA-confiscated) knives, and so has no control over exactly what makes and models arrive in the box.
- One buys discontinued models when found at reasonable prices, in the hope that their value will appreciate over time.
#1 is true for me. I have a lifetime supply of new Marlboro Troubleshooters for this reason. Probably less than lifetime supply of used ones for mod fodder. Again, no idea of the total counts. Don't ask.
#2 is only sort of true for me, and that pool is on a revolving basis, so the argument that it would 'run out' doesn't work.
#3 N/A for me. I've never bought TSA lots, but I do have a LOT of plain-Jane SD/classics that have piled up from *bay lots.
#4 Is somewhat true for me. Like for the Troubleshooters. I don't think they will depreciate below my personal buy price/line. There are other model lines that I buy without much hesitation below certain dollar values.
-
Some people see differences where others do not. Different release dates, tang stamps, versions of implements, such as caplifter with sharpened wire stripper, or different number of twists on the corkscrew. To me, they'd all be multiples of the same thing, but not to the hardcore collectors.
I did try collecting different Wenger Travelers for a while, but I felt uncomfortable and sold most of them. They had very significant differences, such as different scales (stainless, aluminium, wood, etc) and other noticeable differences such as serrated or clip blades, so even luddites like me can see the difference. However, I felt I was only owning them for the sake of it, and just kept the four I liked the best - each of which is quite different to the next.
There were a couple of knives where I owned a like for like spare, and just cut those own to one. The nearest I have to duplication now, is a Spirit X and Spirit RT (identical toolset, but one had a coating on the handles, and an etch on the main blade).
Some folks do have an almost compulsive need for "spares". If they see their favourite knife (or one of their favourites) at the right price, they'll get it - even if they already have fifteen others. Whether it's fear of discontinuation, investment for selling later, or no real conscious thought at all, significant differences to what they already own, subtle differences, or no difference whatsoever, our motivations all seem to differ as wildly as our tastes.
-
Two more Camping Campers c. '80...Most wouldn't know at a glance how similar these two actually are. You're looking at the only observable production difference:

Camping inlays are really at the core of my Victorinox chronology. At least for the '70s portion.
-
-
@kamakiri said:
Two more Camping Campers c. '80...Most wouldn't know at a glance how similar these two actually are. You're looking at the only observable production difference:
Camping inlays are really at the core of my Victorinox chronology. At least for the '70s portion.
Who wouldn't prefer the inlayed one?

-
The only thing I've seriously collected once was stamps, and that's quite a while ago.
That means that I'm probably not aware of my current relationship with tools and knifes :D
I never had enough money to start a serious collection. Because of that I didn't dare to put my few MT pieces to serious use... apart from my Swisschamp.
Just a couple of years ago I found my love back for them and decided to actually use them, giving them some purpose and have fun :D
That resulted in buying at least one spare for my most used tools that I frequently carry... If they're discontinued.
So far that's the Leatherman OG Supertool and Mini Tool and Vic. OG Traveller.
To be continued...
-
@McStitchy said:
The only thing I've seriously collected once was stamps, and that's quite a while ago.That means that I'm probably not aware of my current relationship with tools and knifes :D
I never had enough money to start a serious collection. Because of that I didn't dare to put my few MT pieces to serious use... apart from my Swisschamp.
Just a couple of years ago I found my love back for them and decided to actually use them, giving them some purpose and have fun :D
That resulted in buying at least one spare for my most used tools that I frequently carry... If they're discontinued.
So far that's the Leatherman OG Supertool and Mini Tool and Vic. OG Traveller.
To be continued...
Cool...

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




