Anyone else having this problem?
-
I have used Victrorinox knives for over 25 years and have had a problem with oiling.
I use warm water and soap and clean the knife and then blow it dry with air can. I then put a SMALL drop (one drop) of oil on the joint. When I try to work the blade (or implement), the action gets very hard to use. Harder than original condition before cleaning.
I have used just about all the oils known to man, including Victorinox brand and this happens with all of them.
I can reclean knife as above but not use oil and the action is smooth again and not hard to work with.
Can someone give me advise? Thanks, Bryan
-
The straight forward answer seems to be, no oil. Rusting is not much of an issue if you are not using the knife in very wet or corrosive conditions. Heck I've seen SAKs that likely had little to no care and operate excellent after a bath and no oil. If your experience is 25 years I'd say you might be onto something
@hard.times.lures said:
I have used Victrorinox knives for over 25 years and have had a problem with oiling.I can reclean knife as above but not use oil and the action is smooth again and not hard to work with.
Thanks, Bryan
Now as far as why after a bath and oil why the action is not smooth
. Given that you've tried different oils I am at a loss as to why the introduction of oil would cause an issue. -
Well, I can add another perspective.
I've used SAK's for 50 years, literally. My first SAK was in 1969, and I dragged mine through service with army engineers, lots of backpacking trips, fishing, day to day use. I very very VERY rarely bathe a SAK. Unless it got joint deep in a fish, or caked with food stuff form field kitchen duty, I just wipe well with paper twill or dishrag, and drop back in pocket. I usually don't even oil much. Maybe once or twice a year if it feels like it needs it. A drop of mineral oil with a toothpick o the joints and the it it. Usually a wipe out with a folded paper towel is it.
It's a SAK, not a space shuttle. It really doesn't need much maintenance and too many people over think it. If it gets really dirty, like dropped on a sandy beach, or full of animal stuff a rinse out with water will do.
-
Haven't experienced anything like this.
Normally I only use the toothpick to clean the pocket lint out of the joints. Sometimes the SAK gets oiled. Afterwards it always opens and closes smoother than before.
-
I agree. It's amazing how little-to-no lubrication they need when kept clean. Sand is the mortal enemy of any friction joint, of course, so I make exceptions for SAKs that have gotten sandy.
One thing you might try is putting a micro drop of oil down the length of both sides of the springs when they are exposed (ie, as you open and close an implement and they "bump" up on the back of the knife). When I do oil, I apply Vx factory lubricant to those surfaces, the spot where the end of the spring contacts the back edge of the shank of the implement, and the faces of the implement shank where they rub on the liner. If you do this, and work it in just a few times, you'll find even the laziest spring snap problem can be solved.
I'm sure a lot of people would think of this as over-oiling, but I'd rather have that and wipe the excess down than have the grinding friction of a dirty or sandy SAK.
Good luck.
-
I’ve experienced this too and can explain.
If there’s not a perfect contact surface between the pivot and spring, the steel literally scuffs against itself and you no longer have a smooth action. No amount of oil will fix this.
I’ve modified pivots and springs on custom SAKs and it’s a common problem as it’s nigh impossible to get a factory equivalent contact area once you start reprofiling surfaces. Even polished to a mirror finish, the steel is so hard against each respective surface that the slightest misshape will cause a high point that will grind immediately. You can see the thin scuff line under a magnifier and you may see the same if you examine your knife.
I’ve had the same on a deep clean with an older SAK. The cause is the same (grinding of the contact surface), likely because there was a little contact wear there already, that was masked under compacted dirt.
I have a simple routine to address this issue.
I use an automotive paste that I push down into the pivot area and work the tool open/closed repeatedly to polish down the contact area that’s rough. I then rinse in warm water with liquid soap and toothbrush to agitate/remove the paste and flush the pivot clean.
This may take several cycles...but it does work.
Once the surfaces have bedded in again, the action will be smooth and you can add a drop of oil as needed.
Hope this explains the issue and you come right.
-
@hard.times.lures said:
I have used Victrorinox knives for over 25 years and have had a problem with oiling.I use warm water and soap and clean the knife and then blow it dry with air can. I then put a SMALL drop (one drop) of oil on the joint. When I try to work the blade (or implement), the action gets very hard to use. Harder than original condition before cleaning.
I have used just about all the oils known to man, including Victorinox brand and this happens with all of them.
I can reclean knife as above but not use oil and the action is smooth again and not hard to work with.
Can someone give me advise? Thanks, Bryan
I experienced the exact same issue with Victorinix oil.
Ive tracked it down and found out the mix of remaining moisture and the oil causes the problem.
It even happened when I blow out some dust with my mouth, this little moisture can cause it.
Let it dry and it will be fine again.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
