Knives are Confusing!
-
figured I'd pitch this one out to the collective, see if anyone knows of my dream knife, hidden away on some poorly designed website.
I'd like to get a knife that has a swept blade, like a cold steel scimitar/talwar/espada, or spyderco chinook, about 4" long, with a blade flipper index opener and an axis/arc lock style lock. VG-10 would be a good target steel
does it exist? will it ever exist? am I insane?
thanks!

-
of note; I'm looking mainly at VG-10 because I want something that'll take a fine edge and is corrosion resistant, not necessarily because I want a super steel with amazing edge retention or anything.
-
I'm a bit out of the loop where tac blades are concerned, but someone will be along in a minute :)
-
Knives are Still confusing, but another question for the collective;
has anyone handled both a SOG Vulcan and a BM Griptilian?
or just a Vulcan?
appreciate any comment,
-Danny
-
Have a Mini Griptilian for EDC and have once handled a SOG Vulcan. Prefer Benchmade over SOG here, but the Vulcan is a pretty good knife too. In fact it is the first knife to come to my mind when I read your question. Here´s a (German, sorry) Video on the SOG Vulcan, but it might still be interesting for you to see the lock and size of the knife.
-
While not as upswept as a scimitar blade shape Benchmade does make a nice clip point blade (like a buck 110) with an axis lock in the Harley Hardtail.

-
@DannyZRC said:
blade flipper index opener and an axis/arc lock style lock.As far as I know these two things do not exist together in any production knife. Flippers are almost exclusively limited to liner or frame locks. I say just buy the Chinook.
Narrow down your want list to one major item. Do you want a piston-type lock? an upswept blade? etc. This allows you to take a broader view of the current market and then narrow down your choices when you have a good selection.
-
that hardtail looks fairly nice, actually.
a bit out of my price range though, and I may be struck down for pocketing it (I ride a BMW
)spoonrobot; the vulcan is one (though only, as far as I can tell) example of a flipper combined with a piston lock.
-
:-[
No I know better. How that slipped by me I have no idea. I even handled the dang thing at a BLADE last year. ::)
:D
-
how did you like it? I'm leaning strongly toward it right now =D
-
It was nice. Keep in mind I'm used to carrying thin Spyderco folders.
A little thick for me but I liked the ergos and the lock seems nice and strong. My main gripe is with the price point. I understand piston-type locks and their pricing but @$117 just seems a bit much for VG10 and FRN. That is way into ZDP/S30V and G10 price range for me. I'd snap one up for $75-$85 though.
-
I played with a vulcan, too bulky for my taste. Price is higher than others too it seems.
-
Benchmade Griptilian 551SBK, problem solved.
thing is damn near perfect, I think I'm in love.

-
it does feel a bit cheapish, yeah, but relative to other offerings it actually is a bit cheaper, so I'm ok on that front.
mostly it's just the hollow sound it makes, like a cheap car interior, structurally it is sound and I have no complaint of it's gripping qualities or deformation under load.
feels really great in the hand, too. very well balanced and pleasant.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login