Ideal size?
-
For pocket knives, 60mm +/-5mm is around the sweet spot for me. The Byrd Tern is 57mm edge length, slightly shorter than on a 91mm Victorinox, and just feels right for an everyday folder. I do sometimes carry smaller ones, but mainly when I don't expect to need a knife at all. If I do expect that I might need one, the smallest I'd carry is a 84mm/85mm Swiss knife.
I tend to go larger on fixed blades, and tend to reach for one around 100mm-ish, although I have got others I can reach for varying from around 50mm to 170mm, depending on the task.
-
Folder - 3.25 inches is my preference. In actuality, I've whittled my collection down to the point where I might only have one. I bring it when I go camping but if I'm honest, I've never needed to use it.
The folder that I use outdoors has a 5 inch blade. Its not the ideal length, but the handle and the spine thickness are better for that sort of thing.SAK - I'd probably carry an 84mm if it had scissors. Since I don't have any, I go with a 91mm or 93mm depending on the plans for the day. I EDC a SAK
-
I have found that for some reason I cut the crap out if myself with the smaller blades?
I am fine with a Grip but not with a Mini Grip?
I don’t know why really?
So I tend to carry something bigger if I can.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Same as Nix. I'm finding that the older I get the smaller my carry tends to be.
@Nix said:
I run the full gamut.I might carry just a SAK Classic, I might carry a 130mm. In general, I prefer a knife in the 3.5-4.5" range. 4" is pretty ideal in my view, but a 91mm SAK typically fills 90% of my needs.

-
Over the years as I got older, my pocket knife size has gone down. Used to carry a Buck 301 stickman at 3 7/8th closed, then it went down to the 84mm SAK's, now I carry a 74mm executive. If have a 2 inch blade I'm happy. I find in my suruburan American lifestyle of a retired old fart that goes fishing a lot, I just don't need that much knife.
I've never been a fan of the big single blade lock blade knives. Just too limited. some sort of SAK and mulitblade slip joint has always been my favorite knife. If I need bigger, theres a 12 inch Ontario machete in my car trunk, and a Fiskars sliding blade saw in my daypack.
A 2 inch blade n a trim watch pocket size package does me fine. I've carried just a classic and got by just fine.
-
I like a knife with between a 2" and 3" main blade, and perhaps a pen blade or sheepsfoot/spey combination. Around 3" to 4" closed is a perfect handle. Fixed blades--I can't decide. My 7' Kabar is too big for most smaller jobs, yet my little 2" Eldris too small for a lot of the Kabar's work. My two favorites--the 4" Mora Companion and the USN Mark I (Camillus, post-WWII production using WWII blades) Deck Knife with a 5' blade.
-
Ideal size is 3 1/2 to 3 3/4 closed and carried in the right front pocket. Smaller and I will only carry it if i'm in slacks.
Any thing bigger up to 4 1/4" is a second or field knife and gets carried in a belt sheath. -
Regarding traditional folders:
In 60 years of carrying.... I've found that...
For every day pocket knife carry I find 3 1/4" to 3 5/8" closed size is perfectly adequate for most tasks.
Other occasions may require a larger carry or even a smaller pattern of peanut size may be just fine.
But that's just my take on the subject.
-
I believe that 'ideal-size' would be in the hands/discretion of the user. For me, bigger-is often better. Others may prefer a more diminutive size, or larger mid-range. There is no 'wrong-choice'.




-

So many nice knives you have!
-
Can you ever have too-many, Ray? :D :o

-
True, so very true!

-
I think the ideal size depends on the size of your hands, and on the job to be done.
I carry various sizes of knives for different purposes. -
@Ron Who said:
I think the ideal size depends on the size of your hands, and on the job to be done.
I carry various sizes of knives for different purposes.Agree that it probably has something to do with the size of your hands. All of my users are on the smaller side (smaller hands) except a 5-inch Camillus Lockback that comes camping (but not hiking) with me.
-
For me, an Opinel 9 is the absolute largest that I carry, and that on hikes. The Spyderco PM2 is seeing a good bit of carrying time, but I usually wind up actually using my Vic Executive, old USA made Old Timer small Stockman, Case Barlow or Mini Trapper. I like having the toolkit of the Executive, but love carrying a traditional. They team up pretty well.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login