Batoning Is Stupid
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I poker terms......I see your hatchet, and I raise you Camelthorn (and other Acacia) wood.....And I laugh while I take your money.

Actually... I take your money as my argument also applies to hardwood (unless you are trying to tell me there are Camelthorn logs in the wilderness) and even with hardwood the hatchet will do better than batoning with your knife.
-
@Etherealicer said:
Actually... I take your money as my argument also applies to hardwood (unless you are trying to tell me there are Camelthorn logs in the wilderness) and even with hardwood the hatchet will do better than batoning with your knife.My money is safe, you'll just mess up your wrist with your wee hatchet.

The way it works with Camelthron is you gather dead wood by breaking it off the tree. Most likely no need to split wood to start the fire because you can use the small branches at the tip.
I reality, we cannot and should not gather wood where we camp out of consideration for those that follow, so we're back to the big bags of wood we buy at the service station.......and the safest, easiest way to get small pieces for starting the fire....even with a hatchet, is batoning

-
Last night a girl walked in on me watching batoning videos. She was all like, "You know they exploit those poor knives just so men like you can be 'entertained'."
-
@spudley112 said:
Last night a girl walked in on me watching batoning videos. She was all like, "You know they exploit those poor knives just so men like you can be 'entertained'."That's golden, she is wise beyond Yoda. :D
-
@spudley112 said:
Last night a girl walked in on me watching batoning videos. She was all like, "You know they exploit those poor knives just so men like you can be 'entertained'."Funny, but she's wrong

Men are the ones being exploited, we end up on the living room floor in underwear surrounded by a collection of knives able to "span the average log", eating peanut butter from the jar, mumbling "Nutnfancy made me do it"

-
While I enjoy this guy's videos he makes me cringe whenever he batons with a SAK
:ahhh
-
@Noa Isumi said:
While I enjoy this guy's videos he makes me cringe whenever he batons with a SAK
:ahhhHe does explain that you should only baton with the blade at 90 degrees so you don't break the spring. Probably best not to baton anything too large either
-
True
He only does it for small crafts, and it is just to start a wedge, but it still makes me cringe for some reason. -
Not only can the backspring be broken, but the saw is the thinnest tool SAKs have. I've bent two because I slipped while cutting a tree limb (normal use). Messing around, I've been able to split smaller pieces of wood by using the saw to CUT a notch to start a wedge, then carving a wedge, which I would then drive it in with a larger stick or rock.
-
Got caught batoning in the neighbor's yard last night. Now I think I am on the National Batoners Watch list. Btaon my life.
-
I noted some discolored spots on the blade of my Becker BK9. I think it got a BTD (Baton Transmitted Disease).
-
@spudley112 said:
I noted some discolored spots on the blade of my Becker BK9. I think it got a BTD (Baton Transmitted Disease).Each of those BK with coating probably will get that disease, one way or another. :D That's why I usually do prefer knife without coating, and probably better slicing performance too.
-

Just think what some pioneer dude would've though of a BK9......
....he could've slipped and batoned right through the American continent!

-
@cody6268 said:
Not only can the backspring be broken, but the saw is the thinnest tool SAKs have. I've bent two because I slipped while cutting a tree limb (normal use). Messing around, I've been able to split smaller pieces of wood by using the saw to CUT a notch to start a wedge, then carving a wedge, which I would then drive it in with a larger stick or rock.I do apologize for not reading the whole thread to see if this was addressed...
There's a suggestion of opening the blade to a right angle, so that the stress is off the backspring when you baton the spine.
Edit: yup - it's been addressed. I'll leave this here as a reminder that I'm not that clever.
-
If you must baton, perhaps a hacking knife is better than a bushcraft knife.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
