Fall Follow-up Fixed Blade 30-day Challenge
-
@Nix said:
I like my Garberg.
I chipped the edge of mine in a moment of careless batonning. That event served as a reminder that scandi-grinds are a pain to resharpen. However, the Garberg takes an excellent edge with a bit of effort. That steel is nice stuff.Overbuilt? I don't think so. It's a solid knife, but all knives are subject to breakage if abused. I don't think the Garberg is an exception to that rule. Always nice to have some confidence in a knife, too.
I was thinking about you as I type, and possibly may like the larger handle than me. :D
I know you probably are way better in free hand sharpening than I am, but don't you think the scandi grind has a 'pre-set' angle so it should be easier to sharpen? Or were you trying to restore it back to it factory secondary bevel(which I think is much harder free handling it)?

My biggest qualm with Garberg is the balance, I too like the full tang confidence it instill and don't mind it being heavier. If I have a belt sander, I would love to mod this knife to make a slightly smaller handle with better balance.
-
@Obi1shinobee said:
get Companion Spark 3.9-Inch Fixed-BladeI saw this on Dave Canterbury channel, I think it is a good update on the original Lightmyfire blade. The original LMF knife has so-so balance, but with a knife being so light, the imbalance is probably less noticeable. With bigger and beefier blade, I have hoped the new version might achieve a better balance in hand while making it overall more robust to use.
-
Day 9 New Passport
:ahhh 

-
Day 10: I used my Puuko to cut open a muffin for breakfast. The blade was a little thick but did the trick. This knife is definitely robust!

-
fortunately for me, no blood
@Nix said:
Styx, the handles on these are still bigger than the handle of a SAK. So, from that perspective they are good. My favorite size handles? No, I like 'em bigger, but I can adapt to just about anything with a bit of practice.
i know what you mean by adapting. still nice to have things fit. i'd say like a glove, but sometimes those are a pain to find in the right size

-
@Obi1shinobee said:
get Companion Spark 3.9-Inch Fixed-BladeThats a neat ideal.

-
@PitCarver said:
I hope that my apple pics aren't getting so expected, but, once more...We're running low now, so...
Nice and I’m out of apples and off to the grocery store later today!
-
@comis said:
I know you probably are way better in free hand sharpening than I am, but don't you think the scandi grind has a 'pre-set' angle so it should be easier to sharpen? Or were you trying to restore it back to it factory secondary bevel(which I think is much harder free handling it)?
With a true Scandi grind, there is no secondary bevel, right? It's just a flat V-grind from the blade to the edge. In theory. But, when I "hone" a Scandi knife freehand, I inevitably introduce a "micro-bevel" at the sharp bit of that v-grind.
Just to be sure we're using the same terms the same way:

A micro-bevel on a scandi knife is not 'ideal', but it actually works fairly well and makes for a more durable edge: there is more steel to support the cutting edge carbides. For that reason, I don't mind putting a fine micro-bevel on a Scandi. However, when removing a chip from the edge, i.e. sharpening vs simple honing, you have to remove metal from the entire side of the primary bevel, effectively worknig back into the flat, in order to reestablish a true scandi edge. Even with a slight chip (as in my case), this requires removing a lot of metal.
It's true that you only need to follow the angle set by the factory edge, so I would think it is easier, but maintaining that perfectly consistent angle freehand is really tough (perhaps just personal skill-limitation for me), especially if it requires doing so hundreds of times. When sharpening a chisel, there are no curves to accommodate and the leading edge of a chisel is only a couple inches wide (at most, for typical home chisels). So sharpening a chisel is fairly straightforward.....and I usually end up putting a smalll micro bevel on my chisels, too.
Achieving perfection is harder than it seems.I suppose it's good practice though. :D
With a hollow grind, flat grind w/ secondary bevel, or even convex edge, there is inherently less metal to remove to resharpen a knife, and the process is more forgiving in my experience. Perhaps highly skilled sharpeners would argue the opposite, but that's my experience.
That's not to say that I dislike scandi knives! Quite the opposite. I find Scandi knives to be great for many tasks. They are super-precise when carving wood (essentially a chisel edge on a knife). But I do find them to be a bit trickier to sharpen perfectly. That's my experience anyway: a lot of metal to remove, many chances to introduce variance.

(Couldn't find my old photos of the resharpened Garberg. I'll try to post one a bit later.
) -
@Obi1shinobee said:
Day 9 New Passport
:ahhh 
Nice!
Passport - cool.
-
Day: 10
Mora Garberg pictured with today's carry, a ML EDC. Matt does some great stuff with steel and this little EDC is exceptionally useful. The broad 3" blade is an amazing cutter and allows for some great grips. It's easy to choke up and grip the blade itself for fine work or precise cuts. One of my favorites!


In re sharpening scandi-grinds, in this close up of the Garberg, you can see where I was a bit inconsistent and missed the shoulder (low) in one spot, and again (high) in another spot. It is just tough to be consistent when freehand sharpening (for me).

The dark spot is a reflection of my iPhone. ;)
This edge, even with the inconsistencies, is hair-popping sharp; however, I suspect those inconsistencies might become amplified over time. How much of an issue this might be is debatable. Currently the knife is a great cutter!

-
Mora Garberg pictured with today's carry, a ML EDC. Matt does some great stuff with steel and this little EDC is exceptionally useful. The broad 3" blade is an amazing cutter and allows for some great grips. It's easy to choke up and grip the blade itself for fine work or precise cuts. One of my favorites!


In re sharpening scandi-grinds, in this close up of the Garberg, you can see where I was a bit inconsistent and missed the shoulder (low) in one spot, and again (high) in another spot. It is just tough to be consistent when freehand sharpening (for me).

The dark spot is a reflection of my iPhone. ;)
This edge, even with the inconsistencies, is hair-popping sharp; however, I suspect those inconsistencies might become amplified over time. How much of an issue this might be is debatable. Currently the knife is a great cutter!


-
@Rapidray said:
Nice and I’m out of apples and off to the grocery store later today!@Nix said:
The first apples of the new season are showing up in markets now. I (and Mrs Nix, an apple fiend) are super excited! :ahhhWe're like 5 weeks out from our trip to the mountains. Honeycrisp apples won't be available then. Wife and I prefer them over all others, in season.
Hopefully I can get some tart ones and get my "Granny Smith" to make one of her pies. Her peach crisp was the hit during the summer.
-
Day 10:
Coming along nicely guys!

Opened some boxes and cut cardboard today, and had to use my Sog Kilowatt for stripping a couple of wires as it has a wire stripper in the handle



Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
@Nix said:
With a true Scandi grind, there is no secondary bevel, right? It's just a flat V-grind from the blade to the edge. In theory. But, when I "hone" a Scandi knife freehand, I inevitably introduce a "micro-bevel" at the sharp bit of that v-grind.Just to be sure we're using the same terms the same way:

A micro-bevel on a scandi knife is not 'ideal', but it actually works fairly well and makes for a more durable edge: there is more steel to support the cutting edge carbides. For that reason, I don't mind putting a fine micro-bevel on a Scandi. However, when removing a chip from the edge, i.e. sharpening vs simple honing, you have to remove metal from the entire side of the primary bevel, effectively worknig back into the flat, in order to reestablish a true scandi edge. Even with a slight chip (as in my case), this requires removing a lot of metal.
It's true that you only need to follow the angle set by the factory edge, so I would think it is easier, but maintaining that perfectly consistent angle freehand is really tough (perhaps just personal skill-limitation for me), especially if it requires doing so hundreds of times. When sharpening a chisel, there are no curves to accommodate and the leading edge of a chisel is only a couple inches wide (at most, for typical home chisels). So sharpening a chisel is fairly straightforward.....and I usually end up putting a smalll micro bevel on my chisels, too.
Achieving perfection is harder than it seems.I suppose it's good practice though. :D
With a hollow grind, flat grind w/ secondary bevel, or even convex edge, there is inherently less metal to remove to resharpen a knife, and the process is more forgiving in my experience. Perhaps highly skilled sharpeners would argue the opposite, but that's my experience.
That's not to say that I dislike scandi knives! Quite the opposite. I find Scandi knives to be great for many tasks. They are super-precise when carving wood (essentially a chisel edge on a knife). But I do find them to be a bit trickier to sharpen perfectly. That's my experience anyway: a lot of metal to remove, many chances to introduce variance.

(Couldn't find my old photos of the resharpened Garberg. I'll try to post one a bit later.
)Hey, Nix.
Thanks for taking the time for the write up and the chart.

To be honest, I never did chip my scandi knives enough to require a major do over(I did try batoning my Bushcraft survival thru fire wood literally for hours, but only managed to roll the edge a little bit
, axe is another story...
) What I usually do is put a very small micro bevel on my user scandi(real scandi, no secondary bevel), and so as long I use it within reason, couple passes or even stropping will bring most of my knives back to shaving sharp.For example, the Bushcraft survival is around 25 deg inclusive, and I would maintain a barely visible 40 deg micro bevel on it via the Sharpmaker. The performance is nearly identical, yet I still find it better than my Garberg, which essentially a saber grind with a micro bevel. Which reminds me, one of these days I gonna grind away it's secondary bevel to turn it into real scandi.
Personally, I prefer scandi over most other grinds for my outdoor/camping use, and they are mainly used for light wood work, and maybe some kitchen prep. I figure if I were to seriously damage my blade, to keep the similar thickness behind edge and geometry, I probably would have to remove serious amount of steel anyway, regardless what grind it is. And at least for real scandi or real full flat grind, it is "self guiding" so I would have a higher chance restoring them
Convex grind is inherently stronger, but I would need a belt sander to properly sharpen it which I don't have.Though I'm a SAK enthusiast, funny I don't actually subscribe myself to the one-tool option theory, and always carry my axe or at least my folding saw with me, especially for overnight outdoor trips. Don't get me wrong, I love big knives and chopper, and collected some over the years. But to me, using them as one tool option for outdoor trip is a romantic idea, it is fun for the first few hours, but not so much afterwards.
Anyway, I'm babbling now, but it is a true pleasure to join this great challenge to see different kind of sharps, and learn from everyone. :D
-
Mora Garberg pictured with today's carry, a ML EDC. Matt does some great stuff with steel and this little EDC is exceptionally useful. The broad 3" blade is an amazing cutter and allows for some great grips. It's easy to choke up and grip the blade itself for fine work or precise cuts. One of my favorites!


In re sharpening scandi-grinds, in this close up of the Garberg, you can see where I was a bit inconsistent and missed the shoulder (low) in one spot, and again (high) in another spot. It is just tough to be consistent when freehand sharpening (for me).

The dark spot is a reflection of my iPhone. ;)
This edge, even with the inconsistencies, is hair-popping sharp; however, I suspect those inconsistencies might become amplified over time. How much of an issue this might be is debatable. Currently the knife is a great cutter!

Both looks great!
And I notice you took away the secondary bevel on the Garberg, did you notice any performance difference? 
-
@comis said:
Both looks great!
And I notice you took away the secondary bevel on the Garberg, did you notice any performance difference? 
I don't think my Garberg ever had a secondary bevel. (I could be wrong about that.) It may have a tiny micro-bevel now, but it's mostly a pure scandi. Great cutter/carver.

-
Day: 10 (bonus material)
The ML got a little box opening work in this morning......

And inside was the knife I had hoped to get last month and use for this challenge:

A nice American take on the Puukko.
I'll need to make a sheath for this one, so I may not get to use it during the challenge. We'll see.

(And it came sharp, but could use a little more honing, so I may get a little more practice honing Scandis.......
)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login