Interesting double standard
-
@Leatherman123 said:
As it has already been mentioned, Gerber completely copied an excellent by LM. LM copied a concept of Gerbers and improved on it. The ST300's cutters aren't triangular like Gerbers and they are made from a premium steel.If you think about it, all the MT manufacturers copied LM's idea! SOG, Gerber, Vic, Kutmaster, and even Bear all copied LM's idea of a folding plier tool.
Leatherman didn't originally think of it.
-
@WH867 said:
I noticed the double standard, which Is why I mentioned gerber in the LM 300 thread. The cutters are definately copied from gerber and since the surge exchanger has been mentioned here it is also a ripoff of gerber. LM may have put there own take on it but still a ripoff.
Using other peoples ideas is not a huge deal to me but the double standard here is. Most(not all) around here will only bash gerber and never give them credit for anything.
Also love the people in this thread that are basically saying its just the cutters so no foul. (doesnt count) ::).
+1

-
Is it really copying, or simply accepting what works well and incorporating it? Viewed that way, it's an homage to the company by developing it rather than a ripoff. Evolution takes what works and discards what doesn't, and we, as multi-national and multi-branded multi-people can see the larger picture, and appreciate it for what it is rather than get mired down in who did what first.
Isn't that the beauty of an independent site? :D
Def
-
well said

-
I can't put my finger on it, but I see an unwritten line that if crossed, something becomes a "knockoff". The Gerber Crucial crossed that imaginary line for me. The replaceable wire cutter idea didn't cross that line, although I immediately thought "Hey that's a Gerber design!" and hoped Leatherman improved on it. I owned a MP600 with those carbide cutters and they coulden't cut stranded wire, so they were next to useless for me...I'd like to think Leatherman will improve on that idea with the ST300.
It comes down to this for me. If you want to riff off someone elses idea or design, you damn well better make it an improvement...not just ride the coattails of a good design. I have reason to belive the Crucial is made from inferior materials and inferior construction than the Skeletool.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Is it really copying, or simply accepting what works well and incorporating it? Viewed that way, it's an homage to the company by developing it rather than a ripoff. Evolution takes what works and discards what doesn't, and we, as multi-national and multi-branded multi-people can see the larger picture, and appreciate it for what it is rather than get mired down in who did what first.Isn't that the beauty of an independent site? :D
Def
I would say it's probably both. And as I said. I don't mind them copying, especially good ideas. But there are some people here who don't get the bigger picture. They like the Double standard better.
-
Isn't that the beauty of an independent site?
Well, I suppose being sponsered by Candian Tyre is like being independent.
Well darnit, if we're going to be pedantic - I had replaceable blades on my anvil tree loppers a good 20 years ago.
-
I wish we were sponsored by Canadian Tire... we'd have a hell of a lot bigger budget to work with if we were!
Def
-
I guess LM figured that Gerber would be the last ppl to sue them for stealing an idea ::)

Truth be told any good idea is gonna be stolen at some point in time :)
I do see your point on the double standard though ;)
-
IMO, the replaceable cutter heads is a brilliant way to cut replacement costs by LM. Instead of replacing plierheads under warranty (ie at a cost to LM), they've turned it into a revenue generating feature (ie profit center for LM).
Still, an excellent advance.

-
Yeah, I agree with you 100% Mr.W!
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
IMO, the replaceable cutter heads is a brilliant way to cut replacement costs by LM. Instead of replacing plierheads under warranty (ie at a cost to LM), they've turned it into a revenue generating feature (ie profit center for LM).Still, an excellent advance.

didn't really think of that.....good point!
-
I would love to hear LM's response , "haven't we seen removable cutters before......"
-
Just want to chime in with an example from the computing world.
How many times have we heard of people declaring that Apple has been copied in some OS or phone feature. But hardly anyone talks about the countless times Mr Jobs' company has taken features from companies like Microsoft and Palm for their own products. When pointed out, the fanboys usually declare that "Apple has made it better".
I can't help but see some similar sentiments in this thread.
-
How many times have we heard of people declaring that Apple has been copied in some OS or phone feature. But hardly anyone talks about the countless times Mr Jobs' company has taken features from companies like Microsoft and Palm for their own products. When pointed out, the fanboys usually declare that "Apple has made it better".
I can't help but see some similar sentiments in this thread.
With the obvious exception that people who like Leatherman are perfectly sane and have (more or less) good personal hygiene.
-
But Apple had the first GUI on the consumer market, so everything else is a copy - oh, LM discussion Dejavu ;)
I respect LM for what they are, but like some Gerber stuff too - and as long as it is not illegal everyone is free to copy working ideas.
Woz
-
@Leatherman123 said:
As it has already been mentioned, Gerber completely copied an excellent what?* by LM. LM copied a concept of Gerbers and improved on it. The ST300's cutters aren't triangular like Gerbers and they are made from a premium steel.*an excellent what?
If you mean concept/idea, then you are saying it's fine for one company to "copy" but not the other? Double standards? I think so! Gerber didn't "completely" copy an "idea" they changed it and added their own twist. Leatherman have done the same with Gerbers replaceable cutters. ::)
And how do you know that the all mighty and powerful Leatherman have actually improved on Gerbers "concept" (that has been out for many years now) With LM's "interpretation" of the "idea" you only get one chance at damaging a cutter and then it needs replacing. Will it work better than Gerbers? Who knows until they are in the open market and some one can test them. You are making assumptions based upon your own biases. I for one will hold judgement until i have seen evidence from trusted sources or done some testing myself.
And again re the Crucial, how do you know what it will be like? Do you have one? Have you handled one? ::)
-
I think they were definately inspired or influenced by Gerber... but the basic design of Gerber's triangular cutter is much better, as you get three goes in the same amount of space. That said, the LMs probably use better steel, so it's swings and roundabouts. People should just realise that there are only so many ideas in MT design, and to some degree they're all variations on a theme :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login