Victorinox 91mm Tools Evolution
-
@MiniChamp said:
From my personal observations, I cannot really say much more than early 70's. It does occur on SAKs with and without +Pat on the can opener. Also, while it's relatively rare, it doesn't seem to be rare enough to fit in just one year.Regarding the 2b dates...In order for it to end in '73, I think there would be copies with features that are clear for that year. With clip point <u>and</u> black scissor spring, or new metal saw...otherwise I don't think it made it into '73.
On the start date, I do see late '71 as a possibility. Just really unlikely, IMO. I haven't seen any copies that are +PAT or 'old' scissor <u>and</u> mainline production.
Regarding the 'fit in one year'...I say absolutely possible and likely. With the quantity of knives I have concentrated on the '70s, there would be far more of these in my possession if it did last longer.
Thanks, Ivo...but that Tinker is a bit of a beater! :D -
I’ve checked my early 1970s, here are some of them:
Champion with 2b Phillips (no +Pat, stainless double leaf scissors spring)


Fieldmaster with 1b Phillips and blank stamp (no +Pat, black double leaf scissors spring)


-
Very nice examples!

-
@MiniChamp said:
for 84mm SAKs, the file on the Phillips is always single-cut.@kamakiri said:
84mm with double-cut file:

I guess I was wrong. After seeing your post, I looked at some of my early 84mm SAKs with a Phillips SD. While the files on most of them (particularly on those with the crab-claw can opener) are undoubtedly single-cut, I found one that looks like it's supposed to be a double-cut (that I previously considered to be a single-cut). The second cut on it is kind of shallow, so that it isn't a real cut, but there is some waviness in the teeth that corresponds to a second cut. I guess it can be called wannabe double-cut. So... It looks like, for 84mm SAKs, most of the files on the Phillips SD's are single-cut (right from the time when they started making them), but some are nevertheless double-cut. This is pretty much all that I know at this time. It's certainly worthy of further investigation, but this is outside the scope of a 91mm evolution thread.Back to 91mm: Since I don't recall ever seeing a 91mm SAK with a Phillips + crab-claw can opener combination (and since you didn't say anything on that), I believe that if such SAKs exist, they are very rare. Hence, it seems extremely unlikely to me that 91mm SAKs with a Phillips SD existed (other than prototypes, maybe) at any time before 1950. Also, as far as I can tell, the Phillips SD files on 91mm SAKs with visible rivets are all double-cut. (Of course, given that single-cut files may be the result of a faulty double-cut file production, it seems very likely that a few such files can be found on 91mm SAKs. Such rare expected occurrence shouldn't really change the general picture.)
@kamakiri said:
Hard to see the angled cuts, but they're there. And they run through all the perpendicular teeth, unlike other angled cuts which both stop short and run long.

I don't understand what you tried to say in this post (also, what kind of SAK is this?). The file on the Phillips SD in the last image looks like a damaged single-cut. Is that what it's supposed to be?
I haven't seen any copies that are +PAT or 'old' scissor <u>and</u> mainline production.
You should look at the following FolderBeholder thread: /topic/71213
Regarding the 'fit in one year'...I say absolutely possible and likely.
You may be right, but I suspect that your estimates might be based on assumptions that are not necessarily correct, like assuming that Victorinox only uses one tool version at a time across all it's models. I believe that it doesn't really work this way and for this particular variant, I'm under the impression that it was used on some models (notably on Champions) at the same time when version 1b was used on other models (notably on Fishermen). Another issue is that their transitions seem to take time, so if they stop making a tool variant in mid-1972, say, I expect to find it on some SAKs that are produced well into 1973, if not later. Ultimately, aside from being in line with my limited observations, I like the 1971-1973 guesstimate also because it covers, within an error margin of +/- one year, all of the following:
-
1972-1972 (Kamakiri proposed range).
-
1971-1972 (The most recent, AFAIK, JazzBass proposed range; see /post/1632708).
-
1970-1974 (Earlier JazzBass proposed range; see /post/1534681).
-
-
Great examples, jnoxyd!
Here are some of mine from c. '72.
3 Champions and a Master Craftsman:

The ones from above with phillips, c. '71/'72 146fmaU Champion, c. '72 146fmaU Champion, c. '72 136maUMaster Craftsman:

The c. '72 146fmaU Champion, c. '72 136maUMaster Craftsman c. '73 136fmaU (Master?) Craftsman:

-
@kamakiri said:
Great examples, jnoxyd!Here are some of mine from c. '72.
3 Champions and a Master Craftsman:

The ones from above with phillips, c. '71/'72 146fmaU Champion, c. '72 146fmaU Champion, c. '72 136maUMaster Craftsman:

The c. '72 146fmaU Champion, c. '72 136maUMaster Craftsman c. '73 136fmaU (Master?) Craftsman:

Oh, my lovely Champions in different versions [emoji7], thanks for sharing, Kamakiri!
I think we can call '73 136fmaU just Craftsman although less complicated model without fish tool still has old name Master Craftsman. Victorinox had to learn from Hoffrits how to name new models [emoji38]


-
@MiniChamp said:
I guess I was wrong. After seeing your post, I looked at some of my early 84mm SAKs with a Phillips SD. While the files on most of them (particularly on those with the crab-claw can opener) are undoubtedly single-cut, I found one that looks like it's supposed to be a double-cut (that I previously considered to be a single-cut). The second cut on it is kind of shallow, so that it isn't a real cut, but there is some waviness in the teeth that corresponds to a second cut. I guess it can be called wannabe double-cut. So... It looks like, for 84mm SAKs, most of the files on the Phillips SD's are single-cut (right from the time when they started making them), but some are nevertheless double-cut. This is pretty much all that I know at this time. It's certainly worthy of further investigation, but this is outside the scope of a 91mm evolution thread.Moments like this are why I believe just about anything is possible...Things I would have never guessed keep showing up.
@MiniChamp said:
Back to 91mm: Since I don't recall ever seeing a 91mm SAK with a Phillips + crab-claw can opener combination (and since you didn't say anything on that), I believe that if such SAKs exist, they are very rare. Hence, it seems extremely unlikely to me that 91mm SAKs with a Phillips SD existed (other than prototypes, maybe) at any time before 1950. Also, as far as I can tell, the Phillips SD files on 91mm SAKs with visible rivets are all double-cut. (Of course, given that single-cut files may be the result of a faulty double-cut file production, it seems very likely that a few such files can be found on 91mm SAKs. Such rare expected occurrence shouldn't really change the general picture.)I think they exist, but I don't have any and couldn't find any pics I might have saved. But even without either 'proof', I don't see a reason why they'd make the phillips for only the 84m, for as long as I think they've been in production. I'm guessing at least 3 years for the 84mm based on the variants that I have seen and own.
@MiniChamp said:
I don't understand what you tried to say in this post (also, what kind of SAK is this?). The file on the Phillips SD in the last image looks like a damaged single-cut. Is that what it's supposed to be?It's a Champion c.'62/'63 with horn scales. The phillips is like the "I guess it can be called wannabe double-cut." of yours, I suspect. Hard to photograph, but there are diagonal cuts in each of the main teeth.
@MiniChamp said:
You should look at the following FolderBeholder thread: /topic/71213Betcha hers is actually one of the forged '2a' style.


I've read the thread before. If it has any of jazzbass' posts...good chance I've read the thread.
@MiniChamp said:
You may be right, but I suspect that your estimates might be based on assumptions that are not necessarily correct, like assuming that Victorinox only uses one tool version at a time across all it's models. I believe that it doesn't really work this way and for this particular variant, I'm under the impression that it was used on some models (notably on Champions) at the same time when version 1b was used on other models (notably on Fishermen). Another issue is that their transitions seem to take time, so if they stop making a tool variant in mid-1972, say, I expect to find it on some SAKs that are produced well into 1973, if not later. Ultimately, aside from being in line with my limited observations, I like the 1971-1973 guesstimate also because it covers, within an error margin of +/- one year, all of the following:- 1972-1972 (Kamakiri proposed range).
- 1971-1972 (The most recent, AFAIK, JazzBass proposed range; see /post/1632708).
- 1970-1974 (Earlier JazzBass proposed range; see /post/1534681).
To be clear, I am not certain that it is a '72 start. Could be very late '71 as I believe I have said. Even the '73 end...I believe is possible, just much less likely. When I say within a year, I mean 12 months of production, so a late '71 start and say a mid '72 end is theoretically possible.
Off the cuff, I'm tracking well over 10 changes that I would classify as 'early '70s'. Some of that is bound to bunch up pretty tight, and yes, a lot of it does in '73. But it still leaves very tight ranges for any single change.
....
I hope I'm making some sense. I'm trying to make a timely response over a really thorough explanation.
-
@jnoxyd said:
Oh, my lovely Champions in different versions [emoji7], thanks for sharing, Kamakiri!
I think we can call '73 136fmaU just Craftsman although less complicated model without fish tool still has old name Master Craftsman. Victorinox had to learn from Hoffrits how to name new models [emoji38]


:o


That's also the 5044 reference I've been looking for!! Thanks!!

Unfortunately, it proves one of my other crazy theories wrong about what NASA bought.

-
5002 Artisan :o :ahhh

84mm or 91mm?
:ahhh......
Look at the mistake on the 5014 Electrician... :o Obviously should be 5024... :ahhh
-
@kamakiri said:
Great examples, jnoxyd!Here are some of mine from c. '72.
3 Champions and a Master Craftsman:
The ones from above with phillips, c. '71/'72 146fmaU Champion, c. '72 146fmaU Champion, c. '72 136maUMaster Craftsman:
The c. '72 146fmaU Champion, c. '72 136maUMaster Craftsman c. '73 136fmaU (Master?) Craftsman:
Great looking SAK’s

-
@jnoxyd said:
Oh, my lovely Champions in different versions [emoji7], thanks for sharing, Kamakiri!
I think we can call '73 136fmaU just Craftsman although less complicated model without fish tool still has old name Master Craftsman. Victorinox had to learn from Hoffrits how to name new models [emoji38]

-
@MiniChamp said:
You may be right, but I suspect that your estimates might be based on assumptions that are not necessarily correct, like assuming that Victorinox only uses one tool version at a time across all it's models. I believe that it doesn't really work this way and for this particular variant, I'm under the impression that it was used on some models (notably on Champions) at the same time when version 1b was used on other models (notably on Fishermen).I've gotta say I wouldn't do that...there's a long history of old tools used concurrently with the new versions. Even with main line production...and it's certainly true when advertising and Hoffritz are included. I do believe that some changes have been made in pretty broad moves that bridge all main line models and types. I do have a tendency to treat things like that like a common rung on separate ladders.
@MiniChamp said:
Another issue is that their transitions seem to take time, so if they stop making a tool variant in mid-1972, say, I expect to find it on some SAKs that are produced well into 1973, if not later.I think this one transition wouldn't take any time at all. Even finished back phillips could have been pulled from production and re-tooled very easily. I'm not saying this was done, but it could have. There's nothing difficult about adding the key cut.
@MiniChamp said:
Ultimately, aside from being in line with my limited observations, I like the 1971-1973 guesstimate also because it covers, within an error margin of +/- one year, all of the following:Sure, stating the larger range covers more time. I just feel based on my observations that such a 'conservative' view and estimate is not needed in this case.
Perhaps I should ask: If a can-key was found on a knife from '72, what would it look like?
Spoiler:
This is what I think it would look like:

Main thing there for me is the scraper on the caplifter. The rest seems pretty obvious to me. Sure, it could be very early like Q1 '73...but I sincerely doubt it.
.
-
@kamakiri said:
I do believe that some changes have been made in pretty broad moves that bridge all main line models and types.Hard to be certain, IMO. I do believe that transitions involving multiple parts tend to be relatively sharp. When they changed the thickness of the main blade shank from 2.7mm to 2.4mm, for example, this also involved changing the spring and the corresponding backside tool (corkscrew or Phillips SD). I think that you will never find a pre-3 variant of the backside Phillips SD on a SAK with a 2.4mm main blade shank, because they never made such variants that would fit. When a transition involves a single fully interchangeable part, however, the older parts tend to keep getting used in overlap with the new ones.
There are actually two non-interchangeable types of variant 3 of the backside Phillips SD. The first appeared towards the end of the Victoria era and has a 2.7mm shank. I expect that it was used in some overlap with both variant 2b and variant 1b (because they were all interchangeable). The second has a 2.4mm shank and was introduced along with the corresponding main blades (this should be the only square backside Phillips SD that you will find along with these newer blades).
Perhaps I should ask: If a can-key was found on a knife from '72, what would it look like?
This is what I think it would look like:

I happen to have a similar Grand-Prix. The only difference is that mine has the older big-gap scissors. I believe it to be from "around 1973." For me this essentially means 1972-1974. I tend to be skeptical about anyone's ability to date SAKs with an error margin of less than a year (except, maybe, a small number of very special cases). Nevertheless, I'm curious how you would date the two Victoria craftsmen in the attached image (sorry about the quality). I believe them to be from "around 1973" as well. Both have the same standard-gap scissors with a black spring. The only differences are as follows: The upper one has the can-key Phillips (variant 3) and a scraper on the cap-lifter. The lower one has a file on the Phillips (variant 1b) and no scraper on the cap-lifter.

-
@MiniChamp said:
Hard to be certain, IMO.Yes, but I'm not sure why you'd pick that as an example. Those are reasons why they had parts for both protocols around for so long.
@MiniChamp said:
I happen to have a similar Grand-Prix. The only difference is that mine has the older big-gap scissors. I believe it to be from "around 1973." For me this essentially means 1972-1974.You're avoiding the question a bit. The knife has everything I'd expect from a knife from '72. Or late '72, to be more precise.
Knives that I would put in '73 would then have the black spring, drop the scraper and a few more differences that happen within '73. And if this knife isn't '72 and somewhere in Q1 '73, then my guess would be that yours is '72. I'd like to see yours, both sides 'exploded' like the Grand Prix I posted.
@MiniChamp said:
I tend to be skeptical about anyone's ability to date SAKs with an error margin of less than a year (except, maybe, a small number of very special cases).There are lots of little windows of time where many here should be able to date knives within the year. Like with the various changes that happen in '85 with the backside tools. JMO, but the chisel is the only one I think could be early '86.
In the '70s I think I can peg most of it within a year with models that have enough tools or the right tools to date near the window in question. The hardest for me to separate are in the +PAT range where the most changes were with the scissors, and I believe the LNF versions follow a slightly different timeline.
And to split something that is '78 or '79...I'd need a wood saw to be certain between the two.
@MiniChamp said:
Nevertheless, I'm curious how you would date the two Victoria craftsmen in the attached image (sorry about the quality). I believe them to be from "around 1973" as well. Both have the same standard-gap scissors with a black spring. The only differences are as follows: The upper one has the can-key Phillips (variant 3) and a scraper on the cap-lifter. The lower one has a file on the Phillips (variant 1b) and no scraper on the cap-lifter.Show me 4 pictures of each. Front and Back exploded, top and bottom with the tools closed. I can see what I need to see that way.
I often choose to buy knives from strange and crappy pictures, but 'low quality' is still an understatement here. I can't even see the markings on the lower scaler.
-
Hi MiniChamp, is it good now?

-
@MiniChamp said:
Yes!
Cool!
Thanks! 

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
