Snap or Pinch Closed?
-
@VICMAN said:
I just picked out 50 SAKS randomly from my collection and every one has always had the blades snapped shut.Not a one of them has any mark where the main blade shuts and none of the blades had any dull spots at the tip.
I don't doubt that it could happen, but I think it is pretty rare. I have had it happen on other brand knives, but never on any of my SAKS.
If you are snapping them shut with extra force on the blade I could see it happening, but if you let the blade snap shut on its own I have yet to have a Vic blade hit and make a divot.
I've never had it happen on any of my knifes either, I'd notice if the tip was dull, I cut mainly with the belly/tip.
-
Hmmm... Using a hand lens and strong light, I see my work Swisschamp has a number of tiny, shallow divots in the liner where the near tip of the large blade has met it. My Camper and favourite Sportsman (my other most carried knives) have none. I haven't checked any other knives.
When the large blades of all these knives are closed, it takes some pressure to push the tip against the liner. The SC's blade requires the least pressure.
Thanks for pointing this out, ElevenBlade, McStitchy, and kamakiri. I'd never considered the possibility of this happening. I haven't noticed the SC's blade becoming strangely dull at the tip, but I think I'll change my snappy blade closing habit anyway.

-
I find pretty strange some of you guys saying you don't have that little ding/scratch on the blade's liner or the spacer from closing the main blade. I mean.... O have that on all my sak's, used or even brand new out of the box....

-
@MacGyver said:
I find pretty strange some of you guys saying you don't have that little ding/scratch on the blade's liner or the spacer from closing the main blade. I mean.... O have that on all my sak's, used or even brand new out of the box....
I just took my Spartan out of my pocket. There is at least a mm gap between the spring/liner and the blade when closed. You can't begin to push the blade even close to the spring/liner and I tried hard. There is no possible way that the edge can touch the spring or liner.


I just checked 3 Spartans, a Pioneer, Camper and Outrider. No dings whatsoever and I can't push any of the blades down far enough to touch the spring. When snapping closed they are held by the kick long before they get anywhere near the spring.
-
Personally, I haven't seen much blade rub/dings, unless it was a vintage model or previous user has abused/bent the tip.
However, I still pinch-shut all my slip-joint type of knife/tool, to create a good habit. As said, a well controlled blade is a safe blade, and a quiet/soft shut always avoid unnecessary attention in public places.
-
@pomsbz said:
I just took my Spartan out of my pocket. There is at least a mm gap between the spring/liner and the blade when closed. You can't begin to push the blade even close to the spring/liner and I tried hard. There is no possible way that the edge can touch the spring or liner.

I just checked 3 Spartans, a Pioneer, Camper and Outrider. No dings whatsoever and I can't push any of the blades down far enough to touch the spring. When snapping closed they are held by the kick long before they get anywhere near the spring.
Its just a hair line scratch near the edge of the nickel spacer, but one can see it if look carefully, preferably with a good mag glass



Its just the result of the inertia of the blade coming to a abrupt stop at high velocity on top of a spring, the spring flexes a bit. It only kisses it for a split second. But it does make contact, granted.
-
Interesting results. I'll continue to close as I do.
-
@pomsbz said:
I just took my Spartan out of my pocket. There is at least a mm gap between the spring/liner and the blade when closed. You can't begin to push the blade even close to the spring/liner and I tried hard. There is no possible way that the edge can touch the spring or liner.

I just checked 3 Spartans, a Pioneer, Camper and Outrider. No dings whatsoever and I can't push any of the blades down far enough to touch the spring. When snapping closed they are held by the kick long before they get anywhere near the spring.
I had it on my 2018 Cadet, 2017 Cybertool 41 and a 80's Climber so far. I'm too busy to take pics of that at the moment

-
Since we are on the topic about whether the blade will touch the spring or nicking at the tip of the blade, I have studied a good deal about the relationship between the blade and the spring(from my modding experience), and here are my two cents:

Photo cropped from making my Mountain Yeoman modThe only 'real reason' why the blade will not 'snap' its tip into the chassis is only because the 'corner' of the ricasso is actually resting on top of the spring(which I have circled in red), without that "blade-stop" design, part of the blade will probably nick onto the bottom spring. It really is a small engineering marvel to see how tightly these blades nest to each other and how closely they are situated to the bottom spring, If the tempering or tolerance goes a little off track, I am sure those blades will be nicked easily given the tight spaces.
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
Thanks for pointing this out, ElevenBlade, McStitchy, and kamakiri. I'd never considered the possibility of this happening. I haven't noticed the SC's blade becoming strangely dull at the tip, but I think I'll change my snappy blade closing habit anyway.
SG, Thanks for actually taking a closer look!

I believe this is the reason that Victorinox uses Nickel Silver for the small blade spacer. It's pretty soft and doesn't really dull the tip. The contact mark is also one way I can tell if a blade tip has been repaired, previously bent, or recently bent. The tell tale is multiple marks in that area. The mark can be in the spacer or the adjacent liner/divider layer or even right in-between smashing them both. My understanding is that SAKs are still all hand assembled and that they test the blade movement in QC and snap it shut along with all the tools. I thought I saw that in a video.
Even my 50th Anniversary MOTM PS Tinker has the mark.
-
Pinch close.
Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
