The Nessmuk Challenge
-

Welcome to the Nessmuk challenge thread!
We, Nix and Comis, are proposing a challenge drawn from history and the legendary George W. Sears, a.k.a ‘Nessmuk’.

Most of you know of the author of Woodcraft, written in 1884, when woodsmen still explored the wild reaches of North America.

Nessmuk advocated for the woodsman to carry a ‘trio’ of bladed tools to cover the various needs and tasks of life and living well in the bush: a small axe, a knife, and a pocket knife. This common sense approach is still used by many campers and hunters today.

*Yes, it’s common sense, but how useful is this famous trio? *
*There is only one way to find out. A 30-day challenge! *
We hope you guys will join in, test the Sears philosophy, and have a bit of fun. We’ve pick the month of September to allow most people to get out into the woods and do a bit of camping, hiking, or just messing around with some bushcrafting.

The goal:
For participants to test out Mr Sears’ recommendations for a tool triumvirate and evaluate which tool or tools are the most useful in modern life.
The rules:
1. Prior to the start of the challenge (‘Day 0’ or before), participants will select an axe, fixed blade knife, and folding knife/multitool to use for the duration of the challenge. This will be a fixed set of tools, substitutions or changes are not permitted during the challenge (There was no way for Nessmuk to switch tools during a month-long sojourn into the bush, so you can’t either!). Post a picture of your ‘trio’ before the start of the challenge. You are now committed!

2. If a tool is lost or broken during the challenge, it can not be replaced. (Might influence choice of tools or lanyards)

3. The challenge will run for 30-days. Each day post a photo of one or more of the tools in your kit.

4. In addition to a daily photo, participants are encouraged to add comments about tool performance and/or why one tool was favored for a specific task over another tool.

5. At the end of the challenge, participants are asked to rank the tools in their trio in order of most used and most useful.

-
E.g. Used (most used to least used): Spirit, Fixed blade, Axe* -
Utility (most useful to least useful): Spirit, Axe, Fixed blade.*
This is a fairly straightforward 30-day challenge--perhaps easier than many because of the extra number of tools included--but it should still be fun and encourage some good tool discussion.

-
-
This is going to be a good one. Axes and knives.... :ahhh
-
- comis
- Nix
-
Can't beat this!
- comis
- Nix
- Barry Rowland
-
Ah. If ONLY I lived further out and had an "outside" job, i would jump on this. I will be monitoring this thread for sure
-
september, huh? i'll have to give this a thought
-
Hard to believe we haven't done this challenge already. It seems like a natural for MTo....and MUST be done! :ahhh
(All credit to comis for the idea!
) -
@ThundahBeagle said:
Ah. If ONLY I lived further out and had an "outside" job, i would jump on this. I will be monitoring this thread for sureWell.....you could select your 'Trio' based on your anticipated needs for September. SAK to cover 90% of the time, a fixie and small axe if the chance to get outdoors on a weekend should arise. :D
-
september, huh? i'll have to give this a thought
Please do :DI am definitely in on this one! Oh yeah

- comis
- Nix
- Barry Rowland
- Rapidray
Barry and Rapidray! Great to have you!
Hard to believe we haven't done this challenge already. It seems like a natural for MTo....and MUST be done! :ahhh
(All credit to comis for the idea!
)No, thank you for hosting the previous fixie challenges and the axemen, those were great fun! If anything, I am just connecting the dots. You are definitely whom have inspired me this idea!

-
This will be interesting to follow.
Due to the majority of my daily life being spent in areas where carrying an axe and fixed blade would draw a lot of unwanted attention, I will pass on participating.
-
@Sos24 said:
This will be interesting to follow.Due to the majority of my daily life being spent in areas where carrying an axe and fixed blade would draw a lot of unwanted attention, I will pass on participating.
I actually live in a big city and probably in a similar situation as yours, there's no requirement on "open carry" anything, so I am going to bag carry these tools if I need to. But am looking forward to see whether I get a chance to play with all three in an outdoor setting.
If you have time and do change your mind, please always feel free to join us! :D
-
@comis said:
I actually live in a big city and probably in a similar situation as yours, there's no requirement on "open carry" anything, so I am going to bag carry these tools if I need to. But am looking forward to see whether I get a chance to play with all three in an outdoor setting.If you have time and do change your mind, please always feel free to join us! :D
Asking for a friend.
Would it be acceptable to use a chopping tool other than an ax? An ax is useful in a forest, but some of us may be in a swamp or a jungle where a machete is the preferred tool. Also, I didn't see a listed requirement to carry all 3 tools with you at all times. Having access to all 3 would be no problem, but if we have to actually carry them with us all the time, for the entire month, that is a problem. If that is really what you are expecting I would like to suggest that we begin collecting for an MTO General Bail Fund, since anyone walking around with a large knife or an ax, either openly or concealed, may get themselves arrested in most urban / suburban locations. -
I'm in!
- comis
- Nix
- Barry Rowland
- Rapidray
- RF52
Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
@Alan K. said:
Asking for a friend.
Would it be acceptable to use a chopping tool other than an ax? An ax is useful in a forest, but some of us may be in a swamp or a jungle where a machete is the preferred tool. Also, I didn't see a listed requirement to carry all 3 tools with you at all times. Having access to all 3 would be no problem, but if we have to actually carry them with us all the time, for the entire month, that is a problem. If that is really what you are expecting I would like to suggest that we begin collecting for an MTO General Bail Fund, since anyone walking around with a large knife or an ax, either openly or concealed, may get themselves arrested in most urban / suburban locations.Thanks for bringing this up, I have discussed this with Nix prior to posting, and we both did agree that it is not a requirement to carry any or all of those tools with you at all times. And how many tools you want to carry, if any, is totally a subjective decision. :D
-
@Sos24 said:
This will be interesting to follow.Due to the majority of my daily life being spent in areas where carrying an axe and fixed blade would draw a lot of unwanted attention, I will pass on participating.
It would be great to have you join, Sherry.
As comis said earlier, there is no requirement to carry all three tools all day, every day.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

