Why so many of the same?
-
Here's a poorly lit photo I took real quick to illustrate my approach to collecting from the last post. To almost every sane person in the world these are all the same knife. To me, they are 16 different Motorist variants. Now this is a little extreme since the Motorist is probably my favorite knife so I tend to pick up a lot of them, but that's how a lot of my collection is.
It seems odd that a relatively thin knife that was only made for 20 years would have so many variants, but Elinox knives in the late 60s/early 70s went through a LOT of changes so this is not that uncommon. Funny thing is there are at least 3 other variants that I know are missing here and one questionable one that I did not include in the picture but that I do have. (I'm still trying to decide if pen blade spacers count as a variant or not. If they do, then there's #17 ::) ) However, for my collecting needs, I fulfill goal #1 (get one of every model) and goal #2 (one model from each era/period of production) and am kind of overdoing it on #3 (collect variants with periods). So for me, I don't really care that I don't have those other missing variants and don't really buy Motorists unless I get them for a good price.

For the curious - top row, L-R:
*MVNT: Middle vintage, 1957-1962. Elinox knives so expect unpolished tools. Late MVNT main blades are polished, early are not. *
- MVNT Motorist
*LVNT: Late Vintage, 1962-1968. Elinox knives so expect unpolished tools except main blade, NS spacer. *
2. LVNT Motorist, no nick file, large Elinox, AL spacer
3. LVNT Motorist, no nick file, large Elinox, bail
4. LVNT Motorist, large Elinox, AL pen blade spacer (NS version not shown)
5. LVNT Motorist, large Elinox, bail
6. LVNT Motorist, small Elinox, bail
7. LVNT Motorist, small Elinox
8. LVNT Motorist, small Elinox, key ringbottom row, L-R
TRAN: Transitional Period, 1969-1974. Small Elinox stamp, tools transition unpolished > polished by the end, +PAT disappears, KR replaces bail
9. TRAN Motorist, +PAT, pol cap lifter w/o scraper
10. TRAN Motorist (St Christopher on rear scale), no +PAT pol can opener, pol cap lifter with scraper, pol Philips
11. TRAN Motorist, no +PAT pol can opener, pol cap lifter with scraper, pol Philips, pol fine screwdriver
12. TRAN Motorist, no +PAT pol can opener, pol cap lifter w/o scraper, pol Philips, pol fine screwdriver
13. TRAN Motorist, no +PAT pol can opener, pol cap lifter w/o scraper, pol Philips with file, pol fine screwdriver, Victoria OS main blade, new style metal file with nail cleanerECLS Early Classical, 1974-1979. Elinox lines phased out for all "specialty" models, new 2.4mm blades, file with nail cleaner, all polished tools
14. ECLS Motorist, 2.4mm VSSR/Officer Suisse blade, Philips with can key, key ring, flat style file backspring
15. ECLS Motorist, 2.4mm VSSR/Officer Suisse blade, Philips with can key, key ring, bump style file backspring, 1mm divider full height dividerMCLS Mid Classical, 1980-1985. Officier Suisse blades, SS inlays, all polished, square > round can key philips transition
16. MCLS Motorist, square can key Philips, tapered awl -
Absolutely superb, Jazzbass. Thank you for the post and detailed explanation.
Myron
-
The Master has spoken
The grasshoppers listen and absorb !
:D

-
More of the same. (but different)

]

-

It’s Bartholomew Richard Fitzgerald-Smythe! -
That mint OC is just

I remembered his first name and had to google it to find out the rest of his name.

-
**Why so many of the same? **
In my case, only one word:
Backups
Since for me Sak's, are 95% of the time, standard red cellidor models, different scales pr colors are of little relevance. The last time i bought Climbers i ordered 3 of them exactly alike. When i bought my first Compact o ordered 2 of them.
One of the units is for EDC rotation, the others sit patiently in their boxes on a drawer waiting to be needed.
But for me this is not just a Sak thing, its a "backup OCD" thing. If i could I'd have an exact backup for everything...

Don't let my wife read this though.... :ahhh.

-
I think this hits upon the distinction between collecting and accumulating. I tend to do a little of both. Following my nose and picking up whatever strikes me for a while, and then feverishly pursuing a series or grouping for a few months. It's a sickness, I swear.
-
@Myron said:
I think this hits upon the distinction between collecting and accumulating. I tend to do a little of both. Following my nose and picking up whatever strikes me for a while, and then feverishly pursuing a series or grouping for a few months. ** It's a sickness, I swear.**You and me both. I only pretend there are limits to what I'd collect. :ahhh
@FolderBeholder said:
I still covet that box, tape and all!
I'm sure you'll find one even minty-er! This one has too much 'character'. :D
-
For example, I have a handful of 'original' Woodsman 236 and 236U...though not even one of my favorites, or even on the 'list'.
But when I saw this:



was the only reaction.The only reason I didn't end up with it is that I underestimated it's market value...

Strangely, the only real value to me was that it 'proves' my point about old names and how far back they were used...there are other models from this era that I'd prefer for the same purpose.



-
So many still isn't enough...

-
@Simon_Templar said:
A lifetime supply? That would have to be one hell of a heavy duty user/collector
Check.
Yes. I have Marlboro Troubleshooters just for that reason. Can't even tell you how many. Heaviest use is on the cap lifter as a pry bar, primarily for rebuilding and fixing SAKs. Does a lot of damage to the tools in very short time. And I do a lot of regrinding, forging and polishing in-between, before I move on to the next one.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login







