What I wouldn't do for a modular Multitool.
-
It might be more about how much you would be willing to pay for such a tool, and how many like you there are out there?
Making tools modular would add some extra concerns and constraints designwise, so compared to a non-modular version it would likely be more expensive, larger and heavier. Like Chako said the track record for that hasn't been great so far.
Now if you go from modular to for instance "modifying friendly" the compromises might not be that big - particulary not for pivot held tools. I believe SOG had have (?) easily exchangable pivot tools?
-
@Vidar said:
It might be more about how much you would be willing to pay for such a tool, and how many like you there are out there?Making tools modular would add some extra concerns and constraints designwise, so compared to a non-modular version it would likely be more expensive, larger and heavier. Like Chako said the track record for that hasn't been great so far.
Now if you go from modular to for instance "modifying friendly" the compromises might not be that big - particulary not for pivot held tools. I believe SOG had have (?) easily exchangable pivot tools?
maybe thats more what I am suggesting. think the P4 with a friendly tool exchange system. I know this really doesn't make money for the main company, doesn't mean I wouldnt love the heck out of it. I think this is one of the reasons I love the Surge so much.
Cheers,
H.G. -
Actually I don't think SOG hurt themselves by selling extra bits to install into their multi-tools. You still have to buy the tool...and the extra parts you want to switch around. Sounds like a win win for SOG. Surprised that Leatherman hasn't done something similar actually, or Gerber for that matter.
-
I broke the phillips driver on a SOG PPP and seem to recall paying about $7 shipped to get a new one, which took less than 5 minutes to install. I much prefer that over having to send in a whole tool and wait for it to be repaired/replaced.
-
Any MT with removable fasteners are modular enough. The manufacturers probably figured people will get parts aftermarket or 2nd hand either way. One less problem on hand if people screw up trying to fit other non stock parts into their stock configuration.
-
One thing that has often been cited against modular tools is a perception of additional liability and/or warranty issues. I wonder how much of that is true.
-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
One thing that has often been cited against modular tools is a perception of additional liability and/or warranty issues. I wonder how much of that is true.I agree, if nothing else I feel Like Leatherman could be friendly to ppl making high quality replacement blades for the OHO tools. How awesome would a Surge blade be in CPM 3V?
I was shocked with just how easy it was to Remove and replace the blade on the Signal, the piviot is very different from other tools, and they got rid of the Security Torx. Thanks Leatherman!

-
The Pro-Lock didn't fail, from what I understand Coleman stopped making it because of threats of lawsuits from leatherman. That's why there were no additional cartridges made.
I bought a couple of Pro-Locks and made my own cartridges using parts from other multitools... and it's really useful. The original tools are a bit primitive, but I've mounted modern tools in there, including a leatherman large and small bit holder.
It's a good tool, and I like it, especially for camping. One of these days I'll snag another pro-lock and make another cartridge or two.
Charles.
-
LMs fasteners aren't exaclty tamper proof
. Not suggesting they want us taking apart their tools but they are well aware its done. It would be interesting to be able to purchase the individual parts for replacement ourselves. As far as blades? I have said in the past it would be cool if different steels were offered. I was surprised other sources of blades hadn't come up but I get it now. With a wealth of spare parts on the 2nd hand market and the modding we've seen here on MTo it would be a bit late for them to start now
. -
I'm a little late to the party - Are the LM Surge and Gerber 600 the only current offerings with exchangeable blades?
-
I keep seeing liability being brought up, again and again, my manufacturers as a reason to not offer interchangeable implements. I too prefer to be able to interchange tools to A: suit my liking B: fix stuff I have broken doing something I shouldn't. It's why I like SOG--especially older ones that just use 1/4" hex fasteners. That's a common, easy type. Just use a screwdriver with the bit removed. And they are still covered under warranty!
On my list is Charge cutting hook in a Wave and awl in a Wave--LM already did that, in the Dutch Police model--which I wish would get a civilian variant. ST300 blade exchanger in the regular model, not EOD is another. My 2013 ST300s file also is pretty bad, an issue that was later addressed. I'd like to be able to change that out without having to send it off, wait a few weeks, and pay $8 to ship it off.
It's not really that hard. I have seen that many Leatherman models have implements that interchange with each other already--with no modification to the implements themselves required. Just sell them on their own like SOG.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login