Snap or Pinch Closed?
-
Snap for sure. As MacGyver pointed out, they are made to be closed that way.
If you take any folding knife when closed, you should be able to push down on the blade and see/feel the blade move down farther into the handle. A properly made folding knife blade "floats" inside the handle. Out of all the folding knives I've owned (100?) only one or two have ever hit the back spring and flattened the edge.
-
Ah... the age-old assessment of the "Walk and Talk" of a slipjoint.
I've always pinched my Victorinox knives closed, and always will. even the OHO ones.
Closing a SAK with "satisfying snap" makes my hair stand on end. That snap is the sound of metal on metal making contact at high velocity. I don't enjoy the sound of teeth grinding against one another, and the "talk" of a slipjoint gives me the same visceral reaction.
I don't feel like I gain anything with the extra second I save with closing a knife with the force of the backspring.
The other tools, maybe a different story - Full-length tools like saws and scissors get folded in slowly in a controlled way. Half-length tools like drivers and openers will often be closed with a snap. That's probably due to the ability to maintain a grip on the shorter tool, as well as the half stop on some tools which changes the dynamics.
-
If the kick (the metal at the base of the blade right behind the notch) on a blade is done properly the sound you hear is the kick hitting the back spring when you snap the blade shut and the blade edge will not hit anything.
I was a Victorinox Dealer for 16 years and I have carried and used Victorinox SAKS since the early '80s and have never had a blade damaged from snapping it shut. I ordered all my SAKs in boxes and personally checked every blade and all the tools on every knife that I got in. .
-
I snap everything shut, unless the pivots have got too dirty and the snap has gone. Oh, and the flathead on my first Sportsman that has no snap at all however clean and lubricated the pivot is. (It had great snap until I opened its layer completely, including the awl, awl at once. I think I bent a pin.
) -
Snap shut. Only time I pinch a blade/tool closed, is on a knife in which the knife has an inadequate kick, and the tip strikes the backspring. That is never on SAKs--Vic never messes up.
-
@VICMAN said:
If the kick (the metal at the base of the blade right behind the notch) on a blade is done properly the sound you hear is the kick hitting the back spring when you snap the blade shut and the blade edge will not hit anything.
I snap everything closed, with the exception of tools like the scissors and saw, which actually have enough flex in them that they don't always close properly if snapped.
-
I guess I'm the weird one.

-
Yepp, snap them close too.
Some SAKs main blades come a tad too close to the liner/keyring-spacer.
I still snap them close which produces a defined dent into the liner/keyring-spacer making space for the blade. A little touch up on the blades to afterwards is all it needs then and the problem is solved forever
-
I vote "snap tools, pinch blade", because I feel the only safe blade is a well controlled one, I almost always keep my blade hair shaving sharp, and even just a small nick at the wrong place would freak everyone in the house or friends surrounding.
-
After giving this some thought, I suppose it depends on how big a hurry I’m in, and which tool I’m using.
-
If it's one of my every day carries it gets snapped.
Once it gets gummy feeling it gets a thorough clean to bring the snap back. -
@FolderBeholder said:
If it's one of my every day carries it gets snapped.
Once it gets gummy feeling it gets a thorough clean to bring the snap back.
-
I can't vote. I snap most tools, sometimes do pinch main blades. And usually carefully pinch everything on the rare/expensive/old/minty ones...unless I have more than one and one is designated and prepped for use.
Like it or not, most main blades make contact at the tip when snapped. All anyone needs to do is check the liner and 'birdhead' small blade spacer to see. There's almost always a divot there created by the contact. which like ElevenBlade says - happens at high velocity.
On the Marlboro Spartan that I just prepped for use, I snapped the main blade several times to make sure the divot was there, free of gunk, before sharpening it.
-
I just picked out 50 SAKS randomly from my collection and every one has always had the blades snapped shut.
Not a one of them has any mark where the main blade shuts and none of the blades had any dull spots at the tip.
I don't doubt that it could happen, but I think it is pretty rare. I have had it happen on other brand knives, but never on any of my SAKS.
If you are snapping them shut with extra force on the blade I could see it happening, but if you let the blade snap shut on its own I have yet to have a Vic blade hit and make a divot.
-
@VICMAN said:
I just picked out 50 SAKS randomly from my collection and every one has always had the blades snapped shut.Not a one of them has any mark where the main blade shuts and none of the blades had any dull spots at the tip.
I don't doubt that it could happen, but I think it is pretty rare. I have had it happen on other brand knives, but never on any of my SAKS.
If you are snapping them shut with extra force on the blade I could see it happening, but if you let the blade snap shut on its own I have yet to have a Vic blade hit and make a divot.
I've never had it happen on any of my knifes either, I'd notice if the tip was dull, I cut mainly with the belly/tip.
-
Hmmm... Using a hand lens and strong light, I see my work Swisschamp has a number of tiny, shallow divots in the liner where the near tip of the large blade has met it. My Camper and favourite Sportsman (my other most carried knives) have none. I haven't checked any other knives.
When the large blades of all these knives are closed, it takes some pressure to push the tip against the liner. The SC's blade requires the least pressure.
Thanks for pointing this out, ElevenBlade, McStitchy, and kamakiri. I'd never considered the possibility of this happening. I haven't noticed the SC's blade becoming strangely dull at the tip, but I think I'll change my snappy blade closing habit anyway.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
