Spirit knife
-
@WhichDawg said:
A question asked often. Many of us carry a dedicated blade also (I prefer spear or drop-point)
and the "butter knife" on the Spirit was weird at first but when you use it you realize (many do)
that it is an efficient and nice thing to have.For me it's a back-up blade but it also does a nice job with certain things and the blunter tip
provides safety and strength that many "pointier" blades don't have.Hmmm, but then how would you for example, make holes through stuff if there is no point on the knife to do that? Oh also, just wondering, is the Spirit's steel of better quality than the Leatherman multitools steel?
-
It has a very nice awl! (separate tool) which is a better tool to use then a blade.
I wouldn't say better but Victori "NOX" has a history of strength, endurance and corrossion free
which is good enough for me. -
@WhichDawg said:
It has a very nice awl! (separate tool) which is a better tool to use then a blade.
I wouldn't say better but it has a history of strength, endurance and corrossion free
which is good enough for me.Thank you guys for the replies! This really makes me want one now, I'm just a kid and unfortunately I really can't afford it.
-
Aero dude, you're gonna start the first MT WW if you go on like this. :D
Well, here's my €0.02 worth of opinion. What people call the "butter" knife is a great choice for many occasions. Other than being more appealing/less frightening to NKP and probably a legal choice in some EU countries (who don't ban locking blades but do ban pointed ones), it is a very efficient design. The serrations are well made (not too aggressive, not too dull) and, in the Vic tradition, they cut through various stuff like "butter". ;) For poking holes the awl is a much better option (even if the original Spirit had a pointed blade, I'd still use the awl for such tasks, after seeing 154CM and S30V blades with broken tips due to such usage). That weird blade also has a PE part near the pivot (again in the Vic tradition) which is also much better in several occasions. Much like most combination edge blades, this one is chisel ground and that's my sole complaint. That said, the Spirit also comes with a "normal" drop-point plain edge (Spirit X) and with both blades (Spirit S) so you can choose. You don't get the same steel as high-end LMs (read Charges) but Vic's steel is more corrosion resistant and takes a wicked edge fast (albeit it doesn't hold it for that long). In the end it's all a matter of intended usage/maintenance and tool choice.
-
@Aero said:
Hmmm, but then how would you for example, make holes through stuff if there is no point on the knife to do that? Oh also, just wondering, is the Spirit's steel of better quality than the Leatherman multitools steel?Use the awl. :D
Offhand I would say "Yes!" to Victorinox having the better steel but that may not be measureably true since specs for both companies are still pretty unclear. However, I will say that Victorinox has much better edge/blade geometry than Leatherman, which can actually be more important to sharpness and perceived edge retention that overall steel specs. The Victorinox blades are generally thinner stock with a more acture bevel angle, combine this with the reduced drag from the heavy polish and I feel their blades are sharper and last longer.
-
@noth said:
Aero dude, you're gonna start the first MT WW if you go on like this. :DWell, here's my €0.02 worth of opinion. What people call the "butter" knife is a great choice for many occasions. Other than being more appealing/less frightening to NKP and probably a legal choice in some EU countries (who don't ban locking blades but do ban pointed ones), it is a very efficient design. The serrations are well made (not too aggressive, not too dull) and, in the Vic tradition, they cut through various stuff like "butter". ;) For poking holes the awl is a much better option (even if the original Spirit had a pointed blade, I'd still use the awl for such tasks, after seeing 154CM and S30V blades with broken tips due to such usage). That weird blade also has a PE part near the pivot (again in the Vic tradition) which is also much better in several occasions. Much like most combination edge blades, this one is chisel ground and that's my sole complaint. That said, the Spirit also comes with a "normal" drop-point plain edge (Spirit X) and with both blades (Spirit S) so you can choose. You don't get the same steel as high-end LMs (read Charges) but Vic's steel is more corrosion resistant and takes a wicked edge fast (albeit it doesn't hold it for that long). In the end it's all a matter of intended usage/maintenance and tool choice.
I don't understand why I'd start the first multitool world war, but ok, whatever. :D
-
That's mostly because "LMs rust, Vics don't" and many people are gonna battle over which of the two companies makes the best mts. (The correct answer is obviously "the one with a cross in its logo" but you'll get many erroneous replies) ::)
-
Personally , I like the butterknife , great for dirty jobs.
Chris
-
The butterknife has a far more efficiently ground blade than the newer Leatherman tools I've tried. The thickness at the edge is much thinner. The blade has a better polish. The Vic steel is super-duper stainless. And for those of us with a Spyderco Military in our pocket, the Spirit blade is the sheeple friendly knife that we carry. Vic steel is not very abrasion resistant, but it is very strong, resisting chipping at the edge. I use the butter knife as my "sacrificial lamb", instead of destroying the edge on my Spyderco.
-
i like the "butter" knife, but also the drop-point knife, thats why i got the spirit s and carry a micra for the scissors :)
-
the spirit's serrated knife is a pocket buzzsaw, its cutting ability is mind blowing.
-
Hmmm, but then how would you for example, make holes through stuff if there is no point on the knife to do that? Oh also, just wondering, is the Spirit's steel of better quality than the Leatherman multitools steel?
Use the awl. :D
Offhand I would say "Yes!" to Victorinox having the better steel but that may not be measureably true since specs for both companies are still pretty unclear. However, I will say that Victorinox has much better edge/blade geometry than Leatherman, which can actually be more important to sharpness and perceived edge retention that overall steel specs. The Victorinox blades are generally thinner stock with a more acture bevel angle, combine this with the reduced drag from the heavy polish and I feel their blades are sharper and last longer.
I think leatherman now say theirs use 420HC, and vic's steel content is more or less published. They are quite similar if you look at the numbers.
420HC : Carbon Manganese Chromium Nickel Silicon HRC 0.4-0.5 1.0 12-14 0.5 0.6 55-58 INOX : Carbon Manganese Chromium Molybdenum Silicon HRC 0.52 0.45 15 0.5 0.6 56 -
The steel in the spirit is easy to sharpen , and holds an acceptable edge . More importantly , the grind is very consistent , and it sharpens up beautifully on the Spyderco Sharpmakers . I give the butterknife two thumbs up . I have an X model inbound , time will tell , but I think I may still EDC the "Butterknife ".
Chris
-
I too like the butter knife alot and actually prefer it over a standard blade. A sheepsfoot serated blade offers more utility on a mutli imo, plus I always have a folder on me for more delicate cutting tasks.
-
I agree with what you guys are saying , like the ease of sharpening and amazing cutting power

I work with boats and members of the public and and while I carry an small issue blunt tipped fixed blade knife on my life jacket I use my Spirit for day to day stuff . Actually the Sprits blade has a slightly longer cutting edge , Is sharper and believe it or not I can actually deploy it quicker the the Fixed blade all be it with two hands .The Spirit doesn't look threatening around sheeple and after 5 weeks of work EDC its prooving ideal for me . If I need a point I use the awl or the Vic Farmer in my pocket .Dunc
-
To be honest I very seldom use the Spirit's knife blade. I carry the Spirit coupled with a Classic (for t&t) with a Spyderco Endura 4 for my OH blade.
The most action the Spirit sees is pliers / cutters. ;)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login