Victorinox mistakes?
-
@kamakiri said:
I doubt it's real. Well, the added saw serrations, at least.Hard to tell from the small pics, but** I think it looks like c. '75 construction for the original knife.** At least the parts look consistent that way.
If it is real, I don't think you should take it apart. Even if the serrations are modded, it would still be worth something as an original Modeler, if it is.
The tweezer tip is aluminum and the shield is nickel silver. The black oxide scissor spring and the other details make it c. '75 as I said. I can dial it in for certain if I see the "bottom" side (backspings) with the awl closed. Would be able to help me see if it's earlier than that. But it's certainly not outside of '73 to '75. Probably not '73 or early '74 from what I can already see, but the awl would confirm or reinforce my thoughts. Closeup of the back tang stamp might help too.
-
I took apart a compact the other day and the combo tool had been stamped from the thicker steel that the bottle opener and can opener would be made from. It was so thick the sak was bulging at that end. First time Id see that one.
-
Quoted Syph's post in the 'official' errors club thread
/post/2033482 -
@Syph007 said:
I took apart a compact the other day and the combo tool had been stamped from the thicker steel that the bottle opener and can opener would be made from. It was so thick the sak was bulging at that end. First time Id see that one.2mm thick? I have a Mechanic Jr that's the same. I always assumed it was 111mm combo tool that was used (intentionally or accidentally) and not a stamping error. Not sure what the pin diameter is on 111mm knives though - 2.5mm? 3mm? If the 111mm knives have bigger pins that would answer the question pretty easily.
-
I'm still really puzzled as to who cut these woodsaw teeth into the metal file
ie Who would have the machines/tooling/capability to do this.? ???

From the pictures above it looks very like regular saw teeth.Do you think it was done in the factory by someone fooling around/experimenting ?
Could you do something like this with files or would it have to be machined ?
I'm thinking the latterThoughts ?
-
@Huntsman said:
I'm still really puzzled as to who cut these woodsaw teeth into the metal fileie Who would have the machines/tooling/capability to do this.? ???

From the pictures above it looks very like regular saw teeth.Do you think it was done in the factory by someone fooling around/experimenting ?
Could you do something like this with files or would it have to be machined ?
I'm thinking the latterThoughts ?
Bet you it's a mod.
It would be extremely tedious, but you could even do it with hand files:
If you can file at a steady 45 degree angle, the teeth of the SAK file will allow you to make the spacing look even.
And you can set a depth by putting the file in a vise, or simply by counting vertical bumps as you file. -
@Huntsman said:
I'm still really puzzled as to who cut these woodsaw teeth into the metal fileie Who would have the machines/tooling/capability to do this.? ???

From the pictures above it looks very like regular saw teeth.Do you think it was done in the factory by someone fooling around/experimenting ?
Could you do something like this with files or would it have to be machined ?
I'm thinking the latterThoughts ?
It is well done for sure.
The fact that he did such a good job that we all can not tell... means he did a good job. I think this would take quite a lot of practice and several attempts to do it this well...it doesnt look like he got “bored” and started filing... I mean I cant find any obvious “crooked” or “sloppy” spot and im loooooking.
Also how could you machine this without taking the blade out?
What do you think? Have it replaced with new stainless metal saw? Or keep this saw oditity and restore everything but the saw and scales?
-
Also the belly’s of the saw teeth are “round” just like factory wood saws.
I know if i tried to do this i could not do it like this first try.
-
@Will Bateman said:
What do you think? Have it replaced with new stainless metal saw? Or keep this saw oditity and restore everything but the saw and scales?I can't say for sure, but I suspect the file's steel is not right for use as a saw. So, it's function as a file is severely impaired, and it's functionality as a woodsaw is limited.
So I would replace it.
-
@jazzbass said:
2mm thick? I have a Mechanic Jr that's the same. I always assumed it was 111mm combo tool that was used (intentionally or accidentally) and not a stamping error. Not sure what the pin diameter is on 111mm knives though - 2.5mm? 3mm? If the 111mm knives have bigger pins that would answer the question pretty easily.It had a 2.5mm hole. Was identical to a standard 91mm except for thickness.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login