Victorinox 91mm Tools Evolution
-
Excellent summary; thank you, MiniChamp.
-

And great photos also!
-

@MiniChamp said:
Certainly before 1985, but I believe that 1983-84 is more likely to be correct. This is because it's relatively common to see a square Phillips on SAKs with the latest eyeless variant of the awl.Part of the reason I think '82 is possible, are the quantities of round phillips found in the '80-'85 range. There are also some finer construction details in specific models I've observed which lead me to believe that it's earlier than '83 and that '82 is the pivot year. I say c. '82, but '83 is certainly possible. I very highly doubt '84. And keep in mind this is only for 91mm.
I've read a lot about the various posts and opinions here. I can't say anybody else has dug deeper than you, me and jazzbass combined on the matter.
@MiniChamp said:
Here is what I can say about these variants:- 1a. square, double-cut file, no can-key; used 1951-1960.
- 1b. square, single-cut file, no can-key; used 1960-1973.
- 2a. unpolished square, no file, no can-key; Elinox variant: used on Elinox SAKs from 1957 until the early 1970's.
- 2b. polished square, no file, no can-key; a relatively rare variant that was used quite briefly in the early 1970's (probably in 1971-1973; possibly in some overlap with variant 1b).
- 3. polished square, no file, can-key; used 1973-1983.
- 4. round, can-key; used 1983-1991.
- 5. round, no can-key; used since 1991.
As I say...Excellent work as usual, MiniChamp! My list is only tighter in a few spots and I express a little more uncertainly on the earlier dates. I'd say your dates are better than a 2 year margin of error otherwise. More like one year +/-, aside from the 1960 peg and the 1951 start.
-
Thanks!

@kamakiri said:
As I say...Excellent work as usual, MiniChamp!Thanks, but...
My list is only tighter in a few spots and I express a little more uncertainly on the earlier dates. I'd say your dates are better than a 2 year margin of error otherwise. More like one year +/-, aside from the 1960 peg and the 1951 start.
??? So what does your list say?
(Other than the square-round transition that was already discussed.) I will greatly appreciate you being a little more concrete. Ultimately, our best chance of getting the most accurate information is by combining our knowledge. If you have somewhat different concrete guesstimates, please say what they are. If you can provide some reasoning that would be even better. Thanks! -
Added this thread - and the Vintage SAK Club thread - to the dating and identification stickie
-
Exellent work MiniChamp! Can I make a compiled picture and simplify the text a little, please? This would be very useful for many SAK collectors.

-
I like this one!

-
Thanks!

Can I make a compiled picture and simplify the text a little, please?
Sure (it looks like you did it already ;) ), but I would prefer it if you replace the line that says "by MiniChamp (forum multitool.org)" with one saying
Source: /post/2041782
(where the URL is the full URL to the message with my original image files). This way potential viewers can get to the full res images along with the latest updates and precise info concerning who said/did what.
-
@MiniChamp said:
Thanks, but... ??? So what does your list say?
(Other than the square-round transition that was already discussed.) I will greatly appreciate you being a little more concrete.My apologies for being unclear and not very specific. Here's one example where I can't peg a date and think the margin of error could be more than 2 years.
For your 1a, I doubt '51 is the exact back phillips start date. I don't know what it is or have a stipulated specific date. All I know is that there are the crab-claw/PWAR copies that don't likely match the +PAT/'51 peg, (or the Vic stated '52) IMO. I suspect earlier, but hard to say by how much. But there are enough variants which I've seen that make me suspect more than a year or two earlier. And I'd also say there's a single-cut variant before this...also different in form that it has and angled 'draft' toward the inner liner, much like the conical awls, but a shallower angle.
@MiniChamp said:
Ultimately, our best chance of getting the most accurate information is by combining our knowledge. If you have somewhat different concrete guesstimates, please say what they are. If you can provide some reasoning that would be even better. Thanks!I completely agree about the combination of knowledge. It's why I feel I had to start posting about some of this at the beginning of 2019. I already intend to share what I know...but I realize as I try to answer questions about one tool that it's really difficult to present out of order. Even kicking off my "Dating in the '70s" out of order starting with the Grand Prix inlays caused me some grief. Sure, it's good information...but it says nothing about the process. And I think that's the important part to explain, which I believe should be explained first. The Grand Prix bit was supposed to help motivate me to get the ball rolling. Had a bit of the opposite effect.
-
For the 1a 'end', I think it's a bit later than '60. I have a small awl knife that looks like a revised, smaller second cut was used. I am assuming the earliest that knife could be is '61, but I think this copy is a bit later. Might be a short lived experiment in '62 or '63.
For 2b, I don't think the end is in '73 for 91mm. Knives that I suspect are late '72 already have the can key. Partly because of the relative rarity of this type, and the availability of the '1b' types that are post- PAT, I think the start may also be '72.
I think that's about as much as I can say without getting into the 'proof' and backup documentation or better explanation.
-
@MiniChamp said:
Thanks!
Sure (it looks like you did it already ;) ), but I would prefer it if you replace the line that says "by MiniChamp (forum multitool.org)" with one sayingSource: /post/2041782
(where the URL is the full URL to the message with my original image files). This way potential viewers can get to the full res images along with the latest updates and precise info concerning who said/did what.
Yes I did it already but I can delete it if you don't like it ;)
Let's stay with your nickname on the picture, these are your work, your pictures. I hate to see here and there Ulli's date sheets without mentioning his authority.
Sorry for misunderstanding, should I put link on the picture?? I think it is not useful: https: //forum.multitool.org/index.php/topic,14646.0.html
Maybe this works better:

-
I believe the Phillips cut is longer but them my eyes are kinds shot!

-
@kamakiri said:
My apologies for being unclear and not very specific.Thanks a lot for coming back with the details.

For your 1a, I doubt '51 is the exact back phillips start date. I don't know what it is or have a stipulated specific date. All I know is that there are the crab-claw/PWAR copies that don't likely match the +PAT/'51 peg, (or the Vic stated '52) IMO. I suspect earlier, but hard to say by how much. But there are enough variants which I've seen that make me suspect more than a year or two earlier. And I'd also say there's a single-cut variant before this...also different in form that it has and angled 'draft' toward the inner liner, much like the conical awls, but a shallower angle.
Sounds interesting, but not really familiar. Are you sure that you are talking about 91mm SAKs? There are certainly quite a lot of 84mm SAKs with the Phillips + crab-claw can opener combination, but I don't recall seeing such 91mm SAKs. Also, for 84mm SAKs, the file on the Phillips is always single-cut. Can you post an image of a 91mm SAK with a Phillips + crab-claw can opener?
@kamakiri said:
For the 1a 'end', I think it's a bit later than '60. I have a small awl knife that looks like a revised, smaller second cut was used. I am assuming the earliest that knife could be is '61, but I think this copy is a bit later. Might be a short lived experiment in '62 or '63.Interesting. I don't recall seeing double-cut files on small awl SAKs, but did see single-cut files on big awl SAKs.
For 2b, I don't think the end is in '73 for 91mm. Knives that I suspect are late '72 already have the can key. Partly because of the relative rarity of this type, and the availability of the '1b' types that are post- PAT, I think the start may also be '72.
From my personal observations, I cannot really say much more than early 70's. It does occur on SAKs with and without +Pat on the can opener. Also, while it's relatively rare, it doesn't seem to be rare enough to fit in just one year.
-
@jnoxyd said:
Let's stay with your nickname on the picture, these are your work, your pictures.Fine, I don't have any problem with that. I just think that it's more important to include the full link to the source.
Maybe this works better:

Not so much. I think that the line should say:
Source: https: //forum.multitool.org/index.php/topic,14646.msg2041782.html#msg2041782
While it may be a bit ugly, it should make it much easier to actually find the source.
-
84mm with double-cut file:


-
Hard to see the angled cuts, but they're there. And they run through all the perpendicular teeth, unlike other angled cuts which both stop short and run long.


-
Nice pics and SAK kamakiri

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
