Alox vs "standard" durability
-
@spudley112 said:
Either of those will be excellent knives. The Cadet probably gives you a few more tools to choose from but the advantage to the Bantam is that it is super slim. Of course, the Cadet is pretty slim itself! One of my favorite SAKs of that size is my Alox Lumberjack. I have just found the woodsaw very useful on my walks and I have the Lumberjack in my small Otterbox survival kit.I like the Cadet but I read some Amazon reviews where he complains that the file scratches the blade.
I wonder if even recent production has this defect. -
@SirVicaLot said:
I would go for the Cadet. More usability and still pretty thin.
Thanks SirVicaLot
Do you have any information on this? : "I like the cadet but I read some Amazon reviews where he complains that the file scratches the blade.
I wonder if even recent production has this defect." -
I just checked mine, and I have to admit that there seems to be a small area on the blade that gets scratched. I never noticed that until I just paid attention to it

-
@Stefano said:
Thanks, things like this (pins and springs) is just what I wanted to know.
Also be certain that the "side torsion" (example when using the multi-tool) is as good as the standard model.
I saw that the Alox models are really low!
Only 8 mm for Cadet and 6 mm for Bantam, do they hold equally well compared to a standard model but with greater thickness?I'd say they hold better, because Alox is stronger than celidor. Even if thinner, metal is stronger than "plastic". You can easily break a celidor scale but you'd have a more difficult task in doing the same with an alox one (scales alone, not mounted in a knife).
-
Between Bantam and Cadet, I'd choose the Cadet, because it has more functions, and feels better in the hand.
For a little more thickness, I would recommend the Pioneer, because .... awl! What a tool man!
If thickness isn't an issue, then Pioneer X, which has excellent scissors.
If you like smaller blades, then the Electrician, or the Rancher which replace the can opener with a small blade.
There is also the Farmer, a Pioneer with a saw.Στάλθηκε από το HUAWEI VNS-L31 μου χρησιμοποιώντας Tapatalk
-
@SirVicaLot said:
I just checked mine, and I have to admit that there seems to be a small area on the blade that gets scratched. I never noticed that until I just paid attention to it
Same thing on mine, I just ignore it.

-
I think its worth clarifying that the springs and tools on the 84mm alox knives are no different than on the 84mm cellidor equivalents and the pins are the same diameter. I do think the 84mm alox knives will likely be stronger because the aluminum scales are thicker than the aluminum scale liners used on the cellidor models, and the pins are nickle-silver instead of brass.
Now, the springs and tools are indeed thicker on the 93mm alox range, and the scales themselves are thicker than those of the 84mm alox range, so they will be even more "sturdy."
All that said, for what I would be willing to use a folding knife for, I think the cellidor models are plenty strong enough. If I need stronger, I go to a fixed blade.
I awlways recommedn the pioneer, as I truly think its the greatest pocket knife ever made. The cadet is also a great choice.
-
@gustophersmob said:
I awlways recommend the pioneerI like what you did there Gustophersmob!!

-
Silver Alox is pretty wear resistant and doesn't scratch much, so on a keychain it will wear better.
As for strength, I think you will only note the difference in the 58mm line. The Alox Classic (or if you are willing to do a little modding an Alox Rambler) kicks butt and then some. The price is of course that you no longer have the scale tools. -
When people talk about the alox being more robust, they are talking about the 93mm knives. The Cadet and Bantam are 84mm knives.
Here is a picture of a Cadet (left) and a Pioneer (right).
-
Great feedback everybody - Good luck with your quest/decision Stefano
It's hard! - There are lots of choices and they are all good :)I think for the knife tool/body strength, as mentioned, the Cadet (84mm range) would be very similar to a plastic handled knife
Some folk are concerned with the plastic handles - As they can crack if dropped on a hard surfaceWorth noting that the 93mm (Pioneer) range was initially known as the Sturdy Boy range
And was specifically marketed by Victorinox as being stronger for tough tasks. -
Thank you all for the answers!
-
Nice FB - Thanks - Brilliant -

-
@FolderBeholder said:
Proof:Nice SAK and pic FB!

-
I am no expert on the strength of SAKs, But I would say that the 84mm alox knives are at least as robust as the 91mm cellidor knives, with the 93mm alox knives being much more robust. One thing I love about my alox knives is the lack of liners between the layers. If you get gunk down in the tool all you need to do is open it up and rinse, then dry really good. I use a pioneer as one of my fishing knives for this reason. If I lost my fixed blade and needed to clean a fish with it, the knife would be very easy to clean afterwards.
-
@FolderBeholder said:
Proof:

You win the thread

-
It will be a very difficult choice, Bantam, Cadet, Pioneer, Farmer.
All these Alox are beautiful .. and I can't buy them all as I would like -
@Stefano said:
It will be a very difficult choice, Bantam, Cadet, Pioneer, Farmer.
All these Alox are beautiful .. and I can't buy them all as I would likeYou can’t go wrong with a standard Pioneer to start your collection off.
they are probably my favorite. Unless you see yourself needing scissors or a saw every day that is what I would get. Nowadays I carry a farmer when I will be outside all day and a Pioneer X when I will be in an office, but I don’t use the saw or scissors too often.Another thought is getting a Farmer and pairing it up with a small, inexpensive tool that has scissors like a classic. Then you have the best of both worlds all the time.
You can’t go wrong no matter which option you choose!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
